Jump to content

Type keyword(s) to search

Gilmore Girls Elimination Game

mstaken

By mstaken
in Gilmore Girls

  • Reply
  • Start Topic

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 11.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Taryn74

    2151

  • lulu1960

    1948

  • Kohola3

    1531

  • ghoulina

    1376

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Popular Posts

amensisterfriend
amensisterfriend

I love Rory's speech, but I think I'll vote against 20. One of the things that makes GG so special to me is how much poignancy they can wring from really subtle, understated moments. Rory's sweet and

lulu1960
lulu1960

Well if there are no more votes with a score of 6 to 4  Jess squeaks past Emily. #45 wins. Although both are winners in my book

Taryn74
Taryn74

My entire life is a lie.

Posted Images

amensisterfriend

amensisterfriend

23. Rory and Richard saunter off together after pranking Logan with engagement bit is our S5 winner! Here are our S6 scenes so far:

S6:

 

1. Rory and Lorelai reunite on the front lawn of the CS with a huge hug ("Oh, kid, you have no idea...) (TPDR)

2. Rory stays by Logan's side in the hospital and each blames themselves for Logan's accident while Logan assures her he's going to get better, and not just physically 

3. Lorelai assures Emily she hasn't lost them and talks her out of buying a jet to fill her emptiness (The Prodigal Daughter Returns)

4. Jess gives Rory a copy of his book and tells her he couldn't have done it without her; she says she always knew he was capable of great things (LMHYBRO)

5. Lorelai is ecstatic that Rory called the diner to follow up on the invitation to her birthday party (21ITLN), clearly hopeful for an imminent reconciliation

6. Rory and Paris bond over a planned life of "no men, just lots and lots of Chinese food" (I'm OK, You're OK)

7. Richard leaves the dollhouse on the porch for Lorelai

8. Jess says he knows Rory and knows "this isn't YOU," clearly getting through to her (LMHYBRO)

9. When Luke tells Rory that he and her mom are engaged. (Fight Face)

10. Luke taking care of Paul Anka and making him scrambled eggs after he gets sick. (UnGraduate)

Hep Alien reuniting in time for Lane and Zach's wedding and Zach singing I'm a Believer to Lane

11. Logan helping Rory save the paper from almost not coming out. (FNAFF)

12. Rory being unanimously elected editor of the Yale Daily News. (You've Been Gilmored)

13. Luke insisting that he loves Lorelai and they WILL get married (Vineyard Valentine)

14. Zack asking Mrs Kim to marry Lane, and writing a song together. (I'm OK You're OK)

15. Mrs. Kim telling Lane she's going to go to bed and wear earplugs during their wedding reception. (IGASOOY)

16. Rory introducing Luke as her stepfather to be at her 21st and the look on Luke's face.

17. Rory and Logan fighting over the paper over breakfast at Martha's Vineyard.

18. Hep Alien reuniting in time for Lane and Zach's wedding and Zach singing I'm a Believer to Lane

Link to comment
amensisterfriend

amensisterfriend

1. Rory and Lorelai reunite on the front lawn of the CS with a huge hug ("Oh, kid, you have no idea...) (TPDR)

2. Rory stays by Logan's side in the hospital and each blames themselves for Logan's accident while Logan assures her he's going to get better, and not just physically 

3. Lorelai assures Emily she hasn't lost them and talks her out of buying a jet to fill her emptiness (The Prodigal Daughter Returns)

4. Jess gives Rory a copy of his book and tells her he couldn't have done it without her; she says she always knew he was capable of great things (LMHYBRO)

5. Lorelai is ecstatic that Rory called the diner to follow up on the invitation to her birthday party (21ITLN), clearly hopeful for an imminent reconciliation

