meep.meep November 1, 2020 Share November 1, 2020 3 hours ago, Kohola3 said: Sure, they are in the dill pickle section. So it's OK to be booted out of the competition because of a personal dislike by a judge? Sorry, I don't think that's fair at all. The ironic thing about Paul's aversion to pickles is that the Japanese love pickles. I've been served a course of nothing but pickles at a high end Japanese restaurant. Not just pickled cucumbers, they pickle anything. Wikipedia says: Tsukemono (漬物, literally "pickled things") are Japanese preserved vegetables (usually pickled in salt, brine, or a bed of rice bran). They are served with rice as an okazu (side dish), with drinks as an otsumami (snack), as an accompaniment to or garnish for meals, and as a course in the kaiseki portion of a Japanese tea ceremony. Seems like for "Japan week" he could suck it up. 1 4 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6429349
Irlandesa November 1, 2020 Share November 1, 2020 34 minutes ago, Danny Franks said: I can't think of an example - ever - where someone was booted just because a judge didn't like an ingredient they used. I can think of plenty of examples of one or the other judge saying they didn't like the flavour of a certain ingredient, but still offering valid criticism. But when you ask two people to judge your food, you're asking for a subjective assessment. If they really hate what it tastes like, it doesn't matter if you or your friends love it, it doesn't matter if 90% of the world would love it, the people who are judging it didn't. Right. Take salt, for example. There are people who who are more sensitive to the taste of salt based on simple genetics and what you've trained your palette to accept. For instance, I lived in another city for a while where restaurants seemed to add more salt to the foods than I normally do. It's why you can have Paul saying it's lacking seasoning salt while Prue thinks it's perfect. 28 minutes ago, Kohola3 said: Exactly my point. If a judge is predetermined to hate what you make based on an ingredient, you should at least have fair warning so as not to include it. Honestly, I think most judges are more careful when they taste an ingredient they hate because they know they hate it and are afraid of being unfair. 1 5 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6429362
chaifan November 1, 2020 Share November 1, 2020 1 hour ago, Brookside said: Back to the show, when Laura was crying, it struck me that we don't see tears much on GBBO. Back when Mel & Sue were on, someone said in an interview that if a baker started crying they would just start swearing up a storm. It ruined the footage so it couldn't be used. 2 3 12 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6429387
Adiba November 1, 2020 Share November 1, 2020 1 hour ago, Suzn said: The gherkins I buy are small dill pickles. I don't remember seeing any sweet pickles called gherkins. For me they are preferable to large dill pickles because they are crisp. You can get sweet or tart gherkins (like cornichons). My grandmother used to put out sweet gherkins with ham and cheese as an appetizer, but one could use tart or dill gherkins if they didn’t like sweet. If Paul’s aversion to gherkins was stated well in advance so that a baker had time to request another ingredient, then I think that’s fair— but not the day or minute the challenge starts. And imo, you don’t get to request a plain burger as a judge and then complain the dish is too dry. In that case, just judge the bake/ steam and taste of the bun. 1 5 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6429401
sharifa70 November 1, 2020 Share November 1, 2020 16 hours ago, leighdear said: 80's teen here too. We baked a lot of stuff. Bundt cakes were BIG, and you can't find a mix today to save your life, but most of of our moms still have their Bundt pans. Actually, I have my mom's Bundt pan. I made a Bundt cake from scratch three weeks ago! Apple cider cake with grated apples. It was delicious. Had to freeze most of it. Recently thawed a piece and drizzled warm (homemade) caramel over it and it was amazing. I’m still feeling kind of smug; my bakes can be hit or miss sometimes. Now I’m off to watch the engagement party scene from My Big Fat Greek Wedding. 13 hours ago, chaifan said: I'm a cheesecake purist - give me a slice of traditional NY style cheesecake, and that's all I need. I’m right there with you most of the time. When I was a kid I hated cheesecake until my dad made his first one (in the 80’s). His cheesecakes are legendary. He *does* do a pretty amazing one for Christmas dinner that involves a very light layer of good-quality apple butter on the bottom crust, and very thinly-sliced apples on top of that before he pours the batter over. The apple butter infuses the cake with a very subtle flavor, and I’m telling you, I’ve never been so happy that my dad discovered his love of cooking when he picked up that cheesecake pamphlet. 8 hours ago, ElectricBoogaloo said: I remember my mom steaming stuff by putting water in a large pot and then setting a very shallow bowl inside Ha! I fear that method after my dad and I ended up cleaning a gallon of clam chowder, milk, and shattered pyrex off the stove when he tried to improvise a double boiler. 1 hour ago, Brookside said: (Mary/marry/merry anyone?) All one sound to me. 1 hour ago, Brookside said: Back to the show, when Laura was crying, it struck me that we don't see tears much on GBBO. I thought the same thing. I read an article a few years ago that said Mel and Sue always ran interference when a contestant cried; they’d ruin the shots by swearing or doing other things to make the footage unsuitable for airing. I thought that was pretty badass of them. 1 5 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6429439
