Gilmore Girls Elimination Game

[Taryn74]

7, 13

[lulu1960]

11, 18

[nolieblue]

9 and 18.

[AlinaRay]

2, 8

[mstaken]

9 and 18 are gone, and the next round is open! We're still voting against two:

 

2. Mama Kim and Lorelai find common ground, just wanting their daughters to be safe and happy and to NOT turn out like Lorelai :) (Double Date)
3. Mama Kim vs Emily Gilmore in Kim's antiques (Emily in Wonderland)
4. Mama Kim is determined to pretend that Zach and Brian are girls
6. Mama Kim intimidates even Jess into calling her "m'am" (They Shoot Gilmores)
7. Mama Kim naively notes that Dave Rygalski looked hungry for her eggless egg salad sandwiches (They Shoot Gilmores)
8. Mama Kim bonds with Zach about how Lane looks better with her glasses
10. Mama Kim figures out the band tour. "Oh, please. Prince made fifty-seven million take home last year. He didn’t swear, and he mentioned God. Catch up. Okay, last problem. Transportation." (A House Is Not a Home)
11. Mama Kim tells Lorelai won't go to Lane's baby shower unless some terms are met. "... and there will be no sandboxes or parties with pony rides." (Will You Be My Lorelai Gilmore)
13. Mrs Kim hoses Rory down after learning her house is infested with termites (S&L)
14. After making Zach write a hit song to prove he can provide for Lane, Mrs. Kim gives them her blessing - and a better ring - for marriage (I'm OK, You're OK)
15. Mrs. Kim sadly but firmly tells Lane she must move out if she wants to live by her own rules
16. Mrs. Kim freaks out when she realizes Lane is at the movies with a boy (Double Date)
17. Dave Rygalski reads the entire bible in one night and Mrs. Kim lets him take Lane to prom
 

[lulu1960]

11, 14

[nolieblue]

8, 14

[Taryn74]

7, 13

[mstaken]

Hmmm...I'l go with 11 and 13 

[AlinaRay]

2,8

[nolieblue]

14 and 16

[mstaken]

14 is history, but we have a tie between 8 and 11 for that second elimination spot! 

 

My vote: 11 (I have such a soft spot for 8, in part because it's one of the few times that I actually liked Zach!)

[nolieblue]

8

 

I just love the negotiation scene so much!

[lulu1960]

11

[mstaken]

2. Mama Kim and Lorelai find common ground, just wanting their daughters to be safe and happy and to NOT turn out like Lorelai :) (Double Date)
3. Mama Kim vs Emily Gilmore in Kim's antiques (Emily in Wonderland)
4. Mama Kim is determined to pretend that Zach and Brian are girls
6. Mama Kim intimidates even Jess into calling her "m'am" (They Shoot Gilmores)
7. Mama Kim naively notes that Dave Rygalski looked hungry for her eggless egg salad sandwiches (They Shoot Gilmores)
8. Mama Kim bonds with Zach about how Lane looks better with her glasses
10. Mama Kim figures out the band tour. "Oh, please. Prince made fifty-seven million take home last year. He didn’t swear, and he mentioned God. Catch up. Okay, last problem. Transportation." (A House Is Not a Home)

13. Mrs Kim hoses Rory down after learning her house is infested with termites (S&L)
15. Mrs. Kim sadly but firmly tells Lane she must move out if she wants to live by her own rules
16. Mrs. Kim freaks out when she realizes Lane is at the movies with a boy (Double Date)
17. Dave Rygalski reads the entire bible in one night and Mrs. Kim lets him take Lane to prom

 

The next round is open! We're still voting against two :)

Edited August 16, 2014 by mstaken

[nolieblue]

8 and 16

[lulu1960]

6, 13

[mstaken]

Argh---I love everything that's left! 