6. Rory and Paris bond over a planned life of "no men, just lots and lots of Chinese food" (I'm OK, You're OK)

7. Richard leaves the dollhouse on the porch for Lorelai

8. Jess says he knows Rory and knows "this isn't YOU," clearly getting through to her (LMHYBRO)

9. When Luke tells Rory that he and her mom are engaged. (Fight Face)

10. Luke taking care of Paul Anka and making him scrambled eggs after he gets sick. (UnGraduate)

11. Hep Alien reuniting in time for Lane and Zach's wedding and Zach singing I'm a Believer to Lane

12. Logan helping Rory save the paper from almost not coming out. (FNAFF)

13. Rory being unanimously elected editor of the Yale Daily News. (You've Been Gilmored)

14. Luke insisting that he loves Lorelai and they WILL get married (Vineyard Valentine)

15. Zack asking Mrs Kim to marry Lane, and writing a song together. (I'm OK You're OK)

16. Mrs. Kim telling Lane she's going to go to bed and wear earplugs during their wedding reception. (IGASOOY)

17. Rory introducing Luke as her stepfather to be at her 21st and the look on Luke's face.

18. Rory and Logan fighting over the paper over breakfast at Martha's Vineyard.

19. Hep Alien reuniting in time for Lane and Zach's wedding and Zach singing I'm a Believer to Lane

20. Luke giving Rory his mother's pearls for her 21st birthday.

21. Mrs. Kim pulling out her secret hooch to have a talk with Lane.

22. Rory and Lane overcoming initial awkwardness by admitting they miss each other and hugging (Always a Godmother)

23. Luke and Lorelai having breakfast in bed and talking about the fact that they may have been at Harvey's Beach at the same time.

24. Luke telling Lorelai she can pull sausages out of him.

25. Luke comforting Lorelai when Paul Anka is sick. "You are not a bad mother." 

I consolidated the list and added one more of my own :) Just start voting against the THREE you most want eliminated whenever you're ready :)

Link to comment
Taryn74

Taryn74

19 is a repeat of 11, which will affect some who have voted already.  :)

My votes -

13. Rory being unanimously elected editor of the Yale Daily News. (You've Been Gilmored) -- Ugh

18. Rory and Logan fighting over the paper over breakfast at Martha's Vineyard. -- Hate everything about this episode.

22. Rory and Lane overcoming initial awkwardness by admitting they miss each other and hugging (Always a Godmother) -- Only because I have no recollection of this one.

Link to comment
Taryn74

Taryn74

1 hour ago, amensisterfriend said:

 

Ugh, I am the worst. Can someone less numerically clueless fix the list?! 

LOL, no biggie.  I'll just take out 19 and leave the rest of the numbers as they are so it doesn't screw you up counting votes.  Just know when you count that votes for 11 and 19 are for the same scene.

 

1. Rory and Lorelai reunite on the front lawn of the CS with a huge hug ("Oh, kid, you have no idea...) (TPDR)

2. Rory stays by Logan's side in the hospital and each blames themselves for Logan's accident while Logan assures her he's going to get better, and not just physically 

3. Lorelai assures Emily she hasn't lost them and talks her out of buying a jet to fill her emptiness (The Prodigal Daughter Returns)

4. Jess gives Rory a copy of his book and tells her he couldn't have done it without her; she says she always knew he was capable of great things (LMHYBRO)

5. Lorelai is ecstatic that Rory called the diner to follow up on the invitation to her birthday party (21ITLN), clearly hopeful for an imminent reconciliation