marinite November 1, 2020 Share November 1, 2020 12 hours ago, ElectricBoogaloo said: Honestly, this is pretty par for the course in my experience with watching British cooking shows. No matter how simple a word is in another language, the British pronunciation is usually as far from the original as possible. I mean, even simple words like taco and pasta. It's like they go out of their way to make sure it's not pronounced the same as in the native language. I have noticed the same thing. I loved watching the Two Fat Ladies series and it cracked me up that Clarissa pronounced the “j” in jalapeño as hard, like jail, and disregarded the tilde, so it ended as “peeno.” Heh. I enjoyed this week though the technical was vomit-inducing for me. It didn’t look appealing and I hate white chocolate and also Matcha. It looked like something out of a 1950s bizarre party cookbook where they used wieners and Jell-O together . 1 4 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6429449
Kromm November 1, 2020 Share November 1, 2020 (edited) 2 hours ago, chaifan said: A few seasons ago the bakers made pita bread. In America, pita is pronounced Pee-tah, hard e, like Peter. But the Brits say Pit-ah. Soft i, as in "mosh pit" or "pit helmet". So they kept saying pitah, and I had no idea what the challenge was until I saw the end result. And then I was all oooohh, Pita bread! I'm pretty sure the American pronunciation is closer to correct than the British one. The Greeks say Pee-tah. https://www.wordhippo.com/what-is/the/greek-word-for-30ef03f5156b84eb176139be8aef8132afc1f28e.html Edited November 1, 2020 by Kromm 1 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6429465
J-Man November 1, 2020 Share November 1, 2020 6 hours ago, Pepper Mostly said: Hates peanut butter, hates matcha, loves banana. Don't forget key lime! 1 2 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6429679
BradyB66 November 1, 2020 Share November 1, 2020 5 hours ago, Brookside said: Perhaps they think of crescent primarily as a type of street, as in Mornington Crescent? (Points for those who get the reference.) I'm sorry, I haven't a clue. 1 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6429706
ElectricBoogaloo November 1, 2020 Share November 1, 2020 6 hours ago, Brookside said: There is no single "authentic" pronunciation for the word pasta. Neither is there for taco. Pasta is an Italian word. Taco is Mexican. For me, the authentic pronunciation comes from the country of origin. That's why the British pronunciation of these words is so grating to my ears. I actually don't mind the sound of nails on a chalkboard, but hearing taco pronounced with a short A makes me cringe every time because it sounds so wrong to my ears. 4 hours ago, chaifan said: Back when Mel & Sue were on, someone said in an interview that if a baker started crying they would just start swearing up a storm. It ruined the footage so it couldn't be used. They also used to sing more current songs that they knew the show wouldn't pay licensing fees for (as opposed to songs in the public domain that are free) for the same reason. 1 8 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6429762
dleighg November 1, 2020 Share November 1, 2020 15 minutes ago, ElectricBoogaloo said: but hearing taco pronounced with a short A makes me cringe every time because it sounds so wrong to my ears. Maybe I'm very rusty on "short a, long a" but isn't it a short a? As in "ah" not "bane"? Or do I also pronounce it wrong? What is the a in "bath" called? It's not that one, right? 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6429784
emmawoodhouse November 1, 2020 Share November 1, 2020 Bath is short A. The ah sound is not. 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6429787
dleighg November 1, 2020 Share November 1, 2020 4 minutes ago, emmawoodhouse said: Bath is short A. The ah sound is not. thanks! I've never heard any one say taco as in "bath." Guess I'm lucky! Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6429790
emmawoodhouse November 1, 2020 Share November 1, 2020 Well, they say b-ah-th across the pond, further complicating things. 😁 4 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6429795
Kromm November 1, 2020 Share November 1, 2020 57 minutes ago, ElectricBoogaloo said: There is no single "authentic" pronunciation for the word pasta. Neither is there for taco You mean the way the people in the cultures they come from say it doesn't count? 2 6 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6429827
