Supernatural Survival Game

[SueB]

Mommy Dearest had many delightful and painful moments. Delightful: Get out of my ass! Jefferson Starships. Eat Me! Painful: Lenore. Little Ryan. I felt bad for Cas (Baby in a trenchcoat - Dean, you ass).

Frontierland was fun for the cosplay but it just didn't win me over like Time After Time (next season).

French Mistake was high concept and the best part was the death of Kripke.  But it wasn't my favorite episode of the year.

 

+Weekend at Bobby's

--Appointment in Samarra

 

15 - Weekend at Bobby's

07 - Appointment in Samarra

 

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On
Clap Your Hands If You Believe
Live Free or TwiHard
The Man Who Knew Too Much
The Man Who Would Be King
French Mistake

Mommy Dearest

Frontierland

[AwesomO4000]

Farewell "Mommy Dearest." Such a fun episode. The beginning montage was appropriately horrible in its juxtaposition. The Jefferson Starship thing was fun. Dean's plan was brilliant, and the end with Cas and Crowley... I didn't see that coming. But then so many things made sense - like Cas being squirrelly about Sam's soul. Well, done show, well done.

 

Don't think I could add more to the praise for "Frontierland" except that I loved the whole Clint Eastwood exchange.

 

Frontierland was fun for the cosplay but it just didn't win me over like Time After Time (next season).

 

I loved "Time After Time..." Season 7s gonna be another one where it'll be tough for me to choose amongst my favorites, 'cuz I have so many, but since most of my favs are gone here now, the choice is easy...

 

+ Weekend at Bobby's

-- Appointment in Samarra

 

16 - Weekend at Bobby's

05 - Appointment in Samarra

 

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On
Clap Your Hands If You Believe
Live Free or TwiHard
The Man Who Knew Too Much
The Man Who Would Be King
French Mistake

Mommy Dearest

Frontierland

[catrox14]

--Weekend at Bobby's

+Appointment in Samarra

14 - Weekend at Bobby's

06 - Appointment in Samarra

 

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On
Clap Your Hands If You Believe
Live Free or TwiHard
The Man Who Knew Too Much
The Man Who Would Be King
French Mistake

Mommy Dearest

Frontierland

Edited December 4, 2014 by catrox14

[catrox14]

nothing to see here

Edited December 4, 2014 by catrox14

[amensisterfriend]

Great final two! S6 has definite clunkers, but it's been fun to recall that it has a few genuinely awesome episodes as well :) 

 

Weekend --

Appointment +

 

12 - Weekend at Bobby's
07 - Appointment in Samarra

 

 

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On
Clap Your Hands If You Believe
Live Free or TwiHard
The Man Who Knew Too Much
The Man Who Would Be King
French Mistake
Mommy Dearest
Frontierland

[Demented Daisy]

I can't vote against either, so I'll vote down both to move the game along.

 

Weekend at Bobby's --

Appointment in Samarra --

 

10 - Weekend at Bobby's
05 - Appointment in Samarra


In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On
Clap Your Hands If You Believe
Live Free or TwiHard
The Man Who Knew Too Much
The Man Who Would Be King
French Mistake
Mommy Dearest
Frontierland

[ohjoy]

I like, but don't love, both episodes equally (as, neither is my fave), so moving the game along is pretty much it for me.

 

Weekend at Bobby's --
Appointment in Samarra --
 
08 - Weekend at Bobby's
03 - Appointment in Samarra


In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On
Clap Your Hands If You Believe
Live Free or TwiHard
The Man Who Knew Too Much
The Man Who Would Be King
French Mistake
Mommy Dearest
Frontierland

[Iguana]

-- both

next one up can go for the kill...

 

06 - Weekend at Bobby's
01 - Appointment in Samarra

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On
Clap Your Hands If You Believe
Live Free or TwiHard
The Man Who Knew Too Much
The Man Who Would Be King
French Mistake
Mommy Dearest
Frontierland

[SueB]

And thus Season 6 is in the books for now.

