S04.E03: All I See Is You

[Pallas]

John seeks revenge with help from some unexpected allies.

[toodywoody]

Ugh I can't stand Kayce's wife. She's just so weak. Have they both been locked up in the room the whole time? It's been months and he is right Tate needs to see a doctor and so does she. I guess she doesn't have the professor job anymore since she's been sitting in the room this whole time.

Jimmy should have told Mia that he did pick her and that's why he is in the mess he's in. 

I think we all know who ordered the hit now but I'll wait for the reveal just in case I'm wrong. 

Lloyd is really mad at the wrong person. He needs to be mad at Laramie because she just put him out to pasture for Walker. Rip is right though.

Rip was right about the kid too and I'm glad Beth saw it and told him he was right. 

Sooooo is no one noticing that Roake is gone, like the people he worked with? I'm not looking forward to old lady and her creepy voice. She sounds like the lady off Poltergeist so that's what I will be calling her. 

[SnarkAttack]

Monica annoys me.

The kid annoys me.

Jimmy annoys me.

Tate is getting big.

[RedDelicious]

I loved it when Kayce put that f*ckin flatlander in the grate. I might be turning into a Kayce fan apple. 

[MzLiz]

I was kind of sad that Beth gave up on the kid so quickly. Yes Rip was right. Though the kid ought to know to not to bite the hand that feeds him. But I liked the kid. The actor who plays him is quite a good actor. 

John took a big (stupid risk). He could have very easily died. 

Tate does need a doctor. But It’s been months since the events happened. I would have thought this scene would have happened much earlier. I like Kayce and did think he handled it right (unlike dropping that rancher in that grate which seems like will come back to bite him though I loved seeing him do it). 

That reveal was fairly unsatisfying though I didn’t think we’d get an answer this early. It seems like it can only be one person behind it.

I love this show. 

I’m definitely looking forward to the prequel. 1883. Sam Elliot and Tim McGraw…I’m in! 

Edited November 15, 2021 by MzLiz

[Crashcourse]

Well at least Walker did the right thing by moving him and whatshername into the trailer.  I agree, Lloyd should be angrier at her, but Walker did kind of throw the relationship in Lloyd's face in the bunkhouse.  He was right to be worried that Lloyd might stab him in his sleep, lol. 

31 minutes ago, toodywoody said:

Jimmy should have told Mia that he did pick her and that's why he is in the mess he's in. 

Exactly.  I hope he doesn't get weak and try to get back to her because she's no good for him.

I still say the kid would be better off with another family besides Beth and Rip.  The last thing he needs is a drunken foster mama and a murderin' foster dad.   

Monica and Tate should go back to the trailer where they lived, although I think Tate likes being around the cowboys at the ranch. 

[Msample]

For being Rainwater’s right hand man, Mo gets paid shit if he can barely afford PB&J sandwiches. 

 

Kayce’s military tactics are slipping - when they stopped the two militias in the pick up, he fired at them with friendlies behind the targets

[Bulldog]

I know the Duttons are portrayed as the all powerful ruling class of Montana, but are we to really believe that every one of the law enforcement that participated in those raids not only didn't object, but kept quiet about, what was basically straight up murder. 

Beth would make a terrible mother, but I was definitely hoping she would carry out the assault on the busy body customer in the store with the camera.  Kid was being a brat. 

I get that they are trying to toughen up Jimmy, but making him remove the back and neck brace (which presumably is medically necessary) so as not to damage your fancy truck seats seemed over the top. 

Speaking of over the top, Kayce and his dealings with the guy who installed the cattle guards definitely went to far.  Is there some kind of free range law in Montana?  Is allowing cattle to cross property some how tied to the tax credit he mentioned the guy taking?  If not, seems the guy was well within his rights to not want the cattle on his property.  Now, I grew up in a rural area as I've mentioned before, and I know that good neighbors make allowances when it comes to other peoples' animals, but as far as I know, its not required by law.   Have we seen the guy who owned the cattle before.  He seemed to personally know Kayce.  Would Kayce do that for all of his constituents?    

Edited November 15, 2021 by Bulldog

[Artsda]

Now Lloyd has issues with the girls in the bunkhouse? He didn't before.  I don't understand why they're letting them park/live there? The blonde one is working on the ranch? They both need to go. Hopefully with Jimmy gone Mia is done. She's the reason he's gone and he should realize that.

