2019 Auditions, Finals, and Training Camp Spoilers

[An Offt]

21 minutes ago, Poodle1922 said:

Why ask opinions of guest choreographers and judges BUT don’t listen to it 🤷🏾‍♀️

For the sake of a television show.  How many "guest judges" do you think came in before there were cameras?

[Lily80]

Daphne. Good lawd that leap during Show Group auditions. Jaw on the floor. And she's never been one of my favorites. Other stand-outs: Hannah (of course), Ashlee (YAY!), Kelsey, Amanda, Bridget, and from what I saw, JAYLYN. She always brings it. I don't get it. 😞

[Pj3422]

3 minutes ago, BBK said:

Asked one of my favorite Rookies, Kristen, & she said the person in this picture is...

LILY

You’re Welcome...& sorry, the questions surrounding this picture can now be laid to rest

So was that dress on the internet white & gold or blue & black? And which did you hear  — Yanni or Lauren? 🤪

[Lily80]

Also, Alexandra. 😞 Poor baby. She handled herself well.

[DCCFanInKy]

5 minutes ago, An Offt said:

For the sake of a television show.  How many "guest judges" do you think came in before there were cameras?

0

[KatieC]

1 hour ago, Tootie said:

I enjoyed the part where KaShara picked who she thought would be a good point:  Amy! No, wait.... Maddie!  No, wrong again!  Caroline!  😄

They should have listened to her!  The two this year are just not point material unfortunately.

[CourtneyLoveNJ]

Omg. You know an episode really got to me when I sign up to post after reading this forum for years and watching the show since it started. Even with all the Cassie/Vic drama I have never been so mad. I haven’t yet read what others wrote on here because I just finished the episode, but I am so disgusted at the way Kelli talked to Jalyn after she rightfully got upset. Unprofessional? Yet in the previews she’s crying presumably over Meredith who quite honestly is just god awful????? 

This show has lost everything that got me watching it in the first place and now it’s become this sad reality show and not a real dance audition.  I mean, if CMT drops it, you know it would fit right in in the Bravo line up. (And don’t get me wrong I love me some Real Housewives) but I’m saddened by how pathetic this show has become. 

/endrant 

[BBK]

🤗

[Stee]

I have always loved Kelli and how she handles cutting the girls. I’ve always admired how articulate she is and specifically her choice of language - clear and concise. Not always good news, but honest news. 

Unfortunately this is the first episode in 14 years where something just felt “off.”  She seemed particularly upset with the whole Jalyn situation - even defensive. The fact that Judy had to explain to Kelli that there is a difference between “losing” showgroup vs not making show group shows how illogical and irrational Kelli is being.

If a girl wants to step into the locker room to cry or process her feelings, she should be allowed to do that. If Jalyn has remained in the room and teared up or started crying, would Kelli say that is unprofessional too?   What would be the better option?  Honestly, I think excusing yourself when the girls break is better than creating a scene in the dance studio. 

The show sets these girls up for such huge expectations - cuts every week, guest choreographers, fashion shows and photo shoots positioned as “tests”.. and then they are surprised when the girls react with emotion or disappointment.  You’ve physically and mentally exhausted these girls and the critique them if they don’t happen to be smiling or perky for four hours straight.  

This episode was particularly unflattering for Kelli. I hope she watches this in retrospect and recognizes her strange defensiveness and accusatory behavior towards Jalyn. You’d think she just lied to her about a doctors appointment or something!

Edited September 14, 2019 by Stee

[Holly85]

12 minutes ago, Stee said:

I have always loved Kelli and how she handles cutting the girls. I’ve always admired how articulate she is and specifically her choice of language - clear and concise. Not always good news, but honest news. 

Unfortunately this is the first episode in 14 years where something just felt “off.”  She seemed particularly upset with the whole Jalyn situation - even defensive. The fact that Judy had to explain to Kelli that there is a difference between “losing” showgroup vs not making show group shows how illogical and irrational Kelli is being.

If a girl wants to step into the locker room to cry or process her feelings, she should be allowed to do that. If Jalyn has remained in the room and teared up or started crying, would Kelli say that is unprofessional too?   What would be the better option?  Honestly, I think excusing yourself when the girls break is better than creating a scene in the dance studio. 