 

Appointment at Samarra is one of those "can't lose" episodes because Death shows up.  And, as usual, when he's on the screen it's just riveting.  The dialog, the actor, the interplay with Dean. I think I stop breathing a bit when they are interacting. I loved the use of Robert Englund in this role, along with creepy goth nurse-ish. Tessa/Dean have excellent interaction and although the test and outcome are reasonably predictable, it's still a good watch. Watching Bobby and Soulless Sam? Only accomplished hiding behind my fingers partially over my eyes. I was so proud of Bobby building that trap door. And then the idjit had to go on the prowl looking for Sam.  Arrrrgggg.  In the end, it worked out but it raised my blood pressure. And it made perfect sense that Death could crack the cage.  And excellent resolution IMO to Soulless Sam.

 

Weekend At Bobby's turns out on top in this little game.  But it's just brilliant from start to finish so there's a reason WHY it's at the top.  The Rufus and Bobby team up ('you gotta help me bury a body', 'don't swallow it'/'alright I swallowed it', etc..). I was ready for a spin-off right there. Woodchipper beats everything. Bobby beating the King of Hell.  That's pretty damn hard to do and so I was proud of him for doing it. The little snippets of Sam and Dean were great (Bobby's roast recipe). Jodi Mills exasperation when finding out he had a body outside AND another in the basement. And then the phone bank (no, Garth, the REAL FBI; how are you even alive?). This was such a wonderful world-building episode. Mostly just full of fun and laughter but enough drama that it never crossed over to farce. Like many series who attempt a "Lower Decks"* story, this episode is a memorable one that fleshes out the SPN universe while telling a good tale.

 

**Star Trek: The Next Generation "Lower Decks" episode was the first to really pull focus from the main actors for an episode.  

 

-- Weekend at Bobby's

- Appointment at Samarra

 

04 - Weekend at Bobby's
 

 

In flagrante with the King of Hell
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Unforgiven
Mannequin 3: The Reckoning
Like a Virgin
Family Matters
And Then There Were None
Let it Bleed
Caged Heat
Exile on Main St.
You Can't Handle the Truth
Two and a Half Men
The Third Man
My Heart Will Go On
Clap Your Hands If You Believe
Live Free or TwiHard
The Man Who Knew Too Much
The Man Who Would Be King
French Mistake
Mommy Dearest
Frontierland

Appointment in Samarra

Edited December 5, 2014 by SueB

[AwesomO4000]

:: Rubs hands together in anticipation of season 7 :: ... and I apologize in advance to those of you for whom that season is going to be a chore. I'm already composing my top 5 list in my head, and it's gonna be tough to decide which eps to leave off (#1 is easy though!)

[Iguana]

If Season Seven Time For A Wedding doesn't get voted off first, I will lose what little faith in humanity that I have left.

[DittyDotDot]

Alright, S7. While not an overall favorite, I quite enjoy a good deal of it. Should be interesting, I too hope my faith in humanity isn't shaken either. ;)

 

 

-- Defending Your Life

-- Shut Up, Dr. Phil

-- Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!

 

 

15 - Meet the New Boss

15 - Hello, Cruel World

15 - The Girl Next Door

15 - Slash Fiction

15 - The Mentalists

15 - How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters

15 - Death's Door

15 - Adventures in Babysitting

15 - Time After Time

15 - The Slice Girls

15 - Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie

15 - Repo Man

15 - Out with the Old

15 - The Born-Again Identity

15 - Party On, Garth

15 - Of Grave Importance

15 - The Girl with the Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo

15 - Reading Is Fundamental

15 - There Will Be Blood
15 - Survival of the Fittest

13 - Defending Your Life

13 - Shut Up, Dr. Phil

13 - Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!

[amensisterfriend]

:: Rubs hands together in anticipation of season 7 :: ... and I apologize in advance to those of you for whom that season is going to be a chore. I'm already composing my top 5 list in my head, and it's gonna be tough to decide which eps to leave off (#1 is easy though!)

