Katy M July 20, 2020 Share July 20, 2020 16 minutes ago, peacheslatour said: Lorelai was stupid as hell to pay back the Gilmores just as Rory was starting Yale. She was so super sure Rory was going to get a scholarship. She should have waited to make sure that was going to happen before she did anything with that money. Stupid story line. She didn't think she was going to get a scholarship. She thought that she was going to get financial aid based on her income. Which she would have but for the extra money. Which she apparently didn't think was going to count as income. 2 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6239011
readster July 21, 2020 Share July 21, 2020 18 hours ago, peacheslatour said: Lorelai was stupid as hell to pay back the Gilmores just as Rory was starting Yale. She was so super sure Rory was going to get a scholarship. She should have waited to make sure that was going to happen before she did anything with that money. Stupid story line. Not to mention, the money she got would should have gone for the Inn right away. Also the fact that Richard signing the check and handing it Lorelai magically told FAFSA and the IRS less than a month before graduation would say that Rory couldn't qualify for ANYTHING! Plus the fact that wouldn't be reported until NEXT YEAR'S taxes. Plus the fact the sell off happened at the beginning of the year, so you can't use "not reported" excuse either. It was so stupid. 1 5 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6241022
peacheslatour July 21, 2020 Share July 21, 2020 3 hours ago, readster said: Not to mention, the money she got would should have gone for the Inn right away. Also the fact that Richard signing the check and handing it Lorelai magically told FAFSA and the IRS less than a month before graduation would say that Rory couldn't qualify for ANYTHING! Plus the fact that wouldn't be reported until NEXT YEAR'S taxes. Plus the fact the sell off happened at the beginning of the year, so you can't use "not reported" excuse either. It was so stupid. Exactly. When I got student loans, they looked a the previous year's tax returns. There was no way the lender knew anything about that money. She should have put it straight into the Inn and never said a word to Emily. For someone who claimed she'd spent her entire life keeping her mom out of her business, she sure blew that to hell. 4 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6241250
readster July 22, 2020 Share July 22, 2020 22 hours ago, peacheslatour said: Exactly. When I got student loans, they looked a the previous year's tax returns. There was no way the lender knew anything about that money. She should have put it straight into the Inn and never said a word to Emily. For someone who claimed she'd spent her entire life keeping her mom out of her business, she sure blew that to hell. Well, not to mention that Lorelai was like: "Magically I will NEVER EVER... EVER have to go back to my parents again. Thank you unknown buyer who just gave me $75K. Fuck you mom and dad and the past three years!" Sorry, if I got $75K right now, I wouldn't be just handing it to one person. I take out my ALL of my bills, put money to my son and keep the rest for any future businesses, house repairs or emergency money. But not Lorelai, it was: "Now, now, now, let's go out and eat and drop $50." 2 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6242677
marineg July 24, 2020 Share July 24, 2020 Not to mention the fact that even though 75k was a large sum of money, it wouldn't cover 3 years of Chilton, and much less have anything left over. We can guess Chilton was about $50,000 based on the first episode "Wow, that is a lot of zeros behind that five." I'm guessing it wasn't $5,000 or she wouldn't be shocked and need a loan. 2 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6246590
peacheslatour July 24, 2020 Share July 24, 2020 40 minutes ago, marineg said: Not to mention the fact that even though 75k was a large sum of money, it wouldn't cover 3 years of Chilton, and much less have anything left over. We can guess Chilton was about $50,000 based on the first episode "Wow, that is a lot of zeros behind that five." I'm guessing it wasn't $5,000 or she wouldn't be shocked and need a loan. It certainly wasn't going to cover four years at Yale. My dad went to Yale for a year before transferring to Penn State. 2 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6246672
