I agree. All of the garments she has sent down the runway have been identical. It is all she can do. If they get a real red carpet challenge, she'll be toast.
If they get their fabric at Good Will, do the garments get cleaned first? My impression of Good Wills are that the garments get donated, they put them on hangars, and then they are sold. I clean everything I get there before using.
And, since I am the only person who seems to remember: Heidi Klum had the original idea for the show, got it developed, got sponsors, and got it on the air.