ElectricBoogaloo November 1, 2020 Share November 1, 2020 8 minutes ago, dleighg said: thanks! I've never heard any one say taco as in "bath." Guess I'm lucky! Ha, count yourself lucky! The first time I heard a person pronounce it that way (it was definitely on a British cooking show but I can't remember which one now), it was like a record needle scratch in my brain. If you want to subject yourself to it, this guy says it around 1:35 (if you watch the entire video, feel free to cringe at Oaxaca being spelled phonetically as Wahaca): ETA: Jamie Oliver saying it: Some fancy chef saying it: ETA 2: I grew up in San Diego so fish tacos and shrimp tacos are totally regular things to me, but for years people from outside of southern California who weren't familiar with Baja cuisine were SO GROSSED OUT by the idea of fish tacos. They would ask if it was just a frozen fish stick inside a tortilla or if it was a whole fish slapped onto a tortilla with the fish head sticking out of one end and the tail sticking out of the other end. It both cracks me up and warms my heart that mainstream and high end chefs are now making fish tacos and it's no longer considered weird. There were two chains in San Diego that specialized in fish tacos (in addition to all the mom and pop taco places that sold them): Rubio's and Fins. These two chains had completely opposite philosophies. The Fins owners said they never wanted to get so big that they couldn't personally handle the business. At their height, they had four locations. It was not uncommon to see the owners behind the counter. The owner of Rubio's said that his goal was to expand so much that you could get a fish taco anywhere in the world. I knew he was getting there when I went to Colorado in 2001 and there was a Rubio's in Denver! 1 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6429829
Kromm November 1, 2020 Share November 1, 2020 59 minutes ago, ElectricBoogaloo said: I actually don't mind the sound of nails on a chalkboard, but hearing taco pronounced with a short A makes me cringe every time because it sounds so wrong to my ears. You mean "take owe"? I agree. It actually hurts to hear it for me. Well, figuratively I guess. 1 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6429830
ElectricBoogaloo November 1, 2020 Share November 1, 2020 2 minutes ago, Kromm said: You mean the way the people in the cultures they come from say it doesn't count? Ha, I wasn't the one who said that! Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6429833
Kromm November 1, 2020 Share November 1, 2020 Just now, ElectricBoogaloo said: Ha, I wasn't the one who said that! It's the quote bug. When you select text and use the built in quote pop-up, it fills in the name, not the poster. And it can't be edited out. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6429838
Deskisamess November 2, 2020 Share November 2, 2020 I love Noel, but please, no more drinking blood jokes. Just ick. Not a good way to start a show. 1 2 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6430587
MisterGlass November 2, 2020 Share November 2, 2020 Whenever we talk about pronunciation on this show the word that always comes to mind is "churro." 1 2 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6430792
Rickster November 2, 2020 Share November 2, 2020 I was tickled over the weekend while watching one of the holiday specials to hear Paul, Pru, and whoever was narrating pronounce genoise in the English manner, while the contestants insisted on using the French pronunciation. (This was the special episode in which Paul of lion bread fame appeared) 1 2 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6431264
AnnaBaptist November 2, 2020 Share November 2, 2020 Count me in as another one who was cringing at the way they pronounced Japanese. I am half Japanese, and I truly believe that Japanese is one of the easier languages to pronounce, so I was appalled at how they mangled the language. It was almost as though they were purposely trying to pronounce Japanese incorrectly, which makes me inclined to believe what ElectricBoogaloo said above. The worst was the way Pru pronounced "geisha". (shudder) Although not everything was authentic Japanese, I enjoyed the three challenges, and I thought they did a very good job overall. Now I want to go back to Japan. Darned covid. 6 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6431583
Yajmele November 2, 2020 Share November 2, 2020 I was very fascinated to see the steamed bun signature. I can’t say the technical was anything I’d go seeking out, like the chocolate babka, but it was interesting all the same. The showstopper, I felt was a bit of a cop-out. I think this could have been an amazing opportunity to have the bakers stretch themselves with something they didn’t have as much familiarity with. Instead we get “Kawaii cakes.” This challenge was the equivalent of traveling to somewhere like a resort area or a tourist trap out of the country. You’re excited to try some local cuisine near where you’re at, but you end up getting something seemingly generic made to sell to the tourists. Not the worst thing, but disappointing. 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6431592
