Jump to content

Type keyword(s) to search

Message added by Athena

Keep it polite. Do not get personal and do not get into repetitive arguments about the characters or what defines a fiction. Further posts will be hidden and posters will be warned.

  • Reply
  • Start Topic

Recommended Posts

There was a poster above who said that dany's "reasoning" was proof she hadn't gone mad.  The post was pretty long so I didn't want to quote, but I disagree.

I think being able to "reason" your way into justifying crappy behavior doesnt particularly make a person sane.  I'm sure the mad king was plenty able to reason away his behavior.

  • Love 18
Link to comment

Aside from the piss poor lack of setup, I liked this. If there had been any proper storytelling or decent execution to Dany's mental break, I think this would have actually been fantastic. As the show as gone about it though, it looks like we watched an overall good-hearted person despite some arrogance and ruthlessness snap because she showed up in a new country for a few weeks and people didn't love her yet (and her nephew doesn't want to sleep with her now that he's found out they're related). It was a bullshit setup and that's why the "payoff" just seems out of left field. 

And for show Jaime, I feel like this was a fitting end. He was a morally grey character and may have outgrown Cersei in a lot of ways, but it was well established that he ALWAYS loved her. His last line that nothing matters except for them is the encapsulation of their relationship. I see that this is an unpopular opinion, but I loved their romantic ending. We don't always get the perfect revenge or payoff. Bad people are still human. And Cersei's death wasn't the point of the series.

(ETA: I would also think those who wanted to see Cersei suffer would have found that vengeance in seeing how utterly terrified she was for the first time in the whole series. Any other death, especially by murder, would likely have not had that payoff. You see her fully realize fear and the life she could have had in her final moments.)

I had basically written off the show last week, but ignoring the absolutely unearned heel turn for Dany (and the death of Varys who is more brilliant than he's been written recently and whom I've always loved), I'm back on board for the finale. I still think the writing sucks and D&D have made a travesty of the whole thing, but the acting has been top notch this season, and the cinematography this episode was stunning. The cuts between the Hound and Arya and the camera panning down those narrow alleyways as Arya ran were unreal. Tyrion/Jaime had a heartbreaking goodbye. I am actually interested to see what the hell they're doing to wrap this up next week.

  • Love 17
Link to comment
1 hour ago, MichaelaRae said:

I agree that Dany hasn't had much of a support system - and most of what she had is dead - but Jon didn't betray her. She asked him to swear not tell his family about his origins. He said he couldn't swear that. He was upfront about that. I like both Dany and Jon (despite this episode trying its best to massacre both of them) but Jon's actions are not responsible for Dany's actions and he definitely didn't betray her since he told her all along - while continuing to swear his allegiance to her - that he couldn't keep a secret from his family.

If the show had Jon acknowledge that his honour often causes other’s lives, I could stomach his shit this late in the game. However, he’s that annoying, slumped-shouldered, ‘mine is the weight of the world’ tool that conveniently avoids coming face to face with the repercussions of his “honour” (at least in a self-aware way).

Just to be clear, I’m not laying the destruction of KL at his feet.

  • Love 13
Link to comment

I hated that, and yet I am inclined not to really condemn the producers for it. They bit off more than they could chew with A Song of Ice and Fire.

  • Love 1
Link to comment
2 hours ago, Conan Troutman said:

Okay I did not expect Dany to goll full on bonkers like that. What was even the point? The city has fallen, what did she want to accomplish? I could've taken five minutes less carnage for an explanation on what the hell her motivation was. Or is she just completely bananas now? 

I really liked the Arya/Hound parts (no surprise). Arya walking away from Cersei so she could be the angel of life was a nice almost-ending to her journey. Of course, this being Game of Thrones, everybody died anyways, so it was a gesture I guess?

Jaime offing Euron felt natural, the fight a bit less so - Euron should've kicked Jaime's ass easily. But I'll take it. Jaime and Cersei dying together like that wasn't how I pictured it, but I liked it. Felt like an ending that made sense for Jaime, although a bit rushed (that's more on last week's episode though). 

To me that whole Arya thing made no sense whatsoever and was absolutely ridiculous.  Arya has devoted years of her life to vengeance, and suddenly she is talked out of it by sandor?  That makes absolutely no sense whatsoever and it's absolutely nonsensical.  

