SueB January 3, 2015 Share January 3, 2015 -- Man's Best Friends With Benefits (I feel icky just acknowledging this episodes' existence) -- Remember the Titans -- Heartache (sorry Jensen) 17 - Hunteri Heroici 17 - LARP and the Real Girl 17 - Citizen Fang 17 - As Time Goes By17 - Everybody Hates Hitler 15 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy? 15 - Blood Brother15 - Southern Comfort15 - A Little Slice of Kevin15 - Trial and Error15 - Goodbye Stranger15 - Pac-Man Fever15 - The Great Escapist15 - Clip Show15 - Sacrifice 13 - We Need to Talk About Kevin13 - Torn and Frayed13 - Heartache13 - Freaks and Geeks 13 - Taxi Driver 13 - Bitten 11 - Remember the Titans 11 - Man's Best Friend with Benefits Link to comment
Iguana January 3, 2015 Share January 3, 2015 -- The one that I cannot bring myself to name ++ Everybody Hates Hitler -- Heartache 19 - Everybody Hates Hitler 17 - Hunteri Heroic 17 - LARP and the Real Girl 17 - Citizen Fang 17 - As Time Goes By 15 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy? 15 - Blood Brother 15 - Southern Comfort 15 - A Little Slice of Kevin 15 - Trial and Error 15 - Goodbye Stranger 15 - Pac-Man Fever 15 - The Great Escapist 15 - Clip Show 15 - Sacrifice 13 - We Need to Talk About Kevin 13 - Torn and Frayed 13 - Freaks and Geeks 13 - Taxi Driver 13 - Bitten 11 - Remember the Titans 11 - Heartache 09 - Man's Best Friend with Benefits Link to comment
DittyDotDot January 3, 2015 Share January 3, 2015 ++ Hunteri Heroic++ What's Up, Tiger Mommy? -- Man's Best Friend with Benefits 19 - Everybody Hates Hitler19 - Hunteri Heroic17 - LARP and the Real Girl17 - Citizen Fang17 - As Time Goes By17 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy?15 - Blood Brother15 - Southern Comfort15 - A Little Slice of Kevin15 - Trial and Error15 - Goodbye Stranger15 - Pac-Man Fever15 - The Great Escapist15 - Clip Show15 - Sacrifice13 - We Need to Talk About Kevin13 - Torn and Frayed13 - Freaks and Geeks13 - Taxi Driver13 - Bitten11 - Remember the Titans11 - Heartache07 - Man's Best Friend with Benefits Link to comment
Demented Daisy January 3, 2015 Share January 3, 2015 Hunteri Heroici ++ Citizen Fang -- Southern Comfort -- 21 - Hunteri Heroici 19 - Everybody Hates Hitler 17 - LARP and the Real Girl17 - As Time Goes By17 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy?15 - Blood Brother15 - Citizen Fang 15 - A Little Slice of Kevin15 - Trial and Error15 - Goodbye Stranger15 - Pac-Man Fever15 - The Great Escapist15 - Clip Show15 - Sacrifice 13 - Southern Comfort 13 - We Need to Talk About Kevin 13 - Torn and Frayed13 - Freaks and Geeks13 - Taxi Driver13 - Bitten11 - Remember the Titans11 - Heartache07 - Man's Best Friend with Benefits Link to comment
amensisterfriend January 3, 2015 Share January 3, 2015 Honestly, I don't like or remember most of these to make an informed vote---but I'm jumping in now just to vote against the inexpressible horror that is... Man's Best Friend -- Everybody Hates Hitler ++ Bitten -- 21 - Hunteri Heroici21 - Everybody Hates Hitler17 - LARP and the Real Girl17 - As Time Goes By17 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy?15 - Blood Brother15 - Citizen Fang15 - A Little Slice of Kevin15 - Trial and Error15 - Goodbye Stranger15 - Pac-Man Fever15 - The Great Escapist15 - Clip Show15 - Sacrifice13 - Southern Comfort13 - We Need to Talk About Kevin13 - Torn and Frayed13 - Freaks and Geeks13 - Taxi Driver11 - Bitten11 - Remember the Titans11 - Heartache05 - Man's Best Friend with Benefits Link to comment
7kstar January 3, 2015 Share January 3, 2015 (edited) LARP and the Real Girl ++ Citizen Fang ++ Bitten -- 21 - Hunteri Heroici21 - Everybody Hates Hitler19 - LARP and the Real Girl17 - As Time Goes By17 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy? 17 - Citizen Fang15 - Blood Brother15 - A Little Slice of Kevin15 - Trial and Error15 - Goodbye Stranger15 - Pac-Man Fever15 - The Great Escapist15 - Clip Show15 - Sacrifice13 - Southern Comfort13 - We Need to Talk About Kevin13 - Torn and Frayed13 - Freaks and Geeks13 - Taxi Driver11 - Remember the Titans11 - Heartache 09 - Bitten05 - Man's Best Friend with Benefits I watched some clips last night and what I remember was each ep had something good but many had something awful. Sam's storyline I hated first half but Dean's I liked. So I may be voting on more what I liked than the whole ep. I don't remember Heartache...why is it so bad? Edited January 3, 2015 by 7kstar Link to comment
