lulu1960 February 2, 2017 Share February 2, 2017 I would have said Richard and Luke too. I think once Richard realized that Luke wasn't a 'country bumpkin' and was well informed he would have been less judgemental. I also think Luke could have gotten Richard to enjoy the similar things. I would rather be related to Luke and Jess. I think Rory and Lorelai would be to perky for me. Luke brings April to FND. Does she bond more with Richard or Emily? 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2954486
Kohola3 February 2, 2017 Share February 2, 2017 3 minutes ago, lulu1960 said: Luke brings April to FND. Does she bond more with Richard or Emily? Does Emily play Go Fish with her? 2 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2954496
ghoulina February 2, 2017 Share February 2, 2017 25 minutes ago, lulu1960 said: Luke brings April to FND. Does she bond more with Richard or Emily? I think Richard. Who would you rather set Paris up with? The accountant that the Gilmores sprung on Lorelei at FND? Or Dean's slacker friend, Todd? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2954555
whateverhappened February 2, 2017 Share February 2, 2017 Paris with Todd. I would find that entertaining. Potentially scary, but entertaining! Assuming both were around your own age, would you rather have Lane or Sookie as your best friend? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2954563
Guest February 2, 2017 Share February 2, 2017 Lane. She seemed to be a good friend. Sookie was not, at least not in later Seasons. Would you rather join the DAR and volunteer under Emily or the Yale Daily News under Paris' reign of terror? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2954637
whateverhappened February 2, 2017 Share February 2, 2017 The YDN. I'd love to write and edit a bit even if that would mean being berated by Paris on a regular basis. The DAR would not be especially pleased to have me there! Would you rather have seen a romance between Paris and Jess or Lane and Dean? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2955092
Taryn74 February 2, 2017 Share February 2, 2017 2 hours ago, deaja said: Would you rather join the DAR and volunteer under Emily or the Yale Daily News under Paris' reign of terror? The DAR. I can't imagine any scenario where I would enjoy working under Paris. WYR have seen Paris in a verbal sparring match with Gran over a woman's proper role in society, or with Mrs. Kim over religion? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2955096
whateverhappened February 2, 2017 Share February 2, 2017 (edited) With Mrs Kim over religion! I find discussions around religion and spirituality fascinating even though I'm not always thrilled with how GG handled those issues. Taryn and I posted at around the same time, so reposting my question: Would you rather have seen a romance between Paris and Jess or Lane and Dean? Edited February 2, 2017 by whateverhappened 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2955103
ghoulina February 3, 2017 Share February 3, 2017 Paris and Jess. I think their minds would be evenly matched and they would challenge each other. Dean and Lane just seems to blah to me. Which animal incident would you rather go through - getting beaked by a swan or having a deer hit your car? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2956652
whateverhappened February 3, 2017 Share February 3, 2017 The swan! I'd be traumatized forever if I thought I might have hurt that deer. And car accidents are scary regardless of whether adorable animals are involved. Which barely there relationship would you have wanted to see more of - Paris x Jamie or Lorelai x Alex? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2956670
Guest February 3, 2017 Share February 3, 2017 38 minutes ago, whateverhappened said: The swan! I'd be traumatized forever if I thought I might have hurt that deer. And car accidents are scary regardless of whether adorable animals are involved. Which barely there relationship would you have wanted to see more of - Paris x Jamie or Lorelai x Alex? Ew. I guess if I have to pick one, I'd say Lorelai and Alex. Would you rather by a nanny for Gigi during her terrorist stage or be Emily's maid? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2956759
Taryn74 February 3, 2017 Share February 3, 2017 There's not enough money in the world for me to put up with a terrible brat. Emily's maid. I would just make sure to only screw up a little bit so I would get a nice severance package when she fired me, heh. Rory's "you're not quite so special, snowflake" hard truth begins a little earlier. WYR she struggled all the way thru Chilton (barely making it to graduation) or she only got into Yale, and only because of Richard's status there? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2957277
