ElectricBoogaloo January 30, 2017 Share January 30, 2017 (edited) Quote Holmes and Watson investigate the murder of a former professional eSports video game player who died after being assaulted in front of his fans during a live video stream. Meanwhile, Shinwell seeks advice from Joan when his teen daughter asks to meet with him for the first time in years. Edited February 13, 2017 by ElectricBoogaloo Link to comment
paigow February 20, 2017 Share February 20, 2017 Shinwell will get another call on prom night...No shortage of hot button issues...aboriginal rights, global warming, PETA type activism, human trafficking...Trainspotting Sherlock continuity... Link to comment
Rascotes February 20, 2017 Share February 20, 2017 The entire Shinwell plot is completely disconnected from the rest of the show. The entire series, really. I don't necessarily dislike Shinwell but every time he is in on screen I feel like I'm watching some weird spinoff show. Either bring him into the show properly or get rid of him. 10 Link to comment
paigow February 20, 2017 Share February 20, 2017 59 minutes ago, Rascotes said: The entire Shinwell plot is completely disconnected from the rest of the show. He is proof that Holmes & Watson run best of breed lockpicking school.... 3 Link to comment
fauntleroy February 20, 2017 Share February 20, 2017 The business with Sherlock sniffing the oil and deducing mid-'60s Mustang - yea right. Link to comment
Trey February 20, 2017 Share February 20, 2017 54 minutes ago, fauntleroy said: The business with Sherlock sniffing the oil and deducing mid-'60s Mustang - yea right. Sniffing the oil just gave him the era of the car - it was the marks left on the wall by the hubcaps that led to the Mustang identification. Link to comment
tennisgurl February 20, 2017 Share February 20, 2017 (edited) Wow, even by this shows standards, that was a LOT of twists and turns. We went from a murdered gamer who was killed while live streaming, to the cut throat of world of professional gaming, to prostitution, to human trafficking, to saving the seals, to selfies, to native rights in Canada, to global warming, to more native rights, to sketchy lawyers. Again, there HAD to be an easier way to accomplish your goals then beating a random guy to death online. I do appreciate that, when the guy got clobbered online, people actually altered the authorities, and we didn't get a "people just watch violence and don't do anything" story. I was kind of disappointed be left the gamer stuff behind. Its an interesting sub culture that they could have done decently. At least better than that episode of Law and Order SVU that got "topical" by mixing Gamer Gate and terrorism (because internet trolls frequently publically kidnap and rape female gamers! Like all the time!), the combination we all needed. The Shinwell plot was so completely disconnected to the rest of the show, it felt like I had accidently just changed the channel. I like Shinwell, but he has served his purpose on the show. Its time to move on. And this week was especially boring. It had NOTHING to do with Joan and Sherlock, and the resolution was pretty lame. And I thought his daughter was kind of shitty. Yeah Shimwell was apparently a crappy druggie dad, and she's just a kid who was in trouble through no fault of her own, but still, holy crap girl, you asked your dad to kill a guy for you after seeing him for the first time in years, and he almost did it! I think maybe you can let him walk you home, or get coffee with him. But, again, I don't really care. Edited February 20, 2017 by tennisgurl 4 Link to comment
johntfs February 20, 2017 Share February 20, 2017 Jonny Lee Miller looks good bald. 1 4 Link to comment
Ailianna February 20, 2017 Share February 20, 2017 (edited) I like that the famous guest star had almost nothing to do with the killing, and that almost was rather tangential. (I'm referring of course to Kathy Najimy.) Edited February 21, 2017 by Ailianna 6 Link to comment
mccartygirl February 20, 2017 Share February 20, 2017 1 hour ago, johntfs said: Jonny Lee Miller looks good bald. I thought I was the only one who thought that as well.... 3 Link to comment
LisaM February 21, 2017 Share February 21, 2017 I liked seeing the Captain's niece. 3 Link to comment
