Supernatural Survival Game

[amensisterfriend]

Clap +

Appointment +

Frontierland --

 

31 - Appointment in Samarra

30 - Weekend at Bobby's

29- Frontierland
27 - The Man Who Would Be King
26 - The French Mistake
21 - Mommy Dearest
20 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
15 - Live Free or Twihard
14 - Clap Your Hands If You Believe
06 - My Heart Will Go On

[Iguana]

For posterity's sake (or possibly posterior's sake - both boys have nice butts), please be advised that I usually tend to find Dean more attractive than Sam, although Sam is a fine, fine specimen and scorching hot on occasion.  The Pull Ups happen to be one such occasion.  And now, back to the purpose of this thread:  killing the eps one by one!

 

-- bottom three

 

31 - Appointment in Samarra

30 - Weekend at Bobby's

29- Frontierland
27 - The Man Who Would Be King
26 - The French Mistake
21 - Mommy Dearest
20 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
13 - Live Free or Twihard
12 - Clap Your Hands If You Believe
04 - My Heart Will Go On

 

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man

[catrox14]

+Frontierland

--Weekend at Bobbys

--My Heart Will Go on

 

 

30- Frontierland

29- Appointment in Samarra

28 - Weekend at Bobby's
27 - The Man Who Would Be King
26 - The French Mistake
21 - Mommy Dearest
20 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
13 - Live Free or Twihard
12 - Clap Your Hands If You Believe
02 - My Heart Will Go On

 

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third M

[SueB]

Ah Balthazar, what a wonderful Angel you were Mr I.P. Freely. Delightful rogue. I liked nerdy Fate and I liked how they slowly gave us clues about Castiel. The prop department gets all the awards from me for the 100+ little touches that made in the timeline. Seeing Ellen was bittersweet. Those boys (Sam, Dea, and Bobby) really needed her and it was like losing her again. In sum, some fun moments, some angst, so mythology. Supernatural by the numbers.

+ Live Free or TwiHard

-- The Man a Who Knew Too Much

-- My Heart Will Go on

30- Frontierland

29- Appointment in Samarra

28 - Weekend at Bobby's

27 - The Man Who Would Be King

26 - The French Mistake

21 - Mommy Dearest

18 - The Man Who Knew Too Much

15 - Live Free or Twihard

12 - Clap Your Hands If You Believe

In flagrante with the King of Hell

All Dogs Go to Heaven

Unforgiven

Mannequin 3: The Reckoning

Like a Virgin

Family Matters

And Then There Were None

Let it Bleed

Caged Heat

Exile on Main St.

You Can't Handle the Truth

Two and a Half Men

The Third Man

My Heart Will Go On

[AwesomO4000]

I agree with all of that eulogy SueB. Somehow Fate always reminded me of Reese Witherspoon as Tracy Flick in Election.

 

-- The Man Who Would Be King

-- Appointment in Samarra

+ The Man Who Knew Too Much

 

 

30- Frontierland
28 - Weekend at Bobby's

27- Appointment in Samarra
26 - The French Mistake

25 - The Man Who Would Be King
21 - Mommy Dearest
19 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
15 - Live Free or Twihard
12 - Clap Your Hands If You Believe

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On

[Blue Castle]

I wasn't a big fan of "My Heart Will Go On"--but I did enjoy that Dean kinda liked Titanic.

 

+ Weekend at Bobby's

--Frontierland

--Clap Your Hands

 

29 - Weekend at Bobby's

28- Frontierland

27- Appointment in Samarra
26 - The French Mistake

25 - The Man Who Would Be King
21 - Mommy Dearest
19 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
15 - Live Free or Twihard
10 - Clap Your Hands If You Believe

 

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On

[DittyDotDot]

Being the sucker for alternative universe episodes that I am, I rather liked My Heart Will Go On. Too bad Fate wasn't better in the end, but I'll take the twisted rock/paper/scissors and douchey car anyway. If nothing else, Ellen was nice to see again!