The show sets these girls up for such huge expectations - cuts every week, guest choreographers, fashion shows and photo shoots positioned as “tests”.. and then they are surprised when the girls react with emotion or disappointment.  You’ve physically and mentally exhausted these girls and the critique them if they don’t happen to be smiling or perky for four hours straight.  

This episode was particularly unflattering for Kelli. I hope she watches this in retrospect and recognizes her strange defensiveness and accusatory behavior towards Jalyn. You’d think she just lied to her about a doctors appointment or something!

This season is just weird to me something doesn’t feel right to me 

[pinkandsparkly13]

F Kelli! And keep slaying Jalyn! 

[Lily80]

44 minutes ago, Stee said:

This episode was particularly unflattering for Kelli. I hope she watches this in retrospect and recognizes her strange defensiveness and accusatory behavior towards Jalyn. You’d think she just lied to her about a doctors appointment or something!

I agree with this. It was strange. There's definitely something we don't know--more to the story. And Jalyn comported herself well in the office too.

[ShellyB]

10 hours ago, DCCFanInKy said:

@ShellyB can you tell who this is?

It’s Lily 

[SanDiegoGal]

Now somebody convince me why Jalyn was supposedly out-danced? From what I saw in deliberations, Kelli shut-down the conversation when it came to her. From this screenshot, Jalyn's form is clearly better than the unknown candidate to her left. Yep, something is rotten in the state of Denmark, er Dallas.

[TxBex]

1 hour ago, CourtneyLoveNJ said:

This show has lost everything that got me watching it in the first place and now it’s become this sad reality show and not a real dance audition.  I mean, if CMT drops it, you know it would fit right in in the Bravo line up.

I think you hit on something we keep forgetting. That this is still a reality show. It's not just about dance ability anymore. Making the Team focuses on the same general characters and storylines every season. You've got your Underdogs (Meredith/Alexandria), Class clown (Kat), Ingenue (Chandi), Comeback kids (Victoria/Lily/Kristin), Heartbreak vets (Gabby/Jalyn), etc. TPTB decide each girl's edit to advance and support these storylines. If you aren't featured a lot on the show, it's because you don't have anything dramatic to add. I think TPTB more or less have already chosen the team before training camp, with enough wriggle room to handle any surprises that pop up. I wouldn't be surprised to find out cuts are mapped out and story boarded even before training camp has started. This would explain why some things feel so weird and forced; like they didn't just happen organically.

[DCCFanInKy]

53 minutes ago, ShellyB said:

It’s Lily 

Thank you! 🙂

[hereforthedrama]

On 9/12/2019 at 1:07 PM, Kayce said:

For our people who like to do charts/diagrams/etc....has anyone put together a layout of the kickline order?  I'm just curious.  

Changes week to week based on who is sitting out, but for the most part this is it. 

[Jezlyn]

Is anyone else totally sick of hearing Meredith say I dont know where my head/brain was at, I wasnt myself tonight. I swear she's saying it almost every practice if not every practice 

[dreamcatcher]

5 hours ago, ElenaFR said:

Nothing. She did great. Kelli just said, I didn't notice her.  So we are not getting info. 

Well maybe sweetie that means you need to retire yourself to a nice senior home and let someone else step in. You can’t be a director of a dance team and not notice Jalyn but cry after every vk performance...

4 hours ago, Jennv said:

Right? At least she didn’t, oh I don’t know, throw her head down on Kelli’s desk or something like that

And yet, Kelli never called THIS mess unprofessional. Jalyn keeping her composure is unprofessional. Sure.

4 hours ago, Jennv said:

Nope. Notice Jalyn said she wondered if it was something she had done outside of show group auditions? Kelli didn’t respond, or at least not that it was shown

That for me confirms what the insiders said.

[Lona]

I can't believe what I just saw. And to think I waited till midnight so I could watch it as soon as Amazon put it up ...

So y'all, get this: Jalyn is now "toxic"!!!! Did you hear that. That's right. Being upset and excusing herself so as to not cause a scene was a selfish and "unprofessional" thing to do apparently. As opposed to what, Kelli? Causing a scene in the middle of practice?!?!?!? Good heavens, this show is starting to jump the shark(Yes I know many people will say it already has, please don't laugh at me 😉 ). And to top it all off, they compared her to Savannah! 🤣😂🤣. Like, I like Savannah but I never really thought of her as someone the others absolutely "needed" to follow or look up to. Please someone, tell me. Am I missing something here??????? 😡.

