mstaken July 22, 2014 Author Share July 22, 2014 Rory's Birthday PartiesDouble DateThose Are Strings, Pinocchio And we have our final three! My vote: Double Date (I love it and have probably rewatched it more than I've rewatched the other two, but it's not *quite* as special to me) Link to comment
lulu1960 July 22, 2014 Share July 22, 2014 RBP. Buh bye, Dead Uncles. Have I mentioned that's my favorite episode of the series? 2 Link to comment
mstaken July 23, 2014 Author Share July 23, 2014 Our final two! Rory's Birthday PartiesThose Are Strings, Pinocchio What are we doing next?! Link to comment
nolieblue July 23, 2014 Share July 23, 2014 (edited) Strings How about doing worst episodes of all seasons? Edited July 23, 2014 by nolieblue Link to comment
mstaken July 23, 2014 Author Share July 23, 2014 My vote: RBP How about doing worst episodes of all seasons? I love this idea! We can vote against the first five eliminated from every round. Quick question, though: would we be voting for the best of the worst or the worst of the worst?! In other words, would the last episode left standing be the VERY worst episode (which I think would be a cool idea), or the one we liked best? Link to comment
Taryn74 July 23, 2014 Share July 23, 2014 I think worst of the worst! We rarely get to really think about which eps we HATE the most, so this will be a fun excursion I think. 1 Link to comment
mstaken July 23, 2014 Author Share July 23, 2014 Christopher Returns P.S. I Lo... Love, Daisies and Troubadours The Deer Hunters Kiss and tell Paris is Burning Sadie, Sadie Presenting Lorelai Gilmore The Ins and Outs of Inns It Should Have Been Lorelai Secrets and Loans Help Wanted Application Anxiety I Solemnly Swear Keg! Max! Lorelai Out of Water Here Comes the Son Happy Birthday Baby Ted Koppel's Big Night Out Girls in Bikinis Tick Tick Tick... Die Jerk Afterboom In the Clamor and the Clangor How Many Kropogs to Cape Cod But I'm a Gilmore Blame Booze and Melville He's Slipping 'Em Bread, Dig A Vineyard Valentine Always a Godmother Bridesmais Revisited Driving Miss Gilmore Partings The Great Stink Go Bulldogs French Twist Lorelai's First Cotillion Introducing Lorelai Planetarium Merry Fisticuffs I know we're still finishing up the last round of our other game, but here's our list of the worst episodes from each season! (I feel compelled to add that I'd far rather watch nearly all of the worst episodes from S1-S4 than even the comparatively average episodes of later seasons!) These are the episodes that were voted off during the first two rounds, and since we eliminated three per round, that leaves us with 42 episodes. I figured we can start by voting for four episodes until we get down to 34 or so. And, remember, we're voting for the episodes on this list that we like most---or, er, dislike least :) Link to comment
nolieblue July 23, 2014 Share July 23, 2014 Tick Tick Clamor and Clangor Afterboom P.S. I Lo Link to comment
mstaken July 23, 2014 Author Share July 23, 2014 Wait, did TASP already win our game?! If so, congratulations to Strings! My votes for the best of the worst: The Deer Hunters Presenting Lorelai Gilmore Lorelai Out of Water Clamor and Clangor Link to comment
lulu1960 July 23, 2014 Share July 23, 2014 Inns Clamor But I'm a Gilmore happy Birthday Baby Link to comment
mstaken July 23, 2014 Author Share July 23, 2014 Ins and Outs of Inns will never be a favorite of mine (I can't stand Mia and the fight between Sookie and Lorelai drives me nuts), but after rewatching it a few months ago, I was thrilled to see Luke outed as a sci-fi fan in this episode. I wish we'd seen more of secretly geeky sci-fi fan Luke in the series and am always hoping he'll pop up in fanfic :) 1 Link to comment
nolieblue July 23, 2014 Share July 23, 2014 The only thing I liked about Mia coming to town was that we got a bit of backstory on Luke. Otherwise I found her incredibly grating. 2 Link to comment
