TVForever

I think he was just exhausted and spinning out at that point. And there was likely some survivor's guilt from the fact that she was at the concert with Robby's ticket/in Robby's place (I can't remember the exact reason he wasn't able to go himself-I'm guessing work). Talk about, "There but for the grace of God go I"... You know, it wasn't until Robby's final breakdown that I was reminded that everything we've seen this season (his flashbacks as he was losing it) has all been in the course of ONE DAY. It's a wonder the whole ED team isn't losing it at this point.

Same here. It feels almost like torture porn at this point. Loving her character. I hope we get to see more of her. Good call. And we still don't know which Dutton wife is John's (Kevin Costner) grandmother yet, do we? Elizabeth has recently lost her baby, and Alex is currently pregnant, but things could change so quickly. Agreed on that. I remember the scene with Spencer on the train with the hobos. I thought the dialogue and directing/acting choices of the little girl was a brilliant way to convey that that she had seen and done waaay too many awful things.

Am I supposed to be feeling bad for Hina? Because... What part of anything Kainalu said wasn't valid? She had great fun treating him like crap when she (heck, everybody!) knew how he felt about her. She had no problem moving into his apartment for free when she knew how he felt about her. She had no problem sleeping with him and then letting him down hard when she knew how he felt about her. So, he finally(!) gets the hint and moves on with someone who was into him from the beginning. They like each other, they're happy together, everything's great. So of course, Hina decides that he wasn't so bad after all. Life really is about timing. And Hina's is off. She had her chance, and she turned him down. She should back off and let Kainalu be happy. But we know this show. He'll soon decide that he can't live without her either, so poor Rosie will get kicked to the curb. And of course, Show will turn Rosie into some crazy ex-girlfriend to justify it. Sigh...

Same here. I kept flashing back to the early ER episode when mother and baby were lost. The Oldheads among us know what I’m talking about.😢

Yowsa! This episode was DARK! Slashed throats and head shots! Now that we’ve survived the annual “Maddie in mortal danger” story, can we lay off this theme for awhile? Please?

So Finn just waltzes into the jail, demands to see Luna, and announces that he's not leaving without seeing her. Somebody tell him that's not the way jail works...

I am so very bored with Adam and Chelsea. They've been having the same conversation for months. Please stop it. I don't care. And how long will be subjected to Sharon and Phyllis playing Escape Room? How many times has Sharon been kidnapped this year, anyway? isn't her family tired of this by now?

I really love this show. That said, this was a ROUGH episode. It's funny. Every episode, I find myself thinking that this show would have been great as an ER reboot, with a way older and wiser John Carter in the Marc Greene role, moved from Chicago to Pittsburgh. I know Carter had already left Chicago by the end of ER, but still...

Unfortunately, I don't think it's character direction. We all love EB (even if we despise TGVN) but the actor is almost 84 years old. It pains me to see him struggle with his lines, lose his physicality, etc. I know he's had some health issues recently, but it's actually been happening for quite awhile. I remember seeing it happen with John Aniston/Victor Kiriakis and Joe Mascolo/Stefano DiMera over on DOOL. I don't know how Show will do it with Victor Newman's storyline, but it may be time for some kind of stepping back/semi-retirement. I originally thought that Ashland Locke was brought in to become the show's next Big Bad, and Richard Burgi surely fit the mold. His replacement did not, unfortunately, and I wasn't sorry to see that story end. Tucker would have been good too, but he just took a weird turn with his Ashley obsession and then just...disappeared. I've been wondering if Damian is being tested for the spot. The current group of 30/40 somethings just don't cut it. And the Show needs new blood. Holden can be his sidekick, much like Alfred (I think that was his name) was for Victor waaay back in the day.

I like the dress, not necessarily for Claire, but it's the most adult she's been styled in a long time. Ever since the "Claire is Eve" reveal, she's been styled like she just graduated from high school. Victor needs a hobby. Watching him go after "those dahmned Ahbbotts" for the 1837th time cannot be the best the writers could come up with.

The Wardrobe Department's treatment of the women on this show is borderline abusive. Diane escaped that fate for a long time, but it looks like the curse might be catching up to her.

I BEG to disagree. I might be a member of a very small club, but I always found Abby super annoying. Haven't missed her one minute since she left.

And just barely that. Good grief, those two are just a toxic brew. Will is certainly a quirky guy, but Angie is just awful. Kids together? No. Just no.

I'm over Gabi's treatment of everybody. Agree 10000%

I don’t know. I’m all for a female doctor who’s on top of her game, but I HATE HATE HATE the trope of the brilliant doctor who can’t be bothered to be polite to colleagues or patients, and everyone has to bow to her anyway because, she’s BRILLIANT! A doctor is already in the power position over a patient, who, in a clinical setting, is vulnerable ( and very likely afraid). Being an **shole to your patient just feels mean, and frankly, abusive. Same thing with the relationship between senior and junior doctors. There’s a way to be the smartest person in the room and respect the humanity of the person you’re speaking to. It’s why I eventually stopped watching House. Watching someone be that mean for kicks just got to be too much. I want to like this show, but I think I may be a little gun-shy of the “brilliant-but-awful” thing. I’m in for now. Hopefully I last the season.