Oinky Boinky May 21, 2016 Share May 21, 2016 I can only be helpful once I have info on night actions. Link to comment
Hanged Man May 21, 2016 Share May 21, 2016 1 hour ago, Lisin said: (OMG guys, Chuy's in Virginia! I'm so excited! This means nothing to anyone outside of Texas and I am sorry!!) Special of the Day at Chuy's around here is Hatch green chili chimichanga, and until Hatch-fest in September makes Saturday the best day to go to Chuys Link to comment
egavasc May 21, 2016 Share May 21, 2016 (edited) Going to add some updates to @Lisin's list. I'm the Seer and I opted to look at two unclaimed roles. Doppelganger Werewolf Werewolf Minion - unclaimed role Masons Seer - Claimed by egavasc (it's true!) Apprentice Seer - unclaimed role Robber Troublemaker - Claimed by @SILVERSTORMM Drunk Insomniac Villager - Claimed by @MACHIABELLY Villager - Claimed by @MUUMUUCHAINSMOKER Villager Hunter Tanner Other players who have checked in but not revealed much else: @MARKHB claims team village @DEADPOOL claims team village @LISIN claims team village @AQUARIAN1 claims team village @SVNBOB claims to know where the Doppelganger is (Hinting at Robber maybe, since Apprentice Seer is unclaimed? Could also be mason, wolf, insomniac) @JESSE claims team village @saoirse claims villager and claims that she can confirm someone else who started as a villager (Doppleganger or Robber? @OinkyBoinky claims to not be able to give info until further night actions are in @CuriousParker doesn't want to make a claim until she knows if she's been swapped Players we haven't heard from yet: aethera Edited May 21, 2016 by egavasc Other people (i.e. MarkHB) are smarter than me Link to comment
egavasc May 21, 2016 Share May 21, 2016 (edited) Ah! Didn't think of that. Have edited my previous post (rather than repost giant list). *Edited to add the thought that perhaps my previous post edit is not kosher. Only added the possibility that saoirse could be the robber and that SVNBob could be mason, wolf, insomniac. My apologies for blanking on the whole "Don't edit posts" rule! Edited May 21, 2016 by egavasc 1 Link to comment
formerlyfreedom May 21, 2016 Share May 21, 2016 Just a reminder that @aethera won't be on before late tomorrow night, per her earlier post. Quote I'll be back at my computer late Sunday night, but won't be around for Day until mid-morning Monday, I'm guessing - Monday first thing tends to be very busy at work! (Oh, and I'm in US Eastern time ) Also, I was on mobile when I posted earlier, and kept it short for that reason, but I wasn't trying to claim Robber or Doppleganger. I'm actually a Mason. Or started as one, anyway. 1 Link to comment
MarkHB May 21, 2016 Share May 21, 2016 If everyone is being truthful, then @SVNBob must have started as one of: Doppelganger, Robber, Wolf, or Insomniac. The Seers are accounted for, as is the Minion, and @saoirse implies she only knows of one other Mason and if the Doppelganger had copied a Mason there would have been two others at the lodge meeting. Link to comment
Deadpool May 21, 2016 Share May 21, 2016 Based on @SVNBob saying he knows where the doppelgänger is, he did not start out as the Robber or Insomniac. Because I started as the Insomniac and got Robbed last night so if he was the Robber that wouldn't tell him where the Doppelgänger is which means if @MarkHB logic is correct he's either the Doppelgänger himself, a Wolf or the Tanner. Link to comment
Meredith Quill May 21, 2016 Share May 21, 2016 Ok I'm going to reveal that @SVNBob was one of the two players I swapped. So Bob, if you started as the Doppelgänger and copied a Wolf or Tanner, or started as a Wolf or as the Tanner, now is the time to say what you know because then I can reveal who you I swapped you with. Link to comment
Guest May 21, 2016 Share May 21, 2016 Since it looks like I'm the same as when I started. I'm a VV. Link to comment
