Jump to content

Type keyword(s) to search
Log-in Changes With Upcoming Upgrade - Update

Gilmore Girls Elimination Game

mstaken

By mstaken
in Gilmore Girls

  • Reply
  • Start Topic

Recommended Posts

mstaken

mstaken

  • Author
I always think I'm ambivalent about Logan until I realize how many S5 episodes he ruined for me!

Amen, sister friend!

 

Kropogs and But I'm a Gilmore! are gone (editorial note: Good riddance!!!), but we have a tie for that final spot between Diorama and Blame Booze and Melville. 

 

My tiebreaker vote: Blame Booze and Melville (though I'm more than fine with either episode getting the boot!)

  • Replies 11.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Taryn74

    2151

  • lulu1960

    1948

  • Kohola3

    1531

  • ghoulina

    1376

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Popular Posts

amensisterfriend
amensisterfriend

I love Rory's speech, but I think I'll vote against 20. One of the things that makes GG so special to me is how much poignancy they can wring from really subtle, understated moments. Rory's sweet and

lulu1960
lulu1960

Well if there are no more votes with a score of 6 to 4  Jess squeaks past Emily. #45 wins. Although both are winners in my book

Taryn74
Taryn74

My entire life is a lie.

Posted Images

mstaken

mstaken

  • Author
(edited)

Say Goodbye to Daisy Miller
A Messenger, Nothing More
Written in the Stars
Tippecanoe and Taylor, Too
We Got Us a Pippi Virgin
Norman Mailer, I'm Pregnant
You Jump, I Jump, Jack
The Party's Over
Emily Says Hello
But Not as Cute as Pushkin
Women of Questionable Morals
Come Home
Wedding Bell Blues
Say Something
Jews and Chinese Food
So...Good Talk
Pulp Friction
To Live and Let Diorama
A House is Not a Home

 

Melville is history as well, and the next round is open! 

 

My votes: 

 

Diorama

You Jump, I Jump, Jack

The Parrty's Over (Drunken, tiara-clad Rory fawned over by a horde of frat boy admirers before she and Dean finally endure yet another awkward breakup and somehow Rory again ends up depicted as the victim here, Liz and TJ even more infuriating than usual...ugh!)  

Edited by mstaken
  • Love 1
mstaken

mstaken

  • Author

Thanks to our regulars for voting so quickly...you've done your civic duty :) 

 

Norman Mailer, Diorama and You Jump, I Jump, Jack are history, and the bext round is open! 

 

Say Goodbye to Daisy Miller
A Messenger, Nothing More
Written in the Stars
Tippecanoe and Taylor, Too
We Got Us a Pippi Virgin
The Party's Over
Emily Says Hello
But Not as Cute as Pushkin
Women of Questionable Morals
Come Home
Wedding Bell Blues
Say Something
Jews and Chinese Food
So...Good Talk
Pulp Friction
A House is Not a Home

 

My votes: The Party's Over, Pulp Friction and A House is Not a Home

AlinaRay

AlinaRay

Pippi Virgin

Pushkin

Pulp Friction

 

Mstaken, The reason I dislike it is because I can't stand the girl that they send to Rory...she is nothing like a "young" Rory, and I feel like any student seriously considering an Ivy League school, that goes to Chilton, wouldn't act that way. Plus, Rory is just about the worst tour guide ever. And I find it hard to believe that in the 7 (or more) years that Lorelai has known Luke, she has no idea of his "dark day"

mstaken

mstaken

  • Author
nd I find it hard to believe that in the 7 (or more) years that Lorelai has known Luke, she has no idea of his "dark day"

 

Heh---I'm definitely with you on rolling my eyes that the only person who Luke is close to is the only person in the whole freaking town not to know about this annual tradition of his. Even the idea of a designated, melodramatic Dark Day is a little out-of-character and contrived IMO. I guess I'm just used to handwaving a lot of that stuff, because logic and realism aren't exactly GG's greatest strengths ;) 

mstaken

mstaken

  • Author
House (Damn you, G'rents)
Wedding (Damn you, Christopher)
The Party's Over (Damn you, TJ)

 

Hee! I'll happily 'damn' a lot of people in WBB. Even as someone who generally enjoys Christopher, I find him utterly infuriating here, but Luke behaves ridiculously IMO (don't get me started!), Rory is weirdly out of character as well, Emily and Richard are...well, Emily and Richard. Suffice it to say that while I love a few scenes from WBB too much to have voted for it quite yet, it's definitely an episode that's depicts most of our characters in a deeply unflattering way!

nolieblue

nolieblue

Pulp Friction (too many annoying Yale males)

Tippecanoe

So Good Talk

 

I dislike almost all of the actual wedding (or rather, vow renewal) in WBB but everything else was pretty awesome (Morton Salt boots! Cop Rock, the shower) so I also just try to ignore the crappy wedding stuff, including Lorelai's tacky prom, er, bridesmaid, dress). 

  • Love 1
mstaken

mstaken

  • Author

Say Goodbye to Daisy Miller
A Messenger, Nothing More
Written in the Stars
Tippecanoe and Taylor, Too
We Got Us a Pippi Virgin
Emily Says Hello
But Not as Cute as Pushkin
Women of Questionable Morals
Come Home
Wedding Bell Blues
Say Something
Jews and Chinese Food
So...Good Talk

A House Is Not A Home, Pulp Friction and The Party's Over are history, and the next round is open. We can switch to voting against just two :)

 

My votes: Pippi Virgin and Jews and Chinese Food 

mstaken

mstaken

  • Author

Say Goodbye to Daisy Miller
A Messenger, Nothing More
Written in the Stars
Emily Says Hello
But Not as Cute as Pushkin
Women of Questionable Morals
Come Home
Wedding Bell Blues
Say Something
Jews and Chinese Food
So...Good Talk

 

Pippi and Taylor are history, and the next round is open! Lulu, these games often inspire me to rewatch favorite scenes and episodes as well. 

 

My votes: Jews and Chinese Food and...hmmm...WBB. As we've chatted about above, WBB has some scenes that I really adore, but it also has a bunch of stuff that leaves me deeply annoyed with nearly every freaking character!  

mstaken

mstaken

  • Author

Say Goodbye to Daisy Miller
Written in the Stars
But Not as Cute as Pushkin
Women of Questionable Morals
Come Home
 

 

Say Something and Emily Says Hello (there's a lot of "saying" this season!) are gone, and the next round is open! We're down to voting against just one :)

 

My vote: Say Goodbye to Daisy Miller (yet more "saying!")

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...