Josh & Anna Smuggar: A Series of Unfortunate Events

[hathorlive]

On 1/4/2022 at 5:53 PM, Quilt Fairy said:

At least he was making sure she had an income stream while he was inside.

@hathorlive, now that the trial is behind us, do you have any final thoughts on the evidence presented, the defense arguments, etc.? 

I guess that's one way to make sure the baby gets diapers.  But since you are told that the line is monitored, it's a pretty dumb way to do it.

I am going to withhold judgment until I read the transcripts. I think the defense did the best they could do with the stupid client they had, but Josh just buried himself by talking without his lawyer present.  No sane person was going to let a guy who says "are you here about the CP?" go free.  I do think the Prosecution had an amazing case, but there's always the fear that you talk above the jury's head and lose some of them in the process.  I won't know what the transcripts will show, but the failure to interrogate the router was massive mistake. That should have been fixed by putting the forensics guy back on the stand and asking him what a router does and does it have any static memory. And then point out that the router was not seized and the defense expert could mosey over to Josh's and look at it any old time.    And keep reiterating that router's don't store data. If the router was password protected, the HSI guys should have gone into the router and shown that it was locked and needed a password. Screenshots, guys.  Screenshots. 

I said since day one that if they allowed the testimony about his molestation of the sisters into the trail, Josh was done.  There was no coming back from what he said, what he did in the past and what he downloaded.

I'll add more when I get ahold of the transcrips.

Edited January 11, 2022 by hathorlive
spelling matters

[FizzyPuff]

I could see Josh liking therapy getting to sit in a room and talk about himself, what more could he want. 

[Snow Fairy]

I forgot, when is Josh's sentencing?

[ginger90]

2 hours ago, Snow Fairy said:

I forgot, when is Josh's sentencing?

I don’t believe a date has been set. It will probably be some time in April.

[Snow Fairy]

Thank you. I don't know why I thought it would be somewhere in January. 

[madpsych78]

Jana had a court date scheduled for January; since then, she pled guilty so court date didn't happen.

[DXD526]

The FF basically confessing to the feds when they showed up at the car lot is referenced here a lot, but what took place, exactly? Did they show him their badges, and he immediately asked if they were there because someone downloaded CP? Is he really that stupid? Is it on record exactly what he said and when he said it?

[GeeGolly]

13 minutes ago, DXD526 said:

The FF basically confessing to the feds when they showed up at the car lot is referenced here a lot, but what took place, exactly? Did they show him their badges, and he immediately asked if they were there because someone downloaded CP? Is he really that stupid? Is it on record exactly what he said and when he said it?

A detective testified that Josh agreed to talk with them when the arrived at the car lot. While getting ready to start the interview Josh asked, is this because someone downloaded child pornography?

[Rootbeer]

26 minutes ago, DXD526 said:

The FF basically confessing to the feds when they showed up at the car lot is referenced here a lot, but what took place, exactly? Did they show him their badges, and he immediately asked if they were there because someone downloaded CP? Is he really that stupid? Is it on record exactly what he said and when he said it?

As noted above, yes, he really is that stupid.  He also agreed to answer questions before saying it, without consulting an attorney, let alone having one present.  While sitting in the cop's car, not in a formal setting. So, he really wins the gold medal for stupid on this one.

[MargeGunderson]

I love that Josh got caught for being not only a consumer of CS materials, but also for being stupid. I suspect that the latter bothers him more.

[TeeVeeWatcher]

2 hours ago, GeeGolly said:

A detective testified that Josh agreed to talk with them when the arrived at the car lot. While getting ready to start the interview Josh asked, is this because someone downloaded child pornography?

Perhaps the detective testified as to what his response is (and I've missed it) but I would love to have been a fly on the wall if nothing more than to see the look on the detective's face when Josh replied!

[Rootbeer]

7 minutes ago, TeeVeeWatcher said:

Perhaps the detective testified as to what his response is (and I've missed it) but I would love to have been a fly on the wall if nothing more than to see the look on the detective's face when Josh replied!

He probably felt like he'd won the lottery.  It doesn't get much easier than this.

