Gilmore Girls Elimination Game

[Kohola3]

4 and 13

[AlinaRay]

13, 17

[mstaken]

3. Luke and Lorelai play cards and flirt while Luke musters the courage to ask Lorelai out (Double Date)
4. Luke makes Lorelai a Santa Burger to cheer her up (Forgiveness and Stuff)
5. Luke closes the diner immediately to drive Lorelai to the hospital (Forgiveness and Stuff)
6. Luke and Lorelai huddle in the corner and have a 'moment' while planning to paint Luke's diner (That Damn Donna Reed)
7. Luke tells Lorelai about his dad (TDDR)
8. Luke comes by to search for Lorelai's lost chick (TDDR)
14. Lorelai gives Luke the blue hat. Forgiveness and Stuff
16. The "you always look good scene" in the hospital - Forgiveness and Stuff
 

13 and 17 are gone, and the next agonizingly difficult round is open! 

 

My votes: 8 and 16

[AlinaRay]

3, 16

[nolieblue]

My fav is gone! 17 --- at the Firelight Festival. :(

 

5 and 8.

[lulu1960]

4 and 8.

[Taryn74]

I thought I voted already, did it disappear?

 

4, 8

[amensisterfriend]

Hi everyone---I'm taking over the games for MsTaken :)

 

8 is history, but we have a tie between 4 and 16 for the second spot. Just vote for the one of those two that you most want eliminated!

[Taryn74]

Hi amen!  ;)

 

I vote 4.

[nolieblue]

4

[amensisterfriend]

4 and 8 are gone, and the next round is open! We're down to voting against just one :)

 

3. Luke and Lorelai play cards and flirt while Luke musters the courage to ask Lorelai out (Double Date)
5. Luke closes the diner immediately to drive Lorelai to the hospital (Forgiveness and Stuff)
6. Luke and Lorelai huddle in the corner and have a 'moment' while planning to paint Luke's diner (That Damn Donna Reed)
7. Luke tells Lorelai about his dad (TDDR)
14. Lorelai gives Luke the blue hat. Forgiveness and Stuff
16. The "you always look good scene" in the hospital - Forgiveness and Stuff

[lulu1960]

5

[Taryn74]

16

 

(I think 5 is one of my favorite examples of why I Love Luke Danes.)

[amensisterfriend]

16---agreed on 5, Taryn!

[nolieblue]

5

[AlinaRay]

Aww, 4 was my favorite...

 

I'll pick 5.

[amensisterfriend]

3. Luke and Lorelai play cards and flirt while Luke musters the courage to ask Lorelai out (Double Date)
6. Luke and Lorelai huddle in the corner and have a 'moment' while planning to paint Luke's diner (That Damn Donna Reed)
7. Luke tells Lorelai about his dad (TDDR)
14. Lorelai gives Luke the blue hat. Forgiveness and Stuff
16. The "you always look good scene" in the hospital - Forgiveness and Stuff

 

5 is gone (*sob*!) and the next round is open :) My vote: 16

[nolieblue]

14.

[lulu1960]

16

[Taryn74]

16

[amensisterfriend]

16 is gone, and we're down to our final four!

 

3. Luke and Lorelai play cards and flirt while Luke musters the courage to ask Lorelai out (Double Date)
6. Luke and Lorelai huddle in the corner and have a 'moment' while planning to paint Luke's diner (That Damn Donna Reed)
7. Luke tells Lorelai about his dad (TDDR)
14. Lorelai gives Luke the blue hat. Forgiveness and Stuff

[nolieblue]

6

[Taryn74]

6

[AlinaRay]

6

[amensisterfriend]

6, albeit with difficulty!

[lulu1960]

it's between 6 or 7 so I figure go with 6

[amensisterfriend]

Since the majority has already spoken, let's move on to our final three!

 

3. Luke and Lorelai play cards and flirt while Luke musters the courage to ask Lorelai out (Double Date)
7. Luke tells Lorelai about his dad (TDDR)
14. Lorelai gives Luke the blue hat. Forgiveness and Stuff

[AlinaRay]

7

[nolieblue]

3

[lulu1960]

7

[Taryn74]

7

[Kohola3]

14

[amensisterfriend]

And then there were two...