 

+ Weekend at Bobby's

-- Frontierland

-- Live Free or Twihard

 

30 - Weekend at Bobby's

26 - Frontierland

27- Appointment in Samarra
26 - The French Mistake

25 - The Man Who Would Be King
21 - Mommy Dearest
19 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
13 - Live Free or Twihard
10 - Clap Your Hands If You Believe

 

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On

[SueB]

The rock/paper/scissors thing was my FAVORITE part of the AU-ishness of the episode.

[amensisterfriend]

Appointment +

Frontierland --

Clap +

 

30 - Weekend at Bobby's

28- Appointment in Samarra
26 - The French Mistake
24 - Frontierland
25 - The Man Who Would Be King
21 - Mommy Dearest
19 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
13 - Live Free or Twihard
11 - Clap Your Hands If You Believe

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On

[Demented Daisy]

The French Mistake +

CYHIYB --

Live Free or Twihard --

 

30 - Weekend at Bobby's
28- Appointment in Samarra
27 - The French Mistake

25 - The Man Who Would Be King

24 - Frontierland

21 - Mommy Dearest
19 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
11 - Live Free or Twihard
09 - Clap Your Hands If You Believe

 

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On

[7kstar]

The French Mistake --

Weekend at Bobby's --

Appointment in Samarra --

 

28 - Weekend at Bobby's
26- Appointment in Samarra
25 - The French Mistake

25 - The Man Who Would Be King

24 - Frontierland

21 - Mommy Dearest
19 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
11 - Live Free or Twihard
09 - Clap Your Hands If You Believe

 

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On

 

I really liked "My Heart will Go On"  and I really thought Ellen and Bobby was a good match.  Looks like we are all over the place on the top ones.  It will be interesting to see what happens.  Not sure I will agree with the final results, but some of the better ones aren't majorly better than the others IMO.

Edited November 26, 2014 by 7kstar

[ohjoy]

Not sure I will agree with the final results, but some of the better ones aren't majorly better than the others IMO.

I do agree with this; i feel like this season suffered greatly from an inability to find a good conclusion. There are two, maybe three episodes In which I liked the end of the episode as much as its beginning.

Weekend at Bobby's --

Appointment in Samarra --

Fronteirland +

26 - Weekend at Bobby's

25 - The French Mistake

25 - The Man Who Would Be King

25 - Frontierland

24 - Appointment in Samarra

21 - Mommy Dearest

19 - The Man Who Knew Too Much

11 - Live Free or Twihard

09 - Clap Your Hands If You Believe

In flagrante with the King of Hell

All Dogs Go to Heaven

Unforgiven

Mannequin 3: The Reckoning

Like a Virgin

Family Matters

And Then There Were None

Let it Bleed

Caged Heat

Exile on Main St.

You Can't Handle the Truth

Two and a Half Men

The Third Man

My Heart Will Go On

Edited November 27, 2014 by RandomMe

[catrox14]

Frontierland+

Weekend at Bobby's --
The French Mistake --

 

26 - Frontierland

25 - The Man Who Would Be King

24 -Weekend at Bobby's

24 - Appointment in Samarra
23- The French Mistake
21 - Mommy Dearest
19 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
11 - Live Free or Twihard
09 - Clap Your Hands If You Believe

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On

Edited November 27, 2014 by catrox14

[Mcolleague]

Mommy Dearest -- 

The Man Who Knew Too Much -- 

Weekend at Bobby's -- 

 

26 - Frontierland
25 - The Man Who Would Be King
24 - Appointment in Samarra
23- The French Mistake

22 -Weekend at Bobby's

19 - Mommy Dearest
17 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
11 - Live Free or Twihard
09 - Clap Your Hands If You Believe

 

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On

[AwesomO4000]

-- Live Free or Twihard

+ Mommy Dearest

+ The Man Who Knew Too Much

 

26 - Frontierland
25 - The Man Who Would Be King
24 - Appointment in Samarra
23- The French Mistake

22 -Weekend at Bobby's

20 - Mommy Dearest
18 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
09 - Live Free or Twihard
09 - Clap Your Hands If You Believe

 

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On

Edited November 27, 2014 by AwesomO4000

[DittyDotDot]

-- Frontierland
+ Appointment in Samarra
-- Live Free or Twihard

 

 

25 - The Man Who Would Be King
25 - Appointment in Samarra

24 - Frontierland
23- The French Mistake

22 -Weekend at Bobby's

20 - Mommy Dearest
18 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
09 - Clap Your Hands If You Believe