Taryn74 July 24, 2014 Share July 24, 2014 My head is already messed up trying to figure out how to vote LOL. Thanks for the reminder that it's the ones we like 'best' out of the 'worst' at this point. And, ack! There's too many I want to try to save for at least a few rounds! Presenting Lorelai Gilmore The Deer Hunters Help Wanted Christopher Returns Link to comment
eledgy July 24, 2014 Share July 24, 2014 I was at work and couldn't weigh in earlier and now it's too late for this round, but I just wanted to remind you all that at some point not too long ago Taryn I think mentioned doing an elimination of Mrs. Kim scenes. So tuck that away in the idea file? 1 Link to comment
mstaken July 24, 2014 Author Share July 24, 2014 Wait, elegy, are you playing?! Yes, we should definitely do Mama Kim moments in the very near future. 1 Link to comment
mstaken July 24, 2014 Author Share July 24, 2014 I'll keep this open for a few more hours in case anyone else wants to vote :) Link to comment
eledgy July 24, 2014 Share July 24, 2014 I think I'll just keep my observer status this time around, MsT! I think my previous post was confusing, sorry about that. Link to comment
mstaken July 24, 2014 Author Share July 24, 2014 Heh---I didn't know that people lurked around the game threads without playing. I'd better make sure my vote counting is accurate! (I'm so math-impaired that one can never be sure.) Deer Hunters, Presenting Lorelai Gilmore and Clamor are safe from our wrath! Rather than run a million-way tiebreaker for the final spot, I'm thinking it makes sense to move on to the next round: Christopher ReturnsP.S. I Lo...Love, Daisies and TroubadoursKiss and tellParis is BurningSadie, SadieThe Ins and Outs of InnsIt Should Have Been LorelaiSecrets and LoansHelp WantedApplication AnxietyI Solemnly SwearKeg! Max!Lorelai Out of WaterHere Comes the SonHappy Birthday BabyTed Koppel's Big Night OutGirls in BikinisTick Tick Tick...Die JerkAfterboomHow Many Kropogs to Cape CodBut I'm a GilmoreBlame Booze and MelvilleHe's Slipping 'Em Bread, DigA Vineyard ValentineAlways a GodmotherBridesmais RevisitedDriving Miss GilmorePartingsThe Great StinkGo BulldogsFrench TwistLorelai's First CotillionIntroducing Lorelai PlanetariumMerry Fisticuffs The next round is open. Just vote for the four you want to save! My votes: Die Jerk (I know, I know...I can't defend my love for this one either!) Lorelai Out of Water (or this one...) Secrets and Loans Here Comes the Son (while the scenes from the ill-fated spin off are beyond awful, I actually really love the Connecticut-based scenes in this episode!) Link to comment
nolieblue July 24, 2014 Share July 24, 2014 Tick TickAfterboomP.S. I Lo Secrets and Loans Link to comment
Taryn74 July 24, 2014 Share July 24, 2014 Christopher Returns Application Anxiety HCTS Help Wanted Link to comment
mstaken July 25, 2014 Author Share July 25, 2014 Christopher ReturnsP.S. I Lo...Love, Daisies and TroubadoursKiss and TellParis is BurningSadie, SadieThe Ins and Outs of InnsIt Should Have Been LorelaiHelp WantedApplication AnxietyI Solemnly SwearKeg! Max!Lorelai Out of WaterHappy Birthday BabyTed Koppel's Big Night OutGirls in BikinisDie JerkAfterboomHow Many Kropogs to Cape CodBut I'm a GilmoreBlame Booze and MelvilleHe's Slipping 'Em Bread, DigA Vineyard ValentineAlways a GodmotherBridesmaids RevisitedDriving Miss GilmorePartingsThe Great StinkGo BulldogsFrench TwistLorelai's First CotillionIntroducing Lorelai PlanetariumMerry Fisticuffs Secrets and Loans, Here Comes the Son and Tick Tick Tick have been graciously pardoned by the voters, and the next round is open! My votes: Paris is Burning The Ins and Outs of Inns (we've reached the point where there aren't many more episodes I like, so my fondness for secret sci-fi geek Luke overshadows my annoyance with Mia and the Sookie/Lorelai spat!) Lorelai Out of Water Die Jerk Link to comment