Katy M July 24, 2020 Share July 24, 2020 1 hour ago, marineg said: Not to mention the fact that even though 75k was a large sum of money, it wouldn't cover 3 years of Chilton, and much less have anything left over. We can guess Chilton was about $50,000 based on the first episode "Wow, that is a lot of zeros behind that five." I'm guessing it wasn't $5,000 or she wouldn't be shocked and need a loan. $50K per year? That was about double the cost of Harvard at the time. Seems a bit pricey. I think it was $5K a year or more likely $5K a semester. 1 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6246709
marineg July 24, 2020 Share July 24, 2020 9 minutes ago, Katy M said: $50K per year? That was about double the cost of Harvard at the time. Seems a bit pricey. I think it was $5K a year or more likely $5K a semester. Right you are. However, as much as $50k seems too high for 2003 (although it is appropriate for 2020...) $5k seems too low. Private schools have more or less the same tuition as private colleges. So maybe $25,000 and she met "Wow, that is a lot of zeros behind that five" behind that 2. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6246726
peacheslatour July 24, 2020 Share July 24, 2020 Just now, marineg said: Right you are. However, as much as $50k seems too high for 2003 (although it is appropriate for 2020...) $5k seems too low. Private schools have more or less the same tuition as private colleges. So maybe $25,000 and she met "Wow, that is a lot of zeros behind that five" behind that 2. My son was in private elementary school. Kindergarten alone was 6k a year and that was in the friggin eighties. 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6246730
Katy M July 24, 2020 Share July 24, 2020 8 minutes ago, marineg said: Right you are. However, as much as $50k seems too high for 2003 (although it is appropriate for 2020...) $5k seems too low. Private schools have more or less the same tuition as private colleges. So maybe $25,000 and she met "Wow, that is a lot of zeros behind that five" behind that 2. $5K a quarter? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6246742
marineg July 24, 2020 Share July 24, 2020 10 minutes ago, peacheslatour said: My son was in private elementary school. Kindergarten alone was 6k a year and that was in the friggin eighties. I was reading an article about Harvard tuition and in the 80s, it was about 10k, and it is now almost 50k (not including room and board). From what I read, private school was about the same price, with an increase from kindergarten to middle school to high school. So yeah 25k would make sense. Basically, Richard gave 75k to Lorelai, Rory and she talked about all the things they would do with the money like buying a boat, "no more picking loose change up from the ground," "no more driving around looking for cheap gas" and the best of the best, "we've got the rest of Grandpa's money, that's plenty to buy the Dragonfly Inn." In what world would 75k be enough for 3 years of private school plus buying a frickin' inn in Connecticut and be "plenty"? 2 3 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6246763
peacheslatour July 24, 2020 Share July 24, 2020 17 minutes ago, marineg said: I was reading an article about Harvard tuition and in the 80s, it was about 10k, and it is now almost 50k (not including room and board). From what I read, private school was about the same price, with an increase from kindergarten to middle school to high school. So yeah 25k would make sense. Basically, Richard gave 75k to Lorelai, Rory and she talked about all the things they would do with the money like buying a boat, "no more picking loose change up from the ground," "no more driving around looking for cheap gas" and the best of the best, "we've got the rest of Grandpa's money, that's plenty to buy the Dragonfly Inn." In what world would 75k be enough for 3 years of private school plus buying a frickin' inn in Connecticut and be "plenty"? Totally ridiculous. 3 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6246800
chessiegal July 24, 2020 Share July 24, 2020 When Lorelai says there's a lot of zeros behind that 5, it was for an enrollment fee, not tuition. Quote LORELAI: I'm holding for Miss Bell. I've been trying to get a hold of her all day. [pause] Lorelai Gilmore. [pause] Hi! Oh, hi, hi. Yeah, uh, my daughter Rory has just been accepted - yay. [pause] Thank you, and, um, I got the invoice for your enrollment fee. Wow, that is a lot of zeros behind that five. 2 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6246844