6. Rory and Paris bond over a planned life of "no men, just lots and lots of Chinese food" (I'm OK, You're OK)

7. Richard leaves the dollhouse on the porch for Lorelai

8. Jess says he knows Rory and knows "this isn't YOU," clearly getting through to her (LMHYBRO)

9. When Luke tells Rory that he and her mom are engaged. (Fight Face)

10. Luke taking care of Paul Anka and making him scrambled eggs after he gets sick. (UnGraduate)

11. Hep Alien reuniting in time for Lane and Zach's wedding and Zach singing I'm a Believer to Lane

12. Logan helping Rory save the paper from almost not coming out. (FNAFF)

13. Rory being unanimously elected editor of the Yale Daily News. (You've Been Gilmored)

14. Luke insisting that he loves Lorelai and they WILL get married (Vineyard Valentine)

15. Zack asking Mrs Kim to marry Lane, and writing a song together. (I'm OK You're OK)

16. Mrs. Kim telling Lane she's going to go to bed and wear earplugs during their wedding reception. (IGASOOY)

17. Rory introducing Luke as her stepfather to be at her 21st and the look on Luke's face.

18. Rory and Logan fighting over the paper over breakfast at Martha's Vineyard.

20. Luke giving Rory his mother's pearls for her 21st birthday.

21. Mrs. Kim pulling out her secret hooch to have a talk with Lane.

22. Rory and Lane overcoming initial awkwardness by admitting they miss each other and hugging (Always a Godmother)

23. Luke and Lorelai having breakfast in bed and talking about the fact that they may have been at Harvey's Beach at the same time.

24. Luke telling Lorelai she can pull sausages out of him.

25. Luke comforting Lorelai when Paul Anka is sick. "You are not a bad mother."

  • Love 1
Link to comment
amensisterfriend

amensisterfriend

(edited)

Welcome, Lady C.! 

Sorry again about my screwup, and bless Taryn74 for swooping in to rescue me from my own idiocy :) 

1. Rory and Lorelai reunite on the front lawn of the CS with a huge hug ("Oh, kid, you have no idea...) (TPDR)

2. Rory stays by Logan's side in the hospital and each blames themselves for Logan's accident while Logan assures her he's going to get better, and not just physically 

3. Lorelai assures Emily she hasn't lost them and talks her out of buying a jet to fill her emptiness (The Prodigal Daughter Returns)

4. Jess gives Rory a copy of his book and tells her he couldn't have done it without her; she says she always knew he was capable of great things (LMHYBRO)

5. Lorelai is ecstatic that Rory called the diner to follow up on the invitation to her birthday party (21ITLN), clearly hopeful for an imminent reconciliation

6. Rory and Paris bond over a planned life of "no men, just lots and lots of Chinese food" (I'm OK, You're OK)

7. Richard leaves the dollhouse on the porch for Lorelai

8. Jess says he knows Rory and knows "this isn't YOU," clearly getting through to her (LMHYBRO)

9. When Luke tells Rory that he and her mom are engaged. (Fight Face)

10. Luke taking care of Paul Anka and making him scrambled eggs after he gets sick. (UnGraduate)

11. Hep Alien reuniting in time for Lane and Zach's wedding and Zach singing I'm a Believer to Lane

12. Logan helping Rory save the paper from almost not coming out. (FNAFF)

14. Luke insisting that he loves Lorelai and they WILL get married (Vineyard Valentine)

15. Zack asking Mrs Kim to marry Lane, and writing a song together. (I'm OK You're OK)

16. Mrs. Kim telling Lane she's going to go to bed and wear earplugs during their wedding reception. (IGASOOY)

17. Rory introducing Luke as her stepfather to be at her 21st and the look on Luke's face.

20. Luke giving Rory his mother's pearls for her 21st birthday.

21. Mrs. Kim pulling out her secret hooch to have a talk with Lane.

23. Luke and Lorelai having breakfast in bed and talking about the fact that they may have been at Harvey's Beach at the same time.

24. Luke telling Lorelai she can pull sausages out of him.

25. Luke comforting Lorelai when Paul Anka is sick. "You are not a bad mother."

 

I am once again on my own island here---I loved 22 :) It's now gone along with 13 and 18, and the next round is open. We're still voting against THREE!

Edited by amensisterfriend
Link to comment
Taryn74

Taryn74

56 minutes ago, amensisterfriend said:

I am once again on my own island here---I loved 22

I probably would have loved it too, had I been able to remember it.  Heh.  I probably should have at least looked at the transcript to see if I remembered the scene at all, but honestly I just can't be bothered with S6 and S7.  ASP and her shenanigans finally broke me, and I have never recovered.