 

3. Luke and Lorelai play cards and flirt while Luke musters the courage to ask Lorelai out (Double Date)
14. Lorelai gives Luke the blue hat. Forgiveness and Stuff

 

...meanwhile, feel free to start listing your favorite S2 L/L scenes! 

[lulu1960]

3

[Taryn74]

3

[lulu1960]

1. Luke and Lorelai stand under the chuppah (Red Light)

2. Luke and Lorelai sit on the porch discussing finding the right person. (Red Light)

3. The secret of parenting. Luke and Lorelai in the sleigh (Bracebridge)

4. Lorelai goes to Louie's funeral with Luke. "That's not me is it?" (Dead Uncles)

5. Lorelai goes to the funeral home to help Luke. (Dead Uncles)

6. Lorelai helps Luke find an apt. "Oh Snuffy." (Lost and Found)

7. "Always in your life, forever. "You do." Luke and Lorelai at the diner after Romeo and Juliet (Run Away, Little Boy)

8. "This is nice." Sharing the picnic. (A Tisket)

9. "Save me from the double pathetic." Lorelai begs Luke to bid on the basket. (A-tisket)

10. Luke looks at the termite damage and offers a loan. (Secrets and Loans)

 

That ought to get us started.

Edited August 31, 2014 by lulu1960

[nolieblue]

3

[amensisterfriend]

1. Luke and Lorelai stand under the chuppah (Red Light)

2. Luke and Lorelai sit on the porch discussing finding the right person. (Red Light)
3. The secret of parenting. Luke and Lorelai in the sleigh (Bracebridge)
4. Lorelai goes to Louie's funeral with Luke. "That's not me is it?" (Dead Uncles)
5. Lorelai goes to the funeral home to help Luke. (Dead Uncles)
6. Lorelai helps Luke find an apt. "Oh Snuffy." (Lost and Found)
7. "Always in your life, forever. "You do." Luke and Lorelai at the diner after Romeo and Juliet (Run Away, Little Boy)
8. "This is nice." Sharing the picnic. (A Tisket)
9. "Save me from the double pathetic." Lorelai begs Luke to bid on the basket. (A-tisket)
10. Luke looks at the termite damage and offers a loan. (Secrets and Loans)

11. Lorelai is thrilled (and so am I!) to learn that Luke was a secret Trekkie (Ins and Outs of Inns)

12. Luke shows up to fix the runway, and Lorelai reluctantly admits to an admiring Ava that Luke is single (LM, LD)

13. Luke hands Lorelai an umbrella to protect her from the falling drywall (There's the Rub)

14. Luke shyly approaches Lorelai about Rory tutoring Jess (TMT) 

15. Luke welcomes back a newly single Lorelai and encourages her to pursue her dream of opening her own inn (Road Trip to Harvard) 

16. After learning that Jess will be living with him, Lorelai reminds Luke that if he ever needs any help, she's here for him. (Nick and Nora)

Edited August 31, 2014 by amensisterfriend

[Kohola3]

10

[amensisterfriend]

Kohola, we're not voting for the S2 moments yet---just listing them in anticipation of our S1 round ending tomorrow :) 

[amensisterfriend]

Congratulations to our triumphant S1 winner, Lorelai gives Luke the blue hat (Forgiveness and Stuff)!

 

Here's our S2 list. Feel free to start voting! As always, we'll start by voting against three....which is going to be very hard, since they're all pretty awesome :)  

 

1. Luke and Lorelai stand under the chuppah (Red Light)
2. Luke and Lorelai sit on the porch discussing finding the right person. (Red Light)
3. The secret of parenting. Luke and Lorelai in the sleigh (Bracebridge)
4. Lorelai goes to Louie's funeral with Luke. "That's not me is it?" (Dead Uncles)
5. Lorelai goes to the funeral home to help Luke. (Dead Uncles)
6. Lorelai helps Luke find an apt. "Oh Snuffy." (Lost and Found)
7. "Always in your life, forever. "You do." Luke and Lorelai at the diner after Romeo and Juliet (Run Away, Little Boy)
8. "This is nice." Sharing the picnic. (A Tisket)
9. "Save me from the double pathetic." Lorelai begs Luke to bid on the basket. (A-tisket)
10. Luke looks at the termite damage and offers a loan. (Secrets and Loans)
11. Lorelai is thrilled (and so am I!) to learn that Luke was a secret Trekkie (Ins and Outs of Inns)
12. Luke shows up to fix the runway, and Lorelai reluctantly admits to an admiring Ava that Luke is single (LM, LD)
13. Luke hands Lorelai an umbrella to protect her from the falling drywall (There's the Rub)
14. Luke shyly approaches Lorelai about Rory tutoring Jess (TMT)
15. Luke welcomes back a newly single Lorelai and encourages her to pursue her dream of opening her own inn (Road Trip to Harvard)
16. After learning that Jess will be living with him, Lorelai reminds Luke that if he ever needs any help, she's here for him. (Nick and Nora)