SueB January 4, 2015 Share January 4, 2015 the episode which must not be named -- Heartache -- Remember the Titans -- 21 - Hunteri Heroici21 - Everybody Hates Hitler19 - LARP and the Real Girl17 - As Time Goes By17 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy? 17 - Citizen Fang15 - Blood Brother15 - A Little Slice of Kevin15 - Trial and Error15 - Goodbye Stranger15 - Pac-Man Fever15 - The Great Escapist15 - Clip Show15 - Sacrifice13 - Southern Comfort13 - We Need to Talk About Kevin13 - Torn and Frayed13 - Freaks and Geeks13 - Taxi Driver09 - Remember the Titans09 - Heartache 09 - Bitten03 - Man's Best Friend with Benefits Link to comment
catrox14 January 4, 2015 Share January 4, 2015 the episode that shall not be named -- Bitten-- Remember the Titans -- 21 - Hunteri Heroici 21 - Everybody Hates Hitler 19 - LARP and the Real Girl 17 - As Time Goes By 17 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy? 17 - Citizen Fang 15 - Blood Brother 15 - A Little Slice of Kevin 15 - Trial and Error 15 - Goodbye Stranger 15 - Pac-Man Fever 15 - The Great Escapist 15 - Clip Show 15 - Sacrifice 13 - Southern Comfort 13 - We Need to Talk About Kevin 13 - Torn and Frayed 13 - Freaks and Geeks 13 - Taxi Driver 09 - Heartache 07 - Remember the Titans 07 - Bitten 01 - Man's Best Friend with Benefits Link to comment
rue721 January 4, 2015 Share January 4, 2015 ++ Pac Man Fever ++ As Time Goes By -- Blood Brother 21 - Hunteri Heroici21 - Everybody Hates Hitler19 - LARP and the Real Girl19 - As Time Goes By17 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy?17 - Citizen Fang 15 - Pac-Man Fever15 - A Little Slice of Kevin15 - Trial and Error15 - Goodbye Stranger15 - The Great Escapist15 - Clip Show15 - Sacrifice 13 - Blood Brother13 - Southern Comfort13 - We Need to Talk About Kevin13 - Torn and Frayed13 - Freaks and Geeks13 - Taxi Driver09 - Heartache07 - Remember the Titans07 - Bitten01 - Man's Best Friend with Benefits Link to comment
AwesomO4000 January 4, 2015 Share January 4, 2015 (edited) Yay! I get to be the one to kill "Man's Best Friend With Benefits" I consider it an honor. And here's my eulogy: Hate, hate, hate. Double hate. Loathe entirely!" * If anyone wants to say something else, that's all good, but I just can't with that episode. -- Man's Best Friend... -- Citizen Fang -- Southern Comfort 21 - Hunteri Heroici21 - Everybody Hates Hitler19 - LARP and the Real Girl19 - As Time Goes By17 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy?15 - Citizen Fang 15 - Pac-Man Fever15 - A Little Slice of Kevin15 - Trial and Error15 - Goodbye Stranger15 - The Great Escapist15 - Clip Show15 - Sacrifice 13 - Blood Brother13 - We Need to Talk About Kevin13 - Torn and Frayed13 - Freaks and Geeks13 - Taxi Driver 11 - Southern Comfort09 - Heartache07 - Remember the Titans07 - Bitten Sent to (a Deanless) Purgatory: ** Man's Best Friend with Benefits * As per family tradition, we watched "The Grinch" (The Jim Carrey version - I know, I know, I just go with it) Christmas Eve, so this is stuck in my head now, so I might as well use it here. ** Please feel free to replace / revise / remove the parenthesis part, etc. Edited January 4, 2015 by AwesomO4000 1 Link to comment
Iguana January 4, 2015 Share January 4, 2015 I am just barely too late to kill Man's Best Friend With Benefits, but not too late to eulogize it. Here, then, are my final words on the dogfucker episode: Do not mourn for this ill conceived misbegotten horror of a script. Do not regret the death of this steaming pile of regurgitated dog vomit attempting to pass itself off as a tv show. Rather, let it become a meaningless nothing, an empty space where once an episode of Supernatural stood. Let it be sent back to the fetid bowels of hell from whence it came. Let its name be struck from the minds and memories of all the people of the universe. Let every trace of its offensive existence be wiped from all recorded history and DVDs. Let the very idea of the cop witch and his carnal canine be banished from canon for all time, and never to be thought of again. So say we all. 4 Link to comment
DittyDotDot January 4, 2015 Share January 4, 2015 -- Southern Comfort-- Heartache-- Remember the Titans 21 - Hunteri Heroici21 - Everybody Hates Hitler19 - LARP and the Real Girl19 - As Time Goes By17 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy?15 - Citizen Fang 15 - Pac-Man Fever15 - A Little Slice of Kevin15 - Trial and Error15 - Goodbye Stranger15 - The Great Escapist15 - Clip Show15 - Sacrifice 13 - Blood Brother13 - We Need to Talk About Kevin13 - Torn and Frayed13 - Freaks and Geeks13 - Taxi Driver 09 - Southern Comfort07 - Heartache07 - Bitten 05 - Remember the Titans Sent to (a Deanless) Purgatory: ** Man's Best Friend with Benefits Link to comment
SueB January 4, 2015 Share January 4, 2015 (edited) ****STANDING OVATION***** Well done Iguana. A eulogy full of Shakespearean-class wit. Most impressive. I was truly fist-pumping AwesomeO's eulogy, but yours is sublime. Edited January 4, 2015 by SueB 2 Link to comment