Taryn74 July 24, 2020 Share July 24, 2020 2 hours ago, chessiegal said: When Lorelai says there's a lot of zeros behind that 5, it was for an enrollment fee, not tuition. Yeah, I fanwank that the enrollment fee was $5,000 and Lorelai wasn't expecting to have to pay that right away or Rory would lose her spot. As many people as adore Rory in the town, pulling together $500 to send her to a swanky school wouldn't have been a problem. It's still ridiculous that Lorelai had no real plans for how to pay for Chilton without going to her parents - the show really should have had her counting on getting a scholarship which didn't come through since Rory is, after all, A Gilmore(!) - but we do the best we can with what we were given. 3 hours ago, marineg said: I was reading an article about Harvard tuition and in the 80s, it was about 10k, and it is now almost 50k (not including room and board). Okay well now I'm just pissed off. My daughter's tuition (private college in Arkansas, certainly not an Ivy League) is $55k. That does include room and board and a full meal plan, though. Most of the students go on scholarships of some description, I doubt many of them pay the full price. We certainly couldn't, LOL. 2 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6247113
marineg July 24, 2020 Share July 24, 2020 59 minutes ago, Taryn74 said: Yeah, I fanwank that the enrollment fee was $5,000 and Lorelai wasn't expecting to have to pay that right away or Rory would lose her spot. You're right, that makes sense. 59 minutes ago, Taryn74 said: Okay well now I'm just pissed off. My daughter's tuition (private college in Arkansas, certainly not an Ivy League) is $55k. That does include room and board and a full meal plan Yeah the article was about 2019 tuition and it was about $47.5k tuition, and with room and board just shy of $70k. I went to a private college in Boston (2016) and it was about those prices. I don't think it gets much more expensive if it's Ivy League, I think it's more state vs private. 3 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6247196
Taryn74 July 25, 2020 Share July 25, 2020 And thinking on it further.......the show could have had Lorelai expecting Rory to get a financial aid scholarship for Chilton, find out last minute she didn't qualify, swallow her pride and go to her parents, yada yada yada -- only to find out several months into the FND compromise that Headmaster Charleston had actually contacted Emily and Richard and they advised him not to give Rory a scholarship (knowing it would send Lorelai to them for help). Now THAT would have been the kind of meddling Lorelai always accused them of, and would justify both her not having any plan for paying for Chilton and also paying back the "loan" as soon as she was able to because it had truly been given on false pretenses. What incredible, organic drama that would have been! But, no. Organic is out of the question on this show. 5 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6247311
andromeda331 July 25, 2020 Share July 25, 2020 Either one of those would have made sense. Rory was starting school late so maybe the scholarship or financial money was already gone. Or they could have given Lorelai an emergency that came up before they got the letter that wiped out the money for it. Anyone of them would have made more sense then showing Lorelai being an idiot for not saving up money while trying to get her daughter into a private school and wanting her to go to Harvard. 2 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6247622
junienmomo July 25, 2020 Share July 25, 2020 15 hours ago, Taryn74 said: And thinking on it further.......the show could have had Lorelai expecting Rory to get a financial aid scholarship for Chilton, find out last minute she didn't qualify, swallow her pride and go to her parents, yada yada yada -- only to find out several months into the FND compromise that Headmaster Charleston had actually contacted Emily and Richard and they advised him not to give Rory a scholarship (knowing it would send Lorelai to them for help). Now THAT would have been the kind of meddling Lorelai always accused them of, and would justify both her not having any plan for paying for Chilton and also paying back the "loan" as soon as she was able to because it had truly been given on false pretenses. What incredible, organic drama that would have been! But, no. Organic is out of the question on this show. I would have loved seeing that game play out! Emily could have easily done that. Apropos non-university costs in the year 2000, we paid $10k+ for our daughter to go to an exclusive private school not in a high-rent district like Hartford, CT. I can see annual costs in the $20k range for Chilton. That, of course, precludes Lorelai from using half the $75k for the Dragonfly if she paid her parents back completely. 4 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6248132