[AlinaRay]

10, 12, 13

[amensisterfriend]

My votes: 12, 13 and 14

[nolieblue]

5, 7, 9

[Taryn74]

6, 9, 12

[lulu1960]

Aww man I figured we were going to add more. I didn't want to be the only one listing so I stopped at 10

10, 13, 14

[amensisterfriend]

I added more, too, lulu, but couldn't think of more than six to add to your list. If you can think of some others, feel free to add them now, and we'll include them after this first round! 

[lulu1960]

17. Lorelai tells Luke about being engaged. He asks her if max knows where the coupon drawer is. (Sadie, Sadie)

18. Lorelai asks Luke to come outside to the party. (Hammers and Veils)

19. The Go To Hell fight (Teach me Tonight)

20. Luke and Lorelai fight about Jess at Lorelai's house. (Nick and Nora)

21. Luke tells Lorelai she can't tell him who to date. She responds with the way to get back to Hartford (Like Mother, Like Daughter

22. Luke is fixing Gilbert and telling Lorelai she can handle opening her own inn (Ins and Outs of Inns)

23. Lorelai tries to appologize ... again about the fight over Jess. Luke is being 'robotic' (I Can't Get Started)

Okay I'm done. LOL.

[amensisterfriend]

1. Luke and Lorelai stand under the chuppah (Red Light)
2. Luke and Lorelai sit on the porch discussing finding the right person. (Red Light)
3. The secret of parenting. Luke and Lorelai in the sleigh (Bracebridge)
4. Lorelai goes to Louie's funeral with Luke. "That's not me is it?" (Dead Uncles)
5. Lorelai goes to the funeral home to help Luke. (Dead Uncles)
6. Lorelai helps Luke find an apt. "Oh Snuffy." (Lost and Found)
7. "Always in your life, forever. "You do." Luke and Lorelai at the diner after Romeo and Juliet (Run Away, Little Boy)
8. "This is nice." Sharing the picnic. (A Tisket)
10. Luke looks at the termite damage and offers a loan. (Secrets and Loans)
11. Lorelai is thrilled (and so am I!) to learn that Luke was a secret Trekkie (Ins and Outs of Inns)

14. Luke shyly approaches Lorelai about Rory tutoring Jess (TMT)
15. Luke welcomes back a newly single Lorelai and encourages her to pursue her dream of opening her own inn (Road Trip to Harvard)
16. After learning that Jess will be living with him, Lorelai reminds Luke that if he ever needs any help, she's here for him. (Nick and Nora)

17. Lorelai tells Luke about being engaged. He asks her if max knows where the coupon drawer is. (Sadie, Sadie)
18. Lorelai asks Luke to come outside to the party. (Hammers and Veils)

 

19. The Go To Hell fight (Teach me Tonight)
20. Luke and Lorelai fight about Jess at Lorelai's house. (Nick and Nora)
21. Luke tells Lorelai she can't tell him who to date. She responds with the way to get back to Hartford (Like Mother, Like Daughter
22. Luke is fixing Gilbert and telling Lorelai she can handle opening her own inn (Ins and Outs of Inns)
23. Lorelai tries to appologize ... again about the fight over Jess. Luke is being 'robotic' (I Can't Get Started)

 

Hi everyone! 12 and 13 were eliminated. I changed my vote from 14 to 9 in order to avoid a three-way tiebreaker, so 9 is our third casualty. Above is the updated list, which now includes Lulu's great additions :) We're still voting against three! 

[nolieblue]

5, 7, 16