Demented Daisy January 4, 2015 Share January 4, 2015 Taxi Driver -- Southern Comfort -- Remember the Titans -- 21 - Hunteri Heroici21 - Everybody Hates Hitler19 - LARP and the Real Girl19 - As Time Goes By17 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy?15 - Citizen Fang15 - Pac-Man Fever15 - A Little Slice of Kevin15 - Trial and Error15 - Goodbye Stranger15 - The Great Escapist15 - Clip Show15 - Sacrifice13 - Blood Brother13 - We Need to Talk About Kevin13 - Torn and Frayed13 - Freaks and Geeks11 - Taxi Driver07 - Southern Comfort07 - Heartache07 - Bitten03 - Remember the TitansSent to (a Deanless) Purgatory:Man's Best Friend with Benefits Link to comment
7kstar January 4, 2015 Share January 4, 2015 (edited) Bitten -- Citizen Fang ++ LARP and the Real Girl ++ 21 - Hunteri Heroici21 - Everybody Hates Hitler21 - LARP and the Real Girl19 - As Time Goes By17 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy?17 - Citizen Fang15 - Pac-Man Fever15 - A Little Slice of Kevin15 - Trial and Error15 - Goodbye Stranger15 - The Great Escapist15 - Clip Show15 - Sacrifice13 - Blood Brother13 - We Need to Talk About Kevin13 - Torn and Frayed13 - Freaks and Geeks11 - Taxi Driver07 - Southern Comfort07 - Heartache05 - Bitten03 - Remember the Titans Sent to (a Deanless) Purgatory:Man's Best Friend with Benefits Back to the old grindstone for me. Awesome don't hold back your excitement! lol. Edited January 4, 2015 by 7kstar Link to comment
SueB January 5, 2015 Share January 5, 2015 Heartache -- Remember the Titans -- Blood Brother ++ 21 - Hunteri Heroici 21 - Everybody Hates Hitler 21 - LARP and the Real Girl 19 - As Time Goes By 17 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy? 17 - Citizen Fang 15 - Pac-Man Fever 15 - A Little Slice of Kevin 15 - Trial and Error 15 - Goodbye Stranger 15 - The Great Escapist 15 - Clip Show 15 - Sacrifice 15 - Blood Brother 13 - We Need to Talk About Kevin 13 - Torn and Frayed 13 - Freaks and Geeks 11 - Taxi Driver 07 - Southern Comfort 05 - Heartache 05 - Bitten 01 - Remember the Titans Sent to (a Deanless) Purgatory: Man's Best Friend with Benefits Link to comment
rue721 January 5, 2015 Share January 5, 2015 ++ The Great Escapist -- Heartache -- We Need to Talk about Kevin 21 - Hunteri Heroici21 - Everybody Hates Hitler21 - LARP and the Real Girl19 - As Time Goes By17 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy?17 - Citizen Fang17 - The Great Escapist 15 - A Little Slice of Kevin 15 - Pac-Man Fever15 - Trial and Error15 - Goodbye Stranger15 - Clip Show15 - Sacrifice15 - Blood Brother13 - Torn and Frayed13 - Freaks and Geeks11 - We Need to Talk About Kevin 11 - Taxi Driver07 - Southern Comfort05 - Bitten03 - Heartache 01 - Remember the Titans Sent to (a Deanless) Purgatory:Man's Best Friend with Benefits Link to comment
catrox14 January 5, 2015 Share January 5, 2015 ++ Southern Comfort( I love this for the fight between Dean and Sam) -- Bitten -- Sacrifice 21 - Hunteri Heroici 21 - Everybody Hates Hitler 21 - LARP and the Real Girl 19 - As Time Goes By 17 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy? 17 - Citizen Fang 17 - The Great Escapist 15 - A Little Slice of Kevin 15 - Pac-Man Fever 15 - Trial and Error 15 - Goodbye Stranger 15 - Clip Show 15 - Blood Brother 13 - Sacrifice 13 - Torn and Frayed 13 - Freaks and Geeks 11 - We Need to Talk About Kevin 11 - Taxi Driver 09 - Southern Comfort 03 - Bitten 03 - Heartache 01- Remember the Titans Sent to (a Deanless) Purgatory: Man's Best Friend with Benefits Link to comment
DittyDotDot January 5, 2015 Share January 5, 2015 I was gonna take out Remember the Titans, but I know there's a certain someone out there who loathed it and I thought they should get the honor. -- Citizen Fang -- Torn and Frayed -- Southern Comfort 21 - Hunteri Heroici21 - Everybody Hates Hitler21 - LARP and the Real Girl19 - As Time Goes By17 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy?17 - The Great Escapist 15 - Citizen Fang15 - A Little Slice of Kevin15 - Pac-Man Fever15 - Trial and Error15 - Goodbye Stranger15 - Clip Show15 - Blood Brother13 - Sacrifice13 - Freaks and Geeks 11 - Torn and Frayed11 - We Need to Talk About Kevin11 - Taxi Driver08 - Southern Comfort03 - Bitten03 - Heartache01- Remember the TitansSent to (a Deanless) Purgatory:Man's Best Friend with Benefits 1 Link to comment