 

13 and 16

[Taryn74]

7, 13

[mstaken]

2. Mama Kim and Lorelai find common ground, just wanting their daughters to be safe and happy and to NOT turn out like Lorelai :) (Double Date)
3. Mama Kim vs Emily Gilmore in Kim's antiques (Emily in Wonderland)
4. Mama Kim is determined to pretend that Zach and Brian are girls
6. Mama Kim intimidates even Jess into calling her "m'am" (They Shoot Gilmores)
7. Mama Kim naively notes that Dave Rygalski looked hungry for her eggless egg salad sandwiches (They Shoot Gilmores)
8. Mama Kim bonds with Zach about how Lane looks better with her glasses
10. Mama Kim figures out the band tour. "Oh, please. Prince made fifty-seven million take home last year. He didn’t swear, and he mentioned God. Catch up. Okay, last problem. Transportation." (A House Is Not a Home)
15. Mrs. Kim sadly but firmly tells Lane she must move out if she wants to live by her own rules
17. Dave Rygalski reads the entire bible in one night and Mrs. Kim lets him take Lane to prom

 

13 and 16 are gone, and the next round is open! Just vote for the two you most want eliminated :) 

[lulu1960]

6, 7

[nolieblue]

7, 8

[Kohola3]

7, 8

[mstaken]

6 and 7

[Taryn74]

7, 10

[mstaken]

7 is history, but 6 and 8 are tied for that second spot. You know the drill!

 

My tiebreaker vote: 6

Edited August 18, 2014 by mstaken

[nolieblue]

8

[Taryn74]

6, though I love it.

[mstaken]

2. Mama Kim and Lorelai find common ground, just wanting their daughters to be safe and happy and to NOT turn out like Lorelai :) (Double Date)
3. Mama Kim vs Emily Gilmore in Kim's antiques (Emily in Wonderland)
4. Mama Kim is determined to pretend that Zach and Brian are girls
8. Mama Kim bonds with Zach about how Lane looks better with her glasses
10. Mama Kim figures out the band tour. "Oh, please. Prince made fifty-seven million take home last year. He didn’t swear, and he mentioned God. Catch up. Okay, last problem. Transportation." (A House Is Not a Home)
15. Mrs. Kim sadly but firmly tells Lane she must move out if she wants to live by her own rules
17. Dave Rygalski reads the entire bible in one night and Mrs. Kim lets him take Lane to prom

 

The next round is open! We're still voting against two :) 

[Taryn74]

10, 17

[lulu1960]

8 and 10

[mstaken]

3 (as great as it was, it had the potential to be even better!) and 10

[nolieblue]

2 and 8

[AlinaRay]

I was out of town (vacation in New Orleans!), but I'm back and ready to vote!

 

2,8

[mstaken]

Welcome back, Alina Ray!!!

[mstaken]

2. Mama Kim and Lorelai find common ground, just wanting their daughters to be safe and happy and to NOT turn out like Lorelai :) (Double Date)
3. Mama Kim vs Emily Gilmore in Kim's antiques (Emily in Wonderland)
4. Mama Kim is determined to pretend that Zach and Brian are girls
15. Mrs. Kim sadly but firmly tells Lane she must move out if she wants to live by her own rules
17. Dave Rygalski reads the entire bible in one night and Mrs. Kim lets him take Lane to prom

 

8 and 10 are gone, and the next round is open! We're down to voting against just one...

[AlinaRay]

2

[nolieblue]

2

[Taryn74]

17.  Just not a big fan of Dave Rygalski.  I'll just show myself the door now.....

[mstaken]

3---a great scene that I can't help but think could have been even better :) 

[lulu1960]

2

[mstaken]

3. Mama Kim vs Emily Gilmore in Kim's antiques (Emily in Wonderland)
4. Mama Kim is determined to pretend that Zach and Brian are girls
15. Mrs. Kim sadly but firmly tells Lane she must move out if she wants to live by her own rules
17. Dave Rygalski reads the entire bible in one night and Mrs. Kim lets him take Lane to prom

 

2 is gone (*sob*!), and we're down to just four. My two favorites are gone, but I love the ones that remain. 

 

My vote: 3 

[nolieblue]

15

[Taryn74]

17

[lulu1960]

17

[NichD]

4

[AlinaRay]

15

[mstaken]

I'll change my vote from 3 to 15, which means 15 is history...and we're down to our final three:

 

3. Mama Kim vs Emily Gilmore in Kim's antiques (Emily in Wonderland)
4. Mama Kim is determined to pretend that Zach and Brian are girls
17. Dave Rygalski reads the entire bible in one night and Mrs. Kim lets him take Lane to prom

 

Meanwhile, start thinking of your favorite Luke/Lorelai moments for our next round! There are so many that I'm thinking maybe we should do it one season at a time...?

[nolieblue]

I love 3 but like the others more so 3 it is.

[mstaken]

3 as well :)