 

Right there with you! I've recently decided that S7 is my favorite post-S3 season. (*slinks off to the unpopular opinions thread*)

 

Slash Fiction ++

Time After Time ++

Defending Your Life --

 

 

17 - Time After Time

17 - Slash Fiction

15 - Meet the New Boss
15 - Hello, Cruel World
15 - The Girl Next Door
15 - The Mentalists
15 - How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
15 - Death's Door
15 - Adventures in Babysitting
15 - The Slice Girls
15 - Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
15 - Repo Man
15 - Out with the Old
15 - The Born-Again Identity
15 - Party On, Garth
15 - Of Grave Importance
15 - The Girl with the Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
15 - Reading Is Fundamental
15 - There Will Be Blood
15 - Survival of the Fittest
13 - Shut Up, Dr. Phil
13 - Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!

11 - Defending Your Life

[catrox14]

Oh s7. You are so squirrelly. This will be a really interesting battle I think. 

 

Slash Fiction ++

Time After Time ++

Meet the New Boss ++

 

19- Time After Time

19 - Slash Fiction

17- Meet the New Boss
15 - Hello, Cruel World
15 - The Girl Next Door
15 - The Mentalists
15 - How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
15 - Death's Door
15 - Adventures in Babysitting
15 - The Slice Girls
15 - Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
15 - Repo Man
15 - Out with the Old
15 - The Born-Again Identity
15 - Party On, Garth
15 - Of Grave Importance
15 - The Girl with the Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
15 - Reading Is Fundamental
15 - There Will Be Blood
15 - Survival of the Fittest
13 - Shut Up, Dr. Phil
13 - Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!

11 - Defending Your Life

Edited December 5, 2014 by catrox14

[amensisterfriend]

Catrox, I think you missed my votes :) 

[catrox14]

Thanks I forgot to actually add my votes to the totals..LOL derp

[Demented Daisy]

Shut Up, Dr. Phil --

Season Seven, Time for a Wedding! --
Defending Your Life --

 

19- Time After Time
19 - Slash Fiction
17- Meet the New Boss
15 - Hello, Cruel World
15 - The Girl Next Door
15 - The Mentalists
15 - How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
15 - Death's Door
15 - Adventures in Babysitting
15 - The Slice Girls
15 - Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
15 - Repo Man
15 - Out with the Old
15 - The Born-Again Identity
15 - Party On, Garth
15 - Of Grave Importance
15 - The Girl with the Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
15 - Reading Is Fundamental
15 - There Will Be Blood
15 - Survival of the Fittest
11 - Shut Up, Dr. Phil
11 - Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!
09 - Defending Your Life

[Blue Castle]

++Meet the New Boss

++Hello, Cruel World

++Death's Door

 

19- Time After Time
19 - Slash Fiction
19- Meet the New Boss
17 - Hello, Cruel World

17 - Death's Door
15 - The Girl Next Door
15 - The Mentalists
15 - How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
15 - Adventures in Babysitting
15 - The Slice Girls
15 - Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
15 - Repo Man
15 - Out with the Old
15 - The Born-Again Identity
15 - Party On, Garth
15 - Of Grave Importance
15 - The Girl with the Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
15 - Reading Is Fundamental
15 - There Will Be Blood
15 - Survival of the Fittest
11 - Shut Up, Dr. Phil
11 - Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!
09 - Defending Your Life

 

I hate that the show killed Bobby but I did like that episode a lot.

[AwesomO4000]

My favorite favorites are well on their way, so I'll help out some regular favorites...

 

++ Hello, Cruel World

++ Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie

++ The Mentalists

 

19- Time After Time
19 - Slash Fiction
19- Meet the New Boss
19 - Hello, Cruel World

17 - Death's Door

17 - Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie

17 - The Mentalists
15 - The Girl Next Door
15 - How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
15 - Adventures in Babysitting
15 - The Slice Girls
15 - Repo Man
15 - Out with the Old
15 - The Born-Again Identity
15 - Party On, Garth
15 - Of Grave Importance
15 - The Girl with the Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
15 - Reading Is Fundamental
15 - There Will Be Blood
15 - Survival of the Fittest
11 - Shut Up, Dr. Phil
11 - Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!
09 - Defending Your Life

[ohjoy]

Well, I'm one of those people with exactly two S7 episodes I remember actually liking (although I do also remember appreciating various components of at least five other episodes), so this should be interesting. I'm actually very open to be reminded/convinced of the value of certain other episodes, so I'm game for this round too.

 

++ Hello, Cruel World

++ Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie

-- Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!

