amensisterfriend September 6, 2015 Author Share September 6, 2015 And then there were two...: Sucker PunchTick Tick Tick... Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1481945
S55 September 6, 2015 Share September 6, 2015 Sucker Punch Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1482022
KaveDweller September 6, 2015 Share September 6, 2015 Tick Tick Tick... Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1482226
roamyn September 6, 2015 Share September 6, 2015 Sucker Punch Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1482396
turnitwayup September 7, 2015 Share September 7, 2015 Sucker Punch Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1483098
verdana September 7, 2015 Share September 7, 2015 Tick Tick Tick Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1483230
amensisterfriend September 7, 2015 Author Share September 7, 2015 Our triumphant S2 winner: Tick Tick Tick... I'll be back in a minute with the S3 episode list! I actually love most of these to the point where voting them out will be painful :) A Deadly Affair He's Dead, She's Dead Under the Gun Punked Anatomy of a Murder 3Xk Almost Famous Murder Most Fowl Close Encounters of the Murderous Kind Last Call Nikki Heat Poof! You're Dead Knockdown Lucky Stiff The Final Nail Setup Countdown One Life to Lose Law & Murder Slice of Death The Dead Pool To Love and Die in LA Pretty Dead Knockout Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1484337
verdana September 7, 2015 Share September 7, 2015 Yeah season three is going to be tough one but I'm diving in! Almost Famous. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1484418
amensisterfriend September 7, 2015 Author Share September 7, 2015 Ooops, sorry, we're at the point where we're voting against three! I should have specified :) Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1484558
roamyn September 7, 2015 Share September 7, 2015 Nikki Heat The Dead Pool Pretty Dead Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1484712
KaveDweller September 7, 2015 Share September 7, 2015 Almost FamousLaw and MurderPretty Dead Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1484741
S55 September 8, 2015 Share September 8, 2015 Murder Most Fowl Last Call Law & Murder Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1485089
turnitwayup September 8, 2015 Share September 8, 2015 Murder Most Fowl Law & MurderPretty Dead Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1485237
verdana September 8, 2015 Share September 8, 2015 Okay here's my other two: Murder Most Fowl Pretty Dead Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1486402
amensisterfriend September 9, 2015 Author Share September 9, 2015 A Deadly AffairHe's Dead, She's DeadUnder the GunPunkedAnatomy of a Murder3XkAlmost FamousClose Encounters of the Murderous KindLast CallNikki HeatPoof! You're DeadKnockdownLucky StiffThe Final NailSetupCountdownOne Life to LoseSlice of DeathThe Dead PoolTo Love and Die in LAKnockout Pretty Dead, Murder Most Fowl and Law & Murder are history, and the next round is open! We're still voting against three :) Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1489323
amensisterfriend September 9, 2015 Author Share September 9, 2015 Here's a fun question about past episodes to take a break from worrying about future ones: If you could keep just FIVE episodes of the whole series to rewatch over and over, which would you pick? Yes, I know narrowing it down to just five is nearly impossible...I'm cruel that way :) Also, which of the season premieres were your favorites and least favorites so far? Favorite and least favorite season finales? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1489389
turnitwayup September 9, 2015 Share September 9, 2015 He's Dead, She's Dead Almost Famous The Dead Pool Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1489451
roamyn September 9, 2015 Share September 9, 2015 The Dead Pool Almost Famous A Deadly Affair (I changed my mind abt Nikki Heat. I think it's okay . Not great, but not horrible either.) Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1489532
verdana September 9, 2015 Share September 9, 2015 Almost Famous Close Encounters of the Murderous Kind Slice of Death Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1489608
betsyboo September 9, 2015 Share September 9, 2015 Lucky Stiff Close Encounters of the Murderous Kind Punked Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1490004
S55 September 9, 2015 Share September 9, 2015 Last Call Punked Almost Famous Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1490598
KaveDweller September 9, 2015 Share September 9, 2015 Almost FamousAnatomy of a MurderThe Dead Pool Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1490694