GaT February 21, 2017 Share February 21, 2017 5 hours ago, tennisgurl said: And I thought his daughter was kind of shitty. Yeah Shimwell was apparently a crappy druggie dad, and she's just a kid who was in trouble through no fault of her own, but still, holy crap girl, you asked your dad to kill a guy for you after seeing him for the first time in years, and he almost did it! I think maybe you can let him walk you home, or get coffee with him. But, again, I don't really care. I actually thought that she told him to go away because he didn't kill the guy, if he had, I think she would have kept up the relationship. 1 hour ago, johntfs said: Jonny Lee Miller looks good bald. I'm not thrilled with the look myself, does anyone know why IRL he did it? Or was it really just for the show? 2 Link to comment
chitowngirl February 21, 2017 Share February 21, 2017 2 minutes ago, GaT said: I'm not thrilled with the look myself, does anyone know why IRL he did it? Or was it really just for the show? He's filming Trainspotting 2. 2 Link to comment
sinkwriter February 21, 2017 Share February 21, 2017 Quote I actually thought that she told him to go away because he didn't kill the guy, if he had, I think she would have kept up the relationship. I think Shinwell was going to get dismissed by his daughter either way, if he fell back to old behaviors or - as he did instead - found a way to stay on the "straight and narrow." I can't imagine she would have wanted anything to do with him for killing a kid. She would have needed to distance herself as if she had no part in it. Perhaps she'd been hoping he would have killed the kid, that way she could have a reason to stay away from Shinwell. But because he fixed the situation by arranging a deal instead, she had to dismiss him to his face. Pretty cold, but at the same time, she hasn't had a father all these years because of the life he used to lead, so I can understand a little bit why she still doesn't see him as true family. I still felt bad for Shinwell, though. 5 Link to comment
orza February 21, 2017 Share February 21, 2017 1 hour ago, chitowngirl said: He's filming Trainspotting 2. Filming for T2 happened last summer before production for season 6 commenced and JLM sported Sick Boy's signature white hair. The movie premiered last month in Britain. It was pretty obvious in the first episodes of this season that JLM's hair was dyed back to something close to his natural color. Maybe he got tired of the elaborate combing needed to cover his growing bald spots and decided to embrace the hairless look. 1 Link to comment
Rascotes February 21, 2017 Share February 21, 2017 2 hours ago, Ailianna said: I like that the famous guest star had almost nothing to do with the killing, and that almost was rather tangential. (I'm referring of course to Kathy Najimy.) I'd say that Christine Taylor (The ultimate villain) is at least as famous or more famous than Kathy Najimy. She's been in a bunch of stuff. 4 Link to comment
Maelstrom February 21, 2017 Share February 21, 2017 1 hour ago, orza said: Filming for T2 happened last summer before production for season 6 commenced and JLM sported Sick Boy's signature white hair. The movie premiered last month in Britain. It was pretty obvious in the first episodes of this season that JLM's hair was dyed back to something close to his natural color. Maybe he got tired of the elaborate combing needed to cover his growing bald spots and decided to embrace the hairless look. I wondered if maybe he had to shave it to film pickups for Trainspotting, but if he wasn't bald in the movie then there goes that theory. I personally think it's a terrible look on him, and I hope his hair grows quick! Or he wears lots of hats. This ep fell flat a little flat for me I'm afraid. Lots of twists and turns as noted above, but... eh. Not much focus or development with our main characters, which is really what makes me watch this show. Seems like there's less and less of that this season, which is a bummer. So why no new ep next week, CBS? They must be taking their scheduling cues from the idiots at Fox or NBC. 5 Link to comment
wonderwoman February 21, 2017 Share February 21, 2017 2 minutes ago, Maelstrom said: So why no new ep next week, CBS? They must be taking their scheduling cues from the idiots at Fox or NBC. Nope; the Oscars. 2 Link to comment
juliet73 February 21, 2017 Share February 21, 2017 7 minutes ago, Maelstrom said: This ep fell flat a little flat for me I'm afraid. Lots of twists and turns as noted above, but... eh. Not much focus or development with our main characters, which is really what makes me watch this show. Seems like there's less and less of that this season, which is a bummer. Totally agree! I love JLM, but I miss his Sherlock "quirkiness". Even Joan seems a bit "checked out" this season. The addition of Shinwell added absolutely nothing. I would much rather have the show focus more on Det Bell or Gregson. I think this is the last season. It's not doing well in the ratings and the writing isn't what it used to be. 4 Link to comment
