All Episodes Talk: What's Up Doc?

[Heathen]

9 minutes ago, Mrsmaul2021 said:

I was watching season 2 this weekend and I think Kerry is gravely misunderstood.  TBH I remember liking her back in the day. I understood what position she was in. 

I liked her at times, too. She was in a tough position, but then again, she DID have unnecessarily bitchy moments and she picked on some people. 

Well-written character, all around. 

[Palimelon]

With that said, I did find myself siding with her more often when I'd rewatch the show than I did when watching the show when it came out. Especially during some of her arguments with Doug.

[Mrsmaul2021]

1 hour ago, Palimelon said:

With that said, I did find myself siding with her more often when I'd rewatch the show than I did when watching the show when it came out. Especially during some of her arguments with Doug.

 

 

ESPECIALLY with Doug LOL! But you know who else I see myself agreeing with in my old age? Romano

[Bastet]

2 hours ago, Palimelon said:

With that said, I did find myself siding with her more often when I'd rewatch the show than I did when watching the show when it came out. Especially during some of her arguments with Doug.

I liked her from the beginning, and was usually on her side, especially with Doug.  That guy has no respect for authority, and tosses policy out the window on a regular basis.  He always thinks he knows best, sometimes overriding (or at least trying to) a patient/their parent's express wishes.  Granted, virtually all of them take turns doing that, but it was his MO.  Same with Malucci and Pratt.

[CrazyInAlabama]

I think a lot of the Kerry issue came from the strange way the writing changed.   The writing inconsistencies really bothered a lot of the character and story development.    One season Kerry was more human, than other seasons where she was a total bureaucrat.   

[Heathen]

40 minutes ago, CrazyInAlabama said:

I think a lot of the Kerry issue came from the strange way the writing changed.   The writing inconsistencies really bothered a lot of the character and story development.    One season Kerry was more human, than other seasons where she was a total bureaucrat.   

Heck, sometimes in the same episode. 

[Bastet]

The initial reactions to Kerry were interesting in how they varied, and rang true to me.  First, Morganstern was right that someone who's strong in his weak areas is a better idea than someone who's very similar to him.  Mark knows, yes, she's the right pick, so does it, but at first is wishy washy when conflicts arise (which is so Mark, which is why he needs a Kerry). 

When Peter, who had done a rotation with her, hears about the hire, he tells Mark it's a step in the right direction.  Makes sense, as he likes things orderly and doesn't give a shit about pleasing personalities (see, e.g., his own).

But Susan bristles, because she's stressed out at home (thanks to her dumpster fire of a sister and not far into Kerry's tenure having Little Susie dumped on her) and wants to be dealing with Mark and her friend, the Mark Jr, instead, so things are easy and familiar at work.

And Doug, of course, is an insolent jerk from jump because he won't even listen to his own best friend when he wants to go his own way, so he's certainly not going to listen to someone like Kerry.  I love one of their early interactions, which I just re-watched, where Kerry directs a kid with chicken pox to a room she believes to be empty because Doug can't be bothered to fill out the board - especially when he's treating a patient who should be seen at a clinic, but because they made a mistake he has decided the mother should come to him for everything - and when he gets in her face [complete with raised voice, hand gestures, and that obnoxious self-righteous look on his face] about how his patient, a kid with AIDS, doesn't need to be exposed to chicken pox, she has perfect delivery on her response of "No kidding, so maybe you can let us in on the secret that he's here".

Thinking back, that may be when I was drawn to Kerry as a new character, and certainly something I love on re-watch.  Doug is one of those attractive, charming male characters who gets away with way too much by the writers - and the audience, as art is imitating life here - because of that attractiveness and charm.  An "oh, that rascal" attitude that downplays or even outright dismisses inappropriate behavior.  I was never fully down with that, and as I got older I lost all patience with it.

Edited August 31 by Bastet

[Palimelon]

 

[peacheslatour]

Yay! It's starting over with the pilot on Thursday! I watch it on POP.

[Lisa418722]

When ER started, I was working a 2nd shift job and had a radio with the local TV channels.  You could hear them, but not see them.  Listening only, Doug seemed like a jerk a lot of time, but when I started watching it I could see how Doug came across as charming his way into getting what he wanted.  Now when I rewatch I see what I heard in season one.  