It will be even more ridiculous if Arya kills someone else out of vengence after she let cersei go, because...the hound said so????

It was a nice sentiment, but it should have NEVER worked on someone like Arya.  She might as well have just become lady gendry or whatever at this point because she is no longer the Arya they have developed this entire series.

2 hours ago, Neurochick said:

I didn’t see Dany as going mad.  If you saw basically two of your children murdered in front of you, would you be all, “okay, it’s all good?”

But I ask again, how would you have changed the episode?

But how is that not "going mad?". Madness can be precipitated by an event or aggravated by an event.

She isn't acting rationally or logically, so to me it seems like that would only leave her acting "mad" to some degree.

It didn't make sense for her to burn people alive who a) actually run commerce in the city and help make it a thriving and bustling metropolis and b) who hate cersei just as much as you do.

She said the people of westeros hate her.  But she has no real knowledge of how the people of KL felt about her other than they have been given propaganda by cersei about her.  They hate cersei so their minds should have been relatively easy to change.  

Saying Dany is mad, for me, doesn't mean I wanted her to act any differently.  Because part of this story was clearly that she was going to go mad.  

But it seems weird not to call it madness given her behavior.

  • Love 9
Link to comment

The same woman who chained up her dragons in a dungeon after one of them, supposedly killed one child, accidentally,  hunts down innocent children to burn, after she conquers Kings Landing.  Yeah, that makes sense.

  • LOL 1
  • Love 18
Link to comment
2 hours ago, bluvelvet said:

As hateful as she has been, why did I feel sorry for her when she was saying she wanted her baby to live. As for Jaime, he is my favorite character so I was disappointed that he still is in love with Cersei but darn it if they didn't sell me with those scenes.

Which, in my opinion, is what made it a far more interesting ending than just: Cersei gets stabbed a lot, the end. And this is coming from someone who was really counting on Jaime doing the honors, putting her down like a rabid animal, killing the one he loved so no one else could. That would have been fine, but actually less moving. As much as I loathed Cersei, seeing her let her guard down completely was fascinating, and much more in keeping with this show's attempts to humanize everybody. Except the Mountain, of course.

  • Love 14
Link to comment

For those of you wondering .. why YES, I DID drink all 16 oz of wine in that glass.  I earned it.

Also #GameOfJones (i.e. @Lesdoggg on twitter) is cathartic.  Follow her for a great play by play.

  • Love 6
Link to comment
(edited)
24 minutes ago, WaltersHair said:

Arya has a new list.

Good for her, she can have her list and some random character can pep talk her right out of it.

Edited by RealReality
  • LOL 2
Link to comment
(edited)
2 minutes ago, spaceghostess said:

. . .Auntfucker?

MotherOfDragonsF*cker First of His Name, AuntieDoer, ResurrectedNightWatchman, and Not!ABastard Jon Freakin' Snow aka Aegon Targaryon.

Edited by SueB
  • LOL 7
  • Love 1
Link to comment
1 hour ago, mxc90 said:

Golden Company!? Money well spent Cersei!

Or Is Tyrion responsible for the remaining Lannister debts?

I don't know why the Iron Bank loaned Cersei any of that money. Things have only gotten crazier and less stable since Tywin died. I'm sure Varys was feeding them info on how Daenerys had united with the northern armies. It wouldn't have been that hard to get word to Essos to tell the Golden Company that they were not to go with Euron.

I'm always surprised that Jamie didn't use his golden hand like a melee weapon. It's heavy as shit.

Daenerys' turn wasn't entirely out of character. For 8 seasons we've seen that Daenerys has wanted her birthright back, but at no point has she ever expressed a cultural connection with Westeros. In the earlier part of the series, we'd hear the Stark kids, Joffrey, Tommen, and other younger characters references prominent people in the history of Westeros. But I don't believe Dany ever has. She's mentioned Targaryens, but not mention wanting to see the Wall or being awed by it. She's never wanted to see the Eyrie or the Citadel. She's wanted the throne because of revenge and entitlement. She doesn't really connect with the land or its people. Furthermore, she's demonstrated that she doesn't know shit about governance or seem to have much interest in it. So yeah, I can see why she'd burn down all of Kings Landing rather than have to negotiate hundreds of years of relationships that she doesn't know anything about.

  • Useful 2
  • Love 13
Link to comment

Almost exactly ten years ago I had this same feeling about Battlestar Galactica's finale when Kara

disappeared right behind Lee.

