whateverhappened February 9, 2017 Share February 9, 2017 Book club! Always book club. And if you'd ever seen me dance, you would still be having nightmares about it. Would you rather date Alex or Max? 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2973643
lulu1960 February 9, 2017 Share February 9, 2017 (edited) I'd say Alex. He seemed pretty down to earth. (For the record, I never had an issue with Max other than the fact I don't think he should have pursued Lorelai in the first place because of Rory being in his class. If Rory wasn't his student then I saw no problem.) Would you rather Kirk assist you getting beauty suppies or taking you in his pedi-cab Edited February 9, 2017 by lulu1960 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2973658
Taryn74 February 9, 2017 Share February 9, 2017 Beauty supplies. He seemed to actually know what he was talking about, and I don't have five hours to get from one side of town to the other. Would you rather live in the Twickham House with the creepy diorama mannequins upstairs, or in Kirk's house with his mother? 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2973717
whateverhappened February 9, 2017 Share February 9, 2017 The mannequins! I like the odd and creepy, especially when, unlike Kirk's family members, the odd and creepy things in question can't speak or interact with me. :) Would you rather watch Luke and Lorelai trying to blend in with the arty hipster indie scene with Jess and Rory or at a Life and Death Brigade type of event with Rory and Logan? 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2973721
huahaha February 9, 2017 Share February 9, 2017 Arty hipster scene. The life and death brigade scenes would crumble in the presence of an actual adult. Would you rather have seen Rory at Harvard or Yale? 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2973902
Lady Calypso February 9, 2017 Share February 9, 2017 I actually would have loved to see her at Harvard. Having her far away from home and actually attending the school that she had been dreaming about for years would have made for an interesting freshman year. I think she would have struggled, but she would have probably succeeded. Plus no Logan. Plus her grandparents would have not been happy and it would have been interesting to see how they dealt with it. Would you rather live in the home that Emily was going to buy for Luke/Lorelai at the end of season six, or in Emily's new Nantucket home in the revival? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2974031
lulu1960 February 9, 2017 Share February 9, 2017 I love the Nantucket home. My friend is thinking of moving and she is coveting Emily's furniture choices. Sookie's third kid is born but we never found out what she had. (bad season 7) Did she have a boy or girl? Also how do you all feel about WYRs that include the revival too. I'm for it. 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2974209
Guest February 9, 2017 Share February 9, 2017 Anything in the revival is fair game. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2974561
whateverhappened February 9, 2017 Share February 9, 2017 Girl! Which would you rather remove from the revival - the looming presence of Paul and Odette or that musical, which was so interminable that I keep thinking it's still going on. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2974681
ghoulina February 9, 2017 Share February 9, 2017 Ugh, the musical. I'll keep anything above that. For two weeks - you can only talk in cliches (Chester Fleet) or have to omit every "E"? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2974721
lulu1960 February 9, 2017 Share February 9, 2017 Cliches. I wouldn't leave a stone unturned. ;) Which wedding cake would you choose for Lorelai and Luke. The milestone one, or the one that Sookie was putting red flowers on? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2974732
Taryn74 February 9, 2017 Share February 9, 2017 Cliches. It would be hard, but I don't think I can even put a sentence together without using 'E's, much less hold an entire conversation. Lulu responded while I was thinking up a new question, so I'm making it easy on myself and reposting hers! 2 minutes ago, lulu1960 said: Which wedding cake would you choose for Lorelai and Luke. The milestone one, or the one that Sookie was putting red flowers on? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2974736
huahaha February 9, 2017 Share February 9, 2017 Red flowers cake. The milestone cake would be cute for a rehearsal dinner, though. Cut a best friend from the show: Lane or Sookie? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2974834
lulu1960 February 9, 2017 Share February 9, 2017 Wow that's a tough choice. I'm going to say Lane only because Rory seemed to kind of move on from her on a few occasions. Luke needs another worker. Brian or Kirk? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2975343
whateverhappened February 9, 2017 Share February 9, 2017 Brian! I love Brian. I want more Brian an a little less Kirk :) Which relationship would you rather erase: Rory x Dean past Season 3 or Luke x Nicole? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2975359
Taryn74 February 9, 2017 Share February 9, 2017 Rory/Dean, easily. Nothing good came out of their relationship past S3. Nicole was boring but she didn't turn Luke into an unlikable character. You hire a personal shopping assistant only to find out you have to buy everything they suggest, and ONLY what they suggest. Do you hire Lane for music, Rory for books, or Lorelai for clothes? 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2975370
whateverhappened February 9, 2017 Share February 9, 2017 Great question! Rory for books. My music taste is way too uncool for Lane and I dress pretty differently from Lorelai. In the revival, would you rather Luke and Lorelai have decided to adopt or stick with not having other kids? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2975376