txhorns79 July 25, 2020 Share July 25, 2020 2 hours ago, junienmomo said: Apropos non-university costs in the year 2000, we paid $10k+ for our daughter to go to an exclusive private school not in a high-rent district like Hartford, CT. I can see annual costs in the $20k range for Chilton. That, of course, precludes Lorelai from using half the $75k for the Dragonfly if she paid her parents back completely. Perhaps you could fanwank that Lorelai had been paying them back something each year (perhaps several thousand dollars), so when she did the final lump sum, it wasn't the full amount Emily and Richard had paid for three years. 3 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6248280
chitowngirl October 2, 2020 Share October 2, 2020 (edited) No Sookie-one of the things one remembers from a wedding shower is NOT what kind of cookie is served!! And all the food she made for the shower and then the wedding cake...who paid for that? The Inn? And there is no way Chilton does not post activities or mentions them in the morning/afternoon announcements. Rory should have known the time the Newspaper was meeting and not been 45 minutes late. Edited October 2, 2020 by chitowngirl 3 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6380937
Gam2 October 9, 2020 Share October 9, 2020 I’m not sure which season this was from but the Gilmores are visiting Yale and Richard has arranged an interview for Rory with the Dean of Admissions. This whole season, Lauren Grahams’ hair has looked just awful! The back is long and stringy but the sides are barrel curled backwards. It looks bad enough from the front but from the back—AWFUL. Did they even have a hairdresser on this show?! Or a mirror?! 2 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6393007
sara416 October 16, 2020 Share October 16, 2020 I rewatched "Keg! Max!" last night and one thing that has always bothered me was the housekey on the belt thing. Lorelei says that the only way she will lose it is if she is taking her belt off, but is she not going to go to the bathroom all night? She has to undo the belt for that, and therefore the key could easily fall off. Plus, she's wearing jeans. Just put the key in your pocket! There are also some very weird time issues in that episode that I don't understand, like Michel working at the inn at night and what time that booster meeting could possibly be. 4 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6403725
junienmomo October 16, 2020 Share October 16, 2020 52 minutes ago, sara416 said: I rewatched "Keg! Max!" last night and one thing that has always bothered me was the housekey on the belt thing. Lorelei says that the only way she will lose it is if she is taking her belt off, but is she not going to go to the bathroom all night? She has to undo the belt for that, and therefore the key could easily fall off. Plus, she's wearing jeans. Just put the key in your pocket! There are also some very weird time issues in that episode that I don't understand, like Michel working at the inn at night and what time that booster meeting could possibly be. It was a symbolic chastity belt. 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6403793
Katy M October 16, 2020 Share October 16, 2020 1 hour ago, sara416 said: I rewatched "Keg! Max!" last night and one thing that has always bothered me was the housekey on the belt thing. Lorelei says that the only way she will lose it is if she is taking her belt off, but is she not going to go to the bathroom all night? She has to undo the belt for that, and therefore the key could easily fall off. If she threaded the ring through the belt buckle, it won't fall off even if she unbuckles the belt for whatever reason. She would actually have to lose the entire belt (or have the buckle fall off) to lose the key. It could fall out of her pocket. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6403865
sara416 October 17, 2020 Share October 17, 2020 I didn't think about threading it through the belt buckle. My thought was that she put the stick part of the buckle through the hole in the key, so when she unbuckled it would pretty immediately fall out. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6404359
Gam2 October 27, 2020 Share October 27, 2020 For the life of me, I can’t figure out why the wardrobe people dressed Lor in those low cut dresses for work at the Inn or going to the diner or walking around town. They’re not attractive on her and are much too revealing for work! Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6421365
chessiegal October 27, 2020 Share October 27, 2020 10 minutes ago, Gam2 said: For the life of me, I can’t figure out why the wardrobe people dressed Lor in those low cut dresses for work at the Inn or going to the diner or walking around town. They’re not attractive on her and are much too revealing for work! Is that you Richard Gilmore? 😉 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6421372