And Kashara, thank you for speaking your mind and THANK YOU for your point input. She clearly had thought it out, and when confronted with a choice politely and concisely mentioned that Caroline, not Amy OR Maddie, should be point. But nope, guess Kelli just disregarded that advice and stuck with seniority. Like come on TPTB. This woman was point for two years in a row above dancers like Lacey. Please tell me you at least took this piece of advice somewhat seriously.

Oh, while I'm on a "rant," why did Meredith make the team? Look, I get it. I'm a guy. She's gorgeous. But she can't do the choreography and cries ... like more than teen Brianna from S12 did.

Sigh .... Um. Good points?

I think Kelcey and Chandi are very pretty. Rachel W. is very good looking. I was impressed with Hannah as usual, and Daphne is starting to grow on me. Also felt Alexendria's goodbye was very classy. Good for her.

I dunno guys. Maybe I'm overreacting. But then again, maybe not 😑.

Edited September 14, 2019 by Lona

[kalibean]

I’m still so mad for Jaylyn. Has anyone ever been on show group then dropped the next year? And she was SG as a rookie! Editing was insanely choppy, but still. So upsetting. 

[Agent Gully]

I'm putting my thoughts after finally watching the show (at 6am, lol) here so I don't accidentally post a spoiler.

* Kelli reminded me tonight of why I have never been particularly fond of her. She is the type who takes everything very personally and then holds it against a person throughout eternity. When Jalyn needed a few moments to quietly compose herself, Kelli acted as though it was a personal insult to her. It was good to see the Judi understood why Jalyn was upset. To me, Kelli doesn't have any true warmth unless you are her special pet. 

We didn't get to see what the other judges said about Jalyn for the most part. The only thing I can see is that her current hair color washes her out a bit and doesn't allow her face to shine through. Something brighter might bring out her eyes and smile more.

I noted that while they were in the studio that Kelli mentioned the past triangle as "infamous". I think she needs a dictionary as infamous means well known for some bad quality or deed!

[Weeklydcc]

8 hours ago, Reveala said:

Ahhh-mazed that Kat handed over wigs for them to presumably color and cut. I would think she'd have to wear them while they do it, but I guess not. They looked new and must be expensive. BTW, did former vet Jaycee dance with the natural curls she was wearing tonight?

Apparently black girls can't don their naturally kinky/curly hair, but weaves and wigs are fine.  Sad really.

And might I add that Jacie looks much better with her natural hair style.

Edited September 14, 2019 by Weeklydcc
Added comment

[BCrabby]

9 hours ago, Tootie said:

I enjoyed the part where KaShara picked who she thought would be a good point:  Amy! No, wait.... Maddie!  No, wrong again!  Caroline!  😄

Quite surprising that she didn’t choose her former roommate “best friend” Heather.  

[lkxydhfinl ghsdv]

4 minutes ago, BCrabby said:

Quite surprising that she didn’t choose her former roommate “best friend” Heather.  

And that's why I respect her opinion.  She didn't pick seniority OR her best friend.  She was honest and picked who she thought would be the best person for that position!

[dreamcatcher]

3 hours ago, Lona said:

So y'all, get this: Jalyn is now "toxic"!!!! Did you hear that. That's right. Being upset and excusing herself so as to not cause a scene was a selfish and "unprofessional" thing to do apparently. As opposed to what, Kelli? Causing a scene in the middle of practice?!?!?!?

No, as opposed to mopping Kelli’s desk with her hair. Now that’s a mature and professional way of handling rejection!

Did Kelli ever give a reason why Jalyn lost her spot? Even a stupid thing like you were outdanced even though we could all see she wasn’t?

so much for point not being important to the girls and it’s just us making a big deal out of it...

[njcate]

On 9/5/2019 at 9:46 PM, scorpio1031 said:

I don't blame them.  Kelli make a big deal about earning your boots and your vet status, and it should be a big deal if you can come back year after year and work hard to regain your spot.  And I feel sorry for the other rookies getting pushed aside or made to look bad for VK's sake.

