kismet July 16, 2016 Share July 16, 2016 Good for her. Not sure how many people she draws in, but glad she got something out of this role. 3 Link to comment
statsgirl July 16, 2016 Share July 16, 2016 Me too. She seems like a nice person and she really got shafted in that role. 14 hours ago, quarks said: Well, in films, sure, directors have a lot of power - and screenwriters have more input into the pacing and the look of a film than I think they're often given credit for. But even there, executive producers and film executives can and often do exert a lot of creative control: they're signing the checks, after all, and they have ultimate control on what goes out on screen. On television, writers and directors typically do not have the real power, and everything I've seen/heard from Arrow and interviews with cast, crew and network/WB execs suggests that Arrow is a pretty typical WB production in this regard. I agree, it's EPs and execs who call the real shots. I was commenting in response to a comment that the producers are talking to the actors and I don't think that means much in terms of the overall show. Sure, Paul Blackthorne got a Lance/Donna relationship after lobbying very hard for one but in s4 it seems more of an afterthought than anything. The Flashbacks are an example of what I meant. I'm pretty sure they were determined by Berlanti & Co. but it was up to the writers and directors to do what they could to make them suck less (which usually didn't happen). Even with a better accent, I'm not sure ER could have done much to make Poppy a person anyone cared about, including Oliver. (I suspect Oliver will care more about her in s5 flashbacks than he did in s4.) Link to comment
bijoux July 16, 2016 Share July 16, 2016 A second SA Nerd HQ panel was added for Friday. https://twitter.com/thenerdmachine/status/754382024815751168?s=09 1 Link to comment
Morrigan2575 July 16, 2016 Share July 16, 2016 (edited) 14 minutes ago, bijoux said: Cautious optimism. Lots of spec that it's an OTA panel. I'm trying not to get my hopes up. Of course i did get a partial OTA panel at CoH2 so, i can't complain too much if it doesn't happen Edited July 16, 2016 by Morrigan2575 2 Link to comment
lemotomato July 16, 2016 Share July 16, 2016 I'm not going to get my hopes up for an OTA panel. It's probably Code 8 related. 6 Link to comment
thegirlsleuth July 16, 2016 Share July 16, 2016 Are Willa and Emily really having a yard sale? I'm on my my phone so can't see all the details, but if so, that's kind of delightful. 2 Link to comment
Guest July 16, 2016 Share July 16, 2016 (edited) Aw. Haven't seen an EBR/WH pic in forever! As for SA's panel, I'd love it to be an OTA one but I have zero expectations for that tbh. It'll probably be with RA or whoever was in TMNT2. Edited July 16, 2016 by Guest Link to comment
SmallScreenDiva July 16, 2016 Share July 16, 2016 Yeah, also not getting my hopes up it's an OTA panel. But ... Stephen when he promised to do something for the fans helping out with his MLB poll said he was going to go through his mentions and see what the most popular thing was, and next to the EW cover, an OTA panel at Nerd HQ was the most popular, IMO. In fact, there had been a trend earlier in the day. Sooooo .... *desperately crossing all available digits* 2 Link to comment
apinknightmare July 16, 2016 Share July 16, 2016 I like to think that he surely knows what kind of expectations he's setting up with this tease, that people will assume it's OTA because it's what they've been asking for, and that they'll buy tickets to the panel for that reason. And that they'd be supremely disappointed if it winds up being something not related to Arrow. But he has a history of doing dumb shit and there's a reason why the panel isn't being marketed with his guests' names - which could be completely well-intentioned, like genuinely wanting it to be a surprise or keeping it under wraps in case something comes up with filming or whatever. Here's hoping that whatever it is - there isn't a disappointed audience after the fact. 12 Link to comment
apinknightmare July 16, 2016 Share July 16, 2016 Maybe I shouldn't read into his phrasing considering his not-so-great grammar, but he did specify that the panel was with friends, not just a friend. 1 Link to comment
Guest July 16, 2016 Share July 16, 2016 Felicity and Friends? Because I really love that show. :P Link to comment
Chaser July 16, 2016 Share July 16, 2016 Just now, Angel12d said: Felicity and Friends? Because I really love that show. :P Lol I had that thought too. 2 minutes ago, apinknightmare said: Maybe I shouldn't read into his phrasing considering his not-so-great grammar, but he did specify that the panel was with friends, not just a friend. Cody is bringing his wife. 1 Link to comment