KaveDweller September 9, 2015 Share September 9, 2015 Only five episodes? Wow, that's just mean. I guess I'd pick Flowers for Her Grave, Knockdown, The Lives of Others, Time of Our Lives, and Still. Still because it has clips of the best parts of lots of episodes. My favorite season premiere is After the Storm, and favorite finale is Always. My least favorite premiere is season 2 (I can't remember the name). My least favorite final is For Better or Worse. 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1490738
roamyn September 9, 2015 Share September 9, 2015 Wow, only 5 in 7 seasons?! I'm going with 'Flowers for her Grave', 'Hunt', 'Time of Their Lives', 'Under Fire', 'Vampire', and just for the hell of it 'That 70s Show', because I'm a massive Starsky & Hutch fan. 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1490789
amensisterfriend September 9, 2015 Author Share September 9, 2015 And here I thought I was goinng to be alone in picking Flowers for her Grave, still one of the very best and most rewatchable episodes! Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1490844
WendyCR72 September 9, 2015 Share September 9, 2015 I don't want to be that person, but I'll be that person. :-P The episode title is actually "Flowers For Your Grave". :-) Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1490884
S55 September 10, 2015 Share September 10, 2015 The first five favorites I think of are: A Chill Goes Through Her Veins, The Mistress Always Spanks Twice, To Love and Die in L.A., Cops & Robbers and The Final Frontier. My favorite premiere is A Deadly Affair and my favorite finale is Always. 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1491181
verdana September 10, 2015 Share September 10, 2015 Five episodes to keep watching - Cops and Robbers, Still, The Final Nail, A Chill Goes Through Her Veins, Sucker Punch. Best season premieres - the pilot and S5 wasn't bad either. Least favourites - Watershed and FBFW both are equally terrible for different reasons. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1492017
amensisterfriend September 10, 2015 Author Share September 10, 2015 (edited) I know this is a bizarre choice, but I find The Final Frontier endlessly rewatchable for a bunch of reasons---to the point where, while it's not among the 5-10 I'd objectively consider the 'best', it may well be on the list of 5-10 episodes that I'd bring with me to my imaginary island :) And while we're throwing a little love S5's way, ITA with Still and The Lives of Others as series highlights and that After the Storm is second only to Flowers for Your Grave on my rankings of favorite seaosn premieres :) Favorite to least favorite two-parters??? And I know this is confusing now (I don't quite understand why favorite episodes have to be discussed in the same thread as where a game is being played, but I won't question the wisdom of the mods!), but we ARE still playing the episode elim game here, and I'll be back to end this current round and start the new one in the very near future! Edited September 10, 2015 by amensisterfriend Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1492259
roamyn September 10, 2015 Share September 10, 2015 Favorite to least favorite 2-parters: Target/Hunt Tick..tick..tick../Boom Valykrie/Dreamworld Setup/Countdown If there are any others, I haven't seen them (I think there's one more). But Setup/Countdown will ALWAYS be last on my list. 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1492484
amensisterfriend September 10, 2015 Author Share September 10, 2015 ****Almost Famous and The Dead Pool are history, but we have a tie between Punked and Close Encounters of the Murderous Kind for that third elimination spot. Just vote for the ONE of those two you most want eliminated, and I'll end this after three votes! Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1493180
turnitwayup September 10, 2015 Share September 10, 2015 Punked Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1493641
roamyn September 10, 2015 Share September 10, 2015 I don't think I've seen 'Punked', so I'll vote 'Close Encounters'. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1493651
S55 September 10, 2015 Share September 10, 2015 (edited) Hmmm...that's harder, but if you twisted my arm: Tick, Tick, Tick.../Boom! (wish they had left the deleted Beckett/Alexis scene in Boom!) Setup/Countdown Pandora/Linchpin (also featuring a deleted scene between Castle/Beckett I really wish they would've left in) Valkyrie/Dreamworld Resurrection/Reckoning Target/Hunt ****Almost Famous and The Dead Pool are history, but we have a tie between Punked and Close Encounters of the Murderous Kind for that third elimination spot. Just vote for the ONE of those two you most want eliminated, and I'll end this after three votes! Punked Edited September 10, 2015 by S55 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1493679