I'd be curious to know what the alumni think.

Agreed agreed agreed!

just wanted to add on that it will be VERY interesting to see how many girls retire after this season!!! 

Just now, njcate said:

Agreed agreed agreed!

just wanted to add on that it will be VERY interesting to see how many girls retire after this season!!! 

Sorry - disregard my comment - it's actually a duplicate from something I posted a couple weeks ago - I spazzed out trying to post my actual comment. 

[njcate]

My opinion: I've never felt strongly about Kashara one way or the other - until last night!

Kashara would make a great director for the DCC!!  Maybe if they had someone like her running things then some of these ultra talented girls would stay longer than 2 years! 

It is evident that Kelli has zero insight into how UNPROFESSIONAL SHE is behaving. 

Apparently anyone on the squad can be referred to as toxic except herself and the spawn of her BFF ! 

[ByTor]

2 hours ago, kalibean said:

I’m still so mad for Jaylyn. Has anyone ever been on show group then dropped the next year? And she was SG as a rookie! Editing was insanely choppy, but still. So upsetting. 

I think @LaurenBrook posted a while back that this happened to Emma.

[ElenaFR]

Re-watching the episode today and based on the little material they showed us, Jalyn wad not out danced. She had great technique.

She is striking. There is definitely something going on that us commoners just aren't privy to.

[Jess14]

Well, I 100% believe the insiders about the Jalyn/VK debacle after watching that. Kelli came off terribly IMO, and it’s clear that there was something else underlying Jalyn’s cut. 

What I thought was the worst though wasn’t the “toxic” or “unprofessional” talk, but the fact that Jalyn was all but pleading with K&J for more information about why she was cut from show group, and they refused to give her information (based on what was shown) and instead pivoted to the vague, “no one is safe” bs. If she got cut for dance reasons, she needs to know that. If she got cut for non-dance reasons (even if it was something petty as has been alleged), then own your pettiness, and tell her that. Instead, Kelli sat there and let her walk out of the room with no more info than she had when she came in. Ugh! That scene reminded me so much of the Jenna/point convo a few years back, which I also thought was a low point. 

If I were Jalyn, I would be looking  at other options next year. 

I enjoyed Kashara. I didn’t know she did choreography. Now, I’m side-eyeing the “best of the best” type comments that they keep making about her. She was good, but puh-lease! However, I think she’s great in the type of capacity that she was in last night. Unlike other guests who seem to intimidate the girls, she brings a really positive energy into the room. 

[MsTBGal]

OK, not many posts yet about the continuation of "The Meredith Show."  I just would like to know which Cowboy big-wig's wife's second cousin twice removed best friend's daughter's next-door neighbors's uncle she is related?!?  😂   Certainly tongue-in-cheek, but really, even among all the Jalyn disappointment, CMT and TPTB cannot give us a break from Meredith.  Whyyyyyyyyy?

[Agent Gully]

2 minutes ago, DCCdazzle said:

OK, not many posts yet about the continuation of "The Meredith Show."  I just would like to know which Cowboy big-wig's wife's second cousin twice removed best friend's daughter's next-door neighbors's uncle she is related?!?  😂   Certainly tongue-in-cheek, but really, even among all the Jalyn disappointment, CMT and TPTB cannot give us a break from Meredith.  Whyyyyyyyyy?

I guess they plan to annoy us each week by alternating between the Kat Show and the Meredith Show.

[MirabelMadrigal]

I think Jalyn knew that she didn't make SG because of something Victoria said. During her meeting with K & J she referenced being worried it was about something other than her performance during SG auditions. I feel so bad for her. Major boo on Kelli for not having the grace to let Jalyn have a moment. I think Kelli was having some guilt that she was projecting back onto Jalyn. The editing was horrendous for this episode. So bad that in the previews they made it seem like Cheryl didn't like Jalyn. Totally and intentionally misleading. I honestly don't know how Jalyn has chosen to stay on the team after this blatant BS.

[Route66]

5 minutes ago, DCCdazzle said:

OK, not many posts yet about the continuation of "The Meredith Show."  I just would like to know which Cowboy big-wig's wife's second cousin twice removed best friend's daughter's next-door neighbors's uncle she is related?!?  😂   Certainly tongue-in-cheek, but really, even among all the Jalyn disappointment, CMT and TPTB cannot give us a break from Meredith.  Whyyyyyyyyy?