Oinky Boinky May 22, 2016 Share May 22, 2016 Sorry @Egavasc by unclaimed you mean in the discard pile (unassigned) but that means possibly picked up? Link to comment
egavasc May 22, 2016 Share May 22, 2016 Yes, it's possible that the drunk could pick up one of those roles. So we aim to not kill the Drunk on the chance that they swapped their role for the minion. But I think the Drunk is the only one who can pick up one of the unclaimed roles. 1 Link to comment
SVNBob May 22, 2016 Author Share May 22, 2016 Well deduced everyone. I am the Doppelganger (or was, according to Silver). But I did not copy a Wolf or Tanner. I copied someone else on Team Village, but not a Mason. I won't reveal who or what just yet. 3 hours ago, egavasc said: I think the Drunk is the only one who can pick up one of the unclaimed roles. That is true. Other roles can look at one or two, but only the Drunk can take an unclaimed. @egavasc, did Drogo label the unclaimed as I do; A, B, and C, or did he do something different? Just the generality for now. Don't specifically give the labels to what you saw yet. 7 hours ago, Deadpool said: Because I started as the Insomniac and got Robbed last night There is another scenario which would end up with you having the Robber but you not being the one Robbed. But we need to hear from the Robber first before I'll detail that. And I think that's the only role that needs to speak up before Oinky will be able to talk too. So, updating Lisin's listy list: Doppelganger - claimed by SVNBob, no claim yet on who/what he copied. Werewolf Werewolf Minion - unclaimed role Masons - Claimed by @saoirse and ? Seer - Claimed by egavasc Apprentice Seer - unclaimed role Robber Troublemaker - Claimed by @SILVERSTORMM Drunk Insomniac - Claimed by @Deadpool, but Robbed thereof Villager - Claimed by @MACHIABELLY Villager - Claimed by @MUUMUUCHAINSMOKER Villager - Claimed by @CuriousParker Hunter Tanner And the incomplete claims. @MARKHB claims team village @LISIN claims team village @AQUARIAN1 claims team village @JESSE claims team village @OinkyBoinky claims to not be able to give info until further night actions are in aethera will be in on Monday morning, arriving to a wall of text. 1 Link to comment
Jesse May 22, 2016 Share May 22, 2016 I can confirm what @Deadpool said - I was the Robber. For the record, I feel a little bad that we said Day would be on Monday -- @aethera and anyone else is going to be behind the eight-ball when they get here on Monday! Link to comment
egavasc May 22, 2016 Share May 22, 2016 I had the option to look behind Doors number 1, 2, or 3. Link to comment
SVNBob May 22, 2016 Author Share May 22, 2016 11 minutes ago, egavasc said: I had the option to look behind Doors number 1, 2, or 3. Similar enough. So now we need to find out what door the Drunk looked behind, or if it was already behind the door you didn't choose. And since no-one has claimed Drunk yet, that possibility is looking more probable all the time. 36 minutes ago, Jesse said: @aethera and anyone else is going to be behind the eight-ball when they get here on Monday! True. I think it's only aethera at this point. But if I'm right about a suspicion of mine, they won't be coming back to face a mob. Link to comment
Drogo May 22, 2016 Share May 22, 2016 10 minutes ago, SVNBob said: Similar enough. So now we need to find out what door the Drunk looked behind, or if it was already behind the door you didn't choose. Mod Note: I randomly selected the Drunk's new role; I clearly misread "blindly." The Drunk did not get to pick their own door. The Drunk was randomly given Door 3. The Seer can choose to let the group know if that was one of the doors they opened. 1 Link to comment