ElectricBoogaloo February 21, 2017 Author Share February 21, 2017 9 hours ago, Ailianna said: I like that the famous guest star had almost nothing to do with the killing, and that almost was rather tangential. (I'm referring of course to Kathy Najimy.) 6 hours ago, Rascotes said: I'd say that Christine Taylor (The ultimate villain) is at least as famous or more famous than Kathy Najimy. She's been in a bunch of stuff. Yup, I knew after the first short scene of Kathy Najimy and Christine Taylor at the precinct that Christine Taylor was going to end up the bad guy because you don't bring in someone like that to play a lawyer with only a few lines! Well, at least not on this show. On The Good Wife, yes. 1 2 Link to comment
Ailianna February 21, 2017 Share February 21, 2017 (edited) Maybe I'm out of it then definitely possible!!), but I've never seen Christine Taylor in anything, so to me she was a random extra. ETA: I just looked her up, and the only shows I've ever seen her in are generally one episode guest spots, so nothing that would have stood out. Her filmography is pretty much movies I would pay money not to have to see, so I guess she's famous to other people, but I would never have recognized her. Edited February 21, 2017 by Ailianna 2 Link to comment
Writing Wrongs February 21, 2017 Share February 21, 2017 Brady Bunch movies and Ben Stiller's wife. 1 Link to comment
fauntleroy February 21, 2017 Share February 21, 2017 23 hours ago, Trey said: Sniffing the oil just gave him the era of the car - it was the marks left on the wall by the hubcaps that led to the Mustang identification. Again, yea right! The Shinwell scenes are now so disconnected that it's possible to FF them altogether. Whether they are good or bad doesn't matter, they're effectively a separate show. Link to comment
vibeology February 21, 2017 Share February 21, 2017 6 hours ago, ElectricBoogaloo said: Yup, I knew after the first short scene of Kathy Najimy and Christine Taylor at the precinct that Christine Taylor was going to end up the bad guy because you don't bring in someone like that to play a lawyer with only a few lines! Well, at least not on this show. On The Good Wife, yes. See, I thought that was smart. The show cast two famous people so I knew it would end up being one of them, but which one? That was up in the air for a while at least. 1 3 Link to comment
tennisgurl February 21, 2017 Share February 21, 2017 (edited) 13 hours ago, juliet73 said: The addition of Shinwell added absolutely nothing. I would much rather have the show focus more on Det Bell or Gregson. This is a huge issue for me this season. Joan and Sherlock don't really have any big plots or character development (probably the closest is the Over a Barrel episode)moments or quirks, because they spend their extra time not with the case on Shinwell, who has nothing to do with anything. I understand them wanting to have more than two characters to be developed, but they already have Bell and Gregson if they wanted more time away from Joan and Sherlock. If they must give us more subplots with other characters, we already know and care them, and their plots could actually be connected with the show. Again, its not that I don't like Shinwell as a character, I just don't understand what his point here is. Edited February 21, 2017 by tennisgurl 7 Link to comment
iMonrey February 21, 2017 Share February 21, 2017 (edited) I don't get why the show keeps trying to make Shinwell happen either. Maybe they are hoping for a spin-off? Good luck with that. Quote I'd say that Christine Taylor (The ultimate villain) is at least as famous or more famous than Kathy Najimy. She's been in a bunch of stuff. I'll try to refrain from debating the merits of their respective careers; suffice it to say, Najimy has been around a lot longer and has more credits to her name. That said, I couldn't figure out why either one of them accepted such a small role on a show like this. This episode was lacking the usual humor. It also missed the opportunity for the other characters to react to Sherlock's hair, or lack thereof. Personally JLM's hair has always been something of a tragedy but the bald look doesn't really do him any favors either. He's too skinny and he has somewhat of an elongated cranium. Edited February 21, 2017 by iMonrey 5 Link to comment