amensisterfriend September 10, 2015 Author Share September 10, 2015 (edited) A Deadly AffairHe's Dead, She's DeadUnder the GunAnatomy of a Murder3XkClose Encounters of the Murderous KindLast CallNikki HeatPoof! You're DeadKnockdownLucky StiffThe Final NailSetupCountdownOne Life to LoseSlice of DeathTo Love and Die in LAKnockout Is it bad that I was happy to keep Close Encounters of a Murderous Kind for at least one more round in large part because the title of the episode amuses me?! The next round is open, and we're still voting against THREE :) Edited September 10, 2015 by amensisterfriend Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1493690
S55 September 10, 2015 Share September 10, 2015 He's Dead, She's Dead 3XK Last Call Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1493710
roamyn September 10, 2015 Share September 10, 2015 He's Dead, She's Dead 3XK Last Call 3XK??!! That's a GREAT episode with a great villain. :-( Mine for this round: A Deadly Affair Set Up Nikki Heat Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1494018
turnitwayup September 10, 2015 Share September 10, 2015 He's Dead, She's Dead Setup Slice of Death Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1494156
KaveDweller September 11, 2015 Share September 11, 2015 Anatomy of a Murder Lucky Stiff Last Call Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1494931
verdana September 11, 2015 Share September 11, 2015 Close Encounters of the Murderous Kind Slice of Death Anatomy of a Murder Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1496167
Brit Babe September 11, 2015 Share September 11, 2015 Anatomy of a MurderClose Encounters of the Murderous KindSlice of Death Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1497063
roamyn September 12, 2015 Share September 12, 2015 Favorite to least favorite 2-parters: Target/Hunt Tick..tick..tick../Boom Valykrie/Dreamworld Setup/Countdown If there are any others, I haven't seen them (I think there's one more). But Setup/Countdown will ALWAYS be last on my list. Okay, I just saw Pandora / Lynchpin and was blown.away. Almost as much as all the revelations in Target / Hunt. So I'm revising my list of 2 parters: Target / Hunt Pandora / Lynchpin Tick...tick...tick / Boom Valkrie / Dreamworld Setup / Countdown Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1497912
amensisterfriend September 12, 2015 Author Share September 12, 2015 A Deadly AffairHe's Dead, She's DeadUnder the Gun3XkClose Encounters of the Murderous KindLast CallNikki HeatPoof! You're DeadKnockdownLucky StiffThe Final NailCountdownOne Life to LoseTo Love and Die in LAKnockout I'll vote against Setup, Slice of Death and Anatomy of a Murder as well, and those episodes are now history! The next round is open, and we can shift to voting against just TWO :) Meanwhile, weekend poll: In which season do you most love Kate Beckett overall? In which season do you most love Rick Castle overall? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1497932
S55 September 12, 2015 Share September 12, 2015 He's Dead, She's Dead Last Call I liked Beckett the most in season 1 and probably Castle in season 2. 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1498010
KaveDweller September 12, 2015 Share September 12, 2015 Last Call Lucky Stiff Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1498222
roamyn September 12, 2015 Share September 12, 2015 Countdown A Deadly Affair I liked them both best in S5. 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1498257
turnitwayup September 12, 2015 Share September 12, 2015 He's Dead, She's Dead Countdown Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1498305
verdana September 12, 2015 Share September 12, 2015 Close Encounters of the Murderous Kind Countdown Beckett in S1 she much more relatable to me back then and for Castle S2 and parts of S5. 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1498893
Brit Babe September 13, 2015 Share September 13, 2015 Close Encounters of the Murderous KindLucky Stiff I liked Beckett in season 1 the best and Castle on season 1 & 2. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1500735
amensisterfriend September 13, 2015 Author Share September 13, 2015 A Deadly AffairHe's Dead, She's DeadUnder the Gun3XkClose Encounters of the Murderous KindLast CallNikki HeatPoof! You're DeadKnockdownThe Final NailOne Life to LoseTo Love and Die in LAKnockout I'll vote against Countdown and Lucky Stiff---which, by the way, are also our newly eliminated episodes :) The next round is open, and we're still voting against two! Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/30370-castle-game-thread-eliminations-and-more/page/4/#findComment-1500940
Recommended Posts