26 - Frontierland
25 - The Man Who Would Be King
24 - Appointment in Samarra
23- The French Mistake

22 -Weekend at Bobby's

20 - Mommy Dearest
18 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
09 - Live Free or Twihard
09 - Clap Your Hands If You

 

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On

Edited November 27, 2014 by DittyDotDot

[Demented Daisy]

CYHIYB --

TMWKTM --

TMWWBK --

 

25 - Appointment in Samarra
24 - Frontierland
23- The French Mistake

23 - The Man Who Would Be King

22 -Weekend at Bobby's

20 - Mommy Dearest
16 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
07 - Clap Your Hands If You Believe
 

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On

[DittyDotDot]

I think you're missing Live Free or Twihard there, DD.

[Iguana]

I think I've fixed the Twihard problem...

-- bottom 3

 

25 - Frontierland
24 - The Man Who Would Be King
23 - Appointment in Samarra
23- The French Mistake

22 -Weekend at Bobby's

20 - Mommy Dearest
16 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
07 - Live Free or Twihard
05 - Clap Your Hands If You Believe

 

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On

[catrox14]

+Frontierland

--Weekend at Bobbys

-- Mommy Dearest

 

26 - Frontierland

24 - The Man Who Would Be King

23 - Appointment in Samarra

23- The French Mistake

20 -Weekend at Bobby's

18 - Mommy Dearest

16 - The Man Who Knew Too Much

07 - Live Free or Twihard

05 - Clap Your Hands If You Believe

 

In flagrante with the King of Hell

All Dogs Go to Heaven

Unforgiven

Mannequin 3: The Reckoning

Like a Virgin

Family Matters

And Then There Were None

Let it Bleed

Caged Heat

Exile on Main St.

You Can't Handle the Truth

Two and a Half Men

The Third Man

My Heart Will Go On

[ohjoy]

+ Frontierland

-- The French Mistake

-- The Man Who Knew Too Much

 

27 - Frontierland

24 - The Man Who Would Be King

23 - Appointment in Samarra

21 - The French Mistake

20 - Weekend at Bobby's

18 - Mommy Dearest

14 - The Man Who Knew Too Much

07 - Live Free or Twihard

05 - Clap Your Hands If You Believe

 

In flagrante with the King of Hell

All Dogs Go to Heaven

Unforgiven

Mannequin 3: The Reckoning

Like a Virgin

Family Matters

And Then There Were None

Let it Bleed

Caged Heat

Exile on Main St.

You Can't Handle the Truth

Two and a Half Men

The Third Man

My Heart Will Go On

[SueB]

+ Live Fee or TwiHard

-- The French Mistake

-- The Man Who Knew Too Much

27 - Frontierland

24 - The Man Who Would Be King

23 - Appointment in Samarra

20 - Weekend at Bobby's

19- The French Mistake

18 - Mommy Dearest

12 - The Man Who Knew Too Much

08 - Live Free or Twihard

05 - Clap Your Hands If You Believe

In flagrante with the King of Hell

All Dogs Go to Heaven

Unforgiven

Mannequin 3: The Reckoning

Like a Virgin

Family Matters

And Then There Were None

Let it Bleed

Caged Heat

Exile on Main St.

You Can't Handle the Truth

Two and a Half Men

The Third Man

My Heart Will Go On

[AwesomO4000]

-- Live Free or Twihard

+ The Man Who Knew Too Much - it's a losing battle, but I love this episode

-- Appointment in Samarra

 

27 - Frontierland
24 - The Man Who Would Be King
21 - Appointment in Samarra
20 - Weekend at Bobby's
19- The French Mistake
18 - Mommy Dearest
13 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
06 - Live Free or Twihard
05 - Clap Your Hands If You Believe

 

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On

[Demented Daisy]

I think you're missing Live Free or Twihard there, DD.

 

How on earth did that happen?  Freaky!