 

21 - Hello, Cruel World

19 - Time After Time
19 - Slash Fiction
19 - Meet the New Boss

19 - Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie

17 - Death's Door

17 - The Mentalists
15 - The Girl Next Door
15 - How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
15 - Adventures in Babysitting
15 - The Slice Girls
15 - Repo Man
15 - Out with the Old
15 - The Born-Again Identity
15 - Party On, Garth
15 - Of Grave Importance
15 - The Girl with the Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
15 - Reading Is Fundamental
15 - There Will Be Blood
15 - Survival of the Fittest
11 - Shut Up, Dr. Phil
09 - Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!
09 - Defending Your Life

[amensisterfriend]

I'm actually very open to be reminded/convinced of the value of certain other episodes, so I'm game for this round too.

 

When this is all over, would anyone be up for a group cyber-rewatch of the top 3-5 episodes from each season?! It could be a lot of fun, and I'm always up for an excuse to rewatch :) 

[SueB]

++ Defending Your Life -- I'm stunned that people don't like this -- it had Jo! Jo providing some home truths to Dean! Osiris was a fun villain. And Sam quoted The Good Wife for lawyer knowledge. THIS is worse than The Girl Next a Door? *sigh*

-- Shut Up Dr Phil

-- Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!

21 - Hello, Cruel World

19 - Time After Time

19 - Slash Fiction

19 - Meet the New Boss

19 - Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie

17 - Death's Door

17 - The Mentalists

15 - The Girl Next Door

15 - How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters

15 - Adventures in Babysitting

15 - The Slice Girls

15 - Repo Man

15 - Out with the Old

15 - The Born-Again Identity

15 - Party On, Garth

15 - Of Grave Importance

15 - The Girl with the Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo

15 - Reading Is Fundamental

15 - There Will Be Blood

15 - Survival of the Fittest

11 - Defending Your Life

09 - Shut Up, Dr. Phil

07 - Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!

[catrox14]

I wanted so much to like Girl Next Door but sadly I didn't think it reflected Jensen's best directorial work.

[DittyDotDot]

++ Defending Your Life -- I'm stunned that people don't like this -- it had Jo! Jo providing some home truths to Dean! Osiris was a fun villain. And Sam quoted The Good Wife for lawyer knowledge. THIS is worse than The Girl Next a Door? *sigh*

 

As someone pointed out to me earlier, S7 has a lot of even, but middle ground episodes, some I like a little more than others, but very little I am overly attached to (not like 90 percent of S2 anyway) and nothing rage inducing.  So, it may be less of people not liking the episode so much as just not liking it as much as others. But, I actually like The Girl Next Door other than the arguing and yelling the episode produces over the Amy angst anyway. I think it's a good solid episode and Jensen did a great job directing it. And yes, I'd probably say it's better than Defending Your Life, but mostly because I find what Dean's on trial for to be a bit nonsensical. It was really nice to see Jo again though.

[SueB]

I liked the opener and the bit in the cabin. Hated the kill Amy story line which ended up as a major season arc that I just never liked.

[DittyDotDot]

Well, like I said, never cared for the Amy angst and don't know why it needed to be drug out past this episode. And, if I had my druthers, Dean wouldn't have killed Amy, but I'm not too bothered by it either. I'm not saying it's at the top of the season for me; it's just not at the bottom is all.

[catrox14]

I didn't like the choice of having all the flashbacks in that sepia tone. It took me right out of the story which I blame Jensen for. I do think he did a great job with getting a wonderful performance from Colin Ford. And I shouldnt blame him for the script.

[DittyDotDot]

I blame the sepia tone on flashbacks. Every show feels the need to do something overtly obvious when dealing with flashbacks because, apparently, us viewers are too stupid to know it's not a flashback otherwise. One of the myriad of reasons why I generally loathe flashbacks. All the flashback episodes on this show have a golden tone to them, it's the show's visual style for these things. I'm just thankful they didn't also do the icky out of focus thing some shows do. Those make me totally nauseous when watching.

Edited December 6, 2014 by DittyDotDot

[Iguana]

I'm on my mobile and can't quote. Is it within the rules for me to vote and for who ever is up next to adjust the count? If so, thanks to the next voter. if not just ignore this post.