OhSarah69 October 28, 2020 Share October 28, 2020 On 10/2/2020 at 3:06 PM, chitowngirl said: No Sookie-one of the things one remembers from a wedding shower is NOT what kind of cookie is served!! And all the food she made for the shower and then the wedding cake...who paid for that? The Inn? And there is no way Chilton does not post activities or mentions them in the morning/afternoon announcements. Rory should have known the time the Newspaper was meeting and not been 45 minutes late. Yes, it's not like Rory not to check the start time of the meeting herself instead of just relying on what Paris (at the time her archenemy) told her. But this brings me to the stupid, powerless teachers at that school. Miss Whats-her-face in that newspaper meeting and then on other episodes there is a male teacher (the whom Paris calls "Bedwetter") - they just sit back and let Paris talk to her peers like that? Yeah, yeah, they're trying to teach kids how to act in the real world, how to speak up for yourself, etc. - here's an idea, how about modeling that for the kids and not letting them poop all over each other? 5 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6422122
readster October 28, 2020 Share October 28, 2020 7 hours ago, OhSarah69 said: Yes, it's not like Rory not to check the start time of the meeting herself instead of just relying on what Paris (at the time her archenemy) told her. But this brings me to the stupid, powerless teachers at that school. Miss Whats-her-face in that newspaper meeting and then on other episodes there is a male teacher (the whom Paris calls "Bedwetter") - they just sit back and let Paris talk to her peers like that? Yeah, yeah, they're trying to teach kids how to act in the real world, how to speak up for yourself, etc. - here's an idea, how about modeling that for the kids and not letting them poop all over each other? I have HATED how teachers are depicted on TV shows and movies. Honestly, outside maybe Boston Public. Teachers are constantly shown as: not able to communicate, closed minded, stupid and apparently just letting students run rampant in classes or activities. I can understand that maybe the writers were going for punchlines or had bad experiences with said above in their own pasts. However, AS A TEACHER I grit my teeth when I see that. You don't want to know my feelings on the teachers in the Spider-Man movies. Oh God! 4 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6422384
Katy M October 28, 2020 Share October 28, 2020 1 hour ago, readster said: I have HATED how teachers are depicted on TV shows and movies. Honestly, outside maybe Boston Public. Teachers are constantly shown as: not able to communicate, closed minded, stupid and apparently just letting students run rampant in classes or activities. I can understand that maybe the writers were going for punchlines or had bad experiences with said above in their own pasts. However, AS A TEACHER I grit my teeth when I see that. You don't want to know my feelings on the teachers in the Spider-Man movies. Oh God! What about Mr. Feeney on Boy Meets World? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6422471
readster October 28, 2020 Share October 28, 2020 2 hours ago, Katy M said: What about Mr. Feeney on Boy Meets World? He was well done! The only episode I didn't like was when he talked about being a professional athlete. The lesson wasn't just how few people get to play professional sports. But when the dad was able to bring one in and talk to him about education and sports. That made Mr. Feeney's point mute and didn't really emphasis from a different POV. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6422676
scarynikki12 February 23, 2021 Share February 23, 2021 Watched a couple episodes last night: the season 3 inn fire and the season 4 one when Liz arrives. Like everyone else I cringe when Sookie and Lorelai invade Luke’s. How hard would it have been to write it that Luke was in the know and on board with Phase 2? The scene could have opened with him delaying people/Kirk from ordering as he waits for them to arrive and then express relief when they do. That can easily be comedic and doesn’t make Sookie and Lorelai look like assholes. I appreciate that season 4 laid the foundation for Lorelai’s money problems but I hate how Rory was written. Her noticing that Lorelai is doing little things that imply she’s saving money and being concerned about the inn, fine. But acting appalled by them? Nope not today. Who cares that Lorelai is clipping coupons or cancelled subscriptions? Rory’s attitude about coupons, cancellations, and other ways Lorelai was trying to save money just pisses me off. It does further move her further into the awful person she was by show’s end but still. 8 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6623162