Also on rewatch, I like Kerry more than I did the first time.  I guess now I'm in my own "I don't want to put up with other's bull" time of life.  But like others said above, the writing didn't do her any favors.  Sometimes I think Laura Innes was one of the best actors on the show because of how quickly the writing for Kerry changed. 

[Olis93]

Abby Keaton was such a great character and I wish she stuck around longer. She was an excellent surgeon without all the arrogance and pompous. Sweet yet confident and self-assured.

Her scenes with Benton were so great to watch. The way she handled teaching him and then rejecting him for pediatrics without being mean or condescending about it was exactly what he needed.

The relationship with Carter was cute but unnecessary as it was never gonna go anywhere.

[Cloud9Shopper]

I was watching a late S10 episode last night and it reminds me how much I don’t like Kerry’s custody storyline with Sandy’s family. I know it wraps up so quick in S11 but it doesn’t sit right with me how Sandy’s mother basically hates Kerry and seems determined to keep Henry from her as if Kerry is some terrible unfit mother. (I know some of it is Sandy’s mother being against the relationship and a sign of the times in the early 2000s but it all seems so unnecessary.) 

I like Kerry overall and think she settles nicely more into friendships with other characters later in the series, but liked how good she was with Jeanie (for the most part, save the rift with Jeanie losing her job temporarily in S4). When I was writing a fanfic about Coburn last year I gave Kerry a role as one of her friends/supporters during her time in recovery. 

[peacheslatour]

On 9/1/2024 at 3:55 AM, Lisa418722 said:

When ER started, I was working a 2nd shift job and had a radio with the local TV channels.  You could hear them, but not see them.  Listening only, Doug seemed like a jerk a lot of time, but when I started watching it I could see how Doug came across as charming his way into getting what he wanted.  Now when I rewatch I see what I heard in season one.  

Also on rewatch, I like Kerry more than I did the first time.  I guess now I'm in my own "I don't want to put up with other's bull" time of life.  But like others said above, the writing didn't do her any favors.  Sometimes I think Laura Innes was one of the best actors on the show because of how quickly the writing for Kerry changed. 

Yeah, I hated Weaver during the first run of the show but I think we wandered off around the same time that Clooney did. On my current second watch I have a lot more admiration and compassion for her.

[Heathen]

On 9/1/2024 at 6:55 AM, Lisa418722 said:

When ER started, I was working a 2nd shift job and had a radio with the local TV channels.  You could hear them, but not see them.  Listening only, Doug seemed like a jerk a lot of time, but when I started watching it I could see how Doug came across as charming his way into getting what he wanted.  Now when I rewatch I see what I heard in season one.  

Also on rewatch, I like Kerry more than I did the first time.  I guess now I'm in my own "I don't want to put up with other's bull" time of life.  But like others said above, the writing didn't do her any favors.  Sometimes I think Laura Innes was one of the best actors on the show because of how quickly the writing for Kerry changed. 

She certainly has better range than some of the other actors on the show (this means you, George and Maura in particular). Their characters were largely one-dimensional; Laura played a mean bitch, an uptight administrator, a bureaucrat, a gifted and compassionate physician, a friend, a person with a disability, a partner, a mother, a daughter, and more. Sometimes more than one character at once. And she even had more than one facial expression (this also means you, George and Maura). 

[Palimelon]

The thing about Kerry was her delivery, more than anything else, even when she was making sense. Then again, I guess as far as people running the ER, she needed to be the "bad cop" to Mark's "good cop" as far as the showrunners were concerned. 

And to be fair, Mark could be a bit too lax at times when it came to running the ER.

[Bastet]

4 minutes ago, Palimelon said:

The thing about Kerry was her delivery, more than anything else, even when she was making sense. Then again, I guess as far as people running the ER, she needed to be the "bad cop" to Mark's "good cop" as far as the showrunners were concerned. 

And to be fair, Mark could be a bit too lax at times when it came to running the ER.