whateverhappened February 3, 2017 Share February 3, 2017 Taryn, I hope you're feeling better! I love the idea of her getting into "only" one Ivy League school and grappling with whether she deserved the spot. Rory realizes during college that journalism isn't what she's most passionate about and destined for. Would you rather she decide to become a teacher or work for a small independent publishing company like the one that put out Jess's novel? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2957297
lulu1960 February 3, 2017 Share February 3, 2017 I actually think she would be a good teacher. Her speech to the kids at Chilton (in the revival) had a good vibe to it. WYR Rory's three boyfriends weren't an option. Should it be (non-creepy) Marty from Season 4 and 5 or someone else? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2957326
whateverhappened February 3, 2017 Share February 3, 2017 This is probably unpopular but I'm more than fine with none of the existing three being an option, especially if we're talking endgame! I like Marty, but she didn't seem like she could feel that passionately about him. So I'll pick someone else. I'm wondering what traits and qualities he should have. Would you rather spend a couple of weeks touring with Hep Alien or a trip with the LDB? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2957373
ghoulina February 3, 2017 Share February 3, 2017 Hep Alien for sure. Which embarrassing moment WYR suffer through - your mom kissing your teacher on parent's day? Or waking up naked in dorm hallway at college? 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2957379
Guest February 3, 2017 Share February 3, 2017 7 minutes ago, ghoulina said: Hep Alien for sure. Which embarrassing moment WYR suffer through - your mom kissing your teacher on parent's day? Or waking up naked in dorm hallway at college? Mom kissing teacher, hands down. Which town meeting would be more interesting - a special election to replace Taylor or a special event to plan Kirk and Lulu's wedding? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2957411
whateverhappened February 3, 2017 Share February 3, 2017 (edited) Same, ghoulina. Tbh I would not last one day with the LDB crowd. Not that they would deem me worthy anyway, haha. I'll pick my mom kissing my teacher, since most people know we're not responsible for our parents' actions, but the naked thing would be all on me. Quote Which town meeting would be more interesting - a special election to replace Taylor or a special event to plan Kirk and Lulu's wedding? Kirk and Lulu's wedding. I've had enough election drama to last many lifetimes! Would you rather see Lorelai have to go a month without caffeine or Paris have to go a month without snapping at anyone for any reason? Edited February 3, 2017 by whateverhappened Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2957413
ghoulina February 3, 2017 Share February 3, 2017 52 minutes ago, whateverhappened said: Would you rather see Lorelai have to go a month without caffeine or Paris have to go a month without snapping at anyone for any reason? Lorelai without caffeine, because I LIVE for Paris biting people's heads off. Would you rather try Johnny Machete or Mock Turtle Soup? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2957593
lulu1960 February 3, 2017 Share February 3, 2017 Johnny Machete. I am a cream of mushroom soup kind of gal and that looks like comfort food to me. WYR Own the Independence Inn or The Dragonfly? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2958082
whateverhappened February 3, 2017 Share February 3, 2017 I love both, but the Dragonfly has horses, so that's my pick. I would run any business into the ground, but I'd love to stay there as a guest for as long as they'll have me! Do you prefer Lorelai's hair straight or curly? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2958098
Taryn74 February 3, 2017 Share February 3, 2017 Curly. It looks frazzled and dried out straight. IMO of course. Lane - glasses or contacts? 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2958215
huahaha February 3, 2017 Share February 3, 2017 Glasses. The contacts did look wrong, though I bet she would've looked more comfortable with time. Pick a lover (assuming they're all your age) - Luke, Christopher, Finn, or Tristan. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2958237
whateverhappened February 3, 2017 Share February 3, 2017 (edited) Definitely Luke, no contest. But that's just me! You're spending a week with one of Luke's relatives. Would you rather it be Liz or April? Edited February 3, 2017 by whateverhappened Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2958246
huahaha February 3, 2017 Share February 3, 2017 April. I know how to gently mock the annoyingly brainy. Plus, I could whoop her at Boggle. Liz (and the actress) are in my permanent fast-forward bank. I hear "big brother" in my nightmares. You're getting married. Would you rather Lorelai plan and host it at the Independence Inn or Sookie cater it? 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2958263