MerBearHou November 2, 2020 Share November 2, 2020 On 11/1/2020 at 11:27 AM, chaifan said: Back when Mel & Sue were on, someone said in an interview that if a baker started crying they would just start swearing up a storm. It ruined the footage so it couldn't be used. I am in the Mel & Sue camp -- the minute someone starts crying on a baking / cooking show, I get so mad at the cryer! I know I sound like a cold fish, but it always feels manipulative to me. The cryer is NEVER voted off on the night of the tears. Someone who may have been just as frustrated or disappointed soldiers on without tears and gets eliminated. Bugs me! Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6431628
dgpolo November 2, 2020 Share November 2, 2020 2 minutes ago, MerBearHou said: I am in the Mel & Sue camp -- the minute someone starts crying on a baking / cooking show, I get so mad at the cryer! I know I sound like a cold fish, but it always feels manipulative to me. I don't think you are understanding at all what Mel & Sue were doing. They were so -Sympathetic- to the person crying they kept them from 'prying eyes' until they could get themselves under control. They did NOT think the cryer was manipulative, only someone who deserves privacy. 17 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6431635
MerBearHou November 2, 2020 Share November 2, 2020 2 minutes ago, dgpolo said: I don't think you are understanding at all what Mel & Sue were doing. They were so -Sympathetic- to the person crying they kept them from 'prying eyes' until they could get themselves under control. They did NOT think the cryer was manipulative, only someone who deserves privacy. Ahhh interesting... they're nicer than I am! 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6431641
Crs97 November 2, 2020 Share November 2, 2020 Matcha looks awful and sounds like it tastes the same. Happy not to have to try that. 2 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6431696
HurricaneVal November 2, 2020 Share November 2, 2020 I, too, was a little weirded out over the seeming cultural expansion from "Japanese" to "anything remotely Asian" in the signature challenge. The kawaii challenge with the cute anime figures seemed very Japanese though, so that was appropriate. I do love a good steamed bun. I am in search of the perfect bao of my childhood. My next door neighbor used to take me to her mom's house in Chinatown (renamed to The International District these days) and her mom, this wizened old Chinese lady, would hand me a bao that was the perfect sweet/savory barbeque pork filling as soon as I walked in the door. Always amazing, and I have never found one as good. I'm still looking, though. Hers were always very plain and uniform looking on the outside, all pillowy plump porky goodness! Gawd, I can still feel their slight squishiness in my hand, and the somewhat resilient bounce of the first bite... I'm squarely on the dill pickle side of the pickle fight. I despise sweet pickles and sweet pickle relish, but I love sour dill pickles. You like what you like, but it does put some risks into the judging. Yes, judges have personal preferences and like it or not, that's going to color their judging. If both baker A and B had perfect bakes with exquisite decorations and were neck-and-neck on those qualities, but baker B's dish had anise in it, and Judge B loathes anise, then Judge B is going to be terribly prejudiced on one aspect of the dish. This can also work in your favor, as we saw last week with the key lime bake from Laura and Paul's enthusiasm for the flavor. Poor Hermine, I think she is a far more classic French pastry person and maybe unable to make a cartoon pastry. She totally missed the brief, and didn't take a hint from what the other bakers were putting together. I do like her, and she seems to bake good stuff, but when Paul called her one of the more consistent bakers of the lot, I'm not sure she took that as the compliment as it was intended. Last week she was very close to getting star baker, and I thought this was Paul's way to let her know she was always high in the judging. Then as the episode went on, I started to worry that scene might have been foreshadowing a Hermine farewell. Her showstopper cake was beautiful, but not kawaii-cute. Next week is 80's week. I'm less concerned about the bakes than I am what Noel and Pru might wear.... 3 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6431798
meep.meep November 2, 2020 Share November 2, 2020 I love Hermine but what about gray fondant says cute? Was it supposed to be lavendar? 4 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6431855
Ms Lark November 2, 2020 Share November 2, 2020 (edited) On 11/1/2020 at 11:14 AM, Brookside said: (Mary/marry/merry anyone?) Three slightly different pronunciations for me, although that doesn't hold true for everyone! May-ri was feeling meh-ri because she would soon mah-ri. Sweet gherkins and relish. A nice dill spear with a good ruben! They all have their place. Edited November 2, 2020 by Ms Lark 4 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6431985