-- season 7 time for a wedding

++ Slash Fiction

-- defending your life

[AwesomO4000]

I liked the opener and the bit in the cabin. Hated the kill Amy story line which ended up as a major season arc that I just never liked.

 

I disagree with it being a major season arc. It was a little manipulative in some ways and melodramatic, but it was over in 4 episodes and in my opinion was wrapped up very well in "The Mentalists" where the brothers actually listened to each other and came to a mutual agreement with a minimum of yelling. All of those things - the 4 episode wrap up, the actual communication, the mutual agreement with the equivalent of apologies on both sides, and the minimum of yelling - making this for me one of the better conflict resolutions the brothers ever had on this show.

 

In addition to that, I'm generally surprised on rewatches that the non-Amy killing parts of that episode are often better than I remembered them. I liked the insight into Sam's life here, and that it showed that Sam was not all blowing off his family responsibilities when it came to hunting, but actually helped even in his teens. And in general yes, I find it better than "Defending Your Life" which not only making Sam look like an idiot, in my opinion, didn't make a whole lot of sense either. I'm also sometimes rather burned out when it comes to Dean guilt stories and a whole episode of Dean guilt just isn't my favorite. Miles of course always vary.

 

Counting Iguana's votes:

 

-- season 7 time for a wedding

++ Slash Fiction

-- defending your life

 

21 - Hello, Cruel World

21 - Slash Fiction

19 - Time After Time

19 - Meet the New Boss

19 - Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie

17 - Death's Door

17 - The Mentalists

15 - The Girl Next Door

15 - How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters

15 - Adventures in Babysitting

15 - The Slice Girls

15 - Repo Man

15 - Out with the Old

15 - The Born-Again Identity

15 - Party On, Garth

15 - Of Grave Importance

15 - The Girl with the Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo

15 - Reading Is Fundamental

15 - There Will Be Blood

15 - Survival of the Fittest

09 - Defending Your Life

09 - Shut Up, Dr. Phil

05 - Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!

[amensisterfriend]

Slash Fiction ++ (Is it odd that this has become one of my very favorite episodes of the entire series?!)

Plucky Pennywhistle ++

Time After Time ++

 

23 - Slash Fiction

21 - Hello, Cruel World
21 - Time After Time

21 - Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
19 - Meet the New Boss
17 - Death's Door
17 - The Mentalists
15 - The Girl Next Door
15 - How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
15 - Adventures in Babysitting
15 - The Slice Girls
15 - Repo Man
15 - Out with the Old
15 - The Born-Again Identity
15 - Party On, Garth
15 - Of Grave Importance
15 - The Girl with the Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
15 - Reading Is Fundamental
15 - There Will Be Blood
15 - Survival of the Fittest
09 - Defending Your Life
09 - Shut Up, Dr. Phil
05 - Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!

[Iguana]

Thanks Awesom!

amensisterfriend, Slash Fiction is one of my favourite eps as well. The scene in the diner where Leviathan Sam and Leviathan Dean essentially deconstruct the Winchesters in a few sentences (It's like eating self righteousness) is one of the funniest and best scenes in the whole series.

[DittyDotDot]

++ Hello, Cruel World
++ Time After Time

-- Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!

 

 

23 - Slash Fiction

23 - Hello, Cruel World
23 - Time After Time

21 - Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
19 - Meet the New Boss
17 - Death's Door
17 - The Mentalists
15 - The Girl Next Door
15 - How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
15 - Adventures in Babysitting
15 - The Slice Girls
15 - Repo Man
15 - Out with the Old
15 - The Born-Again Identity
15 - Party On, Garth
15 - Of Grave Importance
15 - The Girl with the Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
15 - Reading Is Fundamental
15 - There Will Be Blood
15 - Survival of the Fittest
09 - Defending Your Life
09 - Shut Up, Dr. Phil
03 - Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!

[7kstar]

++ Death's Door
++ Time After Time

-- Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!

 

25 - Time After Time

23 - Slash Fiction

23 - Hello, Cruel World

21 - Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
19 - Meet the New Boss
19 - Death's Door
17 - The Mentalists
15 - The Girl Next Door
15 - How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
15 - Adventures in Babysitting
15 - The Slice Girls
15 - Repo Man
15 - Out with the Old
15 - The Born-Again Identity
15 - Party On, Garth
15 - Of Grave Importance
15 - The Girl with the Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
15 - Reading Is Fundamental
15 - There Will Be Blood
15 - Survival of the Fittest
09 - Defending Your Life
09 - Shut Up, Dr. Phil
01 - Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!