Moving on.

2, 6, 12

  • Love 3
Link to comment
amensisterfriend

amensisterfriend

1. Rory and Lorelai reunite on the front lawn of the CS with a huge hug ("Oh, kid, you have no idea...) (TPDR)

3. Lorelai assures Emily she hasn't lost them and talks her out of buying a jet to fill her emptiness (The Prodigal Daughter Returns)

4. Jess gives Rory a copy of his book and tells her he couldn't have done it without her; she says she always knew he was capable of great things (LMHYBRO)

5. Lorelai is ecstatic that Rory called the diner to follow up on the invitation to her birthday party (21ITLN), clearly hopeful for an imminent reconciliation

7. Richard leaves the dollhouse on the porch for Lorelai

8. Jess says he knows Rory and knows "this isn't YOU," clearly getting through to her (LMHYBRO)

9. When Luke tells Rory that he and her mom are engaged. (Fight Face)

10. Luke taking care of Paul Anka and making him scrambled eggs after he gets sick. (UnGraduate)

11. Hep Alien reuniting in time for Lane and Zach's wedding and Zach singing I'm a Believer to Lane

14. Luke insisting that he loves Lorelai and they WILL get married (Vineyard Valentine)

15. Zack asking Mrs Kim to marry Lane, and writing a song together. (I'm OK You're OK)

16. Mrs. Kim telling Lane she's going to go to bed and wear earplugs during their wedding reception. (IGASOOY)

17. Rory introducing Luke as her stepfather to be at her 21st and the look on Luke's face.

20. Luke giving Rory his mother's pearls for her 21st birthday.

21. Mrs. Kim pulling out her secret hooch to have a talk with Lane.

23. Luke and Lorelai having breakfast in bed and talking about the fact that they may have been at Harvey's Beach at the same time.

24. Luke telling Lorelai she can pull sausages out of him.

25. Luke comforting Lorelai when Paul Anka is sick. "You are not a bad mother."

 

I always feel like 6 would have been more effective if both Rory and Paris hadn't eagerly reconciled with the men in question, like, 30 seconds after their "no men!" declaration :) 2, 6 and 12 have gotten the boot, and the next round is open. We're still voting against three! 

Link to comment
amensisterfriend

amensisterfriend

1. Rory and Lorelai reunite on the front lawn of the CS with a huge hug ("Oh, kid, you have no idea...) (TPDR)

3. Lorelai assures Emily she hasn't lost them and talks her out of buying a jet to fill her emptiness (The Prodigal Daughter Returns)

4. Jess gives Rory a copy of his book and tells her he couldn't have done it without her; she says she always knew he was capable of great things (LMHYBRO)

5. Lorelai is ecstatic that Rory called the diner to follow up on the invitation to her birthday party (21ITLN), clearly hopeful for an imminent reconciliation

7. Richard leaves the dollhouse on the porch for Lorelai

8. Jess says he knows Rory and knows "this isn't YOU," clearly getting through to her (LMHYBRO)

9. When Luke tells Rory that he and her mom are engaged. (Fight Face)

10. Luke taking care of Paul Anka and making him scrambled eggs after he gets sick. (UnGraduate)

15. Zack asking Mrs Kim to marry Lane, and writing a song together. (I'm OK You're OK)

16. Mrs. Kim telling Lane she's going to go to bed and wear earplugs during their wedding reception. (IGASOOY)

17. Rory introducing Luke as her stepfather to be at her 21st and the look on Luke's face.

20. Luke giving Rory his mother's pearls for her 21st birthday.

21. Mrs. Kim pulling out her secret hooch to have a talk with Lane.

24. Luke telling Lorelai she can pull sausages out of him.

25. Luke comforting Lorelai when Paul Anka is sick. "You are not a bad mother."

 

11, 14 and 23 are gone, and the next round is open! This is the last time we're voting against three :)

Link to comment

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...