BK1978

I forgot about Twila.how could she not be on that list. She was a great player who really made that season watchable for me.

Okay I have to admit I laughed my ass off at this comment, probably more than I should but the funny thing is I could see him doing just that. Him peeing in the water with that shit eating grin on his face being such an asshole.

I agree but he was on the show when it was huge. I mean I did not watch the first season when it first aired and I knew who he was. Fans have been wanting him to come back for years now, so if TPTB really can bring him back it would be good for them. I actually really want Crazy Shane, Peih-Gee and Troy to come back. Shane for the entertainment value and Peih-Gee and Troy just because I think they played pretty good games despite the numbers not being in their favor.

I am really shocked to see Kelly Wigglesworth on that list. I remember her doing an interview were she said she was living in Mexico (I think) and she had not watched the show at all. If they get her and Greg from the first season that is a huge coup for them. If they are doing a twenty person cast I would like to see from the current list: Kelly, Peih-Gee, Chelsea, Sabrina, Abi-Maria, Tasha, Kass, Kimmi, Ciera, and Kelley for the women. Greg, Jeff V., Savage, Shane, Troy, Vytas, Spencer, Cliff, Jeremy, and Terry for the men.

I made the comment last week in the episode thread about how there was not anyone in the game that I really disliked. Well Dan changed my mind this week. This guy might call himself a "superfan" but is he really? I mean in a game like Survivor you are going to piss off people if you last long enough. However, one should not go out of their way to intentionally piss off a potential jury member for no reason. What he did to Shirin was just plain dumb.

You know for the first time in...well hell I think ever I do not outright dislike any of the castaways. Sure Rodney annoys me a bit but not that much and I thought Will made a really dumb move (If the Idol had not been played the move would have worked for him but as I said in his thread I really wish he would have stuck by the people who kept him in the game) but all in all there is not one person that I dislike and that is a good thing.

I felt the same way and was coming in to post that. I like Will but that was just a dumb move to make. Granted had Jenn not played the Idol that would have been a decent move but I still wish he would have stuck by the people that brought him to the dance.

Same here, I have always liked how Wes has played the game. Now maybe it is just the Big Brother fan in me (And I did not watch any of the battle of the exiles) but does anyone think that the Battle of the Exile challenges could have been rigged in favor of Johnny so that he would return? They do it all of the time on Big Brother, where they have challenges that favor certain people so I was wondering if that was the case here.

I was actually coming in here to ask the same question. That cannot be a real last name...can it? I have yet to come across anyone who has defended him but there are always some folks who will stand up for people that do wrong things. The racist chick from Big Brother had her defenders so reading you say that there are people that are defending him does not shock me.

Just wanted to jump in on the selfie hate. TAR always seemed above gimmickry to me for the most part. However, they are really over doing with this crap this season.

Based on the first half of the show I thought for sure they would be the first team to go. I thought the editing was leaning that way but I guess it was not.

Carolyn sort of reminds me of a well spoken Sue Hawke. I am not sure why that is the case but that was the vibe I got off her when watching the show. I was thinking the same thing myself. Granted it will probably not happen but they just do not seem to be a tribe that has their crap together. However, once they are split up they will be of value to their new teams. I was thinking the same thing he is Coach 2.0. Coach also wore feathers in his hair if I remember correctly.

Bam, Bazooka Joe will just pop into my mind every so often as well. I really do not remember much about this season, I was actually confusing it with Key West for some odd reason, but the one thing I will always remember is the Bazooka Joe comment and Frankie's fear of boats. Oh and how hot I thought Jamie and Cameran were.

I still do not get how a Law Student could be put on the "No Collar" Tribe. Why is that the case, is it due to her age?

I am in the same boat. I watched Portland so I have only missed one season but prior to Portland the last season I saw was Brooklyn. So there was a bit of a gap there. I do not remember them breaking the fourth wall during Portland so I am guessing it happened during the Ex-Plosion season. I am not a big fan of how they shoot the show now and I hate hearing the producer's questions but I guess after being on the air for so long they have to do new things in order to appeal to a younger audience. Now I freely admit that the violence does draw me into the show. The reason why I watched Portland was because of the whole Jordan/Nia/Johnny/Averey thing. Granted I do not think they should allow violence but it draws eyes to the show and so that is why I think they are not going to do much about it. Heck look at the other show BMP produces, Bad Girls Club that show is all about the catfights and violence and security takes it sweet time breaking up the fights on that show.

I liked the fact that they seemed to cast older (Or older in regards to recent years of the show) contestants this season.

Yeah the guy just looks like a dick. He sort of looks like Fabio (Not Survivor Fabio, I am talking about the original Fabio).

I agree with this... and this... I have been saying this for years that she is an overrated winner and that had there been a final three I think Cirie should have won. Granted I have not watched the season since it aired so my memory of it might not be that great but I also thought that Amanda played pretty well and probably should have had a better shot at winning had she been able to deal with the jury better.

I have to agree that Murder House in my opinion was the best as well. Plus when I was watching it I was shocked with how they killed off the main characters because at the time I had no clue that it was an anthology series. So I was like, "Why did they kill off Dylan McDermott, he is the star of the show." I did not really like Asylum all that much, I felt that it was the weakest out of the four seasons. I actually liked Coven and FreakShow is what it is, it is decent but nothing great. With all of the seasons tied in together, I wonder how Murder House fits with the other three shows.

I am glad the way this season turned out. I was not expecting them to win but I was happy that they did. Honestly this is the first season in a very long time where there was not one team that I truly disliked in the final four. I really would not have been bothered by any of them winning. Granted Brooke annoyed me a little with her constant complaining and I found Jim to be very cocky but I did not have an intense dislike of them.

Remind me to never watch a Blood vs. Water season ever again. It seems that people I despise always win first Tyson now Natalie. To me her win ranks up there with Evil Dick winning Big Brother (Granted she was nowhere near a bad as Dick but she and her sisters are still thieves who willingly stole from people and then gloated about it and I can never respect someone like that.). A crappy winner for a crappy season I suppose.

What the heck is up with that? Now I did not watch the last Real World season (I tried but after watching the first episode, I realized that it was not something I could sit through. It came across as being a poor man's Big Brother. The last one I watched in full was Portland) but at least they were on an actual Real World season. Heck even people that came off the Fresh Meat seasons might have not been on an actual RW/RR season but they were on an actual Challenge so I was cool with that. But now they are putting people from an entirely different show on here that has no actual ties to the Real World or Road Rules (Well RR has been gone for such a long time now but you get what I am saying), I just don't get it. Hell I have no idea what the heck Are You The One? is. Is that even produced by Bunim/Murray? If they are looking for people from other Bunim/Murray shows, why not cast some of the chicks from The Bad Girls Club?

Why do I have a feeling this is all leading to a Natalie win? Which sucks because besides Missy, she is the person I least want to see win. Oh well I guess it would be the cherry on top of a very bad season.

I think Missy threw the challenge to Baylor both times. It just did not seem to me that Missy put that much effort into that challenge.

I was shocked seeing Jeremy go but I was happy because I hope this means the end of Natalie as well. Missy really irks me for some reason, I can't really put my finger on why but she does.