chaifan November 2, 2020 Share November 2, 2020 Does anyone know how far in advance the bakers are notified of the weekly challenges? I never really thought of it before, but I'd guess most home bakers haven't experimented with steamed buns or cute Japanese anime cakes, and these are things that would have had to be researched and tested quite a bit before the competition. So what's the lead time on this? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6432052
theatremouse November 3, 2020 Share November 3, 2020 I am under the impression they get all the (not Technical) briefs before filming begins, basically as soon as they're confirmed for the show. I have no idea how long a lead that is, but they know them all up front, just not when each will happen. 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6432260
leighdear November 3, 2020 Share November 3, 2020 (edited) 6 hours ago, HurricaneVal said: Next week is 80's week. I'm less concerned about the bakes than I am what Noel and Pru might wear.... Hate to break it to ya, but Pru's necklaces and Noels wild sweaters are already smack dab RIGHT in the middle of 80's style!! *LOL* Edited November 3, 2020 by leighdear 4 3 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6432312
ElectricBoogaloo November 3, 2020 Share November 3, 2020 4 hours ago, chaifan said: Does anyone know how far in advance the bakers are notified of the weekly challenges? I never really thought of it before, but I'd guess most home bakers haven't experimented with steamed buns or cute Japanese anime cakes, and these are things that would have had to be researched and tested quite a bit before the competition. So what's the lead time on this? 1 hour ago, theatremouse said: I am under the impression they get all the (not Technical) briefs before filming begins, basically as soon as they're confirmed for the show. I have no idea how long a lead that is, but they know them all up front, just not when each will happen. I remember ages ago there were a few articles/interviews where it was stated that the bakers are told the weekly themes and the accompanying signature/showstopper assignments well in advance (definitely before they show up to the tent for the first time). This gives them time to research the specific food/dish/ingredient for the challenges (like, say, a pasty) and potentially practice ahead of time. Before they appear on the show, the bakers must submit their recipes and their list of ingredients so that production has time to procure everything they need. 7 hours ago, HurricaneVal said: I, too, was a little weirded out over the seeming cultural expansion from "Japanese" to "anything remotely Asian" in the signature challenge. My understanding was that the Japanese aspect of the signature challenge was the bun (although bao originated in China, they're common in Japan) but that the fillings could be anything they wanted (Japanese or otherwise). 1 3 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6432437
Kiddvideo November 3, 2020 Share November 3, 2020 2 hours ago, ElectricBoogaloo said: My understanding was that the Japanese aspect of the signature challenge was the bun (although bao originated in China, they're common in Japan) but that the fillings could be anything they wanted (Japanese or otherwise). The Cornish pasty is a recent example in my mind. The dough and crimps were the challenge criteria more than the ingredients in the filling. Linda’s had great flavor, but the lack of crimps on her triangle made it a samosa. 5 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6432628
HurricaneVal November 3, 2020 Share November 3, 2020 14 hours ago, leighdear said: Hate to break it to ya, but Pru's necklaces and Noels wild sweaters are already smack dab RIGHT in the middle of 80's style!! *LOL* That's exactly what I'm afraid of...... I think maybe they're going to go full on Flock of Seagulls. Or they could play against type and put Noel as David Bowie "The Gentleman" look. That would turn the tables! And I want to see the new guy go full Michael Jackson in tight red leather, but no wig. Or the aforementioned Flock of Seagulls wig with the Michael Jackson suit. The possibilities are endless.....and frightening! 2 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6433036
sugarbaker design November 3, 2020 Share November 3, 2020 20 hours ago, meep.meep said: I love Hermine but what about gray fondant says cute? Reminds me of Sally Field in Steel Magnolias. "I can't even begin to think how you make gray icing." 4 7 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6433094
