Jump to content

Type keyword(s) to search

Shimmergloom

Member
  • Posts

    143
  • Joined

Reputation

764 Excellent

Recent Profile Visitors

977 profile views
  1. I'm pretty sure that in that first season after Bran falls either Robb or Ned or someone laments how now Bran will never be able to be married or father children, so I think EVERYONE knew and it wasn't a secret.
  2. Season 1, she had Drogo marching on Westoros. She was perfectly willing for the Dothraki to rape and kill and pillage everything in sight to get her the throne all the way back then.
  3. This argument has been going on for years, but if Sansa really wanted to take Joffery's side why didn't she just say he was telling the truth? That's what she's suppose to do. Always take the side of her betrothed. By saying she didn't remember she is in effect saying he is not telling the truth, but I'm not going to say that out loud. It appears to have worked, because Robert knew the real dead with what was up and took that opportunity to try and deflate the situation as much as possible. He is even telling everyone that Joffery is lying by telling Ned that he was going to punish Joffery and Ned would punish Arya. And you're assuming alot in thinking it would have made everything ok for her to say Joffery was lying. Like Ned and everyone would have just been able to go back to Winterfell without incident. That whole court was a sham. The butcher's boy was already killed no matter what had happened for one thing. There was no good way out of what was happening. Only differing tiers of bad. So what more do you really want from the situation? Robert admitted already as it was that Joffery was lying. It didn't change anything.
  4. If you think that Sansa could have called Joffery a liar in public and everyone could have gone home happily you have been watching a different show. In that episode Robert openly makes it clear that he knows Joffery was lying when he sarcastically says "You were disarmed by this little girl". Robert knew why Sansa was claiming she didn't remember, Ned knew why, Cersei knew why. It didn't matter. Robert tells Ned they will each punish their own children, which proved he knew the truth. THEN HE DOES NOT PUNISH JOFFERY AT ALL.
  5. Should Sansa have told Tyrion? Probably not, but Jon didn't have to tell his sisters and Tyrion didn't have to tell Varys and yet Sansa is getting all the blame. And the onus seems to be all on Sansa for not liking Dany, but no blame to Arya for also not liking Dany or Varys for quickly turning against Dany. Arya has seemingly made no attempts to befriend Dany either. I am taking that as being Arya being able to read something about Dany that makes her mistrust her.
  6. This is ok because information cannot be destroyed, so she would remember that timeline meaning it still exists just separate from the one she was in. But Claire disappearing suggests that Claire stopped existing and that creates a paradox, unless she was just going back to her timeline. But I don't think that is what they want us to think, I think the suggestion is that the alternate timeline never existed. I would have preferred if that Claire remained and hid for the next 7 years, meaning her timeline still existed and all she did was create a new timeline. Similar to Yesterday's Enterprise where Alternate Tasha Yar doesn't disappear, but remains so we must assume her timeline didn't change, she and the Enterprise C just created a new one.
  7. Yeah, and it just creates a bigger paradox, because if that Claire doesn't exist then who comes back in time to erase Kelly's memory?
  8. Yeah, I agree. Whether she remembered or not(and it seems she did) this Kelly is in an alternate timeline, where she and Ed never got together.
  9. During the Long Night the White Walkers and Dead were everywhere along the North and the North survived by surviving the winter. It was even said by Old Nan that the older members of the families would go 'hunting' to spare their families when food ran low, meaning they would sacrifice themselves. So it seems to me that surviving the winter is still the bigger threat, being as the white walkers have had free reign in the past in the countryside. That doesn't mean the tv show is going to acknowledge it, but it is in the lore that has been presented from Season 1 onwards.
  10. Also, don't forget that from what we've seen and been told by Sansa, she's made sure to get as many people north of Winterfell to safety as possible and organized as much food to feed them through the winter(though we don't know if she planned on another "long night" or just a regular winter from recent history). That's actually forward thinking. Jon and Dany just showed up with the largest army in the world with no plan at all on how to feed them. For all the talk of the Night King being the real threat, I think we're forgetting that WINTER is the biggest threat. The Night King doesn't need to eat. He can just let Winter do his dirty work for him if he wanted to. Now since the Night King is basically a cartoon villain I'm sure he'll just attack head on and nto show forward thinking, but that doesn't mean that Sansa hasn't shown intelligence in preparing for the winter. It's just not super heroics and it seems like society in general doesn't value solid thinking over super heroics.
  11. When they say many more they mean many more than the 1 in a generation lie that is told by the government. But that could still mean there are so few that it is easy to cover up. For example current earth birthrates are something like 131,400,000 per year so if you say a generation is like every 20 years that's 2.6 billion born per generation. So Moclan was claiming that only 1 female birth was the average per 2.6 billion. But let's say it was .0001% of births, that's around 262,800 per generation or around 13,000 per year. That's still very easy to cover up, while being far greater than just 1. The female Moclan colony was said to have just 6,000 inhabitants and that almost all female births undergo the forced gender surgery. So maybe 1% make it to the colony per generation? Or around 2600 make it per 20 years.
  12. She went straight to Ezekiel and told him in the theater.
  13. I think we are suppose to infer from this and other zombie lore that since everyone is already infected and turn even if not bit when they die, that it's not getting infected that kills you, it's that the bite from a zombie causes an infection(or causes the infection that you already have to get out of control) that is not curable and kills you and then turns you into a zombie. So you can get the flu and survive, get shot and have an infected wound and survive if you get proper meds, but not a zombie bite infection, which has no meds that can help you fight the infection off.
  14. I don't think she is as powerful without her sisters. She needed to get her sisters out of the facility and needed the mutant underground to help make that happen. Once they were out, then the 3 of them were powerful enough to do everything on there own.
  15. Or her pod hasn't made it to the arrowverse earth yet and the arrowverse clark has also not revealed himself. Or even that the arrowverse's Krypton was not destroyed.
×
×
  • Create New...