Demented Daisy January 5, 2015 Share January 5, 2015 I come to kill Remember the Titans, not to eulogize it. Remember the Titans -- Citizen Fang -- Hunteri Heroici ++ 23 - Hunteri Heroici21 - Everybody Hates Hitler21 - LARP and the Real Girl19 - As Time Goes By17 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy?17 - The Great Escapist15 - A Little Slice of Kevin15 - Pac-Man Fever15 - Trial and Error15 - Goodbye Stranger15 - Clip Show15 - Blood Brother 13 - Citizen Fang 13 - Sacrifice 13 - Freaks and Geeks11 - Torn and Frayed11 - We Need to Talk About Kevin11 - Taxi Driver08 - Southern Comfort03 - Bitten03 - Heartache Sent to (a Deanless) Purgatory: Man's Best Friend with Benefits Remember the Titans 1 Link to comment
AwesomO4000 January 5, 2015 Share January 5, 2015 -- Torn and Frayed * -- Citizen Fang -- Southern Comfort ** 23 - Hunteri Heroici21 - Everybody Hates Hitler21 - LARP and the Real Girl19 - As Time Goes By17 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy?17 - The Great Escapist15 - A Little Slice of Kevin15 - Pac-Man Fever15 - Trial and Error15 - Goodbye Stranger15 - Clip Show15 - Blood Brother 13 - Sacrifice 13 - Freaks and Geeks 11 - Citizen Fang11 - We Need to Talk About Kevin11 - Taxi Driver 09 - Torn and Frayed05 - Southern Comfort ***03 - Bitten03 - Heartache Sent to (a Deanless) Purgatory: Man's Best Friend with Benefits Remember the Titans * This episode isn't close to being gone yet? I agree with DittyDotDot (from the episode thread) that this episode is beyond awful and unlike "Man's best Friend...," it's myth-heavy and so therefore not easily disregarded. The gratuitous and unnecessary torture and the stupidity of the Amelia story and the futility of poor Samandriel being "saved" just to be killed in the end... just ugh. And bringing up the "Citizen Fang" thing again - which was so contrived in the first place - just ick. To summarize MST3K's Tom Servo when he got giant-sized :: cave man voice :: Episode bad. Episode go away. ** I apologize in advance, catrox14, as I do not share your love of this particular Sam and Dean fight. I much prefer their fight in "The Mentalists" and the one from "Soul Survivor" or the one from "Scarecrow." So for me this is episode go away, part deux. *** fixed a small clerical error from above. 1 Link to comment
Iguana January 6, 2015 Share January 6, 2015 ++ Hitler -- Taxi Driver -- Southern Comfort I will briefly eulogize "Remember the Titans" with a shallow acknowledgement that Prometheus was a fine looking man. 23 - Hunteri Heroici23 - Everybody Hates Hitler21 - LARP and the Real Girl19 - As Time Goes By17 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy?17 - The Great Escapist15 - A Little Slice of Kevin15 - Pac-Man Fever15 - Trial and Error15 - Goodbye Stranger15 - Clip Show15 - Blood Brother 13 - Sacrifice 13 - Freaks and Geeks 11 - Citizen Fang11 - We Need to Talk About Kevin09 - Taxi Driver 09 - Torn and Frayed03 - Southern Comfort03 - Bitten03 - Heartache Sent to (a Deanless) Purgatory: Man's Best Friend with Benefits Remember the Titans 1 Link to comment
catrox14 January 6, 2015 Share January 6, 2015 Heh. No worries. I I'm one of the few that likes the scene. I can understand that it doesn't save the episode, but Dean reading Sam the riot act was a long time coming and the brawl was some epic screen fighting. Link to comment
7kstar January 6, 2015 Share January 6, 2015 ++ Citizen Fang ++ As Time Goes By -- Bitten 23 - Hunteri Heroici23 - Everybody Hates Hitler21 - LARP and the Real Girl21 - As Time Goes By17 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy?17 - The Great Escapist15 - A Little Slice of Kevin15 - Pac-Man Fever15 - Trial and Error15 - Goodbye Stranger15 - Clip Show15 - Blood Brother 13 - Sacrifice 13 - Freaks and Geeks 13 - Citizen Fang11 - We Need to Talk About Kevin09 - Taxi Driver 09 - Torn and Frayed03 - Southern Comfort 03 - Heartache01 - Bitten Sent to (a Deanless) Purgatory: Man's Best Friend with Benefits Remember the Titans Link to comment
7kstar January 6, 2015 Share January 6, 2015 (edited) Heh. No worries. I I'm one of the few that likes the scene. I can understand that it doesn't save the episode, but Dean reading Sam the riot act was a long time coming and the brawl was some epic screen fighting. Although I did like the fight between Sam and Dean and felt Sam had it coming, the end blows it away and I hate how Dean caves to Sam...just no. Sam didn't look for him, he didn't look for Kevin and really he has no right to be mad that Dean found a new friend and there was truth in that statement, the only one who hasn't betrayed me is Benny. So it has some funny moments with Garth, but it isn't on my radar to save. Now Citizen Fang, sorry...still fighting for it even if it is a losing battle. Not for the Sam part, but for the Dean and Benny story. I could care less about any of Sam's stories this season. It was the season that easy made me hate Sam. Sorry @ Awesom0 Edited January 6, 2015 by 7kstar Link to comment