Every once in a while, I oppose what Kerry is saying or doing, but most of the time I agree with her.  Some of that agreement, however, comes with a cringe as I think, "Jeez, you really should have said that differently."

I think Mark was too lax in general, more of a buddy than a manager.  He was great for team morale, but the department wouldn't have functioned without Kerry.  I love when Anspaugh becomes the new chief of staff and is ascertaining who does what in running the ER.  Everything he asks, Kerry is the answer, so he asks Mark "Aren't you an attending, too?"  Mark's answer to what he does is all feel-good stuff, while Kerry is doing all the administrative work.  Everyone loves to put her down as a bureaucrat and some of her rules are indeed overkill, but you have to have a Kerry.

The big difference for me, in terms of how I felt about a character during the original airing and how I feel now, is Mark.  I remember he bugged me a number of times, but I pretty much thought he was great.  Now, though, I frequently find him insufferable.  They all, being TV characters, bring their personal baggage to work and take it out on their coworkers and sometimes patients, but he's just awful when he's in a mood.  He's pretty much unwatchable after he's attacked; I am sympathetic to your trauma, dude, but good lords.  And the appalling way he behaves with respect to Jeanie's HIV status because he's upset Susan didn't want him?  GTFO.

[Olis93]

3 hours ago, Bastet said:

The big difference for me, in terms of how I felt about a character during the original airing and how I feel now, is Mark.  I remember he bugged me a number of times, but I pretty much thought he was great.  Now, though, I frequently find him insufferable.  They all, being TV characters, bring their personal baggage to work and take it out on their coworkers and sometimes patients, but he's just awful when he's in a mood.  He's pretty much unwatchable after he's attacked; I am sympathetic to your trauma, dude, but good lords.  And the appalling way he behaves with respect to Jeanie's HIV status because he's upset Susan didn't want him?  GTFO.

Mark is my favorite character on the show but even I can see where you're coming from. Him snooping on Jeanie was definitely his lowest moment in the series and I wish the writers didn't have him go that route. I fully sympathize with him during his PTSD arc and I imagine I would be going out of my mind too and lashing out if someone did that to me and just walked away with no consequences.

He had his moments but otherwise I find Mark by far the most consistently likeable character on the show.

[Cloud9Shopper]

3 hours ago, Olis93 said:

Mark is my favorite character on the show but even I can see where you're coming from. Him snooping on Jeanie was definitely his lowest moment in the series and I wish the writers didn't have him go that route. I fully sympathize with him during his PTSD arc and I imagine I would be going out of my mind too and lashing out if someone did that to me and just walked away with no consequences.

He had his moments but otherwise I find Mark by far the most consistently likeable character on the show.

I agree with this. There’s a reason why Mark is one of the top fan favorite characters and a lot of people think his death should have been the series finale. (Although for me, it’s between that and Carter’s S11 departure for when the show probably should have ended.) I find him likable more often than not; he basically is ER for me.

On 9/1/2024 at 5:39 PM, Olis93 said:

Abby Keaton was such a great character and I wish she stuck around longer. She was an excellent surgeon without all the arrogance and pompous. Sweet yet confident and self-assured.

Her scenes with Benton were so great to watch. The way she handled teaching him and then rejecting him for pediatrics without being mean or condescending about it was exactly what he needed.

The relationship with Carter was cute but unnecessary as it was never gonna go anywhere.

I always refer to Abby Keaton as the superior Abby LOL. Loved how much she cared about her work and had a lot of self confidence. It was definitely a time when the show had actual strong female characters; that quality also went downhill in later years.

I never expected hers and Carter’s relationship to go anywhere but I’d be lying if I said I didn’t laugh every time at the scene where Benton busts them and Carter hides the book in front of his face in embarrassment. Everyone’s expressions were great. 

[Heathen]

3 hours ago, Cloud9Shopper said:

I agree with this. There’s a reason why Mark is one of the top fan favorite characters and a lot of people think his death should have been the series finale. (Although for me, it’s between that and Carter’s S11 departure for when the show probably should have ended.) I find him likable more often than not; he basically is ER for me.

