gibasi

Finally an episode I liked. Because it had a horse! And I liked the factoids about the horse. I don't care about Marisa and her son. Why do they continue to have two unrelated stories in one episode? Plug some of the holes in your main story or just fill it in more. It could stand for more character development. The angry ex turned into a good guy in a millisecond from one comment by Alec. smh

I don't watch a lot of reality shows and have never seen Rob before. I liked him and will miss him. Why does everyone hate him so much? Danielle can go any time now. I am not sure who to root for now.

I am ready to give up on this show. It has taken me two weeks to watch this episode and I still have tis week's episode to go. I have been watching because of Jesse L Martin. But the stories just aren't that good. I can't ding any of the actors in the episodes. There is just too much out there that I like better.

In 10 years no one noticed the wall Plate? And they all acted like the murder happened yesterday so the house would still be exactly the same. Ridiculous story. Kaitlin Olsen carries the show and even she couldn't make this episode work.

I didn’t like this episode at all. It was too much exposition. It seemed to be just Karodec, Morgan and Soto standing around talking. Except when you had Daphne and Oz back at the station sitting on a couch and talking. The murder mystery was just not that interesting or difficult. Were they trying to go for a Knives Out vibe? It just didn’t work for me. Like a couple of others have said the whole thing was just too far fetched. Not that other episodes haven’t stretched reality but in this one I could not overlook it. It just was not a fun episode.

Egypt is my favorite and I hope he wins. My second favorite would be Hannah and then Kyle. Hannah has impressed Gordon with her innovative combinations and I doubt her piercings would be a factor one way or another. Once Kyle was in charge last night he was all business and showed what he could do. Really I think any of the three would be a good pick for his head chef.

Yes, it is. Especially with magicians. It seems I have seen this same story elsewhere and more than once. So I was impatient with the episode. And why do they feel they have to shoehorn every character into the story? Except for Simon this time.

Egypt's been my favorite since I figured out who was who. I also like Hannah. If either one of them wins I will be happy.

I agree chaifan. I thought it was off too. Maybe it's just me and I am already over the whole show. The impracticality of her wardrobe really bugs me. I missed her family as well. The story was a miss too. Overall too much handwaving. I was looking forward to its return but the magic wasn't there for me in this episode.

I think possibilities accurately pinpointed all the things wrong with the show. I especially hated the villain of the piece. They didn't have to make Scott Wolfe's character an actual villain. There is enough drama in his being appointed chief, a job she formerly had and presumably will want back. It is the first episode and I hope they dial it back a bit. I think it is a good idea but hope the whole thing becomes more plausible.

That was really low of Daisy to throw Dani under the bus like that. And in front of everyone. It doesn't matter if everyone else knew, Daisy outed Dani because she is petty.

I will not watch a second season. As it was I fast forwarded through so much of every episode including the finale. I thought it was crazy that Tony got a vote. And seeing Amy again (and of course she was crying) made me remember how much I disliked her. I was rooting for either Nick or Punkin to get the extra money. So it was a good end for me. Therron was just too needy as far as I was concerned.

I want to like this show more than I do. I like all of the characters and the writers do too. So they try and make them fit into every episode. It just lacks cohesion. Marisa didn't need to be in tis episode at all. And now I hear Rayna, her new boss is going to be a regular? I think the show needs a tighter focus. Alec is your main and the focus should be there. I like the Alec and Rose story. I like seeing Kylie as she and Alec interact and their sibling bond. I like Alec as mentor to the assistants. And Alec with Marisa. But when they show us all these side characters unrelated to Alec it breaks down for me. By shoe horning everyone in to every episode it makes for a messy disjointed story.

I agree with everything you said. This was a terrible episode. I am in no hurry to watch tonight's episode.

It's becoming uncomfortable to watch. Gary is an alcoholic and needs an intervention. He was cast for the drama and being on the show encourages his self destructive behavior. He should not have been cast. Daisy just wants to room with Gary. Their relationship isn't complicated, it's toxic. Danni is so full of herself. Diana is skeletal thin. Not much of Cloyce in this episode so I guess he is behaving himself. I didn't watch the season where Chase was on. I don't see why Danni and Diana are acting like he is the most gorgeous man on earth. He looks pretty basic to me.