[amensisterfriend]

Appointment +

The Man Who Would Be King --

Frontierland --

 

25 - Frontierland
22 - The Man Who Would Be King
21 - Appointment in Samarra
20 - Weekend at Bobby's
19- The French Mistake
18 - Mommy Dearest
13 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
06 - Live Free or Twihard
05 - Clap Your Hands If You Believe

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On

[7kstar]

Appointment --

The Man Who Would Be King --

Frontierland +

 

26 - Frontierland
20 - The Man Who Would Be King

20 - Weekend at Bobby's
19 - Appointment in Samarra
19- The French Mistake
18 - Mommy Dearest
13 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
06 - Live Free or Twihard
05 - Clap Your Hands If You Believe

 

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On

 

Well although I would love to save Live Free...I only have so many votes...so I guess it will soon move on.  It's just not one I would have moved on yet....choices, choices...

Edited November 28, 2014 by 7kstar

[DittyDotDot]

-- Frontierland
+ Appointment in Samarra
-- Live Free or Twihard

 

 

24 - Frontierland
20 - The Man Who Would Be King

20 - Weekend at Bobby's
20 - Appointment in Samarra
19- The French Mistake
18 - Mommy Dearest
13 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
05 - Clap Your Hands If You Believe

04 - Live Free or Twihard

 

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On

[Iguana]

I'll help you out 7kstar, if only because Dean was scary hot taking out the nest of vampires.  Maybe this will give you more time to accept the inevitable ;-)

+  Twihard

-- Frontierland

--  King

 

22 - Frontierland
18 - The Man Who Would Be King

20 - Weekend at Bobby's
20 - Appointment in Samarra
19- The French Mistake
18 - Mommy Dearest
13 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
05 - Clap Your Hands If You Believe

05 - Live Free or Twihard

 

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On

[Demented Daisy]

Frontierland --

CYHIYB --

Weekend at Bobby's +

 

21 - Weekend at Bobby's
20 - Appointment in Samarra

20 - Frontierland

19- The French Mistake

18 - The Man Who Would Be King

18 - Mommy Dearest

13 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
05 - Live Free or Twihard

03 - Clap Your Hands If You Believe

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On

[catrox14]

Frontierland +

Appointment  in Samarra--

Weekend at Bobby's --

 

21- Frontierland

19  - Weekend at Bobby's

19- The French Mistake

18 - Appointment in Samarra

18-  The Man Who Would Be King

18 - Mommy Dearest

13 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
05 - Live Free or Twihard

03 - Clap Your Hands If You Believe

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On

[ohjoy]

Frontierland +

Appointment  in Samarra --

The Man Who Knew Too Much --

 

22 - Frontierland

19  - Weekend at Bobby's

19 - The French Mistake

18-  The Man Who Would Be King

18 - Mommy Dearest

16 - Appointment in Samarra

11 - The Man Who Knew Too Much

05 - Live Free or Twihard

03 - Clap Your Hands If You Believe

In flagrante with the King of Hell

All Dogs Go to Heaven

Unforgiven

Mannequin 3: The Reckoning

Like a Virgin

Family Matters

And Then There Were None

Let it Bleed

Caged Heat

Exile on Main St.

You Can't Handle the Truth

Two and a Half Men

The Third Man

My Heart Will Go On

[SueB]

Live Fee or TwiHard+

-- Clap Your Hands if You Believe

The Man Who Knew Too Much --

22 - Frontierland

19 - Weekend at Bobby's

19 - The French Mistake

18- The Man Who Would Be King

18 - Mommy Dearest

16 - Appointment in Samarra

09 - The Man Who Knew Too Much

06 - Live Free or Twihard

01 - Clap Your Hands If You Believe

In flagrante with the King of Hell

All Dogs Go to Heaven

Unforgiven

Mannequin 3: The Reckoning

Like a Virgin

Family Matters

And Then There Were None

Let it Bleed

Caged Heat

Exile on Main St.

You Can't Handle the Truth

Two and a Half Men

The Third Man

My Heart Will Go On

[Blue Castle]

+Weekend at Bobby's

+The Man Who Knew Too Much

--Frontierland

 

20 - Frontierland
20 - Weekend at Bobby's
19 - The French Mistake
18- The Man Who Would Be King
18 - Mommy Dearest
16 - Appointment in Samarra
10 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
06 - Live Free or Twihard
01 - Clap Your Hands If You Believe

 

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On

[AwesomO4000]

I know I should kill "Clap Your Hands...," but I can't bring myself to do it. That episode makes me smile every time.