 

I loved the idea of Defending Your Life.  I loved how they used Jo in this one but the whole Amy issue just turns my stomach.  NO WAY was it the issue that Dean felt the most guilty about and for that I can't save it.  I won't kill it, but I won't save it either.  If it had better writers and gone for what the real issues, it could have been awesome instead it divided the fan base over really nothing.

Edited December 6, 2014 by 7kstar

[amensisterfriend]

01 - Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!

 

I'm going to go out on a limb and predict that this one is totally going to in our entire tournament! ;) 

 

I'm loving the love for Time After Time and Slash Fiction :) 

[catrox14]

I just didn't understand the point of Defending Your Life.  I mean guilt is such a weird thing in this show, so for me it was just to push forward the Amy secret. Now what would have been really compelling is to have the secret come out in the trial and then Sam would have been faced with whether he could continue to defend Dean. Now that would have been far more interesting.

 

But I guess they wanted to wait to have Sam learn the secret from Leviathan!Dean to make it seem like regular!Dean was just an absolute monster for killing a monster. And gods that horrible breakup scene is just laughably bad.  "I can't even look at you right now".  Really? I can't imagine how bad it was if Jared and Jensen felt strongly enough to rewrite it and it still was terrible. 

 

Unpopular opinion about the wedding episode.  I kind of loved the demon and it did have some funny moments especially Dean's freaking out about Sam getting married. But aside from that? YIKES

 

++ Slash Fiction
++ Time After Time

-- Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!

27 - Time After Time

25 - Slash Fiction

23 - Hello, Cruel World

21 - Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
19 - Meet the New Boss
19 - Death's Door
17 - The Mentalists
15 - The Girl Next Door
15 - How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
15 - Adventures in Babysitting
15 - The Slice Girls
15 - Repo Man
15 - Out with the Old
15 - The Born-Again Identity
15 - Party On, Garth
15 - Of Grave Importance
15 - The Girl with the Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
15 - Reading Is Fundamental
15 - There Will Be Blood
15 - Survival of the Fittest
09 - Defending Your Life
09 - Shut Up, Dr. Phil
 

Bibbed: (feel free to offer other death monikers)

Season Seven: Time for a Wedding!

Edited December 6, 2014 by catrox14

[Demented Daisy]

Shut Up, Dr. Phil --

Defending Your Life --

Survival of the Fittest --

 

27 - Time After Time
25 - Slash Fiction
23 - Hello, Cruel World
21 - Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
19 - Meet the New Boss
19 - Death's Door
17 - The Mentalists
15 - The Girl Next Door
15 - How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
15 - Adventures in Babysitting
15 - The Slice Girls
15 - Repo Man
15 - Out with the Old
15 - The Born-Again Identity
15 - Party On, Garth
15 - Of Grave Importance
15 - The Girl with the Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
15 - Reading Is Fundamental
15 - There Will Be Blood
13 - Survival of the Fittest
07 - Defending Your Life
07 - Shut Up, Dr. Phil

Bibbed: 
Season Seven: Time for a Wedding!

[SueB]

 

(feel free to offer other death monikers)

Are you kidding? 'Bibbed' is PERFECT.

[catrox14]

LOL well I thought it was perfect but didn't want to presume.  So Bibbed it is!

[Blue Castle]

Bibbed is Awesome (as Dean might say). I definitely laughed when I first read it.

I also kind of liked the wedding episode--mainly cause of Dean's reactions. First to Sam and Becky and then to Garth. I think Garth's introduction is also well done here (I really like how Garth is goofy, and the polar opposite to Dean, but also competent). All the Becky stuff is awful though, of course.

[Iguana]

Catrox, bibbed is perfect.

And with the swift and sure death of season seven time for a wedding my limited faith in humanity remains shakily in place. I thank you all. I loathed this episode witn the white hot intensity of a galactic cluster. Whatever the slight positives that some of you have raised, for me, becky's ongoing sexual assault/sex slaving Sam creates a black hole that pulls the ep down into the deepest darkest depths of suck.