TwistedandBored July 16, 2016 Share July 16, 2016 17 minutes ago, Chaser said: It's probably with Cody Rhodes. Edit this out! 3 Link to comment
AyChihuahua July 16, 2016 Share July 16, 2016 14 minutes ago, Chaser said: Cody is bringing his wife. My exact thought. Link to comment
Morrigan2575 July 16, 2016 Share July 16, 2016 3 minutes ago, Velocity23 said: What would Cody be doing at SDCC? No idea. I don't think Wrestling is a big attraction at SDCC. Link to comment
Chaser July 16, 2016 Share July 16, 2016 I'm actually joking. I don't think they would give an extra slot to SA just so he can put his WWE credit on display. 1 Link to comment
AyChihuahua July 16, 2016 Share July 16, 2016 33 minutes ago, Chaser said: I'm actually joking. I don't think they would give an extra slot to SA just so he can put his WWE credit on display. He's going to play an, I believe, recurring role, on Arrow. He's an official part of the comics-on-tv world, with the added benefit of maybe bringing in new eyeballs. I think it's entirely possible. Link to comment
way2interested July 17, 2016 Share July 17, 2016 31 minutes ago, Chaser said: I'm actually joking. I don't think they would give an extra slot to SA just so he can put his WWE credit on display. I would think that that wouldn't happen either. However, if it does, and if this is what SA meant on twitter by doing something from his mentions that would make people happy, then I will truly believe that SA has basically now completely disconnected with fan interests. 4 Link to comment
Velocity23 July 17, 2016 Share July 17, 2016 7 minutes ago, AyChihuahua said: He's going to play an, I believe, recurring role, on Arrow. He's an official part of the comics-on-tv world, with the added benefit of maybe bringing in new eyeballs. I think it's entirely possible. NOPE 1 Link to comment
AyChihuahua July 17, 2016 Share July 17, 2016 1 minute ago, Velocity23 said: NOPE Ha! I find tv wrestling to be unbearably stupid. But, millions of people not only watch, but actually pay for pay-per-view events. So bringing him on realistically interests some viewers not otherwise interested. It doesn't matter that he's a douche or a TERRIBLE actor. It's just reality. Link to comment
AyChihuahua July 17, 2016 Share July 17, 2016 (edited) 5 minutes ago, way2interested said: I would think that that wouldn't happen either. However, if it does, and if this is what SA meant on twitter by doing something from his mentions that would make people happy, then I will truly believe that SA has basically now completely disconnected with fan interests. People here, yes. But lots of people, I believe in the millions, are totally into WWE. I don't get it, but I know it. Would it really be that bad? SA trading barbs with some silly wrestler and/or maybe the silly wrestler's wife? For me, no harm, no foul. SA should be hanging with DR and EBR, but from his perspective, the audience has been there, done that. The totally silly wrestler is new, and SA is all about the new. For the record, this isn't a prediction. I just won't discount the possibility. Edited July 17, 2016 by AyChihuahua 2 Link to comment
Thundercatmary July 17, 2016 Share July 17, 2016 1 minute ago, Velocity23 said: Isnt she just lovely Sigh I wish she would just stop but I think she likes the attention it gets her. Hopefully fans ignore her. 1 Link to comment
Chaser July 17, 2016 Share July 17, 2016 4 minutes ago, Velocity23 said: Isnt she just lovely I want to know what happened with her. What triggered the switch from good natured trolling to mean spirited attention grabbing trolling. 4 Link to comment
apinknightmare July 17, 2016 Share July 17, 2016 I think she's past her trolling prime. RIP good humor. 8 Link to comment
Thundercatmary July 17, 2016 Share July 17, 2016 (edited) Idk but she claimed several times that Olicity fans were imagining things and that she wasn't trolling/baiting the fans, she was actually pretty nasty about it, but I mean come on this is clearly baiting those fans. ETA: I mean I cold be way off base but come on, she talks about women being treated fairly and then she goes after a largely female (tho ofc not all) female fanbase. This is why I consider her a hypocrite. Edited July 17, 2016 by Thundercatmary 12 Link to comment
catrox14 July 17, 2016 Share July 17, 2016 She's certainly doing nothing to endear me to her and she's IMO harming her own reputation with this petty trolling 4 Link to comment