I guess Jimmy's away a bit. 

So Tate's been under the bed for weeks and weeks and Monica's just been sitting there enabling him? WTH. She's annoying and she's going to blame Kasey for his dad being evil? The same dad she ran to save Kasey from jail? They didn't ask for a militia to attack them.

The kid was a brat in the store, Rip was right. 

 

[RedDelicious]

55 minutes ago, Bulldog said:

Is allowing cattle to cross property some how tied to the tax credit he mentioned the guy taking?  If not, seems the guy was well within his rights to not want the cattle on his property. 

The cattle owner had an easement which by law allowed him to move his cattle over the California guy’s portion of the road. In simple terms, an easement is a legal agreement between landowners for one to utilize the others, whether it’s something like a radius for a well that encroaches on a neighbor’s land or usage of a a section of private road that leads to a neighbor’s pasture. Once it is agreed upon, the easement must be disclosed and it transfers along with future sales of the property.

California guy said he was keeping llamas for the livestock tax break.

I actually don’t think Beth would be a terrible mother. If my kid acted like that in a store he’d get a lot more than his ears boxed. 

Edited November 15, 2021 by RedDelicious

[RedDelicious]

Also Tate is a really bad actor. If he was that freaked out he’d be back under the bed with his dinner plate. He went to the couch with his dinner too easily, as if nothing was amiss. I wouldn’t forsake a plate made by Gator under any circumstances!

Gator if you’re reading this, we still need your biscuit recipe. 

I can’t with Monica. At least she wasn’t in the shower.

[Sharper2002]

So Tate’s been under the bed and Monica’s been sulking this entire time? And then Carter – do any of these kids attend school? Is it a thing? I know Tate did in season 1, but between being kidnapped and suffering from PTSD from this most recent episode, I’m assuming he’s not learning much. And Carter, I know he said he dropped out but I guess there’s going to be no attempt to get him to go back. 

Carter was a brat in the store, but assuming he’d been through a lot and he’s still grieving the death of his father. But I guess Rip turning him into a branded man that will take men to the train station is going to “make him a man”. 

Does this mean Mia can go now? 

[Crashcourse]

Yes, Carter was a brat in the store but I do think Beth overreacted, which led to the woman with the camera overreacting.  Both of the "adults" were wrong, and I was glad the kid apologized to Beth.   

10 hours ago, Sharper2002 said:

But I guess Rip turning him into a branded man that will take men to the train station is going to “make him a man”. 

I hope that doesn't happen to the kid but I could definitely see Rip doing that.  Hell, Carter would even be better off with Jamie and his dad.

[TVbitch]

I enjoy this show, but it is pretty much a soap opera for men. "Toxic masculinity" is a hero's trait to be rooted for, and it solves most of the problems, be they business, family, law enforcement, or legal issues --hell, even children with severe PTSD just need a minute with a real man to sort them out! Taking it easy after being shot all to hell is for pussies! Back braces after severe injuries are things to be laughed at! A guy who raises llamas and wants to involve his lawyer in his dispute is a lame pansy and should be assaulted!  

It's entertaining, but sometimes I just laugh. 

[Msample]

Ugh, more scenes of the kid being rammed down our throats yet no signs of Jamie. Another montage of rodeo porn to showcase that Taylor Sheridan can indeed ride a horse. This show is falling into the classic trap of introducing more characters and plotlines that a 10 show season has room for. 

[Crashcourse]

Things I'm getting tired of:

-  all the violence, the murderin'

- "Rambo" Kasey (who can't stop shooting up people and shit)

- drunk, F-bomb throwing Beth ('cause that's all she's good at)

- sour-faced Monica 

- the rodeo shows

- anything involving Rainwater

- dumbass Jimmy

I don't know if this is supposed to be the last season, but I can only take one more season of this.   Too bad because I used to love this show.

[The Pretender]

So not the greatest episode but in fairness it was hard to top those two first episodes. In my humble opinion of course. Kayce was this weeks MVP for me. Love Rip and Beth's relationship and how far they've come, they fight in the very best way. Beth's greatest fear showcased in the cabin when they were alone though. I'm worried it will come between them even if Rip says it won't. Still a fan of Carter even if he's a brat at times. I hope Tate will join him outside so we can see them bonding (and I suspect some fist fights in the future between them like Kayce/Rip).

