Jump to content

Type keyword(s) to search

Supernatural Survival Game


mstaken
  • Reply
  • Start Topic

Recommended Posts

As has happened entirely too often in the later seasons, we were given a character with tons of potential, only to have him taken away for the sake of drama.  IMO, of course.  I did not love Benny, mainly because his presence made Sam act so stupidly, but had they written the entire situation better, he could have been a great long-term addition to the show.  Alas, it was not to be.

 

But at least I can send him to the place he's most comfortable.

 

Death +

Tessa --

Benny -

 

17 - Death
04 - Tessa
 

Slicing and Dicing in Purgatory Baby!
Eve
Edgar
Rowena
Alpha Vampire
Dr. Eleanor Visyak
Gordon Walker
Dick Roman

Benny

  • Love 1

Oh, Benny...like most bears, cute you were, but not so cuddly. I loved you in Purgatory, but just didn't see what all the fuss was about once you were out--especially since you seemed to only serve the contrived conflict quota. You should team up with Rowena and Dr. Visyak and cut your own path through Purgatory now.

 

-- Death
-- Tessa

 

15 - Death
02 - Tessa
 

Slicing and Dicing in Purgatory Baby!
Eve
Edgar
Rowena
Alpha Vampire
Dr. Eleanor Visyak
Gordon Walker
Dick Roman

Benny

Edited by DittyDotDot
  • Love 1

Death was always going to win in the end. Death always wins. We can't beat Death.

 

Bye Tessa. Others can eulogize her. I really only liked her in the first episode and a little bit in her 2nd appearance. Her demise made zero sense to me because I reject that shift of reapers into being a type of angel instead of their own thing.  

Benny was great. I shipped Denny hard and I'm happy we met him at all.

 

-- Tessa

 

15 - Death

 

Slicing and Dicing in Purgatory Baby!

Eve

Edgar

Rowena

Alpha Vampire

Dr. Eleanor Visyak

Gordon Walker

Dick Roman

Benny

Tessa

Edited by catrox14
  • Love 2

Since I'm in the process of buying a house, I can't guarantee I'll be around later to post this list, but I assume we'll start voting on it later today.  This is the Human master list -- no separation, since we never agreed on a way to equally distribute them.  22 characters, so as someone else pointed out, no longer than a season episode list.

 

I would not be surprised if this carried us to the end of the season.  Some are cannon fodder, but I foresee some back and forth on others.  Alas, I have to wait until tomorrow to vote.  ;-)

 

15 - Kevin
15 - Lisa
15 - Ben
15 - Jody
15 - Chuck
15 - Amelia
15 - Bela
15 - Charlie
15 - Jessica
15 - Ed
15 - Harry
15 - Pamela
15 - Adam
15 - Frank
15 - Henricksen
15 - Cole 
15 - Henry 
15 - Becky
15 - Mrs. Tran
15 - Karen Singer
15 - Claire

 

Double-checking my work and Ronald was only in two episodes.  :-(

Man...RONALD ! NOOO. He was awesome.  I know our rule was 3 episodes...but damn, so many great human characters that were in 2 episodes or less that I still think about..like Ronald and Sheriff Donna! Maybe we can have another round of just those that were in 2 episodes or less? ....One shot wonders so to speak?

 

Ronald

Amy Acker and her son

Jesse

Linda Blair

Sheriff Donna

Sheriff in the Benders

Dorothy

I'll go with the majority, but for me, that list would be way too long.  

 

How about, after this round, we break it down by season?  Limit it to one character per episode, so we'd only be voting for the same number of characters as we do episodes?  So, best One-Offs Per Season?  (Some characters who have been in 2 episodes, like Ronald, would only be included for their first episode, fair?)

 

Since I love lists so very much, I'll make up a list for the first season, then if everyone agrees, we can do that one after this round.  As we're nearing the end of that round, I'll post my season 2 list, and so on and so forth.

 

Unless, of course, no one likes the idea and wants to do something else.  ;-)

 

Edited for clarity.

Edited by Demented Daisy

++ Henry Winchester
-- Amelia
-- Becky

 

21 - Henricksen
21 - Jody

21 - Kevin

19 - Pamela

19 - Bela
19 - Mrs. Tran

17 - Chuck

15 - Lisa

15 - Jessica
15 - Ed
15 - Harry
15 - Karen Singer
15 - Frank
15 - Henry Winchester
13 - Adam
13 - Charlie
13 - Claire
13 - Ben
05 - Cole
01 - Amelia

 

Writer’s Cannon Fodder

 Becky

 

Feel free to come up with a better title I really wanted Amelia gone first but alas it was not to be.  