Chaser July 17, 2016 Share July 17, 2016 SDCC is not the WWE crowd. SA would have to get this approved by NerdHQ and I just have a hard time thinking they would think it's a winner. Flooding mentions (his and NerdHQ) with OTA wishes, his talk about doing something for the fans and a panel is added to included him and friends. Timing wise, I totally see people thinking we could get an OTA panel. I'm keeping my expectations down but it would be nice. 1 Link to comment
apinknightmare July 17, 2016 Share July 17, 2016 (edited) 9 minutes ago, Chaser said: I want to know what happened with her. What triggered the switch from good natured trolling to mean spirited attention grabbing trolling. I think she actually legit hates Olicity and isn't just trolling. So her comments come off more biting and without humor because she isn't trying to rile people up by making them believe she hates Olicity, she's trying to rile people up by actively, actually hating Olicity. I mean, half of the fun of her glory days of trolling were people taking her seriously when she was clearly kidding. She ain't kidding about this particular subject. Maybe she feels protective of her new BFF Katie or something. Edited July 17, 2016 by apinknightmare 14 Link to comment
kismet July 17, 2016 Share July 17, 2016 13 minutes ago, way2interested said: I would think If that that wouldn't happen either. However, if it does, and if this is what SA meant on twitter by doing something from his mentions that would make people happy, then I will truly believe that SA has basically now completely disconnected with fan interests. WWE Is part of his twitter fanbase so maybe a Rhodes panel would appeal to them. I feel like SA Is trying to diversify, so I wouldnt be surprised If this new panel was non-Arrow. Then agaIn OTA would bring $$$$ 1 Link to comment
Guest July 17, 2016 Share July 17, 2016 I feel sorry for GS that she feels like she has to bait Olicity fans just to get some attention. At this point, it's pathetic. I'm sad for her. Hopefully most Olicity fans are too busy voting in the SOTY poll to pay her any attention. Also, I wonder if there will be a day when Olicity or its fans aren't likened to cancer or Trump or all other gross things thrown at us? It's a fictional relationship. Get a life. Link to comment
catrox14 July 17, 2016 Share July 17, 2016 2 minutes ago, Chaser said: SDCC is not the WWE crowd. SA would have to get this approved by NerdHQ and I just have a hard time thinking they would think it's a winner. Flooding mentions (his and NerdHQ) with OTA wishes, his talk about doing something for the fans and a panel is added to included him and friends. Timing wise, I totally see people thinking we could get an OTA panel. I'm keeping my expectations down but it would be nice. Jared Padalecki is doing a solo panel at Nerd HQ after he does the SPN group panel, maybe they are going to join each others' solo panels? Link to comment
Chaser July 17, 2016 Share July 17, 2016 2 minutes ago, apinknightmare said: I think she actually legit hates Olicity and isn't just trolling. So her comments come off more biting and without humor because she isn't trying to rile people up by making them believe she hates Olicity, she's trying to rile people up by actively hating Olicity. I mean, half of the fun of her glory days of trolling were people taking her seriously when she was clearly kidding. She ain't kidding about this particular subject. Maybe she feels protective of her new BFF Katie or something. I wouldn't even say she is sincere about KC. I think she hates everything Arrow. 4 Link to comment
apinknightmare July 17, 2016 Share July 17, 2016 2 minutes ago, Chaser said: I wouldn't even say she is sincere about KC. I think she hates everything Arrow. I have no idea if she is or not. If she hates everything Arrow seems to me she'd be sympathetic to a person who played a terrible version of her fave and then got killed off by those she despises. They could have both commiserated over how wrong they did Dinah/Laurel for all I know. Link to comment
calliope1975 July 17, 2016 Share July 17, 2016 11 minutes ago, Angel12d said: I feel sorry for GS that she feels like she has to bait Olicity fans just to get some attention. At this point, it's pathetic. I'm sad for her. Hopefully most Olicity fans are too busy voting in the SOTY poll to pay her any attention. Also, I wonder if there will be a day when Olicity or its fans aren't likened to cancer or Trump or all other gross things thrown at us? It's a fictional relationship. Get a life. I enjoy a fictional pairing on TV, and it brings me joy in a sometimes shitty world. Such monstrous behavior. Guess I'll go back to kicking kittens. I'm sorry if other Olicity fans attacked or annoyed her or whatever, but jeez, rein it in lady. 19 Link to comment