I'm not a fan of the bunnies either but I can see them hanging around seeing how they were there when the ranch was hit, they're in this screwed up/branded family now I guess. I want to see Lloyd kick Walker's ass in some way or another, he has it coming.

I love Teeter. Jen Landon is doing awesome work in the background, she's hilarious to keep an eye out for, and I appreciated that they didn't show her topless last Sunday even if she was topless in the bunk house. Great placement of head of other actor in that shot. 

Not as impressed by the horses this week. I wanna see llamas. Give me llamas. They're frickin adorable. 

[RedDelicious]

1 hour ago, The Pretender said:

Not as impressed by the horses this week. I wanna see llamas. Give me llamas. They're frickin adorable. 

They really are. One of my high school teachers raised llamas. She said they were very clean and you could bring them right into the house (which they did on occasion). They are camelids so they have soft feet 😊 

I also love Teeter. Did you notice how they had her all glammed up in the first episode(s)? 

[Crashcourse]

For people who know about horses, does it affect their legs in any way when they stop so short like that?  What do they call that and why do people want to watch that?  

Teeter's growing on me.  Never thought I'd say that.

 

[rhygirl720]

55 minutes ago, Crashcourse said:

For people who know about horses, does it affect their legs in any way when they stop so short like that?  What do they call that and why do people want to watch that?  

Teeter's growing on me.  Never thought I'd say that.

 

Its a sliding stop. A signature reining move. Its why they wear the boots. Also a reining horse only competes for a short time .These horses are incredible athletes worth huge $$$$

 love Teeter especially compared to Mia and Laramie...ugh

[Crashcourse]

Thanks for the explanation.  Although I was afraid my legs would hurt just looking at them sliding to a stop like that, lol. 

[rhygirl720]

In case anyone was wondering.   .Who They Rode: Trainers Bring Top Horses to Yellowstone TV Show - Quarter Horse Newhttps://l.facebook.com/l.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.quarterhorsenews.com%2F2020%2F08%2Fwho-they-rode-trainers-bring-top-horses-to-yellowstone-tv-show%2F%3Ffbclid%3DIwAR2RrPUYQX-PeEQNtMvJXYVq4LltNWhPkV-LYtwQuoxW3Ar6F4Ff_sovnQE&h=AT1sBeqA-Uj94n2jL3fg7FFF0ycJ5qRMCWKQPTdU9aJl29aq-Na3yWqFABfvaGFsp5vb-iILIwFiECR6nVWagwOs49kofnjKa5whz8DPC2ijUT-BnBghRuHpRTwZxxIKFg&__tn__=%2CmH-R&c[0]=AT0He9sGw1P1IMSX_PdkGp_j39YWVoEuRrTsRgr0qLNE_bU-kovROokm4CCvmGksdFjV4pgcUoHAapfBzM-Gh3b_PtxHyusKJClsyg3xfW-DGD38kTmLDCuvd9EMXWb0hASr6BmtFruZZQ-7MfIyrJFFtQyDNr3x6QptjQ_RSj70EqKJ0pkkYVdOew

 

 

 

 

 

Edited November 16, 2021 by rhygirl720

[tennisgurl]

Tate's been sitting under that bed for months now while Monica has been sitting there letting it happen? Seriously? Kayce just grabbing the kid and telling him to get it together might not be the best way to handle the problem, but at least its not just sitting there crying and letting the kid stew in his trauma. Freaking Monica. 

Teeter has shockingly become one of my favorites, I appreciate her wackiness as a break to the never ending Dutton melodrama. 

Not the shows best outing, especially such an exciting season premier, but its still just good to have the show back. Shallowly, Kevin Costner has never looked better then he does this season in my opinion. 

[Crashcourse]

4 minutes ago, tennisgurl said:

Teeter has shockingly become one of my favorites, I appreciate her wackiness as a break to the never ending Dutton melodrama. 

I know!  She's a refreshing break from all the Dutton drama.  I wish Colby would trim his damn beard and get a haircut though, lol.

I really do think the show is getting dragged down with all the murdering and shenanigans.  It would be refreshing if they showed some lighter, funnier episodes once in a while.  I'd love to see the bunkhouse folks having fun somewhere.