lulu1960 February 9, 2017 Share February 9, 2017 My gut says no more kids. Luke says he's happy without a fresh kid. Which flash mob do you want to see. Luke's or Lorelai's 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2975422
whateverhappened February 9, 2017 Share February 9, 2017 I think Lorelai's. Which finale do you prefer as the end to the series: Bon Voyage or Fall Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2975432
lulu1960 February 10, 2017 Share February 10, 2017 Fall. Because we got the happy ending for Luke and Lorelai. Even if Rory is in flux I believe she will get it together too. Going to the Multi Cultural Food Festival or The Harvest Festival with the food carts Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2975559
huahaha February 10, 2017 Share February 10, 2017 Didn't vendors at the international food festival have to double up on countries? I'll take a pass on the mystery food and hope for hot cider doughnuts at the harvest festival. Breakfast at Luke's or dinner at the Dragonfly? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2976053
whateverhappened February 10, 2017 Share February 10, 2017 Breakfast at Luke's! I've had dreams about those chocolate chip pancakes. I could wear my usual sweats to Luke's but would probably feel like I had to look presentable at the Dragonfly. Would you rather have Rory or Paris speak to and possibly mentor students at your high school? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2976104
ghoulina February 10, 2017 Share February 10, 2017 I would have rather had Paris because I couldn't stand most people I went to school with and they could have used a good Gellar reaming. You're remodeling your house and you have to choose one - decorating with Sookie's Frog Girl collection? Or having Luke's family heriloom bedroom set? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2976948
lulu1960 February 10, 2017 Share February 10, 2017 Probably the frog collection I can hide those easier. Whose cameo was unnecessary in the revival? Mr. Kim or Bootsy? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2977143
whateverhappened February 10, 2017 Share February 10, 2017 I would have liked Mr Kim remaining a mystery. Not that I think fans were clamoring for more Bootsy. :) Someone other than Luke had a long lost child pop up during the series. Would you rather Lorelai discover she had a half sister or Emily discovering that she had a half-brother out there all these years? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2977231
Guest February 10, 2017 Share February 10, 2017 Emily has a half brother. Lorelai having a half-sibling would just disrupt too many plotlines. Would you rather attend Stars Hollow High or Chilton? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2977824
ghoulina February 10, 2017 Share February 10, 2017 Stars Hollow High. I went to Catholic school K-8 and have had my share of rich snobs, thank you very much. We get to see so few of the Townie homes. Whose would you like to get a tour of? Kirk's (complete with meeting his mother)? Or Miss Patty's? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2978129
whateverhappened February 10, 2017 Share February 10, 2017 Kirk's! Where in the world did all those many siblings sleep? Would you rather live in Lorelai and Rory's house just as it was or the Twickham house, which you coukd decorate any way you'd like? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2978136
Guest February 10, 2017 Share February 10, 2017 Twickham House! The layout of the Crap Shack made no sense. Would you rather - sit through a whole Hep Alien concert or sit through one of Miss Patty's dance recitals (complete with a weird Kirk piece)? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2978231
elang4 February 10, 2017 Share February 10, 2017 4 minutes ago, deaja said: Twickham House! The layout of the Crap Shack made no sense. Would you rather - sit through a whole Hep Alien concert or sit through one of Miss Patty's dance recitals (complete with a weird Kirk piece)? Hep Alien definitely! I liked them! :) Would you rather date mature Jess or season 7 Logan? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2978262
Guest February 10, 2017 Share February 10, 2017 Season 7 Logan because he's way hotter. :) Would you rather date Kirk or Taylor? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2978275
elang4 February 10, 2017 Share February 10, 2017 3 minutes ago, deaja said: Season 7 Logan because he's way hotter. :) Would you rather date Kirk or Taylor? Oooh that's hard but I think I'm actually going to say Kirk. I know he's crazy but I'm pretty sure he'd treat me right. :) Would you rather Emily or Jess be at Luke and Lorelai's wedding? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2978292
lulu1960 February 10, 2017 Share February 10, 2017 Awww man. I miss the Jess verses Logan dating question and get the Kirk or Taylor one? Okay well I guess Kirk. My screen name is lulu after all. ;) Luke gets full custody of April or zero custody? Oopsie I was too slow. I'd say if push came to shove. Emily would have to be there. Mom trumps nephew. You can answer my question above. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2978296
huahaha February 11, 2017 Share February 11, 2017 I'm tempted to say full custody, only because Anna's behavior was despicable. But it's probably not in any happy teenager's best interest to be removed from the parent they grew up with, so I have to go with no custody for Luke. For the revival, would you rather have seen Luke and Lorelai with kids already or without? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2978955
