Jump to content

Type keyword(s) to search

Supernatural Survival Game


mstaken
  • Reply
  • Start Topic

Recommended Posts

I'm so completely on board with the "Die Campbells Die" train.  Gwen was nice but Samuel, with his guyliner of evil, was NOPE.

 

Samuel --
Gwen --
Christian --

 

23 - Ellen
19 - Jo
19 - Bobby
17 - Rufus
17 - Mary
17 - Ash
15 - John
11 - Gwen Campbell
09 - Christian Campbell
09 - Garth
07 - Samuel

  • Love 2
Link to comment

++ John

-- Ellen (I like her, but she's getting so far ahead!)

-- Garth (my fingers are still crossed he'll go out first :P)

 

21 - Ellen
19 - Bobby
19 - Rufus

17 - Jo
17 - Mary
17 - Ash
17 - John
11 - Gwen Campbell
09 - Christian Campbell
07 - Garth
05 - Samuel

Link to comment

Christian --

Mary ++

Jo ++  

 

21 - Ellen
19 - Bobby
19 - Rufus
19 - Jo
19 - Mary
17 - Ash
17 - John
09 - Gwen Campbell
09 - Garth

03 - Christian Campbell

01 - Samuel

 

Couldn't come up with a clever name so let someone else have the pleasure of Killing off Samuel.

Link to comment

++ John
-- Christian Campbell
--  Gwen Campbell

23 - Ellen
21 - Rufus
19 - Bobby
19 - Jo
19 - Mary
17 - Ash
17 - John
07 - Gwen Campbell
07 - Garth

Salted and Burned
 Samuel

Christian Campbell

Link to comment

I have been slammed this week so I'm just now jumping back in (hope that's okay):

 

++ Ash

-- Gwen Campbell

-- Garth

 

21 - Ellen
21 - Rufus
21 - Bobby
19 - Jo
19 - Ash

17 - Mary
17 - John
03 - Gwen Campbell
01 - Garth

 

Salted and Burned:
Samuel

Christian Campbell

  • Love 2
Link to comment

I forgot to weigh in on Samuel getting salted and burned. I really liked what they did with Samuel in S4--and I adore Mitch Pillegi--not sure Samuel made a lot of sense in S6, though. Oh, and that silly gang of his was just so wrong in so many ways, IMO. My only hope is that Samuel did not go to that great Harvelle's in the sky, but is stuck in Purgatory for eternity. He was possessed by a monster worm when he died, after all. ;)

 

And, RandomMe, I for one am elated to see you return to our little game!

  • Love 1
Link to comment

Thanks, DIttyDotDot! I didn't think it was really fair of me to weigh in on S8 and S9 since I've seen a total of 1.25 episodes out of the whole lot, but now I'm back, baby! ;-)

Edited by RandomMe
  • Love 1
Link to comment

++ Ellen

-- John

-- Garth 

Obituary:  Garth Fitzgerald IV died on February 13, 2015 as a result of complications due to irritating the shit out of Iguana every time he appeared in the show.  He is survived by a bunch of hunters who are relieved they no longer have to deal with this ridiculous Bobby-wannabe, a werewolf pack that fucks up established canon beyond tolerance, and Mr. Fizzles, his sock puppet.  In lieu of flowers, donations can be sent to Iguana, who will use them to buy back the hours wasted watching this idjit.

 

23 - Ellen
21 - Rufus
21 - Bobby
19 - Jo
19 - Ash

17 - Mary
15 - John
03 - Gwen Campbell

 

Salted and Burned:
Samuel

Christian Campbell

Garth

  • Love 4
Link to comment

++ John

-- Ellen

-- Jo

 

(I feel bad downvoting the Harvells, because I like them! But I like basically everyone on this list, and out of all these characters, they were probably the two worst at actually hunting (esp Jo), so.)

 

23 - Ellen
21 - Rufus
21 - Bobby
19 - Ash
17 - Jo

17 - John

15 - Mary
01 - Gwen Campbell

 

Salted and Burned:
Samuel
Christian Campbell
Garth

Link to comment

I kind of hate John has a father, but I will never doubt his skills as a hunter. I won't kill Gwen because I actually liked her.

--Ellen

++ John

++ Rufus

 

23 - Rufus

21 - Ellen

21 - Bobby

21 - Ash

17 - John

15 - Jo

15 - Mary

01 - Gwen Campbell

 

Salted and Burned:

Samuel

Christian Campbell

Garth

Link to comment

Oh poor Gwen, of all the ridiculous Campbells you were the best. I wish I could've gotten to know you better, but alas it was not to be. Rest in peace, Gwen Campbell, and go have a beer at that great Harvelle's in the sky.