 

-- Appointment in Samarra

-- Live Free...

+ The Man Who Knew Too Much

 

20 - Frontierland
20 - Weekend at Bobby's
19 - The French Mistake
18- The Man Who Would Be King
18 - Mommy Dearest
14 - Appointment in Samarra
11 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
04 - Live Free or Twihard
01 - Clap Your Hands If You Believe

 

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On

[DittyDotDot]

I'll do it for you AwesomO, only because I like to see progress at this stage of the game, I'll let you do the eulogy though.

 

-- Frontierland
-- Live Free or Twihard
-- Clap Your Hands If You Believe

 

20 - Weekend at Bobby's
19 - The French Mistake
18- The Man Who Would Be King
18 - Mommy Dearest

18 - Frontierland
14 - Appointment in Samarra
11 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
02 - Live Free or Twihard

 

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On

Clap Your Hands If You Believe

[amensisterfriend]

The French Mistake --

Frontierland --

Appointment +

 

20 - Weekend at Bobby's
18- The Man Who Would Be King

18 - Mommy Dearest

17 - The French Mistake
16 - Frontierland
15 - Appointment in Samarra
11 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
02 - Live Free or Twihard

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On
Clap Your Hands If You Believe

[7kstar]

Weekend at Bobby's --

Mommy Dearest --

The Man Who Would Be King --

 

18 - Weekend at Bobby's

17 - The French Mistake
16- The Man Who Would Be King

16 - Mommy Dearest
16 - Frontierland
15 - Appointment in Samarra
11 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
02 - Live Free or Twihard

 

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On
Clap Your Hands If You Believe

 

Well Live Free lasted longer than Clap.  I loved Clap because I'm a Star Trek Voyager Fan, and it was fun to see the doc once again...he is a great actor.  I also liked that Dean was picked due to being the first born son.  It had a few good lines, like the ad-lib "Fight the faries"  I think they could have done more. 

 

I'll mourn Live Free when someone else kills it, noticed I won't.  It's hanging on by a thread.  lol.

 

As far as the top three, it looks like it will be a fight to the finish because I don't think we agree at all.

[Demented Daisy]

TMWWBK --

Mommy Dearest --

Frontierland --

 

18 - Weekend at Bobby's
17 - The French Mistake

15 - Appointment in Samarra

14- The Man Who Would Be King

14 - Mommy Dearest
14 - Frontierland
11 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
02 - Live Free or Twihard

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On
Clap Your Hands If You Believe

[amensisterfriend]

I loved Clap

 

Same here! It's definitely in my top 3-4 most rewatchable episodes of this season.

 

I usually love the meta/humorous episodes, especially in otherwise grim seasons, but for some weird reason The French Mistake doesn't quite work for me. 

Edited November 29, 2014 by amensisterfriend

[Demented Daisy]

I hate CYHIYB with the fire of a thousand suns.  But I'll explain in the episode thread.

[catrox14]

This definitely a fight for the top 3.

 

--Weekend at Bobby's

+Frontierland

--The French Mistake

16 - Weekend at Bobby's

15 - Frontierland

15 - Appointment in Samarra

15 - The French Mistake

14- The Man Who Would Be King

14 - Mommy Dearest

14- Frontierland

11 - The Man Who Knew Too Much

02 - Live Free or Twihard

In flagrante with the King of Hell

All Dogs Go to Heaven

Unforgiven

Mannequin 3: The Reckoning

Like a Virgin

Family Matters

And Then There Were None

Let it Bleed

Caged Heat

Exile on Main St.

You Can't Handle the Truth

Two and a Half Men

The Third Man

My Heart Will Go On

Clap Your Hands If You Believe

[ohjoy]

This definitely a fight for the top 3.

 

+ Frontierland

-- Appointment in Samarra

-- The Man Who Knew Too Much

16 - Weekend at Bobby's

16 - Frontierland

15 - The French Mistake

13 - Appointment in Samarra

14- The Man Who Would Be King

14 - Mommy Dearest

09 - The Man Who Knew Too Much

02 - Live Free or Twihard

In flagrante with the King of Hell

All Dogs Go to Heaven

Unforgiven

Mannequin 3: The Reckoning

Like a Virgin

Family Matters

And Then There Were None

Let it Bleed

Caged Heat

Exile on Main St.