Drogo May 22, 2016 Share May 22, 2016 1 hour ago, Jesse said: an confirm what @Deadpool For the record, I feel a little bad that we said Day would be on Monday -- @aethera and anyone else is going to be behind the eight-ball when they get here on Monday! We started game discussion early but it will continue through tomorrow as planned originally - and voting can begin Tuesday (or before then if there's a 100% vote to vote.) @aethera was going to be away and @MuuMuuChainsmoker was under the weather. 1 Link to comment
egavasc May 22, 2016 Share May 22, 2016 Well then I definitely don't know what the Drunk is as I selected Doors 1 and 2, behind which are the Apprentice Seer and the Minion. Link to comment
SVNBob May 22, 2016 Author Share May 22, 2016 In that case, if we assume everyone on the listy-list has told the truth, then the former Drunk can be one of only 3 roles: Wolf, Tanner, or Hunter. Odds are we can no longer trust the former Drunk, but we don't know if should DL them. Link to comment
Oinky Boinky May 22, 2016 Share May 22, 2016 Don't trust the drunk? I don't trust the drunk and I used to be him. The way I see it, I am either a were wolf or the Tanner and I wouldn't trust me, but I wouldn't kill me. Link to comment
MuuMuuChainsmoker May 22, 2016 Share May 22, 2016 Well, I'm still feeling like warmed over death on a Triscuit, but I'm at least semi functional for the first time in days. Apologies to everyone for my lack of help so far. I'll read and catch up and see if anything hits me. Link to comment
MuuMuuChainsmoker May 23, 2016 Share May 23, 2016 Ok, so to update the list: So, updating Lisin's listy list: Doppelganger - claimed by SVNBob, no claim yet on who/what he copied. Switched with ? per @SILVERSTORMM. Werewolf Werewolf Minion - unclaimed role (per egavasc) Masons - Claimed by @SAOIRSE and ? Seer - Claimed by egavasc Apprentice Seer - unclaimed role (per egavasc) Robber Claimed by @Jesse (Now the Insomniac) Troublemaker - Claimed by @SILVERSTORMM Drunk Claimed by @Oinky Boinky Insomniac - Claimed by @DEADPOOL, but Robbed thereof Villager - Claimed by @MACHIABELLY Villager - Claimed by @MUUMUUCHAINSMOKER Villager - Claimed by @CuriousParker Hunter Tanner And the incomplete claims/additional open questions. @MARKHB claims team village @LISIN claims team village @AQUARIAN1 claims team village aethera will be in on Monday morning, arriving to a wall of text Assuming that Silver is the troublemaker, who did she switch with Bob? Assuming Bob is the Doppelganger, who did he copy? Link to comment
FormerMod-a1 May 23, 2016 Share May 23, 2016 I'm here briefly. It was a long day. I'll catch up tomorrow and post more then. Link to comment
Aethera May 23, 2016 Share May 23, 2016 Wow, that is a lot of text. Just read through, and going back to re-read. I am/was the other Mason. I can confirm what @saoirse claimed. Link to comment
Meredith Quill May 23, 2016 Share May 23, 2016 On 22 May 2016 at 5:59 AM, SVNBob said: Well deduced everyone. I am the Doppelganger (or was, according to Silver). But I did not copy a Wolf or Tanner. I copied someone else on Team Village, but not a Mason. I won't reveal who or what just yet. So Bob, whom did you copy? Because that may confirm someone else's specific or team claim, which will enable them and you* to be taken off the suspect list. *If you copied an as yet unrevealed role and the player confirms it to be correct. Link to comment
SVNBob May 23, 2016 Author Share May 23, 2016 Others, maybe. But not myself. That depends on who I got swapped with. Who else got Troubled Silver? Someone clear or someone not? Link to comment
SVNBob May 23, 2016 Author Share May 23, 2016 I guess I shouldn't be coy then. I copied you Silver, so I made my own trouble. By swapping you and Lisin. 1 Link to comment
Meredith Quill May 23, 2016 Share May 23, 2016 I lied, I swapped you and aethera, so you're a mason now. In which case, please confirm you were being truthful in the above post. Link to comment
SVNBob May 23, 2016 Author Share May 23, 2016 I think we've come to the same conclusion, that Lisin was not Team Village as she claimed. The question is, was she a Wolf or the Tanner? Link to comment