peacheslatour February 23, 2021 Share February 23, 2021 5 hours ago, scarynikki12 said: Watched a couple episodes last night: the season 3 inn fire and the season 4 one when Liz arrives. Like everyone else I cringe when Sookie and Lorelai invade Luke’s. How hard would it have been to write it that Luke was in the know and on board with Phase 2? The scene could have opened with him delaying people/Kirk from ordering as he waits for them to arrive and then express relief when they do. That can easily be comedic and doesn’t make Sookie and Lorelai look like assholes. I appreciate that season 4 laid the foundation for Lorelai’s money problems but I hate how Rory was written. Her noticing that Lorelai is doing little things that imply she’s saving money and being concerned about the inn, fine. But acting appalled by them? Nope not today. Who cares that Lorelai is clipping coupons or cancelled subscriptions? Rory’s attitude about coupons, cancellations, and other ways Lorelai was trying to save money just pisses me off. It does further move her further into the awful person she was by show’s end but still. I hated that they made Cesar throw away all that food. Damn Sookie was so high handed about it all. 2 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6623744
alexa February 26, 2021 Share February 26, 2021 On 2/23/2021 at 1:03 PM, scarynikki12 said: Watched a couple episodes last night: the season 3 inn fire and the season 4 one when Liz arrives. Like everyone else I cringe when Sookie and Lorelai invade Luke’s. How hard would it have been to write it that Luke was in the know and on board with Phase 2? The scene could have opened with him delaying people/Kirk from ordering as he waits for them to arrive and then express relief when they do. That can easily be comedic and doesn’t make Sookie and Lorelai look like assholes. I appreciate that season 4 laid the foundation for Lorelai’s money problems but I hate how Rory was written. Her noticing that Lorelai is doing little things that imply she’s saving money and being concerned about the inn, fine. But acting appalled by them? Nope not today. Who cares that Lorelai is clipping coupons or cancelled subscriptions? Rory’s attitude about coupons, cancellations, and other ways Lorelai was trying to save money just pisses me off. It does further move her further into the awful person she was by show’s end but still. I agree. They acted like Rory was so stupid not to understand lack of money, saving money, or that her education, etc, cost money. It was very annoying and silly. They grew up relatively poor and had a simple life.... I think she knew all about this kind of stuff. 5 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6629932
andromeda331 March 1, 2021 Share March 1, 2021 On 2/26/2021 at 10:39 AM, alexa said: I agree. They acted like Rory was so stupid not to understand lack of money, saving money, or that her education, etc, cost money. It was very annoying and silly. They grew up relatively poor and had a simple life.... I think she knew all about this kind of stuff. They really did. There's no way they weren't using coupons the whole time Rory was growing up. Or Lane's family or pretty much everyone in Stars Hollow. Even the clothes Rory and Lorelai wore in season one weren't that expensive. They were mostly normal clothes. Even the clothes they wore to Friday Night Dinners was normal. 5 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6635610
Katy M March 1, 2021 Share March 1, 2021 On 2/26/2021 at 12:39 PM, alexa said: They grew up relatively poor and had a simple life.... People who "grew up relatively poor" did not generally eat out every single meal or have all the cable channels or have an entire roomful of books (although I'll concede that most of them were probably used). Or go to private school, but her grandparents paid for that, so that's a bit different. When I was a kid we had basic cable and ate out once, maybe twice a month. Usually McDonald's. I can count on two hands the times I went to the movies and we didn't even rent all that often. Again, maybe once or twice a month. 2 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6635873
alexa March 2, 2021 Share March 2, 2021 5 hours ago, Katy M said: People who "grew up relatively poor" did not generally eat out every single meal or have all the cable channels or have an entire roomful of books (although I'll concede that most of them were probably used). Or go to private school, but her grandparents paid for that, so that's a bit different. When I was a kid we had basic cable and ate out once, maybe twice a month. Usually McDonald's. I can count on two hands the times I went to the movies and we didn't even rent all that often. Again, maybe once or twice a month. I am talking more about the early days when she was a maid at the Inn, and they were establishing themselves. I don't mean that they lived poorly when they did all of those things you describe, but I am pretty sure they were very poor when they first started out and lived in that little shed/storeroom outside the inn. I just think Rory understands the not having money part... 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6636334