janie jones November 3, 2020 Share November 3, 2020 On 11/1/2020 at 4:31 AM, Danny Franks said: I disagree. It's on the contestants to craft the recipe they want to make and run the risk of the judges not liking it. We've seen frequently on the show that the judges will say they didn't like the taste of something, but can appreciate the baking talent. Flavour is always going to be subjective, that's just part of the competition. He could have said nothing about the gherkins then complained afterwards but apparently dislikes them strongly enough to ask they not be included, which is the first time I can recall him ever doing that. I don't recall what happened other times bakers were using ingredients he didn't care for, but omitting a pickle is a feasible request, as opposed to telling someone who's making peanut butter cookies to make him one that doesn't have peanut butter in it. On 11/1/2020 at 5:04 AM, Ms Lark said: and Oh, gods, I know! I looked up the phenomenon once since I was curious. A large majority seems to think it's because the British believe their pronunciations are correct and only proper English pronunciations are acceptable. I think it's sort of a carryover from Colonialism. I don't know, makes me want to slap them. Sorta, I'm not really violent. In British people's defense, plenty of other languages make no major attempt to preserve a word's original pronunciation when it gets borrowed from another language, and instead follow their language's own pronunciation rules and/or follow the spelling/pronunciation rules of their own language. The reason it's remarkable that British people do that is because English speakers in other countries don't. Cross-linguistically, it's pretty normal. 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6433309
sharifa70 November 3, 2020 Share November 3, 2020 1 hour ago, janie jones said: In British people's defense, plenty of other languages make no major attempt to preserve a word's original pronunciation when it gets borrowed from another language, and instead follow their language's own pronunciation rules and/or follow the spelling/pronunciation rules of their own language. I just had a flashback to my first trip to Paris, when I was berated by a waiter for asking if I could have an order of salsa as well as a side of guacamole with chips (quick backstory: American here. When I travel overseas I always get HUGE cravings for chicken enchiladas. I don’t know why, because my cravings at home are pretty much “hey, Mexican food sounds good tonight” every few weeks, but there you go. This cafe had chips + salsa on the menu as well as chips + guacamole. All I wanted was chips, salsa, and guacamole and I would have happily paid extra). The waiter would not stop going on about how I could have chips and salsa OR chips and “GWAY-cuh-mohl,” but not both. Over and over he said “GWAY-cuh-mohl” until I didn’t know whether to kick him for not dropping it or start giggling. I’m not usually bothered by most British pronunciations, but then I don’t speak Japanese and have no idea how much the words were butchered. I guess I’m willing to give them a pass because as much as I try, I have difficulties with certain non-English words even when I’ve studied the language. 1 3 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6433435
ABay November 4, 2020 Share November 4, 2020 There was an episode of Sherlock Holmes, the one with Jeremy Brett, where everyone kept talking about someone name GAHseeah and it took me half the episode to realize they were trying to say Garcia. A dropped R, fine--it's RP, but the emphasis on the first syllable really threw me. Also, don't the British refer to the Italian city of Livorno as something not at all like Livorno? You guys talk funny is what I'm saying.] I kid! I kid because I love. 1 3 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6433589
Crs97 November 4, 2020 Share November 4, 2020 Husband was watching an old interview with Ruth Bader Ginsburg (sob!) and Antonin Scalia. At one point, Justice Scalia mentioned Bombay, and Justice Ginsburg quietly corrected him. Of course, he made a big deal about how there was an English word for the place and he wasn’t going to bother learning the “other” pronunciation when the English word was just fine. I found myself hoping that for the rest of his life, she called him Anthony. 2 4 5 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6433692
ElectricBoogaloo November 4, 2020 Share November 4, 2020 8 hours ago, ABay said: There was an episode of Sherlock Holmes, the one with Jeremy Brett, where everyone kept talking about someone name GAHseeah and it took me half the episode to realize they were trying to say Garcia. A dropped R, fine--it's RP, but the emphasis on the first syllable really threw me. Also, don't the British refer to the Italian city of Livorno as something not at all like Livorno? You guys talk funny is what I'm saying.] I kid! I kid because I love. I was confused when I started watching Outlander because everyone kept pronouncing the main character's last name as Beecham and I later learned that her last name was actually Beauchamp. At least with a word like taco you can try to argue that the British are ignoring the original pronunciation in favor of the way it looks like it would be pronounced in British English, but I don't know how anyone looks at Beauchamp and decides to say Beecham. Coincidentally, I just heard a British person say the word macramé for the first time last night and I was gobsmacked. Anyway, the GBBO website finally published Mark's exit interview - better late than never! Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6433887