Meredith Quill May 23, 2016 Share May 23, 2016 I personally, haven't come to any conclusion about @Lisin yet? What makes you jump to that conclusion?? Are you confirming that you were being honest, now that you know you're -still- on Team Village? Link to comment
SVNBob May 23, 2016 Author Share May 23, 2016 I'm going on the fact that all the Village roles have been claimed, and there have been no counter-claims on anything. Logically, @Lisin cannot be Team Village. Which means that she should come clean with her role at this time. 1 Link to comment
Lisin May 23, 2016 Share May 23, 2016 Why can't I be Team Village? No one has claimed the Hunter... But also I'm not sure I believe you Bob. (Also also? Something is fucking up with my computer so I can't @ reply and everything sucks so I may be a bit slow to reply) Link to comment
SVNBob May 23, 2016 Author Share May 23, 2016 Damn. Didn't work. Confession time. @Lisin can't be the Hunter, because I really copied @MarkHB, and he is the Hunter. That's why one Wolf is either Lisin or aquarian. It could be both, leaving Oinky as the Tanner, but I'm not too sure about that. Link to comment
MuuMuuChainsmoker May 23, 2016 Share May 23, 2016 Does that mean @aethera is now the Doppel Hunter? I really need to make myself go to bed, but my sleep cycle is all messed up now and things are starting to get interesting. :) Link to comment
SVNBob May 23, 2016 Author Share May 23, 2016 1 minute ago, MuuMuuChainsmoker said: Does that mean @aethera is now the Doppel Hunter? If Silver wasn't lying, then yes. Link to comment
Meredith Quill May 23, 2016 Share May 23, 2016 Waiting for @MarkHB to confirm that he is the Hunter. The way I see it, @SVNBob now knows he is Team Village no matter what he started as/actions he took, so has no reason to mislead us villagers. Link to comment
SVNBob May 23, 2016 Author Share May 23, 2016 Exactly. I was trying to trap a wolf, but she didn't take the bait. Link to comment
Meredith Quill May 23, 2016 Share May 23, 2016 If the Tanner and a wolf both get equally DL'd, what happens then? Link to comment
MarkHB May 23, 2016 Share May 23, 2016 Confirming I'm the Hunter kind of negates the effectiveness of the Hunter, doesn't it? Which is why I continue to be skeptical of the usefulness of the role in these games. Suffice to say I won't be voting to DL @aethera. My understanding is that DL's of a Wolf and the Tanner result in a shared victory for Town and Tanner. Link to comment
Drogo May 23, 2016 Share May 23, 2016 If the Tanner is killed, any other tied DL's don't matter. The Tanner is "win-stealing." Link to comment
SVNBob May 23, 2016 Author Share May 23, 2016 2 minutes ago, MarkHB said: My understanding is that DL's of a Wolf and the Tanner result in a shared victory for Town and Tanner. 2 minutes ago, Drogo said: If the Tanner is killed, any other tied DL's don't matter. The Tanner is "win-stealing." Actually, Tanner can only win-steal from the Wolves. See this flowchart. Link to comment
Meredith Quill May 23, 2016 Share May 23, 2016 So we can DL both @Lisin and @aquarian1 and Team Village would still win? 2 Link to comment
SVNBob May 23, 2016 Author Share May 23, 2016 Assuming we can pull off the tie, yes. And I really need to go focus on the championship game, so I'll go ahead and take my leave. 1 vote @Lisin (Bob) Link to comment
Meredith Quill May 23, 2016 Share May 23, 2016 1 to DL @Lisin (Bob) 1 to DL @aquarian1 (SilverStormm) Link to comment
Drogo May 23, 2016 Share May 23, 2016 9 minutes ago, SVNBob said: *Apologies, this flow chart was not included in the zip file somebody sent me before this game. ;) Link to comment
Lisin May 23, 2016 Share May 23, 2016 1) I'm confused because I thought a Tanner DL was a win for the Tanner and that's why we always try to find the Tanner and not DL them. 2) Somebody's lying about their role and it isn't me. Link to comment
Recommended Posts