It's definitely weird to think that Kelli is an executive producer of the show, meaning she must have input into editing and what's shown or not. Meredith is terrible. There have been tons of girls cut in the past [Rachel Buckmaster comes to mind] who were trained technical dancers in lyrical or ballet who were unable to pick up the DCC power pom style. Meredith can not, and they're not showing anything by way of positive attitude or showmanship. There have been an infinite number of times where a girl makes a mistake and Kelli, Judy, or a guest teacher says "You made a mistake but you sold it", indicating she didn't cry or freak out or fall apart. Meredith is just a mess.

[dreamcatcher]

44 minutes ago, njcate said:

My opinion: I've never felt strongly about Kashara one way or the other - until last night!

Kashara would make a great director for the DCC!!  Maybe if they had someone like her running things then some of these ultra talented girls would stay longer than 2 years! 

It is evident that Kelli has zero insight into how UNPROFESSIONAL SHE is behaving. 

Apparently anyone on the squad can be referred to as toxic except herself and the spawn of her BFF ! 

Isn’t it unbelievable that someone who just retired from the team was able to choose a better point than the long-standing director?

26 minutes ago, Jess14 said:

Well, I 100% believe the insiders about the Jalyn/VK debacle after watching that. Kelli came off terribly IMO, and it’s clear that there was something else underlying Jalyn’s cut. 

What I thought was the worst though wasn’t the “toxic” or “unprofessional” talk, but the fact that Jalyn was all but pleading with K&J for more information about why she was cut from show group, and they refused to give her information (based on what was shown) and instead pivoted to the vague, “no one is safe” bs. If she got cut for dance reasons, she needs to know that. If she got cut for non-dance reasons (even if it was something petty as has been alleged), then own your pettiness, and tell her that. Instead, Kelli sat there and let her walk out of the room with no more info than she had when she came in. Ugh! That scene reminded me so much of the Jenna/point convo a few years back, which I also thought was a low point. 

If I were Jalyn, I would be looking  at other options next year. 

I enjoyed Kashara. I didn’t know she did choreography. Now, I’m side-eyeing the “best of the best” type comments that they keep making about her. She was good, but puh-lease! However, I think she’s great in the type of capacity that she was in last night. Unlike other guests who seem to intimidate the girls, she brings a really positive energy into the room. 

If they had legit reasons, they would’ve told her. They didn’t say anything because clearly kelli doesn’t want to say on camera anything that will be traced back to her precious VK.

[Pau84]

1 hour ago, njcate said:

My opinion: I've never felt strongly about Kashara one way or the other - until last night!

Kashara would make a great director for the DCC!!  Maybe if they had someone like her running things then some of these ultra talented girls would stay longer than 2 years! 

It is evident that Kelli has zero insight into how UNPROFESSIONAL SHE is behaving. 

Apparently anyone on the squad can be referred to as toxic except herself and the spawn of her BFF ! 

I agree.

Kelli is being unprofessional as hell with her abuse of power. There is NO reason for cutting Jalyn, no objective reason which could be validated by others. Pure subjectiveness covered by an untolerable blanket statement: ‘toxic’.

You could attack and take out anyone with ‘she is being toxic’ reason. 

Kelli is there to manage the team, NOT to live out her emotions on innocent girls, who are subject to the worst BS and nepotism I have seen on TV.

Jalyn should realize that her talent can’t beat irrational BS, and that she is at the mercy of an incredible unprofessionalism. The fact that she is still on the team is a proof of what kind of professional she really is. 

Melissa Wallace, Megan Carcioppolo, Maggie Rouse, Amy Trader, all left before their time, and we can add Jalyn to this list.

[Opine]

12 hours ago, Erinbridget said:

Okay, K & J, WHY COULDN'T YOU HAVE LISTENED TO KASHARA AND PUT CAROLINE AT POINT?!

Maybe because Kelly doesn't know her name.  She called her Carolyn not Caroline.  Oh, but she's still calling Jalyn Jay-Lynn even after being corrected last season.  Out of touch much, Kells?

