mstaken June 26, 2014 Author Share June 26, 2014 Our final two! We've Got Magic to DoTwenty-One is the Loneliest Number Link to comment
mstaken June 26, 2014 Author Share June 26, 2014 Magic is gone, so 21 is our winner! Let's start killing off S7, shall we?! The Long Morrow That's What You Get, Folks, For Makin' Whoopee Lorelai's First Cotillion 'S Wonderful, 'S Marvelous The Great Stink Go, Bulldogs! French Twist Introducing Lorelai Planetarium Knit People Knit Merry Fisticuffs Santa's Secret Stuff To Whom It May Concern I'd Rather Be in Philadelphia Farwell, My Pet I Am Kayak, Hear Me Roar Will You Be My Lorelai Gilmore? Gilmore Girls Only Hay Bale Maze It's Just Like Riding A Bike Lorelai? Lorelai? Unto the Breach Bon Voyage Just vote for the three you most want eliminated! 1 Link to comment
mstaken June 26, 2014 Author Share June 26, 2014 My votes: I'd Rather Be in Philadelphia (I actually think the awfulness of this one is overrated!) Go, Bulldogs (easily one of the three worst episodes of the series IMO) Introducing Lorelai Planetarium (I just hate this one. I can't even explain exactly why) Link to comment
AlinaRay June 26, 2014 Share June 26, 2014 French Twist Santa (I hate that they put off xmas for a little kid in favor of Rory) Bulldogs Link to comment
nolieblue June 26, 2014 Share June 26, 2014 Stink Bulldogs French Twist All three stink. Link to comment
mstaken June 27, 2014 Author Share June 27, 2014 The Long MorrowThat's What You Get, Folks, For Makin' WhoopeeLorelai's First Cotillion'S Wonderful, 'S MarvelousIntroducing Lorelai PlanetariumKnit People KnitMerry FisticuffsSanta's Secret StuffTo Whom It May ConcernI'd Rather Be in PhiladelphiaFarwell, My PetI Am Kayak, Hear Me RoarWill You Be My Lorelai Gilmore?Gilmore Girls OnlyHay Bale MazeIt's Just Like Riding A BikeLorelai? Lorelai?Unto the BreachBon Voyage Stink, Bulldogs and French Twist are gone, and the next round is open! My votes: Introducing Lorelai Planetarium Merry Fisticuffs I'd Rather Be in Philadelphia Link to comment
lulu1960 June 27, 2014 Share June 27, 2014 Lorelai's First Cotillion S'Wonderful Lorelai Planetarium Link to comment
mstaken June 28, 2014 Author Share June 28, 2014 The Long MorrowThat's What You Get, Folks, For Makin' Whoopee'S Wonderful, 'S MarvelousKnit People KnitSanta's Secret StuffTo Whom It May ConcernI'd Rather Be in PhiladelphiaFarwell, My PetI Am Kayak, Hear Me RoarWill You Be My Lorelai Gilmore?Gilmore Girls OnlyHay Bale MazeIt's Just Like Riding A BikeLorelai? Lorelai?Unto the BreachBon Voyage Cotillion, Planetarium and Fisticuffs are history, and the next round is open! My votes: To Whom It May Concern, I'd Rather Be in Philadelphia, Hay Bale Maze Link to comment
mstaken June 28, 2014 Author Share June 28, 2014 Heh---Whoopee and Santa's Secret Stuff are both among my top four episodes of the season. After this round, we get to do an all-seasons battle among the top five from each of the seven seasons! I think we had a really great idea for what to do after that, but naturally it's already slipped my sieve-like memory... :) Link to comment
AlinaRay June 28, 2014 Share June 28, 2014 I think I remember seeing in another thread about Mama Kim's moments. 1 Link to comment
mstaken June 28, 2014 Author Share June 28, 2014 We could do best moments for a few of the non-main characters: Paris, Sookie, Mama Kim, Kirk, etc.! Link to comment
mstaken June 29, 2014 Author Share June 29, 2014 The Long Morrow is history, but four episodes are vying for the remaining two spots: Whoopee (please don't make me write out the full title!), 'S Wonderful, I'd Rather Be in Philadelphia and Santa's Secret Stuff. Just vote for the two of those four you most want eliminated, and I'll try to end this after three voters. Link to comment
Taryn74 June 29, 2014 Share June 29, 2014 Santa and 'S Wonderful, so we can move on. I'll attack Philly again next round, heh. Link to comment
