mstaken May 30, 2014 Author Share May 30, 2014 Balllrooms and BiscottiThe Lorelais' First Day at YaleChicken or BeefThe Fundamental Things ApplyThe Festival of Living ArtThe Incredible S(hr)inking LorelaisScene in a MallThe Reigning LorelaiLuke Can See Her FaceLast Week Fights, This Week TightsRaincoats and Recipes An Affair to Remember and Nag are gone, and the next round is open! My votes: Last Week Fights and The Incredible S(hr)inking Lorelais Link to comment
nolieblue May 30, 2014 Share May 30, 2014 Chicken or Beef (I hate the Taylor/Lorelai story line) Festival of Living Art Link to comment
Taryn74 May 30, 2014 Share May 30, 2014 CoB and TISL (but I LOVE the Gran/Jason stuff beyond the telling of it) Link to comment
cantbeflapped May 30, 2014 Share May 30, 2014 Festival of Living Art Fundamental I remember that Chicken or Beef was one of my top five favorite episodes of the whole series. But it s been so long since I re watched, I can't remember all the reasons why. But the mention of Taylor/Lorelai reminded me that I do love her "twisting the mustache" rant...lol. I think four of my top 5 are probable from S4...Tights, Raincoats, and Ballrooms being the other 3). Nick and Nora from S2 is probably the fifth. Link to comment
mstaken May 31, 2014 Author Share May 31, 2014 Oh, dear, we have a five-way tie for those two spots! I'll leave this open for a bit in hopes that another voter comes along to help break the massive tie :) Link to comment
mstaken June 1, 2014 Author Share June 1, 2014 In the interest of moving us along, I'll change my votes to CoB and FoLA, which means that they're now eliminated. Initially I was really reluctant to eliminate CoB, but then you guys reminded me of Taylor being even more insufferable than usual and I recalled the irksomeness of DrunkDean...and suddenly eliminating this one didn't seem nearly as painful :) Balllrooms and BiscottiThe Lorelais' First Day at YaleThe Fundamental Things ApplyThe Incredible S(hr)inking LorelaisScene in a MallThe Reigning LorelaiLuke Can See Her FaceLast Week Fights, This Week TightsRaincoats and Recipes The next round is open! This is the last time we're voting against two. My votes: TISL and LWF, TWT Link to comment
mstaken June 2, 2014 Author Share June 2, 2014 TISL is gone, but we have a tie for that second elimination spot between Scene in a Mall and Last Week Fights. You know the drill! My tiebreaker vote: LWF, TWT Link to comment
cantbeflapped June 2, 2014 Share June 2, 2014 Scene in a Mall ( though I absolutely love it) Link to comment
mstaken June 2, 2014 Author Share June 2, 2014 Balllrooms and BiscottiThe Lorelais' First Day at YaleThe Fundamental Things ApplyThe Reigning LorelaiLuke Can See Her FaceLast Week Fights, This Week TightsRaincoats and Recipes This is the last time we'll vote against two! My votes: The Reigning Lorelai and LWF, TWT Link to comment
nolieblue June 2, 2014 Share June 2, 2014 (edited) The Reigning Lorelai Lorelais' First Day at Yale. This is HARD! Edited June 2, 2014 by nolieblue Link to comment
lulu1960 June 2, 2014 Share June 2, 2014 Ballrooms Fundamentals Very hard, nolie. I think I love something about each and every season four episode. TLFDAY -The mattress banter, Fundamentals- The movie banter, The Reigning Lorelai- Bathrobed Emily and her 'tude Link to comment
mstaken June 3, 2014 Author Share June 3, 2014 The Reigning Lorelai and (*SOB*) The Fundamental Things Apply are history, and the next round is open! We're now down to voting against just one :) Balllrooms and BiscottiThe Lorelais' First Day at YaleLuke Can See Her FaceLast Week Fights, This Week TightsRaincoats and Recipes Heh----I'm pretty sure only one of these episodes is in my own top five! I'll vote against LWF, TWT Link to comment
nolieblue June 3, 2014 Share June 3, 2014 TLFDAY Bye Fundamental, I think I'll miss you most of all. Link to comment
mstaken June 3, 2014 Author Share June 3, 2014 Bye Fundamental, I think I'll miss you most of all. Me too! It's such a "go to", comfort food episode for me. 1 Link to comment
Taryn74 June 3, 2014 Share June 3, 2014 First Day I'll miss Fundamental too, even though I voted for it last round LOL. It's like a big ole' bowl of mac n cheese to me, something to fall back on and enjoy when nothing else sounds good. 1 Link to comment
mstaken June 4, 2014 Author Share June 4, 2014 TLDAY is gone, and the next round is open: Balllrooms and BiscottiLuke Can See Her FaceLast Week Fights, This Week TightsRaincoats and Recipes I actually don't love any of these episodes, but I'll go with LWF, TWT again :) Link to comment
nolieblue June 4, 2014 Share June 4, 2014 (edited) Ballrooms (I LOVE Rory making out with her closet. :) Edited June 4, 2014 by nolieblue Link to comment
mstaken June 5, 2014 Author Share June 5, 2014 (edited) Our Final Three: Luke Can See Her FaceLast Week Fights, This Week TightsRaincoats and Recipes Heh---this is definitely the first time that none of our final three would be in my personal top half of the season! My vote: LWF, TWT Edited June 5, 2014 by mstaken Link to comment
nolieblue June 5, 2014 Share June 5, 2014 LCSHF Another tough one because I love the scene with Lorelai, Michel and Sookie putting the brochures together and then sleeping with the zucchini. 1 Link to comment
mstaken June 6, 2014 Author Share June 6, 2014 Our final two! Last Week Fights, This Week TightsRaincoats and Recipes Link to comment
lulu1960 June 6, 2014 Share June 6, 2014 Raincoats. Although I love both. When I rewatch I always do the trilogy as a package deal. 1 Link to comment
cantbeflapped June 6, 2014 Share June 6, 2014 LWF...Raincoats is my all time favorite epi. Link to comment
mstaken June 7, 2014 Author Share June 7, 2014 Raincoats and Recipes is our S4 winner, and we're on to Season 5! I have odd taste on S4 episodes (none of my favorites made it very far), and be forewarned that I have even odder taste in S5 episodes :) Say Goodbye to Daisy Miller A Messenger, Nothing More Written in the Stars Tippecanoe and Taylor, Too We Got Us a Pippi Virgin Norman Mailer, I'm Pregnant You Jump, I Jump, Jack The Party's Over Emily Says Hello But Not as Cute as Pushkin Women of Questionable Morals Come Home Wedding Bell Blues Say Something Jews and Chinese Food So...Good Talk Pulp Friction To Live and Let Diorama But I'm a Gilmore! How Many Kropogs to Cape Cod? Blame Booze and Melville A House is Not a Home My votes: How Many Kropogs But I'm a Gilmore Blame Booze and Melville ...I'm always surprised all over again by how few episodes from this season I truly love and how many I can't stand! Link to comment
AlinaRay June 7, 2014 Share June 7, 2014 Pippi Virgin You Jump, I Jump But I'm a GIlmore Link to comment
Taryn74 June 7, 2014 Share June 7, 2014 How Many Kropogs But I'm a Gilmore Blame Booze and Melville Link to comment
nolieblue June 7, 2014 Share June 7, 2014 (edited) Kropogs Diorama But I'm a Gilmore I always think I'm ambivalent about Logan until I realize how many S5 episodes he ruined for me! Edited June 7, 2014 by nolieblue 1 Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.