Katy M March 2, 2021 Share March 2, 2021 14 minutes ago, alexa said: I am talking more about the early days when she was a maid at the Inn, and they were establishing themselves. I don't mean that they lived poorly when they did all of those things you describe, but I am pretty sure they were very poor when they first started out and lived in that little shed/storeroom outside the inn. I just think Rory understands the not having money part... But they were living and eating for free at the inn, plus she was fairly young, so I don't think she would have thought anything about not having money. the one time she worried about the roof or something and either suggested Lorelai go to R&E or went behind her back (I forgot which), Lorelai pointed out that she was self-sufficient and had provided all of Rory's wants and needs over the years. there was nothing shown on screen to suggest that Rory had to think in terms of penny pinching as a kid. 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6636350
alexa March 2, 2021 Share March 2, 2021 41 minutes ago, Katy M said: But they were living and eating for free at the inn, plus she was fairly young, so I don't think she would have thought anything about not having money. the one time she worried about the roof or something and either suggested Lorelai go to R&E or went behind her back (I forgot which), Lorelai pointed out that she was self-sufficient and had provided all of Rory's wants and needs over the years. there was nothing shown on screen to suggest that Rory had to think in terms of penny pinching as a kid. I just see it differently. I don’t see any of their life as extravagant, and my gut feeling is that Rory understood not having tons of extra cash sitting around. But it is fine to see it differently than I do. 2 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6636419
Taryn74 March 11, 2021 Share March 11, 2021 Today on the 253rd episode of Random Gilmore Girls Thoughts Which Pop Into My Head, do you think if Lorelai and Rory were peers instead of mother/daughter, they would even be friends? Because I'm thinking no. I think Lorelai would be far more likely to hang out with Madeline and Louise than she would with Rory, if they were the same age and in school together. I need to go back and watch some early season GG soon, I'm starting to forget that Lorelai wasn't always as shallow, immature, and somewhat unlikable as she ended up being as the show went on. For that matter, neither was Rory. Maybe they would have been friends. Heh. 4 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6655869
Katy M March 11, 2021 Share March 11, 2021 2 hours ago, Taryn74 said: Today on the 253rd episode of Random Gilmore Girls Thoughts Which Pop Into My Head, do you think if Lorelai and Rory were peers instead of mother/daughter, they would even be friends? Because I'm thinking no. I think Lorelai would be far more likely to hang out with Madeline and Louise than she would with Rory, if they were the same age and in school together. I need to go back and watch some early season GG soon, I'm starting to forget that Lorelai wasn't always as shallow, immature, and somewhat unlikable as she ended up being as the show went on. For that matter, neither was Rory. Maybe they would have been friends. Heh. Adult Rory would not want to be friends with adult Lorelai because she would be beneather. Adult Lorelai wouldn't want to be friends with Adult Rory because she would be too snobby. Teen counterparts are harder. We don't really see that much of Lorelai as a teen. We know she got pregnant and thought her parents too strict. So, she may have seen teen Rory as too much of a follower of the rules. I think they would probably jsut be friendly acquaintances. You really had to go out of your way to actually get on the bad side of teen Rory and I don't see teen Lorelai bothering to do that. 6 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6656166