You Can't Handle the Truth

Two and a Half Men

The Third Man

My Heart Will Go On

Clap Your Hands If You Believe

[SueB]

Clap Your Hand if You Believe is a fun, absurd, episode, IMO where Ben Edlund's imagination ran free to both horror and delight. Horror, of course, is the blatant association with an anti-gay message. It doesn't matter if it wasn't Edlund's intent, people were offended and rightly so. OTOH, the brilliance of the X-files homage, Soulless Sam unplugged, and the most reliable witness being the lady with the demitasse cups, is also hard to ignore. This is one of those cases where someone should have said 'how might people perceive what were doing', with a little more critical eye than the episode was afforded. Despite its problems, I can't help but laugh thru Sam's cluelessness and Dean fighting a Tinkerbell-esque fairy to David Bowie's 'Space Oddity.'

-- Mommy Dearest

-- The Man Who Knew too Much

+ Live Free or TwiHard

16 - Weekend at Bobby's

15 - Frontierland

15 - Appointment in Samarra

15 - The French Mistake

14- The Man Who Would Be King

14- Frontierland

12 - Mommy Dearest

09 - The Man Who Knew Too Much

03 - Live Free or Twihard

In flagrante with the King of Hell

All Dogs Go to Heaven

Unforgiven

Mannequin 3: The Reckoning

Like a Virgin

Family Matters

And Then There Were None

Let it Bleed

Caged Heat

Exile on Main St.

You Can't Handle the Truth

Two and a Half Men

The Third Man

My Heart Will Go On

Clap Your Hands If You Believe

[ohjoy]

Hey SueB, my votes aren't in your count.

[7kstar]

16 - Weekend at Bobby's
16 - Frontierland
15 - The French Mistake

14- The Man Who Would Be King

13 - Appointment in Samarra
12 - Mommy Dearest
07 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
03 - Live Free or Twihard

 

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On
Clap Your Hands If You Believe

 

* Just fixing the votes and took off the extra repeat ep.  So as far as I can tell the count is now correct.  Darn I really tried to changed the votes, but luckily my angelic side won, and I fixed my mistake.  I didn't see it honestly at first....But after checking it three times I think it is now all fixed.  :)

Edited November 30, 2014 by 7kstar

[SueB]

Sorry RandomMe! Looks like it's fixed (thanks 7kstar). I was caught in a fifth dimensional gravity based time paradox. I may or may not have seen Interstellar this weekend.

[DittyDotDot]

-- Frontierland
+ Appointment in Samarra
-- Live Free or Twihard

 

16 - Weekend at Bobby's
15 - The French Mistake

14- The Man Who Would Be King

14 - Appointment in Samarra

14 - Frontierland
12 - Mommy Dearest
07 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
01 - Live Free or Twihard

 

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On
Clap Your Hands If You Believe

[amensisterfriend]

Appointment +

French Mistake --

The Man Who Would Be King --

 

16 - Weekend at Bobby's

15 - Appointment in Samarra
14 - Frontierland

13 - The French Mistake

12- The Man Who Would Be King
12 - Mommy Dearest
07 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
01 - Live Free or Twihard

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On
Clap Your Hands If You Believe

[7kstar]

Appointment --

Weekend at Bobby's --

Frontierland +

 

15 - Frontierland

14 - Weekend at Bobby's

13 - Appointment in Samarra

13 - The French Mistake

12- The Man Who Would Be King
12 - Mommy Dearest
07 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
01 - Live Free or Twihard

 

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On
Clap Your Hands If You Believe

[Demented Daisy]

Frontierland --

Weekend at Bobby's +

Appointment in Samarra +

 

15 - Weekend at Bobby's
14 - Appointment in Samarra

13 - Frontierland

13 - The French Mistake

12- The Man Who Would Be King
12 - Mommy Dearest
07 - The Man Who Knew Too Much
01 - Live Free or Twihard

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On
Clap Your Hands If You Believe