 

-- Ash
-- John
-- Gwen Campbell

 

23 - Rufus
21 - Ellen
21 - Bobby
19 - Ash
15 - John
15 - Jo
15 - Mary

Salted and Burned:
Samuel
Christian Campbell
Garth

Gwen Campbell

  • Love 1
Link to comment

This is much harder now that the Campbell clan is gone.

++ Ellen

++ Ash

-- Mary

 

25 - Ellen

23 - Rufus

23 - Bobby

21 - Ash

13 - Jo

11 - Mary

11 - John

 

Salted and Burned:

Samuel

Christian Campbell

Garth

Gwen Campbell

Link to comment
This is much harder now that the Campbell clan is gone.

 

TRUTH.  Best Hunter?  I'd put Bobby.  Brilliant? Ash. Ellen is just NEEDED. I loved Jo.  I wanna hang with Rufus.  Mary was a BadAss. And John? Well, he has a lot to answer for, then again, he did raise the two best hunters on the planet in the history of forever.  *sigh* I'm going to be a bit ruthless this round. 

 

-- John

-- Ash

-- Mary

25 - Ellen

23 - Rufus

23 - Bobby

19 - Ash

13 - Jo

09 - Mary

09 - John

Salted and Burned:

Samuel

Christian Campbell

Garth

Gwen Campbell

Link to comment

++ John

-- Jo

-- Ellen

 

23 - Ellen
23 - Rufus
23 - Bobby
19 - Ash
11 - Jo
11 - John

09 - Mary

 

Salted and Burned:
Samuel
Christian Campbell
Garth
Gwen Campbell

Edited by rue721
Link to comment

I think it's fitting John and Mary go out at the same time, so working towards that end, but it's getting harder now...

 

-- Ash
-- Jo
-- John

 

23 - Ellen
23 - Rufus
23 - Bobby
17 - Ash
09 - Jo
09 - John

09 - Mary

 

Salted and Burned:
Samuel
Christian Campbell
Garth
Gwen Campbell

Link to comment

I can live with John and Mary going out together...I think they are very important and I like both...I just think some bad writing has really harmed John.  I never thought he was such a bully because I don't believe that Dean would be so loyal to a bully if John never had a really good side.  There had to be some really good moments that out weighed the bad for Dean to feel such torment.  Otherwise he would have walked away from John.  The show has given us it is Sam but that still doesn't work for me.  So my handwave is there are some really special moments when he taught Dean how to shoot and hunt that Dean clings too and can overlook the other stuff as that's just Dad being drunk but he doesn't really mean it.  JMV.

 

Although Ash is fun, I think he should go out before Jo but I like all that is left...dang it.

 

-- Ash
++ Jo
++ Ellen

 

25 - Ellen
23 - Rufus
23 - Bobby
15 - Ash
11 - Jo
09 - John

09 - Mary

 

Salted and Burned:
Samuel
Christian Campbell
Garth
Gwen Campbell

Link to comment

It weirdly seems fitting if Ellen, Jo and Ash went out together too...probably not going to happen, but that's the only reason I could bring myself to vote against delightful Ellen.

 

-- Ellen
-- John
-- Mary

 

23 - Ellen
23 - Bobby

21 - Rufus

15 - Ash
13 - Jo
03 - John
03 - Mary

 

Salted and Burned:
Samuel
Christian Campbell
Garth
Gwen Campbell

Edited by DittyDotDot
Link to comment

John and Mary going out before Ash and Jo? I like Ash, and Jo's OK, but no way can I get behind that!

 

++ John

-- Jo

-- Ash

 

23 - Ellen
23 - Bobby

21 - Rufus

13 - Ash
11 - Jo
05 - John
03 - Mary

 

Salted and Burned:
Samuel
Christian Campbell
Garth
Gwen Campbell

Link to comment

Ellen +
Jo +
Ash --

26 - Ellen
25 - Rufus
23 - Bobby

12 - Jo
09 - Ash
 

Salted and Burned:
Samuel
Christian Campbell
Garth
Gwen Campbell
John
Mary

 

Sniff Sniff John and Mary...how we love you and sometimes hate you both for the way you messed up Dean and Sam.  But you went out together so go be happy and drink some beers together.

 

I really only know one to vote off and the rest I really want to keep...Rats this will get really tough won't it.  :(

Link to comment

Raise your hand if you sang "John and Mary, husband and wife..." when seeing them voted off....just sayin'

 

Rufus --  (OUCH) 
Jo --
Ash --

 

26 - Ellen
23 - Rufus
23 - Bobby
10 - Jo
07 - Ash

Salted and Burned:
Samuel
Christian Campbell
Garth
Gwen Campbell
John
Mary

  • Love 2
Link to comment

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...