AZChristian November 4, 2020 Share November 4, 2020 5 hours ago, ElectricBoogaloo said: I was confused when I started watching Outlander because everyone kept pronouncing the main character's last name as Beecham and I later learned that her last name was actually Beauchamp. At least with a word like taco you can try to argue that the British are ignoring the original pronunciation in favor of the way it looks like it would be pronounced in British English, but I don't know how anyone looks at Beauchamp and decides to say Beecham. I found this on a website of people whose names are a frustration to them and to others: Having the surname "Beauchamp" - pronounced "Beecham" - has caused me no end of grief. My family and I are all used to spelling it out for people and correcting those who attempt to pronounce it in a French way. The name has been in England since around 1066 and the pronunciation has obviously changed since then, but I have had people argue with me, at length, that I pronounce my own surname wrong. My latest response is to tell them that if you ask a taxi driver to go to Beauchamp Place in London by pronouncing it in a French way, they won't have a clue where you mean. My family are descendants of the Beauchamp who was imprisoned in the Tower of London, and subsequently had the Tower named after him. I like it as a name - it's an interesting historical name, with a coat of arms and a motto which is always nice to have - but I do wish people would stop "correcting" me on how to pronounce it! 3 3 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6434013
debalex November 4, 2020 Share November 4, 2020 I assumed Paul is allergic to pickles. Because I was struck my how carefully they made sure his was marked. I get an asthma attack from some pickles and would have been just as insistent. 4 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6434260
buttercupia November 4, 2020 Share November 4, 2020 re: pronunciation of names, southern us "taliaferro" can be mystifying. so sorry to see mark go, he was adorable and talented. lottie continues to bug me. she's a gifted baker for sure but she needs to get her hair out of her face. 2 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6434317
Irlandesa November 4, 2020 Share November 4, 2020 1 hour ago, debalex said: I assumed Paul is allergic to pickles. Because I was struck my how carefully they made sure his was marked. I get an asthma attack from some pickles and would have been just as insistent. That's what I was wondering because he has certainly eaten things he hasn't cared for before. And sometimes people aren't overt with their sensitivities/allergies and say it's a preference if they know they're not going to die from it. I remember a chef from another food show talking about how much he hated a fruit but later revealed he was allergic to it. It's not that he'd die if he ate it but he would definitely have physical discomfort. 2 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6434355
Kohola3 November 4, 2020 Share November 4, 2020 1 hour ago, debalex said: I assumed Paul is allergic to pickles. That's not what he said at all plus pulled a face when they were mentioned. 5 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6434368
Quilt Fairy November 5, 2020 Share November 5, 2020 9 hours ago, AZChristian said: 14 hours ago, ElectricBoogaloo said: I was confused when I started watching Outlander because everyone kept pronouncing the main character's last name as Beecham and I later learned that her last name was actually Beauchamp. At least with a word like taco you can try to argue that the British are ignoring the original pronunciation in favor of the way it looks like it would be pronounced in British English, but I don't know how anyone looks at Beauchamp and decides to say Beecham. I found this on a website of people whose names are a frustration to them and to others: Having the surname "Beauchamp" - pronounced "Beecham" - has caused me no end of grief. My family and I are all used to spelling it out for people and correcting those who attempt to pronounce it in a French way. The name has been in England since around 1066 and the pronunciation has obviously changed since then, but I have had people argue with me, at length, that I pronounce my own surname wrong. My latest response is to tell them that if you ask a taxi driver to go to Beauchamp Place in London by pronouncing it in a French way, they won't have a clue where you mean. My family are descendants of the Beauchamp who was imprisoned in the Tower of London, and subsequently had the Tower named after him. I like it as a name - it's an interesting historical name, with a coat of arms and a motto which is always nice to have - but I do wish people would stop "correcting" me on how to pronounce it! Not to get totally off the topic, but don't forget that in Outlander, Clare was specifically asked by The Mackenzie why she pronounced her name the English way rather than the French way. It was a mark against her that she did this. 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6434580
meep.meep November 5, 2020 Share November 5, 2020 23 hours ago, ABay said: Also, don't the British refer to the Italian city of Livorno as something not at all like Livorno? They named it Leghorn. My father was stationed there in the army. 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/112486-s11e06-japanese-week/page/3/#findComment-6434582
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.