I always refer to Abby Keaton as the superior Abby LOL. Loved how much she cared about her work and had a lot of self confidence. It was definitely a time when the show had actual strong female characters; that quality also went downhill in later years.

I never expected hers and Carter’s relationship to go anywhere but I’d be lying if I said I didn’t laugh every time at the scene where Benton busts them and Carter hides the book in front of his face in embarrassment. Everyone’s expressions were great. 

There's also the scene in Dr. Keaton's office where Carter is about to take off his shirt, I think, and then he hides behind her desk so Benton doesn't see him. Then Dr. Keaton says she was "reviewing some anatomy." Always makes me laugh, although not as much as the got-caught scene. 

By FAR the superior Abby! 

Edited September 3 by Heathen

[Bastet]

7 hours ago, Olis93 said:

I fully sympathize with him during his PTSD arc and I imagine I would be going out of my mind too and lashing out if someone did that to me and just walked away with no consequences.

That I can sympathize with.  Falsely accusing a young Black man, I cannot.  And he knew damn well it was a false accusation; he had no idea who attacked him, and the police told him his dead patient's brother had an alibi.  But he swore up and down that's who'd done it.  And in the end, his big apology was to go the family's house and admit racism was "probably" part of the reason he'd made his false assumption about the patient in the first place.

3 hours ago, Cloud9Shopper said:

I never expected hers and Carter’s relationship to go anywhere but I’d be lying if I said I didn’t laugh every time at the scene where Benton busts them and Carter hides the book in front of his face in embarrassment. Everyone’s expressions were great. 

That is a funny moment, but the Keaton-Carter relationship never worked for me.  If you're afraid someone can blackmail you into a recommendation in exchange for not reporting a relationship, maybe that relationship is a bad idea.  At least it wasn't a direct report relationship, and the show was terribly blasé about power differences in general, but this is another instance where she knew it was a bad idea and pursued it anyway.  It's off-putting on an additional level on re-watch, knowing Carter's mommy issues which we did not know at the time, because she has such a maternal vibe, there's an ick factor there.

Edited September 3 by Bastet

[Mrsmaul2021]

17 hours ago, Bastet said:

 

The big difference for me, in terms of how I felt about a character during the original airing and how I feel now, is Mark.  I remember he bugged me a number of times, but I pretty much thought he was great.  Now, though, I frequently find him insufferable.  They all, being TV characters, bring their personal baggage to work and take it out on their coworkers and sometimes patients, but he's just awful when he's in a mood.  He's pretty much unwatchable after he's attacked; I am sympathetic to your trauma, dude, but good lords.  And the appalling way he behaves with respect to Jeanie's HIV status because he's upset Susan didn't want him?  GTFO.

 

 

Now for me it's season 7-9 Carter. On re watch I just can't get over how self centered he is.  Particularly when it came to Abby. He truly felt entitled to her.  You know how you re watch and maybe gain some clarity? No. It's bad every time. In season 8 you could see where they were aiming for a quadrangle. The blatant disrespect he showed Luka was nothing less than appalling.  I will never understand the need for this. When that debacle finally ended I felt it set all three characters free(Luka, Abby and Carter) 

[Palimelon]

Ok I know the bomb on Grey's Anatomy was much bigger, but the comment in this video did make me chuckle:

"Grey's anatomy: rocket in body cavity for 2 episodes.                                     ER: Benton chucks the bomb aside and moves on."

 

 

[Olis93]

Mark's attack in the washroom was just as hard to watch as I remembered but it did lead to a great PTSD storyline for him. I just need to remind myself that it's not real lol.

I'm just getting up to the Cynthia episodes now and while a lot of the fandom seems to hate her I actually really enjoy her character. She was sweet and likeable despite being a mess most of the time. She could have done a lot better than Mark.

Also, after years of watching Mariska Hargitay on SVU, her performance as Cynthia really highlights how great of an actress she really is. 

[Mrsmaul2021]

4 hours ago, Olis93 said:

Mark's attack in the washroom was just as hard to watch as I remembered but it did lead to a great PTSD storyline for him. I just need to remind myself that it's not real lol.

I'm just getting up to the Cynthia episodes now and while a lot of the fandom seems to hate her I actually really enjoy her character. She was sweet and likeable despite being a mess most of the time. She could have done a lot better than Mark.