[Agent Gully]

12 minutes ago, Pau84 said:

Kelli is there to manage the team, NOT to live out her emotions on innocent girls, who are subject to the worst BS and nepotism I have seen on TV.

I wish I could like this statement 1,000 times. Beautifully said!

[DAthene]

I hate that they announce show group at practice now. They used to do it that night and it gave the girls a chance to process their disappointment before having to perform.  This is just heartless.

[ElenaFR]

1 minute ago, DAthene said:

I hate that they announce show group at practice now. They used to do it that night and it gave the girls a chance to process their disappointment before having to perform.  This is just heartless.

Agree. 

[Loves2Dance]

Kelli is a toxic mean girl. This isn't a secret and I stopped giving her the benefit of the doubt ages ago. 

I did appreciate Judy standing up for her, but to be frank, Judy was in the room when SG positions were chosen and Judy made the choice not to call her name. She could have added her as the 19th position just like we got a 37 person triangle. Judy's lack of integrity and ability to stand up to Kelli is appalling and it's on Judy to stand up to that. I lost all respect for her last year---not just with the editing for the show, but her rant at the fans for not 'understanding'. Hello, I understand---you work for a mean girl, now grow a back bone.

Jalyn's words were measured and anxious. She knows why she was cut from SG and she knows she can't call Kelli out for it. The sad part is that she stayed. 

I hate to compare anything to domestic violence because domestic violence is gross; but watching Jalyn essentially beg for her uniform reminded me of a battered wife begging her abusive husband to take her back and how sorry she is for upsetting him in the first place. The DCC system is, at it's core, toxic and unfortunately, the root cause is the director.

I understand the 'best of the best' mentality---unfortunately, when you have that style of mentality, abusive tendencies tend to get overlooked and excused as 'this is what it takes.' There is not a single sport that hasn't had this type of situation happen whether it was a single team or the entire federation (*cough* USAG *cough*). 

It is going to take the girls standing up, much like they did when Jones took over, to see any real progress and I just don't see that happening. The smart and educated leave because they see through the bullshit quicker and the others don't have the perspective in the moment.

I'm not a Cowboys fan, and frankly, I've only been a fan of this show because I love dance---and while I continue to sometimes remember to watch, I'm mostly over it. I'll hate watch when I'm bored, but continuing to watch these women get beat down and abused over and over again, season after season (though it used to be way more subtle) is just...not entertaining.  

Edited September 14, 2019 by Loves2Dance

[5678Pixie]

7 minutes ago, Loves2Dance said:

Kelli is a toxic mean girl. This isn't a secret and I stopped giving her the benefit of the doubt ages ago. 

I did appreciate Judy standing up for her, but to be frank, Judy was in the room when SG positions were chosen and Judy made the choice not to call her name. She could have added her as the 19th position just like we got a 37 person triangle. Judy's lack of integrity and ability to stand up to Kelli is appalling and it's on Judy to stand up to that. I lost all respect for her last year---not just with the editing for the show, but her rant at the fans for not 'understanding'. Hello, I understand---you work for a mean girl, now grow a back bone.

Jalyn's words were measured and anxious. She knows why she was cut from SG and she knows she can't call Kelli out for it. The sad part is that she stayed. 

I hate to compare anything to domestic violence because domestic violence is gross; but watching Jalyn essentially beg for her uniform reminded me of a battered wife begging her abusive husband to take her back and how sorry she is for upsetting him in the first place. The DCC system is, at it's core, toxic and unfortunately, the root cause is the director.

I understand the 'best of the best' mentality---unfortunately, when you have that style of mentality, abusive tendencies tend to get overlooked and excused as 'this is what it takes.' There is not a single sport that hasn't had this type of situation happen whether it was a single team or the entire federal (*cough* USAG *cough*). 

It is going to take the girls standing up, much like they did when Jones took over, to see any real progress and I just don't see that happening. The smart and educated leave because they see through the bullshit quicker and the others don't have the perspective in the moment.

I'm not a Cowboys fan, and frankly, I've only been a fan of this show because I love dance---and while I continue to sometimes remember to watch, I'm mostly over it. I'll hate watch when I'm bored, but continuing to watch these women get beat down and abused over and over again, season after season (though it used to be way more subtle) is just...not entertaining.  