SueB January 6, 2015 Share January 6, 2015 I'll send Bitten on it's way, backpack and all. I actually liked the found footage approach in this episode. I liked Kate, not so much the other two. I particularly enjoyed their comments regarding the brothers and the way the Impala sort of glides into the shot. It was an experimental kind of episode but I liked it. I don't actually think it's the third worst episode but since it's destined to meet it's doom early, I'll send it off to be with it's other kind in Purgatory. Wolves probably like it there anyway. -- Heartache -- Southern Comfort -- Bitten 23 - Hunteri Heroici23 - Everybody Hates Hitler21 - LARP and the Real Girl21 - As Time Goes By17 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy?17 - The Great Escapist15 - A Little Slice of Kevin15 - Pac-Man Fever15 - Trial and Error15 - Goodbye Stranger15 - Clip Show15 - Blood Brother 13 - Sacrifice 13 - Freaks and Geeks 13 - Citizen Fang11 - We Need to Talk About Kevin09 - Taxi Driver 09 - Torn and Frayed01 - Southern Comfort 01 - Heartache Sent to (a Deanless) Purgatory: Man's Best Friend with Benefits Remember the Titans Bitten Link to comment
AwesomO4000 January 6, 2015 Share January 6, 2015 I could care less about any of Sam's stories this season. It was the season that easy made me hate Sam. Sorry @ Awesom0 No need to apologize. I didn't like Sam in the first part of season 8 either. I also didn't recognize him, and thought he was out of character, especially based on season 7 (where I adored Sam's characterization). So I blamed it on Carver trying to make his story fit and sacrificing Sam to do it... Basically I pretend the first half of season 8 and certain parts of season 9 don't exist or are at the least aberrations. I'd rather that than have to hate a character that I loved for 7 years (again, thanks a lot, Carver /sarcasm/ you've turned me into a delusional person.) ... which is also why I'm gleefully trying to kill as many of the offending episodes I can here - it's kind of cathartic actually. Link to comment
rue721 January 6, 2015 Share January 6, 2015 -- Torn and Frayed -- We Need to Talk About Kevin -- Clip Show 23 - Hunteri Heroici23 - Everybody Hates Hitler21 - LARP and the Real Girl21 - As Time Goes By17 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy?17 - The Great Escapist15 - A Little Slice of Kevin15 - Pac-Man Fever15 - Trial and Error15 - Goodbye Stranger15 - Blood Brother 13 - Clip Show 13 - Sacrifice 13 - Freaks and Geeks 13 - Citizen Fang09 - We Need to Talk About Kevin09 - Taxi Driver 07 - Torn and Frayed01 - Southern Comfort 01 - Heartache Sent to (a Deanless) Purgatory: Man's Best Friend with Benefits Remember the Titans Bitten Link to comment
catrox14 January 6, 2015 Share January 6, 2015 ++ Goodbye Stranger ++ What's Up, Tiger Mommy -- Sacrifice 23 - Hunteri Heroici 23 - Everybody Hates Hitler 21 - LARP and the Real Girl 21 - As Time Goes By 19 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy? 17 - Goodbye Stranger 17 - The Great Escapist 15 - A Little Slice of Kevin 15 - Pac-Man Fever 15 - Trial and Error 15 - Blood Brother 13 - Clip Show 13 - Freaks and Geeks 13 - Citizen Fang 11 - Sacrifice 09 - We Need to Talk About Kevin 09 - Taxi Driver 07 - Torn and Frayed 01 - Southern Comfort 01 - Heartache Sent to (a Deanless) Purgatory: Man's Best Friend with Benefits Remember the Titans Bitten Link to comment
DittyDotDot January 6, 2015 Share January 6, 2015 Killing two birds with one vote. I have nothing nice to say about them, so I'll leave them for others to eulogize. -- Torn and Frayed- - Southern Comfort-- Heartache 23 - Hunteri Heroici23 - Everybody Hates Hitler21 - LARP and the Real Girl21 - As Time Goes By19 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy?17 - Goodbye Stranger17 - The Great Escapist15 - A Little Slice of Kevin15 - Pac-Man Fever15 - Trial and Error15 - Blood Brother13 - Clip Show13 - Freaks and Geeks13 - Citizen Fang11 - Sacrifice09 - We Need to Talk About Kevin09 - Taxi Driver05 - Torn and FrayedSent to (a Deanless) Purgatory:Man's Best Friend with BenefitsRemember the TitansBitten Southern ComfortHeartache Link to comment
SueB January 6, 2015 Share January 6, 2015 I'm up for supporting that catharsis AwesomeO. Link to comment
catrox14 January 6, 2015 Share January 6, 2015 I guess I find the good with Dean and Purgatory and Benny and the Trans and Crowley outweighs the bullshit with Sam hitting a dog for most of the first half of s8. I struggle far more with the back half and what seems to be a weird shift with no good explanation of why the trials went to Sam outside of Sam stabbing the hellhound. But I really love some of the Dean/Cas stuff in the back half which outweighs my annoyance with Sam and the trials and Dean becoming a babysitter. Link to comment