Also, after years of watching Mariska Hargitay on SVU, her performance as Cynthia really highlights how great of an actress she really is. 

 

 

I gave Cynthia credit because she realized her relationship with Mark  was dead and she walked away. You're right, I feel too many fans are hard on her

Edited September 16 by Mrsmaul2021

[Mrsmaul2021]

ER's will turn 30 years old this Thursday September 19. 2024.  I was 20 when it premiered. I did not watch until season 2, The Baby Shower episode. I work in medical billing today and though I would hardly compare myself to a doctor, terms like QA really stands out now 😄

 

 

 

[Palimelon]

The style of that add was more Chicago Hope than ER. Also, I cracked up when the "In a world..." guy was narrating that commercial.

[Bastet]

I can't stand Cynthia.  She's a weepy, clingy, incompetent mess who enables and excuses Mark's asshole behavior when the people who've actually known him for more than five minutes are trying to point out he has a serious problem.  And then she tags along when he goes to tend to his parents after his mom is injured, before finally realizing she's not his family and is never going to be.  Only once she leaves his ass and refuses all contact do I like her.

Also Mariska Hargitay is one of those actors whose success far exceeds their talent, but there are a lot of those and many of them are assholes, while she is by all accounts a nice person, so good for her.  She seems to be a very good friend, and I like that she and Maria Bello are still close following their fairly brief time working together on this show.

[Dr.OO7]

On 9/16/2024 at 1:01 PM, Mrsmaul2021 said:

ER's will turn 30 years old this Thursday September 19. 2024.  I was 20 when it premiered. I did not watch until season 2, The Baby Shower episode. I work in medical billing today and though I would hardly compare myself to a doctor, terms like QA really stands out now 😄

 

 

 

https://tvline.com/news/er-anniversary-george-clooney-julianna-margulies-doug-carol-1235331966/

I watched sporadically in Season 1 (I was devastated about Clooney's character on "Sisters" being killed off and couldn't bear to see him in anything else). Then I caught the promos for "Hell & High Water", decided to watch and was hooked ever since.

[Bastet]

I watched the pilot because of Sherry Stringfield.  I'd loved her as Blake on Guiding Light, so first followed her to NYPD Blue (which I loathed, so I was glad she left) and then ER.  I don't think I ever saw her in anything else.

[Mrsmaul2021]

1 hour ago, Bastet said:

I watched the pilot because of Sherry Stringfield.  I'd loved her as Blake on Guiding Light, so first followed her to NYPD Blue (which I loathed, so I was glad she left) and then ER.  I don't think I ever saw her in anything else.

 

Boy, Ross  Holly and Blake. I didn't watch GL regularly but I was spending the summer with my aunt in 1992 and she watched it. That's how I know about this trio

[Palimelon]

Sherry was really good in that role.

[Dr.OO7]

This article showing some of the notes exchanged between John Wells and Michael Crichton during the show's early days;

https://deadline.com/2024/09/er-tv-series-michael-crichton-memos-1236094390/

[Mrsmaul2021]

10 Main Character Deaths That Also Killed the Show #8 Mark Greene

[Cloud9Shopper]

I’m crawling through an abridged rewatch of S11 now. And now that I work in a grocery store to earn some extra money, it’s fascinating and cringeworthy at the same time to watch Neela apply for work. No way with that attitude would she be able to be a barista or work in a clothing store and be polite to customers or do chores she doesn’t want to do. At my job the cashiers have all kinds of chores on the front end. I’ve taken out trash, swept floors, picked up shopping baskets, cleaned coolers…Neela is going to do any of that and not give attitude? Hahaha. No. She reminds me of the teenagers I work with who call out every time the wind blows the wrong way and complain that cashiering is too stressful. I would never want to work with her if she was a real person. 

Thanks for coming to my Ted talk.

Of note, the actor who plays Neela’s father is in three seasons of New Amsterdam as a doctor.

