S10.E05: Fan Fiction

[The Companion]

On 11/11/2014 at 8:59 PM, bluebonnet said:

omg.  ok, this may be an unpopular opinion but i love the meta episodes.  LOVE THEM.  Always.  This one might go down as my very favorite meta episode.  I laughed out loud so many times and then there was that feel good warm feeling within my tv heart at the idea of the boys getting back to the basics.  Of course seeing Chuck there at the end sealed the deal.  

 

tl;dr - squeeeeee.

Squee, indeed. I loved this one so much.

 

On 11/12/2014 at 1:03 AM, msbeesknees said:

been watching this show since episode numero UNO. after season 5, i watched more out of loyalty then anything but tonight. TONIGHT! SN has redeemed itself. and fuck it, i'm 42 and fangirling the shit out of this episode right now. icanteven. and that metallicar porn in the beginning? forget it. this episode gave me LIFE.

 

eta: LOVE LOVE the ghostfacers shoutout! hahahahaa

Yes, I am a little embarrassed by how hard I fangirled and JA in just a tshirt cleaning baby was phenomenal.

On 11/12/2014 at 6:51 AM, Jediknight said:

You have no idea how much I was hoping it would be The Trickster that saw the musical.  He could have said "I liked it, it had style."

I figured it was Chuck, but this would have been amazing.

Y'all, this episode was perfect and I refuse to hear otherwise. LALALALA. 😆

I giggled so hard over the one man tear and Mary's death and the Destiel discussion and, well, all of it. Carry on my Wayward Son definitely made me tear up.

I said it before: my favorite thing is when the brothers are good with one another. This episode was so much of what I love about the show.

I did laugh when the vines got the teacher that maybe they should have done Little Shop. I am definitely a theater nerd and the overly earnest drama didn't feel unfamiliar. 

I did not realize this was episode 200. I have watched 200 episodes in like two months? Sweet Dracula on a Moped, I may need an intervention.

Anyway, this was delightful. Definitely one of my favorites. I can't improve upon 5 pages of comments.

[rhofmovalley]

My opinions on episodes are usually the complete opposite of everyone else's, so I'm pleasantly surprised to see most of the people who posted here liked this ep as much as I did.  Acting was spot on, the music (and the singers' voices!) were superb.  Since I bought the season I'll rewatch to look for all of the little details you all mentioned that I missed the first time.