 That same, alrighty then, guess I'll just delete this episode from the DVR now. The up side is I was later able to go back and re watch the well written parts of the show.

  • Love 4
Link to comment

I guess Dany didn't get the memo that she only needed to torch the Red Keep and would have taken over a perfectly intact city with a huge tax paying population.  Now she gets to rule over....rubble.

  • Love 14
Link to comment
1 minute ago, ulkis said:

Almost exactly ten years ago I had this same feeling about Battlestar Galactica's finale when Kara

  Reveal spoiler

disappeared right behind Lee.

 That same, alrighty then, guess I'll just delete this episode from the DVR now. The up side is I was later able to go back and re watch the well written parts of the show.

That show taught me to no longer off buy season box sets until the end is in the bag. I’m pretty sure I still have season “2.5” kicking around somewhere. I totally am with you on both shows. When you think about rewatching them because you’ve recently thought of some neat aspect, but then you re-center and remember it’s not worth it. Welcome GOT.

  • Useful 1
  • Love 3
Link to comment
2 hours ago, seawind said:

I really hate that Varys died for nothing. NOTHING. (Unless one of his letters makes something happen next episode, I suppose.)

From last season:

"Swear this to me, Varys,” Dany asked in response. “If you ever think I’m failing the people, you won’t conspire behind my back. You’ll look me in the eye as you have done today and you’ll tell me how I’m failing them.”

“I swear it, my queen,” Varys promised.

“And I swear this,” Daenerys promised in turn. "If you ever betray me, I’ll burn you alive.”

  • Useful 2
  • Love 18
Link to comment
11 minutes ago, Dobian said:

So Kings Landing is a burning wreck, and the only ones left standing are Arya and a white stallion.  Eeeeeokay.

Death riding a pale horse.

  • Love 10
Link to comment
(edited)

To be honest, Daeny did exactly what I thought she'd do-kill King's Landing. I didn't think she'd slaughter so many people and then do a shake and bake for good measure, but the signs were there in retrospect.

I kept think of pompeii throughout this episode.

Jon and Daeny can never rule now, of course. It wouldn't surprise me if it was Arya and Gendry. Sansa is going to be so pissed

 

Edited by WaltersHair
  • LOL 1
  • Love 5
Link to comment
(edited)
7 minutes ago, ShellsandCheese said:

I try not to overthink this show too much but one thing is bothering me. Drogon put on a masterclass performance and thus illustrated a huge problem with the show; dragons are only as effective as the plot demands. Last week, Rhaegal was unceremoniously shot down and this week Drogon manages to take out the entire Iron Fleet, all of the scorpions, the gates to King’s Landing, and he destroyed most of the city. 

Yet two weeks ago, we had two dragons who could hardly make a dent against the AOTD. It makes no sense. None. 

Rhaegal was badly wounded, and could barely fly, let alone maneuver.  I couldn't tell, did Dany sweep in from behind?  Or did she hide Drogon in the clouds until the last second. 

She was certainly more prepared this time, and Drogon was healthy.

Edited by Umbelina
  • Love 7
Link to comment
Just now, Giselle said:

Death riding a pale horse.

The craziest thing, I immediately and for no reason when the stallion showed up, I thought she was Drogo, she was dead, and finally riding to the Nightlands.  Haven't seen the commercial for next week but I assume Arya's alive and I was maybe drunk?

  • LOL 4
  • Love 3
Link to comment
1 minute ago, whoknowswho said:

The craziest thing, I immediately and for no reason when the stallion showed up, I thought she was Drogo, she was dead, and finally riding to the Nightlands.  Haven't seen the commercial for next week but I assume Arya's alive and I was maybe drunk?

They did show white horses earlier, belonging to the Dothraki, so probably one of them died, and Arya found it.

That said, Arya has skillz.  She learned them when she tried to become No One, so I can't believe she could survive chaos and being hurt.  She did when the waif was after her...

  • Love 6
Link to comment
2 hours ago, nodorothyparker said:

I'm particularly pissed on this point myself.  In one fell swoop the show basically told us all that growth and trying to be better and figure out who he was beyond part of the collective Lannisters never mattered a lick.  We never got a single clue about his motivations.  Just that he died exactly where he started.  