nolieblue July 25, 2014 Share July 25, 2014 (edited) P.S. I Lo Sadie Sadie Afterboom Kiss and Tell Edited July 25, 2014 by nolieblue Link to comment
Taryn74 July 25, 2014 Share July 25, 2014 Christopher Returns Help Wanted ISHBL Application Anxiety Link to comment
mstaken July 26, 2014 Author Share July 26, 2014 Christopher ReturnsP.S. I Lo...Love, Daisies and TroubadoursParis is BurningSadie, SadieIt Should Have Been LorelaiHelp WantedApplication AnxietyI Solemnly SwearKeg! Max!Lorelai Out of WaterHappy Birthday BabyTed Koppel's Big Night OutGirls in BikinisDie JerkHow Many Kropogs to Cape CodBut I'm a GilmoreBlame Booze and MelvilleHe's Slipping 'Em Bread, DigA Vineyard ValentineAlways a GodmotherBridesmaids RevisitedDriving Miss GilmorePartingsThe Great StinkGo BulldogsFrench TwistLorelai's First CotillionIntroducing Lorelai PlanetariumMerry Fisticuffs Kiss and Tell, Ins and Outs of Inns and Afterboom can all exhale, as they're now all saved from the dreaded fate of being our Worst Episode Ever. The next round is open! My votes: Paris is Burning Lorelai Out of Water Die Jerk Link to comment
lulu1960 July 26, 2014 Share July 26, 2014 Lorelai Out of Water But I'm a Gilmore Happy BirthdayvBaby Link to comment
mstaken July 27, 2014 Author Share July 27, 2014 Waiting a bit for Nolie and/or other voters! Link to comment
nolieblue July 27, 2014 Share July 27, 2014 P. S. I Lo Daisies Sadie Sadie. I've been away -- thanks for waiting! Link to comment
mstaken July 27, 2014 Author Share July 27, 2014 Welcome back, nolie!!! I worry when a member of our cyber-family goes MIA :) Come catch up on the zillion photos we posted in the Guess the Episode thread! So, interestingly, the only episode to receive more than one vote was Lorelai Out of Water, which is now safe. Should we bother doing a 10-way tiebreaker, or just move on to the next round?! Link to comment
mstaken July 28, 2014 Author Share July 28, 2014 (edited) Christopher ReturnsP.S. I Lo...Love, Daisies and TroubadoursParis is BurningSadie, SadieIt Should Have Been LorelaiHelp WantedApplication AnxietyI Solemnly SwearKeg! Max!Happy Birthday BabyTed Koppel's Big Night OutGirls in BikinisDie JerkHow Many Kropogs to Cape CodBut I'm a GilmoreBlame Booze and MelvilleHe's Slipping 'Em Bread, DigA Vineyard ValentineAlways a GodmotherBridesmaids RevisitedDriving Miss GilmorePartingsThe Great StinkGo BulldogsFrench TwistLorelai's First CotillionIntroducing Lorelai PlanetariumMerry Fisticuffs Thanks guys---I was kind of dreading that 10-way tiebreaker :) Just vote for the three of the above that you most want to 'save'! Edited July 28, 2014 by mstaken Link to comment
lulu1960 July 28, 2014 Share July 28, 2014 Happy Birthday, Baby But I'm a Gilmore PS I Lo... Link to comment
mstaken July 28, 2014 Author Share July 28, 2014 Help Wanted I Solemnly Swear Die Jerk Link to comment
nolieblue July 28, 2014 Share July 28, 2014 P.S. I Lo...Love, Daisies and TroubadoursSadie, Sadie Link to comment
mstaken July 29, 2014 Author Share July 29, 2014 Christopher ReturnsLove, Daisies and TroubadoursParis is BurningSadie, SadieIt Should Have Been LorelaiApplication AnxietyI Solemnly SwearKeg! Max!Happy Birthday BabyTed Koppel's Big Night OutGirls in BikinisDie JerkHow Many Kropogs to Cape CodBut I'm a GilmoreBlame Booze and MelvilleHe's Slipping 'Em Bread, DigA Vineyard ValentineAlways a GodmotherBridesmaids RevisitedDriving Miss GilmorePartingsThe Great StinkGo BulldogsFrench TwistLorelai's First CotillionIntroducing Lorelai PlanetariumMerry Fisticuffs Help Wanted and P.S. I Lo.... are safe, and the next round is open! Just vote for the three remaining episodes that you want to save :) My this-is-already-getting-hard votes: I Solemnly Swear Die Jerk It Should Have Been Lorelai Link to comment
mstaken July 29, 2014 Author Share July 29, 2014 Booze That limo scene you guys posted pictures of has me more inclined to save BBAM than ever before. See how much you guys influence me?! Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.