I just noticed how two of the first three episodes of S11 have shades of the S3 premiere when Carter’s first day as an intern is on the 4th of July: 

In the S11 premiere Abby is running a case and asks someone to make a call. Haleh replies by saying “Abby you are the doctor” similar to how Carter says “Somebody call a doctor!” and Carol replies “You are the doctor!” 

In the third episode of S11, Carter is working an understaffed ER on the 4th and 12 med students are starting. Carter’s first day as an intern was also the 4th although he was on his own covering the ER. Were the writers even trying to be original eight years after that?

Still cringe at Chuck and the male breast pump and Susan naming her kid Cosmo. I’m looking forward to Chuck going offscreen before he moves to NYC to become NYPD lieutenant Declan Murphy.  

[Mrsmaul2021]

doing another re watch, this time on Pop(I work from home and it's my background). I love catching things and coming to  realizations. For starters Luka and Abby were not "toxic" and Luka was indeed a good boyfriend.  Abby screwed that up(I've said this before). 

 

ETA: Still watching on Pop. Abby didn't ruin her relationship with Carter. In fact, I think she was a better GF to him than she was to Luka. This is a case of the infatuation wore off and when reality set in, it just naturally fell apart. 

Edited October 31 by Mrsmaul2021

[RedbirdNelly]

On 9/18/2024 at 3:23 PM, Dr.OO7 said:

https://tvline.com/news/er-anniversary-george-clooney-julianna-margulies-doug-carol-1235331966/

I watched sporadically in Season 1 (I was devastated about Clooney's character on "Sisters" being killed off and couldn't bear to see him in anything else). Then I caught the promos for "Hell & High Water", decided to watch and was hooked ever since.

I loved Clooney on Sisters and Selena Ward's scene where she breaks down just tour me up. I didn't start watching until season 2 and then understood why he needed to move on to ER.

[Olis93]

Watching early season 6 again and adjusting to all these new faces and some old faces leaving.

I'm remembering how obnoxious and careless Malucci was and why I never really warmed up to him. Cleo was alright at first but her character adds little to the show overall. Carter and Elaine storyline was completely disposable and led nowhere.  

Jeanie's exit felt rushed but I know Gloria Reuben left to sing back-up on Tina Turner's tour. Still sucks to lose her as she was one of my favorite characters.

As for Luka, season 6 was his most likeable season IMO and even then, some of his more annoying traits are already rearing their ugly heads for the first time.

Ultimately, season 6 feels like the beginning of the end for "classic" ER.

[Mrsmaul2021]

Max shows a small snippet of Noah Wyle's new show The Pitt

 

[Cloud9Shopper]

5 hours ago, Olis93 said:

Watching early season 6 again and adjusting to all these new faces and some old faces leaving.

I'm remembering how obnoxious and careless Malucci was and why I never really warmed up to him. Cleo was alright at first but her character adds little to the show overall. Carter and Elaine storyline was completely disposable and led nowhere.  

Jeanie's exit felt rushed but I know Gloria Reuben left to sing back-up on Tina Turner's tour. Still sucks to lose her as she was one of my favorite characters.

As for Luka, season 6 was his most likeable season IMO and even then, some of his more annoying traits are already rearing their ugly heads for the first time.

Ultimately, season 6 feels like the beginning of the end for "classic" ER.

I really only liked Luka in seasons 6 and 7. S8 is where he starts to go downhill and then S9 and on I just can’t stand him. 

What stands out most to me now about Cleo/Michael Michele is how she seems to only have one facial expression. Even when she tried to portray Cleo as flirty and sexy with Benton, she sounded bored. I honestly couldn’t believe they got married at some point between S8 and the end of the series. I feel like they’d have a dead bedroom, for those of you who get the Reddit reference.

S6 is my favorite season, but I’d put S7 and S8 in beginning of the end territory.

I’m slowly working my way through some of S11 (and skipping a lot of it) and the Christmas episode, outside of Chen’s story with her father, is completely uninteresting and dull. There’s just no camaraderie or upbeat moments like there was in Christmas episodes of earlier seasons. Also…I wasn’t that sad that Chen left and we never heard about her again. I was either neutral to her or annoyed with her. I really only liked her during her adoption storyline in S7. 