[GeeGolly]

3 hours ago, TeeVeeWatcher said:

Perhaps the detective testified as to what his response is (and I've missed it) but I would love to have been a fly on the wall if nothing more than to see the look on the detective's face when Josh replied!

I'm not sure what his response was, but for some reason I think he said we'll get to why we're here in a minute and then proceeded to formally get the interview going, including recording it.

But... I may be making this up. 🤷🏽‍♂️

[Cinnabon]

Why is Josh calling Hilaria from jail???

As for phone calls, inmates can only make outgoing collect calls and cannot receive incoming ones, according to Washington County Jail. 

The Sun confirmed the phone numbers listed through public records. They were also confirmed by The SoJo Files. 

Josh made 64 calls to Anna from December 10, 2021 to December 30, 2021, as some of the calls failed. 

He successfully called dad Jim Bob twice on December 26 and once on December 29. 

He spoke to his mom Michelle on December 14 for almost four minutes. 

Josh also had three successful calls with Michelle on December 21, one on December 22 and another on December 25. 

Josh called brother Jed twice before he picked up on the third try. 

They talked for over 16 minutes on December 21.

Other calls include to his younger brother Justin’s in-laws Robert and Hilary Spivey, family member David Waller and his lawyer Travis Story. 

https://www.the-sun.com/entertainment/4440987/josh-duggar-anna-jail-calls-child-pornography-guilty/

 

[emmawoodhouse]

Pa Spivey was the director of the IBLP post in Little Rock that Smuggar was sent to way back when. It might explain their presence at the trial. 

Edited January 12, 2022 by emmawoodhouse

[GeeGolly]

15 minutes ago, Cinnabon said:

Why is Josh calling Hilaria from jail???

As for phone calls, inmates can only make outgoing collect calls and cannot receive incoming ones, according to Washington County Jail. 

The Sun confirmed the phone numbers listed through public records. They were also confirmed by The SoJo Files. 

Josh made 64 calls to Anna from December 10, 2021 to December 30, 2021, as some of the calls failed. 

He successfully called dad Jim Bob twice on December 26 and once on December 29. 

He spoke to his mom Michelle on December 14 for almost four minutes. 

Josh also had three successful calls with Michelle on December 21, one on December 22 and another on December 25. 

Josh called brother Jed twice before he picked up on the third try. 

They talked for over 16 minutes on December 21.

Other calls include to his younger brother Justin’s in-laws Robert and Hilary Spivey, family member David Waller and his lawyer Travis Story. 

https://www.the-sun.com/entertainment/4440987/josh-duggar-anna-jail-calls-child-pornography-guilty/

 

Maybe to thank her for her support and because he's bored AF?

[Zella]

Maybe Josh finds her as bizarrely entertaining as we do. 

As for the detective's response to Josh's "are you here because someone's been downloading child pornography" moment, I'm pretty sure they said in court or in the motions that they tried to caution him to not say anything until they'd started recording. 

Edited January 12, 2022 by Zella

[jschoolgirl]

https://www.the-sun.com/entertainment/4409825/josh-duggar-jail-gifts-food-child-pornography-guilty/

I cracked up at the pickles! 

SINCE HE'S BEAN GONE 

Josh Duggar’s family & fans can send him ‘gifts’ in jail including Cheetos, pickles, refried beans & more

 

 

[ChiCricket]

13 minutes ago, jschoolgirl said:

https://www.the-sun.com/entertainment/4409825/josh-duggar-jail-gifts-food-child-pornography-guilty/

I cracked up at the pickles! 

SINCE HE'S BEAN GONE 

Josh Duggar’s family & fans can send him ‘gifts’ in jail including Cheetos, pickles, refried beans & more

 

 

OMGosh I always thought being in jail would suck, but after seeing this:

"The jail also offers the A.M. Delight Care Pack for $44. 

This includes two instant coffee packets, five cappuccino packets, five hot chocolate packets, one creamer" <snip>

 I think the worst possible punishment would be NO coffee when I felt like having it! 

 I get terrible caffeine withdrawal headaches when I try and go cold-turkey, so I always fall off the wagon.

(I hope FF got the worst headache ever.) 😁 

Edited January 12, 2022 by ChiCricket

[iwantcookies]

11 minutes ago, ChiCricket said:

OMGosh I always thought being in jail would suck, but after seeing this:

"The jail also offers the A.M. Delight Care Pack for $44. 