[blackwing]

When did Jimmy become the lead actor on this show?  I thought this show was "Yellowstone" and the primary characters were the Duttons led by Kevin Costner.  It seemed like 50% of the scenes on this episode featured Jimmy.  Honestly, I really couldn't give a crap about Jimmy.  I don't care if he's hurt, I don't care how he got hurt, I don't care about his rodeo, I don't care about his girlfriend being mad at him because he didn't acknowledge her... I simply DO NOT CARE at all about Jimmy anymore.  It's season 4 and we have suffered through three seasons of "Jimmy is a fish out of water" and it is BEYOND TIRED and irritating.  Please just ship him off to the Four Sixes Ranch permanently.

The other 40% of the scenes seemed to feature the kid.  And I really don't care about the kid.  He's a brat and he looks like a younger version of the twin on "Superman and Lois" with the pudgy face and floppy hair.  I get that he has a reason to hate his life, but I wish he would hate it somewhere else and not on this TV show.

I would have preferred to have seen what was going on with Jamie and his birth dad.  Or Beth investigating who ordered the hits.  The reveal of that guy in the car and the photo of the other guy in prison was completely unsatisfying because we have no idea who they are.  I wanted to see them being tied to Silver Hair and/or Jamie's dad.

Don't really care about Monica or Tate.  I liked Monica in the prior season when she was a professor (is she still a professor?  Or is she just sitting in Tate's room all day long) and she educated her ignorant students.  But this season... it's been three months (I think) since the hits and Tate is still hiding under the bed every day and not eating?  Kayce went to the dining room and acted like he was surprised/disappointed that Monica and Tate didn't show up, but it sounds like this a daily thing?  Both Monica and Tate need to go see a psychiatrist or therapist.

I know that Kayce is a livestock agent and that's an official law enforcement position authorised to have guns, but can someone please explain what happened in the opening sequence?  Where Kayce killed the big bald underwear brute, and then killed those two guys in the pickup truck with a barrage of automatic weapons fire that was reminiscent of hunting down Bonnie and Clyde?  Was he following up on leads about who tried to kill his family, or is this something he does in his ordinary role as livestock agent?  Or maybe these scenes were just there to demonstrate that "Kayce is badass, he is putting all his anger about the hits on his family into his job, don't cross him".  I was greatly confused because when Rainwater showed John the picture of the guy in prison who ordered the hits, I thought that was the same guy as Bald Underwear Guy who was killed in the opening sequence.

On 11/14/2021 at 10:24 PM, Artsda said:

Now Lloyd has issues with the girls in the bunkhouse? He didn't before.  I don't understand why they're letting them park/live there? The blonde one is working on the ranch? They both need to go. Hopefully with Jimmy gone Mia is done. She's the reason he's gone and he should realize that.

They are all useless... except for the one that was almost killed with Colby last season.  I think that one is Teeter?  The one with the pink/blonde hair?  I recall there was one that was actually hired as a ranch hand (who I think might be Teeter) but I thought the other ones (including Jimmy's girlfriend) are just barrel racers.  I have no idea why they are being allowed to stay there.

On 11/15/2021 at 11:03 AM, Crashcourse said:

Yes, Carter was a brat in the store but I do think Beth overreacted, which led to the woman with the camera overreacting.  Both of the "adults" were wrong, and I was glad the kid apologized to Beth.   

I think she overreacted a bit but she had told him he needed boots and he's like nope you're buying me this shirt and I'm not taking it off.  She is not used to being a parent, he's not used to listening to a parent, and I think they were both in the wrong.  But honestly, I would have told that woman with the phone to STFU, it was completely none of her business.  And she's all "I'm recording you and going to put this on YouTube and make myself a star".

21 hours ago, Msample said:

Ugh, more scenes of the kid being rammed down our throats yet no signs of Jamie. Another montage of rodeo porn to showcase that Taylor Sheridan can indeed ride a horse. This show is falling into the classic trap of introducing more characters and plotlines that a 10 show season has room for. 

I didn't understand why he had at least two sequences of turning the horses around and round in circles.  And skidding to a halt.  I would have rather have seen more of the main characters.

Edited November 16, 2021 by blackwing

[bichonblitz]

20 hours ago, The Pretender said:

Jen Landon is doing awesome work in the background

Jen Landon= the late great Michael Landon's daughter. Who knew. 