mstaken June 29, 2014 Author Share June 29, 2014 That's What You Get, Folks, For Makin' WhoopeeKnit People KnitTo Whom It May ConcernI'd Rather Be in PhiladelphiaFarwell, My PetI Am Kayak, Hear Me RoarWill You Be My Lorelai Gilmore?Gilmore Girls OnlyHay Bale MazeIt's Just Like Riding A BikeLorelai? Lorelai?Unto the BreachBon Voyage The next round is now open! We're down to voting against just two :) My votes: I'd Rather Be in Philadelphia and To Whom It May Concern Link to comment
lulu1960 June 30, 2014 Share June 30, 2014 I love that we shorten the titles. Makes me smile. Link to comment
mstaken June 30, 2014 Author Share June 30, 2014 Voters have decided that they would NOT rather be in Philadelphia. We have a four-way tie for that one final spot, but in the interest of moving us along, I'll join Taryn in voting against Gilmore Girls Only, which IMO had potential to be one of the best episodes ever and fell way, way, WAY short :) That's What You Get, Folks, For Makin' WhoopeeKnit People KnitTo Whom It May ConcernFarwell, My PetI Am Kayak, Hear Me RoarWill You Be My Lorelai Gilmore?Hay Bale MazeIt's Just Like Riding A BikeLorelai? Lorelai?Unto the BreachBon Voyage My votes: To Whom It May Concern and Hay Bale Maze Link to comment
lulu1960 June 30, 2014 Share June 30, 2014 Whoopee Kayak (This would have been great if Emily hadn't ruined it for me at the end) Link to comment
mstaken July 1, 2014 Author Share July 1, 2014 (edited) Knit People KnitTo Whom It May ConcernFarewell, My PetWill You Be My Lorelai Gilmore?Hay Bale MazeIt's Just Like Riding A BikeLorelai? Lorelai?Unto the BreachBon Voyage In the interest of avoiding another tiebreaker (and because ITA about the ending being bang-your-head-against-the-wall frustrating), I'll vote against Kayak, so that and my beloved Whoopee are history. We're still voting against two! My votes: To Whom It May Concern and Hay Bale Maze ( I understand why L/L shippers like this one, but the dialogue between them feels so un-them-ish and psychobabble-y! I mean, Luke spouting off about 'compartmentalizing'?! Seriously? And the Logan/Rory stuff is kind of eye rolling too IMO. The whole episode just feels really heavyhanded, Hallmark-y and un-GG-ish to me.) Edited July 1, 2014 by mstaken Link to comment
AlinaRay July 1, 2014 Share July 1, 2014 Hmm... I actually kind of like most of the ones that are left. Farewell To Whom Link to comment
cantbeflapped July 1, 2014 Share July 1, 2014 (edited) I agree about liking the ones that are left. S7 seems to be more likable than S6 by most folks' standards. Farewell To Whom I'm a Luke/Lorelai fan but that doesn't have a ton of influence over which episodes I love (though I'm sure it affects me subconsciously). I've always really liked Hay Bale Maze cuz I think it's fun...Zach, Logan visiting Stars Hollow, Taylor being done in by his dream, the symbolism that some think is too anvilicious. (I have a hard head...less sensitive to anvils than most.) :). I do like Luke and Lorelai's talk. I have some nitpicking about it (which I'm forgetting, need to rewatch) but I buy Luke reflecting and figuring some things out. He has visited the self help section before. :). Edited July 1, 2014 by cantbeflapped Link to comment
mstaken July 2, 2014 Author Share July 2, 2014 Knit People KnitWill You Be My Lorelai Gilmore?Hay Bale MazeIt's Just Like Riding A BikeLorelai? Lorelai?Unto the BreachBon Voyage To Whom It May Concern has been written off by the voters and we've bid farewell to Farewell (which is actually my favorite of the whole season...four of my five favorites, aka the only five episodes I really care about, are already gone!) The next round is open, and this is the last time we're voting against two. My votes: Hay Bale Maze and Lorelai, Lorelai Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.