whateverhappened February 3, 2017 Share February 3, 2017 Quote April. I know how to gently mock the annoyingly brainy. Plus, I could whoop her at Boggle. Liz (and the actress) are in my permanent fast-forward bank. I hear "big brother" in my nightmares. Same on all counts. And I love Boggle! I would rather Sookie cater it. My ideal wedding would be too small, inexpensive and casual for the Independence Inn. Would you rather spend your Saturday night watching Casablanca and other old movies with Luke, Lorelai and pizza or at a five-star restaurant and club with Logan and Rory? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2958267
Taryn74 February 3, 2017 Share February 3, 2017 25 minutes ago, huahaha said: I hear "big brother" in my nightmares. Aw, that makes me sad. I've long since fanwanked that Liz calls him that because they used to watch the Peanuts specials together as kids (Sally always calls Charlie Brown "big brother"). 26 minutes ago, whateverhappened said: Would you rather spend your Saturday night watching Casablanca and other old movies with Luke, Lorelai and pizza or at a five-star restaurant and club with Logan and Rory? Lord, is there even a contest here? Movies with L/L. And Sookie needs to bring over some comfort/junk food, please. Blueberry shortcake or one of the wedding cake samplers at Fran's? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2958326
huahaha February 4, 2017 Share February 4, 2017 40 minutes ago, Taryn74 said: Aw, that makes me sad. I've long since fanwanked that Liz calls him that because they used to watch the Peanuts specials together as kids (Sally always calls Charlie Brown "big brother"). Cute when Sally does it. With Liz, it's somewhere between emotional coercion and clunky exposition. She uses "My brother" a lot too when addressing Luke. I'll go with the wedding cake samplers. I like variety. Town festivals or town meetings (and you can't go to any of the other type). Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2958454
lulu1960 February 4, 2017 Share February 4, 2017 Festivals all the way. They have one pretty much every occasion. Would you like to try Luke's lasagna (he is the lasagna king according to Liz) or hos Torilla soup. (he makes them fresh the store bought are crap according to him) Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2958637
whateverhappened February 4, 2017 Share February 4, 2017 Lasagna! I'm swooning just thinking about it. Which of Lorelai's men, other than Luke, would you rather go on a date with: Max, Jason, Alex or Christopher? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2958651
huahaha February 4, 2017 Share February 4, 2017 Christopher. He's fun and easy to get along with. Ok, dream vacation of your choice with Rune or stuck on Luke's boat (but you get to be with Luke). Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2958842
lulu1960 February 4, 2017 Share February 4, 2017 Luke's boat with Luke. Rune would ruin (hee) my dream vacation. Would you have liked to see Al's Pancake World or JoJo's 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2958883
Taryn74 February 4, 2017 Share February 4, 2017 Al's. Mostly because I have a hard time believing Taylor allowed him to keep the name 'Pancake World' when he serves everything except pancakes, and I have to see the man behind the legend. Ignoring that we supposedly saw Lane's dad in the revival, WYR find out that he was "Asian Ceasar" or one of the random guys at the various Korean functions? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2958911
whateverhappened February 4, 2017 Share February 4, 2017 He can stay random please. I really liked that there was some mystery surrounding Mr Kim! Would you rather see an episode about our characters celebrating New Year's Eve and making resolutions for themselves and one another or Mother's Day since mothers are such an important part of the show? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2958975
hippielamb February 4, 2017 Share February 4, 2017 New years Eve. I'll pick an easy one: would you rather dogsit Paul Anka, or catsit for Babette's ginger kitten Apricot? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2959042
lulu1960 February 4, 2017 Share February 4, 2017 I love dogs but I'm thinking Paul Anka would be too high maintenance. Luke has to lose the flannels or the hat permanently? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2959123
Taryn74 February 5, 2017 Share February 5, 2017 (edited) And just who's making that choice, Sophie? I guess that'd be me. Ugh. The flannels, I guess, because there's very few times his hair looks good without a hat. (I'm sure it's just the show and not SP in general.) But under protest. (And Apricot is pretty much the cutest kitten in the world, btw. Ahhhhh, I melt.) Whose former SO would you rather meet - Miss Patty's, or Babette's? (It sounded like both of them had their share of .....strange relationships, and I was always fascinated.) Edited February 5, 2017 by Taryn74 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2961416