 

Ah sweet Becky how I liked you at first but the writer's really took you too far when you married poor Sam and for that you have to go.

Edited by 7kstar

I'll gladly kill off Amelia (#sorrynotsorry). Someone else may want to give her a eulogy, but it won't be me. Too much time was wasted on her mostly meaningless story already, in my opinion. Sam deserved better.

 

-- Amelia

-- Henry Winchester

++ Chuck

 

 

23 - Henricksen
21 - Jody

21 - Kevin

19 - Pamela

19 - Bela
19 - Mrs. Tran

19 - Chuck

15 - Lisa

15 - Jessica
15 - Ed
15 - Harry
15 - Karen Singer
15 - Frank
13 - Henry Winchester
13 - Adam
13 - Charlie
13 - Ben
11 - Claire

03 - Cole
 

Writer’s Cannon Fodder

Becky

Amelia

Henricksen -- (I like him, just can't let him get too far ahead.)

Ben --

Cole - (If someone wants to, they can eulogize.  I got nothing.)

 

21 - Henricksen
21 - Jody
21 - Kevin
19 - Pamela
19 - Bela
19 - Mrs. Tran
19 - Chuck
15 - Lisa
15 - Jessica
15 - Ed
15 - Harry
15 - Karen Singer
15 - Frank
13 - Adam
13 - Charlie
11 - Ben
11 - Henry Winchester
09 - Claire


Writer’s Cannon Fodder
Becky
Amelia

Cole

++Henriksen

--Charlie

--Lisa

 

23 - Henricksen

21 - Jody

21 - Kevin

19 - Pamela

19 - Bela

19 - Mrs. Tran

19 - Chuck

15 - Lisa

15 - Jessica

15 - Ed

15 - Harry

15 - Karen Singer

15 - Frank

13 - Charlie

13 - Henry Winchester

13 - Adam

11 - Ben

09 - Claire

 

Writer’s Cannon Fodder

Becky

Amelia

Cole

I can't eulogize Cole. I might have if they would have not ever filmed 'The Things They Carried'.  Cole is a victim of IMO they are trying to WAY TO HARD to make FETCH happen.  It's not going to happen.  I didn't hate Cole until the episode wherein they tried to hard to make him happen. RIP Cole. Don't come back.

I'll post a few eulogies:

 

Becky: I'm sorry for your character assassination in the Wedding episode.  You were goofy and over the top before, but that episode was beneath any fan-representative.  I'm going to pretend that you were somehow roofied too.  I do want to thank you for publishing Carver's unpublished works.  It's tough on the boys but good for people like Charlie.  But it's been 3 years now, so it's time to let this particular fandom go.  Can I interest you in Buffy???

 

Amelia...I think the limes made you a bit sour.  But you got a bad deal.  I'm pissed Sam did not break things off with you cleanly. You deserved better than that.  And I'll even forgive you for sleeping with Sam while being married because...damn, he's good looking and you two seemed to be in synch as "troubled souls".  But I think it's best for everyone if you just settled back into you vet job with your husband and keep the memory of Sam warm in your heart.

 

Cole...Dude.  Walk away.  Seriously, you've had enough trauma. Stay away from this freaky shit and take care of your family.  Sam and Dean have this covered.  And eventually Dean is going to pull you up by the short-hairs if you keep calling Sam "Sammy".  So, now is the time for a retreat.  Glad you didn't have to be beheaded due to Khan Worm, but stick to the civilian life now.  

 

 

-- Harry
-- Ed
++ Frank

25 - Henricksen
21 - Jody
21 - Kevin
19 - Pamela
19 - Bela
19 - Mrs. Tran
17 - Chuck

17 - Frank

15 - Lisa
15 - Jessica
13 - Ed
13 - Harry
13 - Karen Singer
13 - Charlie
13 - Adam
11 - Henry Winchester
11 - Ben
09 - Claire

Writer’s Cannon Fodder
Becky
Amelia
Cole

  • Love 1

Hey guys -- it's been a while. ;-)

(Work last week did a number on my voting schedule.)

 

++Henriksen
++ Jody
++ Frank (for fun)

27 - Henriksen
25 - Jody
23 - Kevin
19 - Pamela
19 - Bela
19 - Mrs. Tran

19 - Frank

17 - Chuck
15 - Jessica
13 - Ed
13 - Lisa
13 - Harry
13 - Karen Singer
13 - Charlie
13 - Adam
09 - Henry Winchester
07 - Ben
07 - Claire

Writer’s Cannon Fodder
Becky
Amelia
Cole

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...