lulu1960 February 11, 2017 Share February 11, 2017 If they were to have kids they should have had them already. Like Luke said 5 or 6 years ago. But I would have said even sooner. Keeping with the kids question. Twins like the dream or one and what gender? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2979033
huahaha February 11, 2017 Share February 11, 2017 I'd say twins so they can entertain each other in season 8 scenes and not pull too much plot. A boy and a girl, preferably running around like slightly wild animals, then obsessing over laptop screens. A few scenes of Luke being tricked by kid technology instead of the dull diner wifi gag. A few summer camp scenes, complete with care package from Mama Lorelai instead of the terrible musical. Would you rather be Rory, Lorelai, or Emily? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2979205
ghoulina February 11, 2017 Share February 11, 2017 I'd rather be Rory. I don't think I could pull of Lorelai's fashion, and Emily's life is just not suitable for me. Which parent confrontation would you rather be subject to - when the sweater moms confront Lorelai after the speech at SHH? Or when Lindsey's mom runs into her in the square? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2979974
lulu1960 February 11, 2017 Share February 11, 2017 The sweater moms. Lorelai was right in that instance. Lindsey's mom had ever right to be upset. Brian needs a new job. Should he work for Sophie or for Andrew? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2980227
Taryn74 February 11, 2017 Share February 11, 2017 Sophie. I think that would be a lot of fun to watch. Brian's a nerd but he knows his music and instruments. At least that's the impression I always got. Which meta music moment would you rather have seen in the revival - Sophie singing a bit of the theme song, or Gil busting out Skid Row? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2980374
lulu1960 February 11, 2017 Share February 11, 2017 Sophie singing the theme song. In the revival. More scenes with Miss Patty or more scenes with Hep Alien? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2981031
huahaha February 11, 2017 Share February 11, 2017 Miss Patty!! What on earth happened there? They only showed her from a distance, and she used to be such a huge presence. At the very least, she belonged all over the (terrible) musical scenes. I understood ASP wanting to insert some Bunheads cameos, but she cut down beloved characters to do it. If you could pick, would you rather the father of Rory's baby be Jess, Logan, or the Wookiee? 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2981079
Guest February 12, 2017 Share February 12, 2017 Logan- the other options don't make sense with the story we were shown. Would you rather the final four words have been "Mom? Yeah? I'm pregnant" or "Rory? Yeah? I'm pregnant." Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2982554
whateverhappened February 12, 2017 Share February 12, 2017 More like Lorelai: "You're pregnant?!"/Rory: "Just joking!" as those last four words, but if I had to pick, I'll have Lorelai pregnant, and not from the Wookie. :) Would you rather Max and Lorelai never have gotten engaged or Luke and Nicole never have gotten married? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2982563
ghoulina February 12, 2017 Share February 12, 2017 Luke and Nicole never got married. I think the Max relationship was important to understanding Lorelai as a person. The Nicole relationship was weird and did nothing for Luke. What would you rather wake up to find in your front room? An antique printing press? Or Tana's soldering iron station? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2982785
lulu1960 February 12, 2017 Share February 12, 2017 Tana's soldering station it wasn't nearly as cumbersome. Which let your actions speak gesture before L/L were a couple. Building the Chuppa or 5 hrs of work on Lorelai's birthday. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2983291
Taryn74 February 13, 2017 Share February 13, 2017 Building the chuppa. Because, damn, that had to have taken hours upon hours. Who has a "cougar" fling with Brian - Sophie, or Miss Patty? 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2983396
whateverhappened February 13, 2017 Share February 13, 2017 I also love the chuppah because it shows that even if she's marrying another man, which even back then clearly hurt him, he'll always care about her as a person. Sophie and Brian! Which event would you rather had never happened: Rory steals a yacht and drops out of Yale or Luke discovers a daughter and starts to shut out Lorelai, eventually leading to their breakup? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2983413
Lady Calypso February 13, 2017 Share February 13, 2017 Man, that's hard because both are so, so bad. But I'll go with Luke's long lost daughter. That entire plotline was pretty badly done and very little made sense or was likable. At least with Rory's plot, we got some good scenes of her finding her niche in the DAR, and Lorelai/Luke scenes were top. If you had to take care of someone's pet for an entire week, whose would it be: Lorelai's dog Paul Anka and his neediness, or Kirk's old cat Kirk? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2983440
lulu1960 February 13, 2017 Share February 13, 2017 Paul Anka. Cat Kirk scares me. Tofurkey or the Soy meatballs? LOL. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2983448
ghoulina February 13, 2017 Share February 13, 2017 Ew. Um. Tofurkey? (I pretty much just flipped a coin on that one.) Would you rather spend the night with the zucchinis or at the Dance Marathon? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/7/#findComment-2985182
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.