ghoulina February 5, 2017 Share February 5, 2017 Miss Patty. I NEED to meet Sinjin (sp?)!!! WYR attend Sherry's baby shower or Rory's all-male alumni party? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2961733
elang4 February 5, 2017 Share February 5, 2017 8 minutes ago, ghoulina said: Miss Patty. I NEED to meet Sinjin (sp?)!!! WYR attend Sherry's baby shower or Rory's all-male alumni party? Sorry I've been awol. It was my birthday yesterday so was celebrating with family. :) Sherry's baby shower. At least there were games! :P Would you rather go fishing with Luke or have a movie marathon with Lorelai? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2961743
huahaha February 5, 2017 Share February 5, 2017 Movie marathon! I'm a vegetarian who gets seasick. :) Pick one friend to survive on a desert island with you: Paris or Kirk. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2961790
whateverhappened February 5, 2017 Share February 5, 2017 Paris. Both would drive me crazy, but Paris is smart enough to help us survive and get us off that island sooner! Would you rather have Lorelai's clothes or Rory's? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2961897
elang4 February 5, 2017 Share February 5, 2017 1 hour ago, whateverhappened said: Paris. Both would drive me crazy, but Paris is smart enough to help us survive and get us off that island sooner! Would you rather have Lorelai's clothes or Rory's? Rory's I think :) Would you rather accompany Luke and April on their boat trip or accompany Lorelai and Rory on their Europe trip? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2962014
whateverhappened February 5, 2017 Share February 5, 2017 Lorelai and Rory because April would annoy me in such large doses and because I get extremely seasick! Would you rather Lane not have gotten together with Zach or Liz not have gotten together with TJ? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2962017
elang4 February 5, 2017 Share February 5, 2017 Liz just because I actually love Lane and Zach. Would you rather spend a day with Mrs Kim or Michel? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2962033
whateverhappened February 5, 2017 Share February 5, 2017 Mrs. Kim. I actually think I could learn a lot from her, though based on her idea of food, I wouldn't let her feed me. If both were around your age, would you rather date Jackson or Doyle? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2962047
elang4 February 5, 2017 Share February 5, 2017 1 minute ago, whateverhappened said: Mrs. Kim. I actually think I could learn a lot from her, though based on her idea of food, I wouldn't let her feed me. If both were around your age, would you rather date Jackson or Doyle? Jackson I think. He just seems more loving and he would be more fun. :) Would you rather go out on the town with Kirk or spend an evening in with Michel? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2962053
Taryn74 February 5, 2017 Share February 5, 2017 I asked my daughter this one. She says "I feel like Kirk would be more fun. He's a wreck to be around, which is funny. He'd probably get hit by a car or something. Michel would just nag me all night, which is no fun at all." So there you go. Ha! Miss Patty hooks up with someone we know, and it turns into a surprisingly lasting romance. Is it Taylor, or Andrew? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2962219
elang4 February 5, 2017 Share February 5, 2017 3 minutes ago, Taryn74 said: I asked my daughter this one. She says "I feel like Kirk would be more fun. He's a wreck to be around, which is funny. He'd probably get hit by a car or something. Michel would just nag me all night, which is no fun at all." So there you go. Ha! Miss Patty hooks up with someone we know, and it turns into a surprisingly lasting romance. Is it Taylor, or Andrew? Taylor. I always had a feeling Andrew liked Gypsy! :P Would you have rather seen Paris and Jess being given a shot of a relationship or Rory and Marty (season 4/5 version of him)? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2962233
lulu1960 February 5, 2017 Share February 5, 2017 Rory and Marty. I liked Season 4/5 version. Baby sitting for Steve and Kwan or babysitting for Martha and Davy and little no name? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2962294
ghoulina February 5, 2017 Share February 5, 2017 The Belleville kids. I can't do multiples. Emily and Richard never reconcile. They end up divorced and one remarries. Who would you rather see? Richard with Pennilynn Lott or Emily with that lawyer guy she went out with? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/5172-gilmore-girls-would-you-rather/page/5/#findComment-2962419
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.