peacheslatour March 11, 2021 Share March 11, 2021 7 minutes ago, Katy M said: Adult Rory would not want to be friends with adult Lorelai because she would be beneather. Adult Lorelai wouldn't want to be friends with Adult Rory because she would be too snobby. Teen counterparts are harder. We don't really see that much of Lorelai as a teen. We know she got pregnant and thought her parents too strict. So, she may have seen teen Rory as too much of a follower of the rules. I think they would probably jsut be friendly acquaintances. You really had to go out of your way to actually get on the bad side of teen Rory and I don't see teen Lorelai bothering to do that. In many ways Lorelai was way more ambitious than Rory. She was more of a grab life by the fetlock and work your way to the top with clear goals. Rory was kind of a doormat. 10 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6656182
Taryn74 March 11, 2021 Share March 11, 2021 1 hour ago, Katy M said: I think they would probably just be friendly acquaintances. You really had to go out of your way to actually get on the bad side of teen Rory and I don't see teen Lorelai bothering to do that. Very true. 1 hour ago, peacheslatour said: In many ways Lorelai was way more ambitious than Rory. She was more of a grab life by the fetlock and work your way to the top with clear goals. Definitely. It was bad during the series, especially after around S2/S3, but horrible during the Revival when Rory couldn't even be bothered with journalism she had been assigned to do. Jeebus. 3 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6656393
chitowngirl March 30, 2021 Share March 30, 2021 I love the story arc of Hammers & Veils/Red Light on a Wedding Night/The Road Trip to Harvard. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6691849
Taryn74 April 7, 2021 Share April 7, 2021 Really random question that's been bugging me for a while. From Double Date - Quote SOOKIE: I know. I’m just - Oh, I’m so nervous. LORELAI: You’re nervous? You don’t have some guy staring at you like he’s Cher and you’re the kid from ‘Mask’. Now, I've never watched 'Mask' but I've seen enough scenes from it to know that Cher is the mom and she loves her son. Why would she be staring at her kid like she's horrified by him, the way that Rune kept staring at Lorelai? Does Cher start out horrified by him or something and only later comes to love him? Anyone seen the movie who can fill me in? The things that bug me about this show, I swear. LOL 3 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6706372
Gam2 April 16, 2021 Share April 16, 2021 This has been bugging me for years. Why do the Gilmores lean on their elbows when they’re at the dinner table? My parents were very strict about table manners and that was one of the biggest sins. My dad would say “If you’re so tired that you have to lean on the table, you’re excused to go to bed.” Also talking with food in your mouth, not wiping your mouth with your napkin (cloth, of course) and eating huge bites of food. 2 2 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6725524
peacheslatour April 17, 2021 Share April 17, 2021 19 hours ago, Gam2 said: This has been bugging me for years. Why do the Gilmores lean on their elbows when they’re at the dinner table? My parents were very strict about table manners and that was one of the biggest sins. My dad would say “If you’re so tired that you have to lean on the table, you’re excused to go to bed.” Also talking with food in your mouth, not wiping your mouth with your napkin (cloth, of course) and eating huge bites of food. Rory and Lorelai should each weigh about five hundred pounds. 6 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6726705
chediavolo April 18, 2021 Share April 18, 2021 Just started watching “3rd Rock From The Sun”. Episode with Lauren as a college student, she had what appeared to be naturally curly hair & looked beautiful! Too bad she now fights against it. I never did like her hair, it looks dull & unhealthy. What do people have against curls? 6 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6727556
Taryn74 June 9, 2021 Share June 9, 2021 Couldn't help myself, watched the Pilot and TLFDAC again this morning. I always forget how funny and non-stilted Lane was even the very first time we see her. "I'm hayriding with a future proctologist. I have potential." Hee! Keiko plays her so perfectly, beginning to end. 9 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6830948
qtpye June 17, 2021 Share June 17, 2021 On 3/11/2021 at 1:42 PM, peacheslatour said: In many ways Lorelai was way more ambitious than Rory. She was more of a grab life by the fetlock and work your way to the top with clear goals. Rory was kind of a doormat. Yes, I can not ever see Rory fleeing a life of privilege to be a maid. 4 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/4655-all-episodes-talk-lorelai-and-rory-and-the-people-they-love/page/44/#findComment-6844520
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.