possibilities February 21, 2017 Share February 21, 2017 I liked the episode. The actor I recognized the most was the one who ran the gaming training house and had been hiring prostitutes for his team. And even though he's the one I thought was the most famous, I don't know his name! I hate Bell's haircut. Usually I like shaved heads (I had one for a while myself), but I don't really think it flatters JLM. I have no opinion about his usual hair, having never noticed it one way or the other. I do know from experience that a shaved head grows back really fast, so it shouldn't last long unless they keep shaving it. 3 Link to comment
ZoqFotPik February 21, 2017 Share February 21, 2017 16 minutes ago, possibilities said: The actor I recognized the most was the one who ran the gaming training house and had been hiring prostitutes for his team. And even though he's the one I thought was the most famous, I don't know his name! James Kyson Lee. Most well known for playing Ando on 'Heroes". 10 Link to comment
mojoween February 21, 2017 Share February 21, 2017 (edited) I usually watch with my husband but he was home sick yesterday and watched while I was working. I am angry with him for not warning me about a Shinwell sighting. I like advanced notice so I can do calisthenics on my eyeballs to get them ready for all the rolling they do when Shinwell is on screen. Otherwise, I liked the case and found it interesting. I was actually sad about OG's death because that character was rather charming. Edited February 21, 2017 by mojoween 1 Link to comment
mtlchick February 21, 2017 Share February 21, 2017 This was an episode full of "Hey it's that actor/actress!" and...not much else. I watch the show. Not religiously but enough where I think JLM and Lucy Liu are great together. This Shinwell business is really putting me to sleep as he's simply not interesting or engaging me enough. Also indirectly, taking too much of Clyde's screen time! Quote Maybe I'm out of it then definitely possible!!), but I've never seen Christine Taylor in anything, so to me she was a random extra If it helps you, "Dodgeball" "Zoolander" and Marcia Brady in the Brady Bunch movies are probably her standout roles. 1 Link to comment
Trey February 21, 2017 Share February 21, 2017 9 hours ago, fauntleroy said: Again, yea right! He's Sherlock Holmes - that's what he does. 1 Link to comment
solea February 21, 2017 Share February 21, 2017 Why are they trying to make Shinwell happen so hard? The character is fine and all, but I don't see the point of him having his own story line separate from Sherlock/Watson. 1 Link to comment
shapeshifter February 22, 2017 Share February 22, 2017 (edited) I vote nay on bald Jonny. OTOH, this was the first episode in which I found Shinwell appealing. Maybe it was because they had him in more well lit scenes instead of sinister darkness. The last shot of him standing forlornly alone got to me. Edited February 22, 2017 by shapeshifter 4 Link to comment
iMonrey February 22, 2017 Share February 22, 2017 Quote James Kyson Lee. Most well known for playing Ando on 'Heroes". Thank you. 3 Link to comment
Ailianna February 22, 2017 Share February 22, 2017 1 hour ago, mtlchick said: This was an episode full of "Hey it's that actor/actress!" and...not much else. I watch the show. Not religiously but enough where I think JLM and Lucy Liu are great together. This Shinwell business is really putting me to sleep as he's simply not interesting or engaging me enough. Also indirectly, taking too much of Clyde's screen time! If it helps you, "Dodgeball" "Zoolander" and Marcia Brady in the Brady Bunch movies are probably her standout roles. I absolutely agree we need more Clyde! As for your other point--that's exactly why I've never heard of her. 4 Link to comment
Texasmom1970 February 22, 2017 Share February 22, 2017 I am a Mom and would do anything for my daughters. That being said even though I am not crazy about Shinwell I did not like how his daughter begged him for help and then was like whatever don't wanna see ya. 3 Link to comment