Kelli is more than a mean girl she is a bully.  Last year she was so mean to  Heather and she stayed too.  

[Loves2Dance]

4 minutes ago, 5678Pixie said:

Kelli is more than a mean girl she is a bully.  Last year she was so mean to  Heather and she stayed too.  

I know what happened in Heather's situation and I'm not sure I agree. What Kelli did to Heather, imo, was justified because she was protecting the brand should the issue blow up. Where Kelli failed is in not telling Heather that is what she was doing or why she did it. 

And that is Kelli's consistent MO. It's like, if she tells the girls why they're in trouble she is worried that they'll come at her with facts and evidence that she's wrong so instead of giving them the ability to challenge her; she just gives them that look like they should know and refuses to elaborate. 

[nancy444]

On 9/7/2019 at 1:23 PM, MTTFan said:

Ummm I am not sure why dancers like Meredith or Kat made the team especially if there were so many quality dancers coming through that K&J could take their pic.  Meredith and Kat would have never made the team even as alternates. They are medicore at best.  After Charmin again, I have to agree with her assessment that the last three groups she looked at were awful and should have been cut -- my only disagreement with her - Kat, I never would have given her a sticker much less two.

On the other hand, given the obviously shrinking numbers showing up to try out means mathematically that fewer rock star dancers are showing up.  Shrinking numbers means less rock stars are auditioning and making the squad.  This explains, IMHO, why dancers like Kat and Meredith made the squad, why dancers like Christina are still on the squad and why Maddie is point.

Yes, exactly my point.  Perhaps because I'm not a dancer, I don't know how to discern the "technical" dancers from the others.  However, I do know what I enjoy watching, and up until recently, I thought the DCC had been very clear on the mission of its "brand". 

 Not so much anymore.

Let's face it: we're not tuning in to see the Bolshoi Ballet perform Swan Lake here, guys.  Presumably, we're all here to 1) see rock star performers who are very beautiful and fit dance around a stadium, 2) remember fondly how long its been since any of us had enough self-esteem to leave the house wearing a bikini, and 3) speculate what kind of dark magic allows their hair and makeup to look just as pristine in double-overtime as it did when they first pranced out of the tunnel 5 hours earlier.

If this latest mediocre iteration of the DCC is a deliberate a result (as some posters suggested) of "only the truly good dancers trying out anymore", then I say, "Bring back the 'sub-par' dancers like Kelsi Reich, Ashton Torres, and Brooke Sorensen!"  My eyes can do without staring at the "excellence" of Amy, Gina, and VK.

This is why "So You Think You Can Dance" has been such a hit.  The judges help the audience along by weeding out the worst dancers, but when it gets to the Top 10 or so, they let America decide who they enjoy watching the most, NOT who is the most advanced technical dancer.  Did less "technically capable" dancers win in past seasons? You betcha.  But the title they win is "America's Favorite Dancer", NOT "America's Most Technically Trained and Talented Dancer".

Kelly, Inc. should take that to heart.

[Opine]

Jalyn, You are a great dancer and have the support of many, many fans.  This too shall pass.  Finish the year, retire, and then go get a better dance job.  You will always be introduced as a dancer that was successful on not one but two NFL teams.  You will also have the many special friends and relationships you made as a DCC.  Don't succumb to this BS after this year.  Color your hair the way you want and go out and be successful and show them!  And, btw, if you want to write a tell all book, you could make a killing.  :)!

[TUOwl84]

Let's not forget that TPTB took more girls this year in Show Group.  So no reason for Jalyn's cut from show group this year.  She actually had a better chance making it because they took more girls. 

I wouldn't like it if Jalyn retired after this year, but I understand why she would.  She is one of my top 3 rookies from last year and one of my favorite veterans this year.  

And WHY couldn't we get Caroline at point this year? 🙄

[Booboo]

Kashara would add so much to the show. She is funny, spot on and cute!! CMT needs to at least replace her with Melissa Rycroft, who comes across “drippy” on the show.

[SmpIsimon]

Jalyn’s cut was to send a message to others not to in any way question or criticize VK. 

[Holly85]

2 minutes ago, SmpIsimon said:

Jalyn’s cut was to send a message to others not to in any way question or criticize VK. 

I think a lot of ladies will retire after this season on being jalyn