[Moose135]

1 hour ago, blackwing said:

When did Jimmy become the lead actor on this show?  I thought this show was "Yellowstone" and the primary characters were the Duttons led by Kevin Costner.  It seemed like 50% of the scenes on this episode featured Jimmy. 

I think Jimmy is going to be in the "6666" spin-off coming to Paramount+ so this was all to set up that new show, similar to the "flashback" scene with Tim McGraw and the Native American wanting to bury his father's remains on the ranch.

1 hour ago, blackwing said:

Both Monica and Tate need to go see a psychiatrist or therapist.

They all do.

 

1 hour ago, blackwing said:

I know that Kayce is a livestock agent and that's an official law enforcement position authorised to have guns, but can someone please explain what happened in the opening sequence?  Where Kayce killed the big bald underwear brute, and then killed those two guys in the pickup truck with a barrage of automatic weapons fire that was reminiscent of hunting down Bonnie and Clyde?  Was he following up on leads about who tried to kill his family, or is this something he does in his ordinary role as livestock agent?

They were all part of the militia group that was involved with kidnapping Tate last (?) season on behalf of the Beck brothers. The Duttons believe the remaining militia members were responsible for the assassination attempts, and Papa Dutton - while they were in that pool in the woods - told Kayce to kill them all.

3 hours ago, tennisgurl said:

Tate's been sitting under that bed for months now while Monica has been sitting there letting it happen? Seriously? Kayce just grabbing the kid and telling him to get it together might not be the best way to handle the problem, but at least its not just sitting there crying and letting the kid stew in his trauma. Freaking Monica. 

Tate's father certainly hasn't helped much either. It took him how long to notice and do something?

2 hours ago, blackwing said:

I didn't understand why he had at least two sequences of turning the horses around and round in circles.

Made me wonder if horses get dizzy doing that.

[Moose135]

On 11/14/2021 at 11:22 PM, Bulldog said:

Have we seen the guy who owned the cattle before.  He seemed to personally know Kayce. 

I think he was one of the ranchers who went to see Kayce last season asking him to run for governor.

[LegalParrot81]

3 hours ago, bichonblitz said:

Jen Landon= the late great Michael Landon's daughter. Who knew. 

I must confess....I knew.  Her first big break was on my soap.  Nice to see her making a successful transition, so many soap actors don't.  

Right now, her character is my favorite.  They've made everyone else major downers.

 

[kn51]

This episode was such a discombobulated mess.  Feels like it is trying to be all things to all people which usually results in a bunch of cringe worthy nonsense tacked together with a hot glue gun.  And my god in that regard this episode proved it.

Hard to put a finger on, just felt really contrived.  Hell I was expecting a disfigured Tate to leap out from under the bed as a rabid jungle boy gnawing on a bone and grunting.  

 

[Msample]

8 hours ago, Moose135 said:

I think he was one of the ranchers who went to see Kayce last season asking him to run for governor.

Correct. I thought he looked familiar - the actor portrayed one of Wyatt Earps posse in TOMBSTONE , Turkey Creek Jack Johnson ( interestingly, the  non Costner Earp movie ) . 

https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0852076/?ref_=ttfc_fc_cl_t23

[rhygirl720]

10 hours ago, blackwing said:

 

11 hours ago, blackwing said:

 

I didn't understand why he had at least two sequences of turning the horses around and round in circles.  And skidding to a halt.  I would have rather have seen more of the main characters.

well personally I'd rather watch the horses than say..Laramie, mia, carter, jimmy and a whole bunch of other stuff including the monica and tate scene 

[Lonesome Rhodes]

This may have  been the record for outrageous and impossible actions in one ep of Y.  I did enjoy the heck out of the Karen and the Cali weasel getting their comeuppance, if only for a very short time. 

I noticed just before the shooting commenced in the traffic stop that the agents who were behind the stopped truck moved off to their left.  No dummies them, they were not in the direct line of fire.   Vaporizing the driver who went for his weapon was entirely lawful.  All the previous killings in the sequence?  Murder.  Not sure about the companion who was with the dude who reached.

It was a joke that Kayce was  not aware of a  months-long dispute about the cattle and the easements.  The Godfather, er, John Dutton, would have been apprised and asked for assistance.