After the absolute horror show that Cersei has been, I shouldn't be coming out of this episode feeling like she was the lesser of the two evils in the queen sweepstakes.  But here we are.

Now now, that's not true. He started out being only partially p**sy whipped by his sister, then he ended completely p**ssy whipped by her. 

  • Love 5
Link to comment
2 hours ago, Timetoread said:

They ALL are until they are in power.  That is the point of this tale, absolute power corrupts absolutely.

I think this makes sense. 

Though I think someone that doesn't want the power may be a decent ruler.

  • Love 4
Link to comment
3 hours ago, Paws said:

The scene between Jamie and Tyrion was PERFECT.

Damn, that scene killed me like no other in this whole series. I may have cried like a baby, but that would have been uncool. So, clearly I did not do that.

  • Love 15
Link to comment
(edited)
Quote

I try not to overthink this show too much but one thing is bothering me. Drogon put on a masterclass performance and thus illustrated a huge problem with the show; dragons are only as effective as the plot demands. Last week, Rhaegal was unceremoniously shot down and this week Drogon manages to take out the entire Iron Fleet, all of the scorpions, the gates to King’s Landing, and he destroyed most of the city. 

Yet two weeks ago, we had two dragons who could hardly make a dent against the AOTD. It makes no sense. None. 

Drogon is her most battle tested dragon. We've seen before that he knows the rhythm of battles. He's dodged projectiles before including from the NK. Both during the Wight Hunt and the battle at Winterfell.

Locking Viserion and Rhaegal up was a mistake on Dany's part. It stunted them physically and left them vulnerable during battles. They never got to learn that humans = danger like Drogon did in the fighting pits. Whenever they were deployed Dany had a very strong advantage and their big brother was doing the heavy lifting first.

I mean their deaths were entirely plot based but I'll give the show runners the above. I think they set some of that up well.

Edited by Couver
  • Useful 2
  • Love 15
Link to comment

I loved this episode so much! Danny has had tyrannical moments in the past, but been held in check by those around her. I'm not surprised. This was never going to to a "happily ever after" ending. I think it's great!

  • Love 11
Link to comment
13 minutes ago, Solace247 said:

That show taught me to no longer off buy season box sets until the end is in the bag. I’m pretty sure I still have season “2.5” kicking around somewhere. I totally am with you on both shows. When you think about rewatching them because you’ve recently thought of some neat aspect, but then you re-center and remember it’s not worth it. Welcome GOT.

I said i was later to re-watch some of the episodes. But yeah, never prematurely buy boxed sets, heh.

  • Love 2
Link to comment
2 hours ago, Kanner said:

Jon understands executing traitors and he knew firsthand that Varys was one. However, he most definitely gave her an unsettled look after Varys’ execution. 

And unlike the Unsullied who followed their Queen, Jon tried to stop his men from engaging. 

So I do think he is not onboard as he used to be. And if Dany really threatened his family that would definitely be it.

I think most of his actions toward Dany have been because of guilt more than anything else. Not that that is a good reason to do anything. He does/did love her but to me he bent the knee because he got everything he wanted and she got nothing plus she lost a child. He feels guilty about his claim so he is holding fast to his backing of her. No more. 

But with these writers, who knows. 

I'm also a little sore with dany's perferred method of execution.

We get it, you got dragons, they spit hot fire.

But there is no reason not to pick a more humane method of execution for someone who had vaunted her humanity.  You could behead someone and it's relatively quick and painless (relatively).  Why always go the route that is guaranteed to cause as much pain as possible?  Especially for a man who DID tell you that he felt you were making a mistake.  Or for men who made their choice and chose a different queen?  Yeah maybe you felt you had to kill them but why do it in the meanest way possible when their biggest sin was standing by their conscience?

  • Love 16
Link to comment
54 minutes ago, jade.black said:

And for show Jaime, I feel like this was a fitting end. He was a morally grey character and may have outgrown Cersei in a lot of ways, but it was well established that he ALWAYS loved her. His last line that nothing matters except for them is the encapsulation of their relationship.

I could've accepted this ending better, as distasteful as it was to me, if Jaime hadn't dragged Brienne and her feelings into the clusterfuck that is his relationship with his sister. It just seems so pointless to deal another blow to Brienne when it was all fo naught, since Jaime was always going to run back yo Cersei. 