Demented Daisy January 6, 2015 Share January 6, 2015 Hunteri Heroici ++ Bottom 2 -- 25 - Hunteri Heroici23 - Everybody Hates Hitler21 - LARP and the Real Girl21 - As Time Goes By19 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy?17 - Goodbye Stranger17 - The Great Escapist15 - A Little Slice of Kevin15 - Pac-Man Fever15 - Trial and Error15 - Blood Brother13 - Clip Show13 - Freaks and Geeks13 - Citizen Fang11 - Sacrifice09 - We Need to Talk About Kevin07 - Taxi Driver03 - Torn and Frayed Sent to (a Deanless) Purgatory:Man's Best Friend with BenefitsRemember the TitansBittenSouthern ComfortHeartache Link to comment
Iguana January 6, 2015 Share January 6, 2015 ++ Everybody Hates Hitler -- bottom 2 You know, for Season 8, I just so generally dislike the season that with the exception of the one I liked and the one I consign to the depths of hell, it really doesn't matter to me what order the eps go out in. I'm like, lets just kill them all and let Chuck sort it out. 25 - Hunteri Heroici25 - Everybody Hates Hitler21 - LARP and the Real Girl21 - As Time Goes By19 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy?17 - Goodbye Stranger17 - The Great Escapist15 - A Little Slice of Kevin15 - Pac-Man Fever15 - Trial and Error15 - Blood Brother13 - Clip Show13 - Freaks and Geeks13 - Citizen Fang11 - Sacrifice09 - We Need to Talk About Kevin05 - Taxi Driver01 - Torn and Frayed Sent to (a Deanless) Purgatory:Man's Best Friend with BenefitsRemember the TitansBittenSouthern ComfortHeartache 1 Link to comment
AwesomO4000 January 7, 2015 Share January 7, 2015 :: Rubs hands together gleefully :: Ooh, I get to kill the - in my opinion - boring, torture porn that was "Torn and Frayed." Yay! (again) Episode bad. Episode die. I have no eulogy to give, so if someone else would like to... -- Torn and Frayed -- Citizen Fang ++ Everybody Hates Hitler 27 - Everybody Hates Hitler 25 - Hunteri Heroici21 - LARP and the Real Girl21 - As Time Goes By19 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy?17 - Goodbye Stranger17 - The Great Escapist15 - A Little Slice of Kevin15 - Pac-Man Fever15 - Trial and Error15 - Blood Brother13 - Clip Show13 - Freaks and Geeks11 - Citizen Fang11 - Sacrifice09 - We Need to Talk About Kevin05 - Taxi Driver Sent to (a Deanless) Purgatory:Man's Best Friend with BenefitsRemember the TitansBittenSouthern ComfortHeartache Torn and Frayed Link to comment
7kstar January 7, 2015 Share January 7, 2015 (edited) -- Sacrifice ++ Citizen Fang ++ LARP and the Real Girl 27 - Everybody Hates Hitler 25 - Hunteri Heroici23 - LARP and the Real Girl21 - As Time Goes By19 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy?17 - Goodbye Stranger17 - The Great Escapist15 - A Little Slice of Kevin15 - Pac-Man Fever15 - Trial and Error15 - Blood Brother13 - Clip Show13 - Freaks and Geeks13 - Citizen Fang09 - Sacrifice09 - We Need to Talk About Kevin05 - Taxi Driver Sent to (a Deanless) Purgatory:Man's Best Friend with BenefitsRemember the TitansBittenSouthern ComfortHeartache Torn and Frayed There were some good moments in Torn and Frayed, such as Cas telling Dean and Sam to stow their crap. I've seen a few other good moments in clips but I don't remember them right now. Edited January 7, 2015 by 7kstar Link to comment
SueB January 7, 2015 Share January 7, 2015 -- Taxi Driver -- they completely ruined Hell ++ Goodbye Stranger -- Hunter Heroici 27 - Everybody Hates Hitler 23 - Hunteri Heroici23 - LARP and the Real Girl21 - As Time Goes By19 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy?19 - Goodbye Stranger17 - The Great Escapist15 - A Little Slice of Kevin15 - Pac-Man Fever15 - Trial and Error15 - Blood Brother13 - Clip Show13 - Freaks and Geeks13 - Citizen Fang09 - Sacrifice09 - We Need to Talk About Kevin03 - Taxi Driver Sent to (a Deanless) Purgatory:Man's Best Friend with BenefitsRemember the TitansBittenSouthern ComfortHeartache Torn and Frayed Link to comment
rue721 January 7, 2015 Share January 7, 2015 ++ The Great Escapist -- Clip Show -- LARP and the Real Girl 27 - Everybody Hates Hitler 23 - Hunteri Heroici21 - LARP and the Real Girl21 - As Time Goes By19 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy?19 - Goodbye Stranger19 - The Great Escapist15 - A Little Slice of Kevin15 - Pac-Man Fever15 - Trial and Error15 - Blood Brother13 - Freaks and Geeks13 - Citizen Fang11 - Clip Show 09 - Sacrifice09 - We Need to Talk About Kevin03 - Taxi Driver Sent to (a Deanless) Purgatory:Man's Best Friend with BenefitsRemember the TitansBittenSouthern ComfortHeartache Torn and Frayed Link to comment