It is now official:  Monica is more cray cray than Beth.  Do any of y'all recall when it was finally decided that she would bring Tate to the Y that she begged to live on the reservation?  My sense is that a whole lot of stuff went down and the only reasonable choice was to go all-in with JD and the Y.

Beth was so right about the Karen's true motivations and fears.  Wow.  Methinks she is mistaken about Rip growing a resentment over her being barren.

Once again, I loved the meet with Rainwater.  Peas in a pod, those two.  For me, the tensions between them are the show.  They each have difficult hands to play.  Dutton's is horrid (impossible?).  Yet they each share the very same and ancient love of their land.  Nobody outside can understand it, nor them.  They need each other.

 

[SuprSuprElevated]

On 11/15/2021 at 6:32 PM, Crashcourse said:

Thanks for the explanation.  Although I was afraid my legs would hurt just looking at them sliding to a stop like that, lol. 

My husband and I had the same concerns.  "Isn't that terribly hard on those horses"?  I choose not to think about what happens when their 'career' ends.

[SuprSuprElevated]

On 11/16/2021 at 11:37 AM, blackwing said:

I didn't understand why he had at least two sequences of turning the horses around and round in circles.  And skidding to a halt.  I would have rather have seen more of the main characters.

They are indulgently cross-promoting other shows, to the point of aggravation for the viewer, well this viewer anyway.  I also find it tedious and not germane to the storyline.  I know John wants to blah blah horses, and Jimmy blah blah whatever, but still.

I also agree that they are taking huge liberties with Kayce's Livestock Agent authority.  "Let me just put on my LA flak vest, then go murder people in the name of cattlemen everywhere."  It's more stretch than my Spanx get on a given day.  

Edited November 17, 2021 by SuprSuprElevated

[Cool Breeze]

15 hours ago, Msample said:

Correct. I thought he looked familiar - the actor portrayed one of Wyatt Earps posse in TOMBSTONE , Turkey Creek Jack Johnson ( interestingly, the  non Costner Earp movie ) . 

https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0852076/?ref_=ttfc_fc_cl_t23

Buck Taylor goes way back.  He was a series regular on "Gunsmoke" in the '60's.

[Haleth]

4 hours ago, SuprSuprElevated said:

My husband and I had the same concerns.  "Isn't that terribly hard on those horses"?  I choose not to think about what happens when their 'career' ends.

Yeah, I did not enjoy watching this. It seems awfully hard on the horses’ joints. And it’s not like they can choose to play. 

[rhygirl720]

5 hours ago, SuprSuprElevated said:

My husband and I had the same concerns.  "Isn't that terribly hard on those horses"?  I choose not to think about what happens when their 'career' ends.

They re put put to stud. The great ones are worth millions. metallic cat who was on last year is the 4.3 million dollar horse. His progeny have earned 4.3 not to mention what he earned and what his stud fees are. this is what John is talking about when discussing how to generate money through horses.

[sas616]

On 11/16/2021 at 11:59 AM, bichonblitz said:

Jen Landon= the late great Michael Landon's daughter. Who knew. 

When I saw her listed in the credits, I couldn't for the life of me figure out which character she was playing.   Then on here I saw she was Teeter and couldn't believe it.   A bit different from the character she played on As The World Turns (and won an Daytime Emmy). 

 

Edited November 18, 2021 by sas616
Edited to delete file that wouldn't upload.

[Bali]

I'm in the minority because I didn't miss Jaime at all. I don't care what he's doing. 

I've been done with Monica since the beginning. I'm with Kayce, it's time to drag the kid out from under that bed. And then, Kayce, get a divorce and let her go away. The woman is a loon.

Speaking of loons, John is going to die in the saddle.

I hope that when Jimmy becomes paralyzed, he sues John Dutton. The attitude of "ignore the doctors" is stupid.

My husband likes this show a lot more than I do.

[SuprSuprElevated]

2 minutes ago, Bali said:

I'm in the minority because I didn't miss Jaime at all. I don't care what he's doing. 

I've been done with Monica since the beginning. I'm with Kayce, it's time to drag the kid out from under that bed. And then, Kayce, get a divorce and let her go away. The woman is a loon.

Speaking of loons, John is going to die in the saddle.

I hope that when Jimmy becomes paralyzed, he sues John Dutton. The attitude of "ignore the doctors" is stupid.

My husband likes this show a lot more than I do.