  • Love 16
Link to comment

For anyone upset by Jaime and Cersei's Grand Romantic Tragic Death scene...have you watched the show? D&D have always loved Jaime/Cersei and think of them as a grand romantic tragedy rather than the toxic pair they are. Also they see Cersei mostly as a mother who does what's best for her kids. Even in her final moments, Cersei was going on about her damn fetus. Not expressing regret for the innocent people she's killed, but oh poor Cersei, she's pregnant, how sad that she'll die. 

I was hoping Jaime and Euron would kill each other. I'm annoyed to no end by Jaime. Whatever, he's dead.

Arya on the white horse was cheesy, but that was some beautiful cinematography. I also very much enjoyed the Cleganebowl fight intercut with Arya trying to escape King's Landing. Maisie Williams did a bang-up job in her scenes; they must have been a real physical challenge for her.

Very cool visual in Varys' execution when Drogon first made his appearance looming behind Dany. Jon looked perturbed; perhaps he has considered that maybe Dany is going to dracarys his sister next? 

I just don't understand why Dany went ballistic after the bells had rung. I also don't understand why she was so sad that Missandei died when she didn't take two seconds of her time to talk to Missandei this season. Poor Missandei. Ignored then refrigerated.

  • Love 7
Link to comment

I have to disagree with those who felt Jaime's character arc was trashed by having him go back to Cersei. It isn't as though he suddenly reverted to the man we saw in the beginning of the series -- he was still the better, nobler, version of himself we have watched him become. But he was that man while still loving Cersei. He may have come to see her more clearly, but he was never NOT going to love her and he was honest enough with himself to realize that. He didn't go there to help her win, but because he knew this was very likely the end, and he wanted to be there with her.

  • Useful 6
  • Love 10
Link to comment
3 minutes ago, Minneapple said:

For anyone upset by Jaime and Cersei's Grand Romantic Tragic Death scene...have you watched the show? D&D have always loved Jaime/Cersei and think of them as a grand romantic tragedy rather than the toxic pair they are.

It seemed after season 6 they were starting to go back to Brienne and Jaime a bit. I wasn't expecting it end well, but like, damn, Cersei never even finds out about his relationship with brienne? I don't mean romantically but basically like . . . all of it. Even if they hadn't slept together, there were still a ton of moments, and most of them more meaningful than them sleeping together, like him knighting her.

The point of the story doesn't seem to me "some people don't want to be redeemed", but "some people are really stupid." And one of those people is Jaime.

  • Love 5
Link to comment
5 minutes ago, Minneapple said:

For anyone upset by Jaime and Cersei's Grand Romantic Tragic Death scene...have you watched the show? D&D have always loved Jaime/Cersei and think of them as a grand romantic tragedy rather than the toxic pair they are. Also they see Cersei mostly as a mother who does what's best for her kids. Even in her final moments, Cersei was going on about her damn fetus. Not expressing regret for the innocent people she's killed, but oh poor Cersei, she's pregnant, how sad that she'll die. 

I was hoping Jaime and Euron would kill each other. I'm annoyed to no end by Jaime. Whatever, he's dead.

Arya on the white horse was cheesy, but that was some beautiful cinematography. I also very much enjoyed the Cleganebowl fight intercut with Arya trying to escape King's Landing. Maisie Williams did a bang-up job in her scenes; they must have been a real physical challenge for her.

Very cool visual in Varys' execution when Drogon first made his appearance looming behind Dany. Jon looked perturbed; perhaps he has considered that maybe Dany is going to dracarys his sister next? 

I just don't understand why Dany went ballistic after the bells had rung. I also don't understand why she was so sad that Missandei died when she didn't take two seconds of her time to talk to Missandei this season. Poor Missandei. Ignored then refrigerated.

Maybe Dany never had any intention of ever letting that city survive once she had decided that the entire city was her enemy.  

If Dany is doing this out if rage grief over seeing two of her dragon kids die it seems odd that she kept taking them into battles and making it clear she would use them as weapons when when it was made abundantly clear that they were mortal.

One of her dumbest moves was to let cersei see she only had two dragons.  

If your dragons mean so much to you that losing them would make you roast innocent people alive ..maybe keep them at home, or stop bringing all of them to every fight.

  • Useful 1
  • Love 10
Link to comment
Message added by Athena

Keep it polite. Do not get personal and do not get into repetitive arguments about the characters or what defines a fiction. Further posts will be hidden and posters will be warned.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...