DittyDotDot January 7, 2015 Share January 7, 2015 Darn it, I was so hoping to continue my killing spree...guess I'll have to save my bloodlust for another day. -- A Little Slice of Kevin-- Citizen Fang-- Taxi Driver 27 - Everybody Hates Hitler 23 - Hunteri Heroici21 - LARP and the Real Girl21 - As Time Goes By19 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy?19 - Goodbye Stranger19 - The Great Escapist15 - Pac-Man Fever15 - Trial and Error 13 - A Little Slice of Kevin13 - Blood Brother13 - Freaks and Geeks13 - Citizen Fang11 - Clip Show 09 - Sacrifice09 - We Need to Talk About Kevin01 - Taxi Driver Sent to (a Deanless) Purgatory:Man's Best Friend with BenefitsRemember the TitansBittenSouthern ComfortHeartache Torn and Frayed 1 Link to comment
catrox14 January 7, 2015 Share January 7, 2015 ++ Pac Man Fever ++ Hunter Heroici -- The Great Escapist 27 - Everybody Hates Hitler 25 - Hunteri Heroici 21 - LARP and the Real Girl 21 - As Time Goes By 19 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy? 19 - Goodbye Stranger 17 - The Great Escapist 17 - Pac-Man Fever 15 - Trial and Error 13 - A Little Slice of Kevin 13 - Blood Brother 13 - Freaks and Geeks 13 - Citizen Fang 11 - Clip Show 09 - Sacrifice 09 - We Need to Talk About Kevin 01 - Taxi Driver Sent to (a Deanless) Purgatory: Man's Best Friend with Benefits Remember the Titans Bitten Southern Comfort Heartache Torn and Frayed Link to comment
Demented Daisy January 7, 2015 Share January 7, 2015 Ooh, my turn again! As I said in the episode thread, way to screw canon, show. Death allows rogue Reapers? Never gonna believe that. The only bright point in the episode was Naomi and Crowley at the end, IMO. Anyone else have something to say? Hunteri Heroici ++ Citizen Fang -- Taxi Driver -- 27 - Everybody Hates Hitler27 - Hunteri Heroici21 - LARP and the Real Girl21 - As Time Goes By19 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy?19 - Goodbye Stranger17 - The Great Escapist17 - Pac-Man Fever15 - Trial and Error13 - A Little Slice of Kevin13 - Blood Brother13 - Freaks and Geeks11 - Citizen Fang11 - Clip Show09 - Sacrifice09 - We Need to Talk About Kevin Sent to (a Deanless) Purgatory:Man's Best Friend with BenefitsRemember the TitansBittenSouthern ComfortHeartacheTorn and Frayed Taxi Driver Link to comment
AwesomO4000 January 7, 2015 Share January 7, 2015 Ooh, my turn again! As I said in the episode thread, way to screw canon, show. Death allows rogue Reapers? Never gonna believe that. The only bright point in the episode was Naomi and Crowley at the end, IMO. Anyone else have something to say? Sam had been willing to take Benny back with him and admitted to Dean (in the Winchester way) that he was wrong? Otherwise I got nothing. Oh, wait... I guess I could include the Dean killing Benny scene, but by that time I was tired of the whole soap-opera thing they had turned Benny/Dean into for me - which it never should have been, in my opinion - so it ended up being too melodramatic for me despite Jensen's and Ty's best efforts. :: sigh :: Though truthfully, I did prefer this episode to the drama-fest, "here's a cool character who due to our plot-manipulations you'll never get to see again. And another interesting character who you previously liked and now we'll totally destroy for teh drama... and then kill. Oh, and we'll have Sam be a semi-roid rage ass and delusional idiot for that purpose, also" soap-opera that was "Citizen Fang",* so there is that also. * My opinion only here - and yup I'm telling it how I really feel there. No regrets... and if I'm lucky, I'll get to kill that episode, too... heh heh heh - though Ditty Dot Dot also deserves a good kill, too. (Sorry 7kstar and catrox14, my hatred for that episode is just irrationally strong.) Link to comment
supposebly January 8, 2015 Share January 8, 2015 I just adore you guys tearing this awful season to shreds. I think most of the worst are done if I remember the episode titles correctly. Well done and keep going! Link to comment
AwesomO4000 January 8, 2015 Share January 8, 2015 A couple more to go for me, supposebly, including.. -- Citizen Fang -- We Need to Talk About Kevin ++ Pac Man Fever 27 - Everybody Hates Hitler27 - Hunteri Heroici21 - LARP and the Real Girl21 - As Time Goes By19 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy?19 - Goodbye Stranger 19 - Pac Man Fever 17 - The Great Escapist15 - Trial and Error13 - A Little Slice of Kevin13 - Blood Brother13 - Freaks and Geeks11 - Clip Show 09 - Citizen Fang09 - Sacrifice 07 - We Need to Talk About Kevin Sent to (a Deanless) Purgatory:Man's Best Friend with BenefitsRemember the TitansBittenSouthern ComfortHeartacheTorn and Frayed Taxi Driver Link to comment