Wasn't it John who, after paying Jimmy's substantial medical bills, told him to stop the rodeo nonsense or he would be done with him?  I agree that John himself excels in ignoring medical advice, but Jimmy made his own bed I thought.  Am I remembering it incorrectly?

 

[Moose135]

57 minutes ago, SuprSuprElevated said:

Wasn't it John who, after paying Jimmy's substantial medical bills, told him to stop the rodeo nonsense or he would be done with him?  I agree that John himself excels in ignoring medical advice, but Jimmy made his own bed I thought.  Am I remembering it incorrectly?

No, you are correct. John told him to stop riding rodeo, and Jimmy ignored him because of his buckle bunny.

[mledawn]

46 minutes ago, Moose135 said:

No, you are correct. John told him to stop riding rodeo, and Jimmy ignored him because of his buckle bunny.

Yes and thankfully this is why Jimmy is off to 6666. John had that sit-down with Jimmy and said basically I told you not to do this but you did, so you’re done here.

Jimmy is such a colossal waste of time. “I have nothing”. Well, you had something and you blew it. But also now you sort of have some marketable ranch skills. Go work somewhere else ffs. 

[Moose135]

Jimmy has always been our favorite, "Poor Jimmy" we usually call him, but he hasn't been doing himself any favors lately.

BTW, love your dog, @mledawn! He/she isn't an Aussie by chance?

[mledawn]

23 minutes ago, Moose135 said:

Jimmy has always been our favorite, "Poor Jimmy" we usually call him, but he hasn't been doing himself any favors lately.

BTW, love your dog, @mledawn! He/she isn't an Aussie by chance?

Jimmy will have an opportunity to redeem himself on that new show, I am sure. 

Thank you - she’s a border. 50/50 chance you guessed correctly, really ;)

 

[MBayGal]

4 hours ago, Bali said:

hope that when Jimmy becomes paralyzed, he sues John Dutton. The attitude of "ignore the doctors" is stupid.

Why sue John ? John told him to listen to the doctor and quit riding for good. That bitch Mia basically said if he wouldn't get on that rodeo horse he wasn't man enough for her.  That's why he's in the shape he's in.  He may be in worse shape after Travis made him take of the brace so it wouldn't scratch his crocodile leather seat, but that's not on John either. 

[roughing it]

5 hours ago, Bali said:

My husband likes this show a lot more than I do.

Mine too.

[madmax]

On 11/16/2021 at 10:34 AM, Crashcourse said:

I really do think the show is getting dragged down with all the murdering and shenanigans.  It would be refreshing if they showed some lighter, funnier episodes once in a while.  I'd love to see the bunkhouse folks having fun somewhere.

It's been pretty much murdering and shenanigans since the beginning, with a sprinkling of funny.

On 11/16/2021 at 11:03 PM, Lonesome Rhodes said:

Beth was so right about the Karen's true motivations and fears.  Wow.  Methinks she is mistaken about Rip growing a resentment over her being barren.

I think she is completely mistaken.  I think Rip is with her for the long haul, come what may, even if it's snotty kids named Carter.

Speaking of Beth, I'm a fan.  I wasn't in the beginning, but she's really grown on me.  Still a bitch on heels, but she's shown some softness, mostly because of Rip.  But her in the truck, explaining the 4 ways to become rich?  I laughed my ass off, then laughed even harder at Carter's response.  And her dealing with the nosy shopper was great.

So John gave the guy an unwiped gun and just let it rip?  Didn't clean the prints, didn't look for the gun when the guy fell (to me it looked like he was empty-handed when he fell)?  And isn't that "train station" getting full?

[ShortyMac]

I love Beth as a character. In real life, I’m sure I wouldn’t. I love when her claws come out, I love her vulnerable moments. 

[Bali]

On 11/18/2021 at 7:50 AM, SuprSuprElevated said:

Wasn't it John who, after paying Jimmy's substantial medical bills, told him to stop the rodeo nonsense or he would be done with him?  I agree that John himself excels in ignoring medical advice, but Jimmy made his own bed I thought.  Am I remembering it incorrectly?

 

Yes, you are correct. But then Jimmy DID ignore and fell. But John should not have sent Jimmy to learn to cowboy up. Ok, Jimmy shouldn't sue John. Jimmy is now, always has been, and ever shall be- an idjit