This includes two instant coffee packets, five cappuccino packets, five hot chocolate packets, one creamer" <snip>

 I think the worst possible punishment would be NO coffee when I felt like having it! 

 I get terrible caffeine withdrawal headaches when I try and go cold-turkey, so I always fall off the wagon.

(I hope FF got the worst headache ever.) 😁 

FF=fat felon? Or is it something else?

[crazycatlady58]

1 hour ago, iwantcookies said:

FF=fat felon? Or is it something else?

I think it is family felon.

[CalicoKitty]

Does the prison accommodate special diets for people with food allergies?  Looking at the "gift packs", there is nothing that I would eat.  I have a wheat allergy, and I do not like coffee (at all).  I also do not like chocolate.  I guess it is good that I am not planning to go to jail.

[MsJamieDornan]

6 hours ago, Cinnabon said:

As for phone calls, inmates can only make outgoing collect calls and cannot receive incoming ones, according to Washington County Jail. 

Wait until they see what a collect call from jail costs.

[FizzyPuff]

The article says that fans can send him gifts, what fans? 

[iwantcookies]

16 minutes ago, FizzyPuff said:

The article says that fans can send him gifts, what fans? 

Hilaria?

[iwantcookies]

4 hours ago, CalicoKitty said:

Does the prison accommodate special diets for people with food allergies?  Looking at the "gift packs", there is nothing that I would eat.  I have a wheat allergy, and I do not like coffee (at all).  I also do not like chocolate.  I guess it is good that I am not planning to go to jail.

I would think yes. 

[SMama]

1 hour ago, FizzyPuff said:

The article says that fans can send him gifts, what fans? 

You’d be surprised at the amount of fools who will keep the Fucking Felon well stocked with snacks.

Edited January 12, 2022 by SMama

[merylinkid]

How do they know WHO he talked to?   He called a number.   Who he talked to is not part of the record I would think.   The calls are recorded but those records are not released to the general public.   

I mean if my hubby wants to talk to his dad, he calls his Mom's cell phone.   Because Dad never picks up.   So even if the Felon is calling a cellphone there is no guarantee that is who he is talking to.  

[Ijustwantsomechips]

8 hours ago, crazycatlady58 said:

I think it is family felon.

Ha! I was thinking Fat Fuck.

[GeeGolly]

1 hour ago, merylinkid said:

How do they know WHO he talked to?   He called a number.   Who he talked to is not part of the record I would think.   The calls are recorded but those records are not released to the general public.   

I mean if my hubby wants to talk to his dad, he calls his Mom's cell phone.   Because Dad never picks up.   So even if the Felon is calling a cellphone there is no guarantee that is who he is talking to.  

Maybe the name indicates who Josh says he is trying to reach?

[dariafan]

Can we get together and write a book called how to NOT be a shitty person and then send him a copy ??

[Zella]

10 minutes ago, dariafan said:

Can we get together and write a book called how to NOT be a shitty person and then send him a copy ??

If someone doesn't instinctively know that downloading and viewing CSAM and assaulting their siblings makes them a shitty person, I doubt a whole book devoted to the topic is going to do them much good. 

[ALittleShelfish]

9 hours ago, FizzyPuff said:

The article says that fans can send him gifts, what fans? 

The list is endless!  

JKLOL it just has Anna's name on it from 1 thru infinity. 

[Teriacky]

Calico Kitty isn’t planning on going to jail/prison but then again, neither was Josh…

[GeeGolly]

Josh being so casual about mentioning CP makes me realize how 'casual' he felt about it. Like it wasn't much different than say, setting an odometer back.

He really is a scary, cold hearted, psychopathic excuse for a human being.

[Rootbeer]

3 minutes ago, GeeGolly said:

Josh being so casual about mentioning CP makes me realize how 'casual' he felt about it. Like it wasn't much different than say, setting an odometer back.

He really is a scary, cold hearted, psychopathic excuse for a human being.

Josh really seems to think this was NBD and 'everybody does it' just as he was taught that it is only natural for teen boys to molest their sisters.