7kstar January 8, 2015 Share January 8, 2015 (edited) @Awesome0 I get why you hate it but I hate what they do to Dean in the second half and yes, I love good character development. But by this season I'm sick to death of Dean only having I will bow to King Sam and be depressed. The only good things he got, they just drop and by this season I had join I'm sick of King Sam. I get we don't agree and I won't see it your way either, I can respect it but I can't agree. The best Part of Taxi Driver was having Sam having to eat his words about Benny and realize that he was wrong to do what he did to his brother. And the heartbreak of Dean killing Benny but believing that Benny would come back. Once again Dean is blinded by the thought that he can't save everyone and not seeing how tired Benny was of fighting his own instincts as a vampire. The place he had longed for on earth wasn't the paradise he thought it was. So it's the only good part. I did like seeing Bobby again, but I hated how they brought him back. So I was willing to let it go, but Citizen Fang & Blood Brothers, nope not ready yet. ++ Citizen Fang -- Clip Show ++ Blood Brother 27 - Everybody Hates Hitler27 - Hunteri Heroici21 - LARP and the Real Girl21 - As Time Goes By19 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy?19 - Goodbye Stranger 19 - Pac Man Fever 17 - The Great Escapist15 - Trial and Error 15 - Blood Brother13 - A Little Slice of Kevin13 - Freaks and Geeks 11 - Citizen Fang 09 - Clip Show09 - Sacrifice 07 - We Need to Talk About Kevin Sent to (a Deanless) Purgatory:Man's Best Friend with BenefitsRemember the TitansBittenSouthern ComfortHeartacheTorn and Frayed Taxi Driver Edited January 8, 2015 by 7kstar Link to comment
SueB January 8, 2015 Share January 8, 2015 I'll mourn Taxi Driver for Benny's sake and Torn and Frayed for Dean whispering that Kevin's Mom was hot to an oblivious Kevin (and I think Dean MEANT it). -- We need to talk about Kevin -- Sam's character assassination -- Freaks and Geeks -- creepy dude was meh ++ Blood Brother -- I LOVE the whistling flashback 27 - Everybody Hates Hitler27 - Hunteri Heroici21 - LARP and the Real Girl21 - As Time Goes By19 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy?19 - Goodbye Stranger 19 - Pac Man Fever 17 - The Great Escapist15 - Trial and Error 15 - Blood Brother13 - A Little Slice of Kevin11 - Freaks and Geeks 11 - Citizen Fang 09 - Clip Show09 - Sacrifice 05 - We Need to Talk About Kevin Sent to (a Deanless) Purgatory:Man's Best Friend with BenefitsRemember the TitansBittenSouthern ComfortHeartacheTorn and Frayed Taxi Driver Link to comment
rue721 January 8, 2015 Share January 8, 2015 ++ The Great Escapist -- Clip Show -- Blood Brother 27 - Everybody Hates Hitler27 - Hunteri Heroici21 - LARP and the Real Girl21 - As Time Goes By19 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy?19 - Goodbye Stranger 19 - Pac Man Fever 19 - The Great Escapist15 - Trial and Error 13 - Blood Brother13 - A Little Slice of Kevin11 - Freaks and Geeks 11 - Citizen Fang 09 - Sacrifice 07 - Clip Show 05 - We Need to Talk About Kevin Sent to (a Deanless) Purgatory:Man's Best Friend with BenefitsRemember the TitansBittenSouthern ComfortHeartacheTorn and Frayed Taxi Driver Link to comment
Demented Daisy January 8, 2015 Share January 8, 2015 Hunteri Heroici ++ Citizen Fang -- Freaks and Geeks -- 29 - Hunteri Heroici 27 - Everybody Hates Hitler 21 - LARP and the Real Girl21 - As Time Goes By19 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy?19 - Goodbye Stranger19 - Pac Man Fever19 - The Great Escapist15 - Trial and Error13 - Blood Brother13 - A Little Slice of Kevin09 - Freaks and Geeks09 - Citizen Fang09 - Sacrifice07 - Clip Show05 - We Need to Talk About KevinSent to (a Deanless) Purgatory:Man's Best Friend with BenefitsRemember the TitansBittenSouthern ComfortHeartacheTorn and FrayedTaxi Driver Link to comment
catrox14 January 8, 2015 Share January 8, 2015 (edited) I'll eulogize taxi driver for all the Benny and Dean stuff. Pissed me off to no end that Sam had to be in Purgatory too. And that Dean had to kill his own friend to do that. To me it would have been more satisfying for Dean to do the trials. Benny would have soul trained back to Purgatory with Dean and helped Dean find Bobby. Benny head wouldn't have needed to be lopped off. . Everybody Hates Hitler ++ Citizen Fang ++ sacrifice - - 29 - Hunteri Heroici 29 - Everybody Hates Hitler 21 - LARP and the Real Girl 21 - As Time Goes By 19 - What's Up, Tiger Mommy? 19 - Goodbye Stranger 19 - Pac Man Fever 19 - The Great Escapist 15 - Trial and Error 13 - Blood Brother 13 - A Little Slice of Kevin 11 - Citizen Fang 09 - Freaks and geeks 07 - Sacrifice 07 - Clip Show 05 - We Need to Talk About Kevin Sent to (a Deanless) Purgatory: Man's Best Friend with Benefits Remember the Titans Bitten Southern Comfort Heartache Torn and Frayed Taxi Driver Edited January 8, 2015 by catrox14 Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.