I’m also irrationally annoyed to see Neela working at the hospital again. She really didn’t deserve an internship after what she pulled.

Elizabeth’s last episode still upsets me that she wasn’t written off better. The writers owed her more than what she got, but her speech to Carter about how she feels like she has nothing at County anymore with Mark and all her friends gone/moved on is poignant. I remember reading another take (this was well over a year ago) about how it summed up how much the show had changed, and that seems about right. 

Every once in a while I think about starting back at the pilot and watching all the episodes again for a fresh take, but ultimately I feel no desire to do so. 

Edited November 11 by Cloud9Shopper

[Mrsmaul2021]

9 hours ago, Cloud9Shopper said:

 

I’m also irrationally annoyed to see Neela working at the hospital again. She really didn’t deserve an internship after what she pulled.

 

 

 

The whole subplot felt stupid an pointless. The way she came back was equally ridiculous.

Susan runs to Jumbo Mart: "Hey we lost an Intern, you want to come back Neela!?"

Is it really that easy @Notabug? 🤣

 

[Notabug]

2 hours ago, Mrsmaul2021 said:

 

 

The whole subplot felt stupid an pointless. The way she came back was equally ridiculous.

Susan runs to Jumbo Mart: "Hey we lost an Intern, you want to come back Neela!?"

Is it really that easy @Notabug? 🤣

 

I'm sure the folks at HR as well as the director of the residency program were delighted to hear Neela was back and expecting a paycheck and to pick up her residency where she left it.  

In real life, County has a huge bureaucracy and there are rules.  In addition, since residency training is an educational experience, meant to prepare a physician to become board certified in a specialty, you can't just quit a residency and then change your mind.  In real life, I know someone who was disgruntled and unhappy in their residency and submitted a resignation as of the end of the educational year.  She gave 90 days' notice or something as required in her contract and changed her mind about a month before she would've left.  I think because she couldn't find another residency that would take her or a job to support herself.

She was told in no uncertain terms that she was NOT returning, her resignation  had been accepted and her position was no longer there.  The residency I was in actually didn't fill empty slots those days so my fellow residents and I were going to pick up the slack.  Quite frankly, she was a miserable person who complained about any and everything and, even with the extra work, I don't think any of us wanted her back.

So, no Neela could not return just because Susan said so.  It would require at the very least, a meeting with the various department heads as well as whoever was running the residency.  If the resignation had already been submitted to the Emergency Medicine Board, they'd have to approve it, too.

Of course, even my crabby colleague had better options than working in a mini-mart; so it isn't like the residency thing was the most unrealistic part of the story.  BTW, crabby resident stayed out of medicine (don't know what she did) for a couple years and then applied to a different residency who gave her credit for her prior 2 years in OB/GYN and she did finish and ended up in practice at some point.  Haven't seen her since her last day of work as a resident (we had also gone to med school together); nor have I sought her out.

Edited November 11 by Notabug

[Cloud9Shopper]

I hate the episode where Abby gets kidnapped so I skipped it and went to the one right after. I was confused by the timeline how she goes for her shift, leaves early because she thinks she came back too soon, and then by nighttime she’s back at the hospital waiting for a patient transfer seemingly doing better and the kidnapping and whatever trauma she has is never mentioned again. 

Also a choice: bringing back the personal injury lawyer who worked with Mark in S4 to settle his civil suit and pretended to be a doctor. And in the next episode, Carter’s incompetent med student Henry also from S4 comes back. Did the writers just run out of ideas and plot for “most obscure characters we can find to make a reappearance”? Too bad they didn’t come up with a storyline to bring someone more interesting (like Hicks or Randi or any side character with some history to the show who is well-liked) but hey it’s S11 so I guess this is who we get. 

The plot about the patient satisfaction scores is giving me job-related anxiety…all this stuff about empathy and survey scores and using soft skills was my past everyday life trying to meet expectations. But now I get to teach others how to do those things. 🤣

[Palimelon]

I wouldn't call Henry that obscure, since he was in quite a few episodes during season 4 and even interacted quite a bit with Anna too (not one on one, but usually with Carter present).

But yeah, the lawyer was...an interesting choice.