Edited December 6, 2014 by Iguana

[SueB]

Shut Up, Dr. Phil --

Defending Your Life ++

The Girl Next Door --

27 - Time After Time

25 - Slash Fiction

23 - Hello, Cruel World

21 - Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie

19 - Meet the New Boss

19 - Death's Door

17 - The Mentalists

15 - How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters

15 - Adventures in Babysitting

15 - The Slice Girls

15 - Repo Man

15 - Out with the Old

15 - The Born-Again Identity

15 - Party On, Garth

15 - Of Grave Importance

15 - The Girl with the Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo

15 - Reading Is Fundamental

15 - There Will Be Blood

13 - Survival of the Fittest

13 - The Girl Next Door

09- Defending Your Life

05 - Shut Up, Dr. Phil

Bibbed:

Season Seven: Time for a Wedding!

[AwesomO4000]

I kind of agree with catrox about liking the demon in "Season 7, Time For A Wedding." There was just a whole lot of yikes there though. It probably says a lot that my favorite line in the episode is Sam's only somewhat muffled "Fuck you!" (I'm still not sure how that one got by the censors.) And Becky's totally oblivious retort "I love you, too." That obliviousness kinda sums it up right there.

 

-- Defending Your Life

-- Party on Garth... this requires a visual: see below *

++ How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters - stoned Dean and poor ranger Rick: hee

 

27 - Time After Time
25 - Slash Fiction
23 - Hello, Cruel World
21 - Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
19 - Meet the New Boss
19 - Death's Door
17 - The Mentalists
17 - How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
15 - Adventures in Babysitting
15 - The Slice Girls
15 - Repo Man
15 - Out with the Old
15 - The Born-Again Identity
15 - Of Grave Importance
15 - The Girl with the Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
15 - Reading Is Fundamental
15 - There Will Be Blood

13 - Party On, Garth
13 - Survival of the Fittest
13 - The Girl Next Door
07- Defending Your Life
05 - Shut Up, Dr. Phil

 

Bibbed:
Season Seven: Time for a Wedding!

 

* Okay the promised visual:

Ahhhhh!

Edited December 7, 2014 by AwesomO4000

[catrox14]

Don't make me get out a Leviathan who will actually eat that annoying sock puppet.

[DittyDotDot]

Now I'm picturing you having a bunch of little monsters you keep in your back pocket for just such occasions. ;)

 

ETA; would a Leviathan find a sock puppet filling even if they were small enough to fit in catrox's back pocket?

Edited December 7, 2014 by DittyDotDot

[catrox14]

LOL...it makes it awkward when I invite Dean over for pie, I'll tell you that!

Edited December 7, 2014 by catrox14

[catrox14]

Now I'm picturing you having a bunch of little monsters you keep in your back pocket for just such occasions. ;)

 

ETA; would a Leviathan find a sock puppet filling even if they were small enough to fit in catrox's back pocket?

 

It's really an appetizer.

[Iguana]

Arrrrghhh!!! The fucking sock puppet. Mr. Giggles? Number 3 on my list of reasons to hate Garth.

[Demented Daisy]

Now, AwesomO, does that mean I need to post a certain picture when Plucky Pennywhistle's is eliminated?  ;-)

[DittyDotDot]

-- Party On, Garth
-- Defending Your Life
-- Shut Up, Dr. Phil

 

27 - Time After Time
25 - Slash Fiction
23 - Hello, Cruel World
21 - Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
19 - Meet the New Boss
19 - Death's Door
17 - The Mentalists
17 - How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
15 - Adventures in Babysitting
15 - The Slice Girls
15 - Repo Man
15 - Out with the Old
15 - The Born-Again Identity
15 - Of Grave Importance
15 - The Girl with the Dungeons and Dragons Tattoo
15 - Reading Is Fundamental
15 - There Will Be Blood

13 - Survival of the Fittest
13 - The Girl Next Door

11 - Party On, Garth
05 - Defending Your Life
03 - Shut Up, Dr. Phil

 

Bibbed:
Season Seven: Time for a Wedding!