Guest July 17, 2016 Share July 17, 2016 (edited) 18 minutes ago, calliope1975 said: I enjoy a fictional pairing on TV, and it brings me joy in a sometimes shitty world. Such monstrous behavior. Guess I'll go back to kicking kittens. I'm sorry if other Olicity fans attacked or annoyed her or whatever, but jeez, rein it in lady. Exactly. I don't excuse any fans that attacked her, there's no need for that at all and I will never understand people like that, but she's being truly awful right now and it's not the first time. I'm sick of it tbh. We take so much crap because why? Because it interrupted a comic canon couple. OH THE HORROR. Get the f*** over it. Edited July 17, 2016 by Guest Link to comment
wonderwall July 17, 2016 Share July 17, 2016 I'm feeling very good about boycotting her comics right now. 2 Link to comment
thegirlsleuth July 17, 2016 Share July 17, 2016 (edited) I find Gail Simone's comments especially hilarious since there is a "make arrow great again" movement a la Trump, which mostly consists of "get rid of Olicity". Edited July 17, 2016 by thegirlsleuth 2 Link to comment
lemotomato July 17, 2016 Share July 17, 2016 3 minutes ago, thegirlsleuth said: I find Gail Simone's comments especially hilarious since there is a "make arrow great again" movement a la Trump, which mostly consists of "get rid of Olicity". Killing Felicity is also one of their talking points. For someone who is supposed to have a legacy championing feminism, GS seems to enjoy disparaging the mostly female fanbase of a female character and the female character herself. 18 Link to comment
statsgirl July 17, 2016 Share July 17, 2016 It's sad because she used to be someone worth reading. 3 hours ago, AyChihuahua said: People here, yes. But lots of people, I believe in the millions, are totally into WWE. I don't get it, but I know it. Would it really be that bad? SA trading barbs with some silly wrestler and/or maybe the silly wrestler's wife? For me, no harm, no foul. SA should be hanging with DR and EBR, but from his perspective, the audience has been there, done that. The totally silly wrestler is new, and SA is all about the new. They may get more eyeballs for a while but they would be people who would tune in for the silliness of the costumes and the fight sequences. So either they'll be disappointed when they figure out the show is about character development, or I'll be disappointed when the show caters to their expectations. I can see it happening at a HVFF but does SA have the clout to get a room for a vanity project like that at SDCC? 1 Link to comment
AyChihuahua July 17, 2016 Share July 17, 2016 15 minutes ago, statsgirl said: I can see it happening at a HVFF but does SA have the clout to get a room for a vanity project like that at SDCC? He had the clout to get the guy a recurring gig on the show. Link to comment
Chaser July 17, 2016 Share July 17, 2016 36 minutes ago, AyChihuahua said: He had the clout to get the guy a recurring gig on the show. Spoiler All I'm seeing is Guest Star in Ep 3. Not recurring. A spot on his show is vastly different than a panel at a SDCC event. 2 Link to comment
sadfangirl July 17, 2016 Share July 17, 2016 43 minutes ago, AyChihuahua said: He had the clout to get the guy a recurring gig on the show. There is a really good documentary called Showrunners that explains just how much clout the "name in the title" actor has on a show. If I remember rightly it's something like: Year 1 they work for you Year 2 you work together Year 3 you work for them. Arrow is going into year 5. SA did voice some displeasure at the BMD story and got a few things changed. Then raved about it. He might not get everything his own way, but I'm sure he got CR the audition and a recommendation. 3 Link to comment
AyChihuahua July 17, 2016 Share July 17, 2016 9 minutes ago, Chaser said: Hide contents All I'm seeing is Guest Star in Ep 3. Not recurring. A spot on his show is vastly different than a panel at a SDCC event. I thought he got Spoiler the Jewish flashback character? If he's only in one ep, that's great news. I think he's a douche. (At least his persona, no clue re his RL personality.) Link to comment
kismet July 17, 2016 Share July 17, 2016 I think his additional event is for NerdHQ not SDCC, so rules might be a little different. It's really what Zach Levi & co want to do. I think SA & ZL are buds or enough of buds to pull some strings. Honestly, I hope its just a good panel no matter who his friends are. Link to comment
Recommended Posts