[SusanM]

10 minutes ago, GeeGolly said:

Josh being so casual about mentioning CP makes me realize how 'casual' he felt about it. Like it wasn't much different than say, setting an odometer back.

 

I felt that this was the attitude most of his family were taking as well.  After the verdict many of them posted about how their thoughts and sympathy went out to victims of CP but I dunno, maybe some of this was sincere but not all of it.  I really had the impression that the Duggars, en masse, think this was all much ado about nothing much.

[MargeGunderson]

10 minutes ago, SusannahM said:

I felt that this was the attitude most of his family were taking as well.  After the verdict many of them posted about how their thoughts and sympathy went out to victims of CP but I dunno, maybe some of this was sincere but not all of it.  I really had the impression that the Duggars, en masse, think this was all much ado about nothing much.

I think that they make a distinction between the people who do the abuse vs Josh, who just looked at it.* The Duggars are very black and white in their thinking for everything EXCEPT when it comes to themselves and people who subscribe to the same belief systems; that’s when they are willing to be more morally flexible. 

*Nope, if you look at CSA materials you are a piece of crap

[merylinkid]

3 hours ago, GeeGolly said:

Josh being so casual about mentioning CP makes me realize how 'casual' he felt about it. Like it wasn't much different than say, setting an odometer back.

He really is a scary, cold hearted, psychopathic excuse for a human being.

When all sin is the same, then yes to him it is no worse than setting an odometer back or cursing or whatever.

[Fosca]

I'm watching an old episode of COPS, and a cop is searching a car and pulls out a pill, and the driver says "Wait, is that a Xanax . . . . . . . . . . . . or a Tylenol?  It's a Tylenol."  It wasn't a Tylenol, and he went to jail.  I laughed so hard my cat got scared.  Guess Smuggar isn't alone in this sort of stupidity.

[GeeGolly]

3 minutes ago, merylinkid said:

When all sin is the same, then yes to him it is no worse than setting an odometer back or cursing or whatever.

But even though they say that, we all know they don't believe it.

They commit sins all the time, yet no one but Josh is in jail. If all sins are the same, then more uber Fundies would be in jail.

[DXD526]

When I used FF, I was thinking Family Felon, but Fat Fuck is good, too! How about FFF, Fat Felonious Fuck?

Any combination works for me!

[JoanArc]

Quote

Cheetos, pickles, refried beans & more

Ah, the 'Diarrhea Sampler".

[iwantcookies]

Maybe Jill Rodrigues should send him some plexus 😂

He is Nathan Keller’s bil 😂

[Xena]

13 hours ago, Fosca said:

I'm watching an old episode of COPS, and a cop is searching a car and pulls out a pill, and the driver says "Wait, is that a Xanax . . . . . . . . . . . . or a Tylenol?  It's a Tylenol."  It wasn't a Tylenol, and he went to jail.  I laughed so hard my cat got scared.  Guess Smuggar isn't alone in this sort of stupidity.

Hee!   My favorite from old Cops is when the officer is asking the guy he pulled over if there are any drugs in the car or on his person.  The guy is insisting there is nothing ... while the cameraman slowly zooms in on the joint he has wedged on top of his ear (like a pencil).

Joshie is dumber than a box of rocks.

[BetyBee]

3 hours ago, iwantcookies said:

Maybe Jill Rodrigues should send him some plexus 😂

He is Nathan Keller’s bil 😂

Jill's not giving away her precious miracle drink!

[JoanArc]

15 hours ago, iwantcookies said:

Maybe Jill Rodrigues should send him some plexus 😂

 

“Lose enough weight to just slide through the prison bars!”

[marleyfan]

On 1/11/2022 at 6:25 AM, Snow Fairy said:

I don't know why I thought it would be somewhere in January.

I think Josh's appeal has to be filed in January

[Rabbittron]

I can't wait until he gets sentenced and Blob objects I  don't accept that Prison where he is going to. Do you? 

[Tikichick]

13 hours ago, marleyfan said:

I think Josh's appeal has to be filed in January

I believe the appeals clock timeline starts running after sentencing. 

ETA:  The sentencing phase can also open up additional avenues for appeal, which is another reason why the appellate phase begins after sentencing takes place.

Edited January 14, 2022 by Tikichick