Season 03

[Sake614]

I can’t believe they killed Jamie!!!!! I mean, I knew as soon as his father walked in that he’d turn off the box but I can’t believe they did it at all! And I guess Muncy is leaving to make room for a Rollins return. Oh joy 🙄 not sure why the SVU gang wrapped up the episode but whatever. Very disappointed in the whole thing. The only possible redeeming factor will be if that goodbye between Liv and Elliot finally closes the book on the possibility of them hooking up. They do work well together and I still enjoy watching them but I never wanted them as a couPle.

last thought: there’s no one, I mean NO ONE in the NYPD, FBI, CIA, Interpol etc who could shut down that site? This kid was the only one in the entire world capable of doing it? That certainly speaks volumes about the capabilities of our tech people.

[WendyCR72]

41 minutes ago, Sake614 said:

The only possible redeeming factor will be if that goodbye between Liv and Elliot finally closes the book on the possibility of them hooking up. They do work well together and I still enjoy watching them but I never wanted them as a couPle.

Yeah...as much as I agree, I think this is unlikely. Therefore, just call this all a waste.

[jabRI]

I'm all for people reinventing themselves, pulling themselves up, etc.  but Amanda as a profiler for a mass murderer?  Maybe start with a mugger and work your way up.  Sheez.  Her only background was teaching a few classes.   Get a real expert next time, and bring her back for some believable reason if you want.

 

Do you know who played Jamies' dad? He looked familiar.

[Raja]

29 minutes ago, jabRI said:

Do you know who played Jamies' dad? He looked familiar.

IMBd list him as John Lawrence Payne with no other credits reported.  A quick Google search only brings up a 30s actor with the same name.

[Andyourlittledog2]

This was a national and international case.  They would have used an FBI profiler not Amanda. This show I swear.

[1775rik]

KInd of liked the way they gave the daddy of death no lines.

[TV Anonymous]

Jet and Jamie? Since when? And who removed Jamie's life support to let him go? Reyes? Would that not be a homicide on its own?

Our heroes were in Dublin, OH. They were raiding a suspect's home. Of course NYC finest led the raid. And when they breached the door, "NYPD!" Did citizens of Ohio suppose to understand what NYPD was? Just by that call alone, they did not announce themselves as police, IMO and therefore potentially opened themselves to liability if someone was actually at home.

[Raja]

On 6/20/2023 at 12:17 PM, TV Anonymous said:

Jet and Jamie? Since when? And who removed Jamie's life support to let him go? Reyes? Would that not be a homicide on its own?

Our heroes were in Dublin, OH. They were raiding a suspect's home. Of course NYC finest led the raid. And when they breached the door, "NYPD!" Did citizens of Ohio suppose to understand what NYPD was? 

Reyes wouldn't and then the father arrived.

NYPD was a mild show branding compared to their TV show peers 

Edited June 23, 2023 by Raja

[christie]

On 6/20/2023 at 10:17 PM, TV Anonymous said:

Jet and Jamie? Since when? And who removed Jamie's life support to let him go? Reyes? Would that not be a homicide on its own?

Our heroes were in Dublin, OH. They were raiding a suspect's home. Of course NYC finest led the raid. And when they breached the door, "NYPD!" Did citizens of Ohio suppose to understand what NYPD was? Just by that call alone, they did not announce themselves as police, IMO and therefore potentially opened themselves to liability if someone was actually at home.

I always thought that the actor played Jamie as having a crush on Jet. Now Jet being interested in Jamie was completely out of the blue.

Yeah, Jamie's dad pulled the life support.

Everybody knows what NYPD means - heck I'm not even American and I know. 

[ribboninthesky1]

On 6/23/2023 at 12:17 AM, christie said:

I always thought that the actor played Jamie as having a crush on Jet. Now Jet being interested in Jamie was completely out of the blue.

And not just interested...she told him ILY.  I was NOT supposed to be laughing at that, I am certain.

[christie]

4 hours ago, ribboninthesky1 said:

And not just interested...she told him ILY. 

She did? Ok I guess that shows how much attention I pay lol

[ribboninthesky1]

It was totally out of left field.  It was only a few episodes before that she was "in love" with that Seamus character, so I have no idea what the writers were thinking. Don't know if the Jamie actor wanted out or was let go, but from my perspective, he got the better end of the bargain.  This show is a mess. 

[txhorns79]

Just a reminder everyone, we made a decision last year that this particular show would not have individual episode threads for each new episode.  Instead, we are using this thread to discuss any and all new episodes of the show going forward.  Please do not create a new episode thread.  Your comments from the thread created for the first episode of Season 4 have been moved here.  Any questions, please let me know @txhorns79.

[The Wild Sow]

Oh, great -- I can't look at Dean Norris (Randall) without seeing Detective Lee Scanlon's "bad guy" brother, Paul, from Medium.

Yeah, I see he was on Breaking Bad, but I didn't watch that show -- so Paul Scanlon it is.  Is he going to specialize in playing good cop's bad guy brother?