thuganomics85 February 22, 2017 Share February 22, 2017 So, in typical Elementary fashion, the episode quickly goes from "Sherlock Holmes and the Case of the Dead Pro Gamer", to sex trafficking, prostitution, a real-life Pretty Woman situation, and then it all ends up being about global warming. Yep, that checks out! Totally pegged the lawyer, since they wouldn't bother getting Christine Taylor to only say a few "lawyerims." Sure, she might not be an A-lister, but being Ben Stiller's wife (and Marcia Brady in the Brady Bunch films) has to count for something! I did like seeing good old Ando from Heroes too. At least he wasn't involved with the killing, even if he apparently is OK with hiring prostitutes that he knows are likely suffering, just to appease a bunch of gamers. What would Hiro, think?! Was bored with all of Shinwell's stuff involving his daughter who is kind of unlikable. Again, I really love Nelsan Ellis, and I don't even really hate the character, but he just doesn't have a spark to him. Even when, say, Kitty could be obnoxious, I at least was paying attention to her and her ongoing stories/arcs. Surprisingly, I pretty use to Bald Sherlock. Jonny Lee Miller seems to have the right head shape to pull that off. 1 Link to comment
Kathira February 22, 2017 Share February 22, 2017 Was that a reappearance of Joan's long black coat with the buttons? It's truly gorgeous and emphasizes her slim figure. I noticed that she didn't even have to unbutton it when she sat down. Joan's clothes are almosy always highly covetable, but the coat porn on this show is out of this world. 5 Link to comment
fastiller February 22, 2017 Share February 22, 2017 @Kathira - I actually said out loud when the coat appeared "I want that coat." My cat didn't respond. 11 Link to comment
Canada February 23, 2017 Share February 23, 2017 Wow, Shinwell's daughter turned out to be a little bitch. "I want nothing to do with you because you're a criminal. Oh wait, I'm in need of a criminal, so now I'll talk to you and demand your help. No, wait, you're a criminal, so now I want nothing to do with you again. Until I need something else." I was really hoping he would say something as she was walking away from him. 3 Link to comment
Clanstarling February 26, 2017 Share February 26, 2017 On 2/20/2017 at 6:24 PM, Rascotes said: I'd say that Christine Taylor (The ultimate villain) is at least as famous or more famous than Kathy Najimy. She's been in a bunch of stuff. Being a little older for me it was "Hey, it's Kathy Najimy" and "hmm...she looks familiar, why am I thinking Marcia Marcia Marcia!?" On 2/21/2017 at 11:09 AM, ZoqFotPik said: James Kyson Lee. Most well known for playing Ando on 'Heroes". I was so pleased to see James Kyson Lee. Ando was one of my favorites on Heroes. I thought it was a good choice to have three recognizable actors with motives (though I guess we didn't know Christine Taylor's motive until the end). I agree that the Shinwell story is kind of boring and out of place. Though that forlorn shot of him after his daughter ditched him did move me. 2 Link to comment
Miss Dee February 26, 2017 Share February 26, 2017 Just wanted to point out that Sherlock identifying a car from the smell of motor oil and some hubcap marks is completely in line with the original character, who could identify cigarettes brands from the ash they made and all the different types of mud splashes London neighborhoods could produce. Sherlock was always written as someone who studied weird, esoteric and obscure stuff he thought might help him in his work. 4 Link to comment
paigow February 27, 2017 Share February 27, 2017 9 hours ago, Miss Dee said: Just wanted to point out that Sherlock identifying a car from the smell of motor oil and some hubcap marks is completely in line with the original character, who could identify cigarettes brands from the ash they made Movie Sherlock [Game Of Shadows] deduced that the sniper smoked tobacco sourced from Afghanistan...which allowed Watson to identify Moran as the shooter. 1 Link to comment
jhlipton February 27, 2017 Share February 27, 2017 On 2/20/2017 at 9:55 AM, Trey said: Sniffing the oil just gave him the era of the car - it was the marks left on the wall by the hubcaps that led to the Mustang identification. No one -- not one single person -- with a classic 'Stang is going to leave hubcap marks on the wall. They're not savages, ya know! 3 Link to comment
Ailianna February 28, 2017 Share February 28, 2017 Not even when trying to hustle that 'Stang out of a major fire they just set? Link to comment
jhlipton March 2, 2017 Share March 2, 2017 On 2/28/2017 at 6:19 AM, Ailianna said: Not even when trying to hustle that 'Stang out of a major fire they just set? Nope --park the 'Stang down the street and then set the fire! If they had a Monet or Degas on the wall, they wouldn't mar it getting it out of the fire. 2 Link to comment
Recommended Posts