[Olis93]

8 hours ago, Cloud9Shopper said:

I hate the episode where Abby gets kidnapped so I skipped it and went to the one right after. I was confused by the timeline how she goes for her shift, leaves early because she thinks she came back too soon, and then by nighttime she’s back at the hospital waiting for a patient transfer seemingly doing better and the kidnapping and whatever trauma she has is never mentioned again.

Usually I hate Abby's personal drama sucking up the show but that episode was an exception. I enjoyed it and thought it was some great acting from Maura Tierney. At the very least it was something different in an otherwise dull season. The fact that it's almost never mentioned again is kinda odd. Like what was the point? Just more drama for Abby?

[Notabug]

1 hour ago, Olis93 said:

 Like what was the point? Just more drama for Abby?

That was pretty much the theme of the entire show in the last few years.  What is happening to Abby?  What does Abby think?  What would Abby do?  She is thrust front and center into most of the storylines in the show.  It seems TPTB felt like nothing on the show mattered unless we discovered how Abby felt about it.

[Cloud9Shopper]

43 minutes ago, Notabug said:

That was pretty much the theme of the entire show in the last few years.  What is happening to Abby?  What does Abby think?  What would Abby do?  She is thrust front and center into most of the storylines in the show.  It seems TPTB felt like nothing on the show mattered unless we discovered how Abby felt about it.

Not gonna lie, one of my favorite things about S15 is that even though the first half was kinda “meh,” it was nice after Episode 3 when the show wasn’t all about Abby anymore and we could focus on other characters and the return of the old guard. I don’t love that she turned up again in Neela’s last episode but at least it was only for a minute or two and she didn’t eat the scenery. 

[Olis93]

5 hours ago, Notabug said:

That was pretty much the theme of the entire show in the last few years.  What is happening to Abby?  What does Abby think?  What would Abby do?  She is thrust front and center into most of the storylines in the show.  It seems TPTB felt like nothing on the show mattered unless we discovered how Abby felt about it.

That was one of my biggest pet peeves with Abby as a character. While I generally liked her, I hated how all her personal drama just swallowed up the show and almost everything became about her. If it wasn't drama with her family members she was thrown into love triangles, had issues with drinking, attacked by her neighbor, getting kidnapped, career setbacks, complications with labor or relapsing. It's just too much and I don't need to see any of this. 

The early seasons were always more focused on the medicine/workplace with just bits of personal drama sprinkled in and I prefer that style of show over what's happening with Abby?

[peacheslatour]

14 minutes ago, Olis93 said:

That was one of my biggest pet peeves with Abby as a character. While I generally liked her, I hated how all her personal drama just swallowed up the show and almost everything became about her. If it wasn't drama with her family members she was thrown into love triangles, had issues with drinking, attacked by her neighbor, getting kidnapped, career setbacks, complications with labor or relapsing. It's just too much and I don't need to see any of this. 

The early seasons were always more focused on the medicine/workplace with just bits of personal drama sprinkled in and I prefer that style of show over what's happening with Abby?

I could not agree more.

[Mrsmaul2021]

30 minutes ago, Olis93 said:

That was one of my biggest pet peeves with Abby as a character. While I generally liked her, I hated how all her personal drama just swallowed up the show and almost everything became about her. If it wasn't drama with her family members she was thrown into love triangles, had issues with drinking, attacked by her neighbor, getting kidnapped, career setbacks, complications with labor or relapsing. It's just too much and I don't need to see any of this. 

The early seasons were always more focused on the medicine/workplace with just bits of personal drama sprinkled in and I prefer that style of show over what's happening with Abby?

I love Abby but I can't disagree with this. Two storylines I loved with Abby. Her relationship with Luka and her mother Maggie. I loved them both. They could have kept the alcoholism because they only whipped it out for drama. The triangle sucked because they abruptly ended she and Luka for she and Carter and their romantic chemistry was DOA. Eric was needless because we just saw the same shit with Maggie. Lastly, why give her a hysterectomy?  It was too much. 

[ch1]

That’s the problem with long running shows.  They eventually jump the shark and character stories get more over the top because everything has already been done.  ER really became absurd in the last few seasons.