Gilmore Girls Elimination Game

[lulu1960]

1 (I agree with Taryn, it is a very nice visual but I like others more)

11

[nolieblue]

Especially after what ASP did in S6 and if that was her plan all along, the chuppah shot seems just mean in retrospect. 

[amensisterfriend]

I'll vote against 1 and 11, so those two are gone...and the next round is open :) We're down to voting against just one:

 

2. Luke and Lorelai sit on the porch discussing finding the right person. (Red Light)
4. Lorelai goes to Louie's funeral with Luke. "That's not me is it?" (Dead Uncles)
7. "Always in your life, forever. "You do." Luke and Lorelai at the diner after Romeo and Juliet (Run Away, Little Boy)
8. "This is nice." Sharing the picnic. (A Tisket)
15. Luke welcomes back a newly single Lorelai and encourages her to pursue her dream of opening her own inn (Road Trip to Harvard)
22. Luke is fixing Gilbert and telling Lorelai she can handle opening her own inn (Ins and Outs of Inns)

Edited September 8, 2014 by amensisterfriend

[Taryn74]

8.  Because it was nice, until the jealous one showed up and ruined it.

[nolieblue]

7 It kind of bugged me that Lorelai knew that Luke was into her but still wanted to have his adoration. 

 

Taryn, so agree on number 8!

[amensisterfriend]

8! 

(Taryn convinced me!) 

[AlinaRay]

8

[lulu1960]

15 (I get what you mean about 8 but I will just ignore Dean)

[Kohola3]

15

[amensisterfriend]

2. Luke and Lorelai sit on the porch discussing finding the right person. (Red Light)
4. Lorelai goes to Louie's funeral with Luke. "That's not me is it?" (Dead Uncles)
7. "Always in your life, forever. "You do." Luke and Lorelai at the diner after Romeo and Juliet (Run Away, Little Boy)
15. Luke welcomes back a newly single Lorelai and encourages her to pursue her dream of opening her own inn (Road Trip to Harvard)
22. Luke is fixing Gilbert and telling Lorelai she can handle opening her own inn (Ins and Outs of Inns)

 

8 is gone, and the next round is open! 

[Taryn74]

7

[AlinaRay]

4

[Kohola3]

15

[lulu1960]

15

[amensisterfriend]

22 (as far as 'Luke supporting Lorelai's dream of opening an inn' scenes go, I love 15 even more than 22!) 

[nolieblue]

7

[amensisterfriend]

We have a tie between 7 and 15! Just vote for the one of those two that you most want eliminated... 

[Taryn74]

7

[amensisterfriend]

I love both 7 and 15 so much, but I'll vote against 7 also to move us along. The next round is open! 

 

2. Luke and Lorelai sit on the porch discussing finding the right person. (Red Light)
4. Lorelai goes to Louie's funeral with Luke. "That's not me is it?" (Dead Uncles)
15. Luke welcomes back a newly single Lorelai and encourages her to pursue her dream of opening her own inn (Road Trip to Harvard)
22. Luke is fixing Gilbert and telling Lorelai she can handle opening her own inn (Ins and Outs of Inns)

[Taryn74]

22

[amensisterfriend]

22 

[Kohola3]

15

[lulu1960]

15

[nolieblue]

15

[amensisterfriend]

2. Luke and Lorelai sit on the porch discussing finding the right person. (Red Light)
4. Lorelai goes to Louie's funeral with Luke. "That's not me is it?" (Dead Uncles)
22. Luke is fixing Gilbert and telling Lorelai she can handle opening her own inn (Ins and Outs of Inns)

 

15 (*sob*) is gone, and the next round is open! Also, feel free to start listing your favorite L/L scenes from Season 3 :) 

 

My vote: 22

[lulu1960]

22

[Taryn74]

22

[amensisterfriend]

A few S3 L/L scenes to get us started:

 

Luke tells "Mimi" to come again and hands her a donut as they subtly reconcile from their fight (LHCDS) 

Luke tries to get a sick Lorelai to eat chicken soup (Haunted Leg)

Luke teases Lorelai about her "relationship" with Kirk (Haunted Leg)

Lorelai threatens Lorelai with her Louie Armstrong impersonation if he doesn't speak at the school (One Has Class)

Lorelai faux swoons over "Butch" Danes (One Has Class)

Luke fixes Lorelai's shoe and awkwardly explains that maybe he would want kids...with the right person (TSG,DT)

Lorelai tells a happily surprised Luke that Jess and Rory have started dating (Let the Games Begin)

Lorelai calmly informs Luke, who's proud of what close tabs he'll keep on Jess, that Jess and Rory are together right at that moment (LtGB)

When Lorelai sees that Luke is disappointed at the possibility of not having Thanksgiving with Lorelai and Rory, she pretends their plans just changed (ADFKT)

Jess indicates that Luke was waiting for Lorelai and Rory to arrive (ADFKT)

 Luke teaches Lorelai how to fish (Lorelai Out of Water)

Lorelai sleeps over at Luke's ("dream tramp!") (Poes and Fire)

Luke is thrilled at Lorelai and Rory's news that she got accepted to all of her chosen colleges and shyly tells Lorelai about Jess getting Employee of the Month 

Luke comes over to the CS to do Lorelai's list of chores in honor of her birthday (best gift EVER, by the way!)

Luke lurks on Lorelai's porch and eagerly gets her attention to tell her that Jess has left town (HCtS)

Luke is among those totally NOT crying at Rory's graduation (TASP)

Luke dreams of Lorelai telling him not to go on that cruise with Nicole (TASP) 

Edited September 11, 2014 by amensisterfriend

[Kohola3]

22

[nolieblue]

22

[lulu1960]

Luke know an awful lot about the different sweater colors Lorelai has. "You’ve got the purple, you’ve got the powder blue, you’ve got three shades of red, you’ve got a ton of black, all of which will go with that coat. Plus, you’ve got a dozen scarves to mix and match with any of those tops." (Swan Song)

Luke tells Lorelai about his system of going upstairs to check on Rory and Jess (Swan Song)

[amensisterfriend]

22 is gone, and we're down to our final two! 

 

2. Luke and Lorelai sit on the porch discussing finding the right person. (Red Light)
4. Lorelai goes to Louie's funeral with Luke. "That's not me is it?" (Dead Uncles)

 

My vote: 2 (Lulu has transformed me into a DUAV fan!) 

[nolieblue]

4. Mostly because I love love love the French food line in 2. :)

[Taryn74]

2

 

I LOVE DUAV.

[lulu1960]

2 DUAV is my fave

[Kohola3]

2  Ditto on the Dead Uncle love!

[amensisterfriend]

4. Lorelai goes to Louie's funeral with Luke. "That's not me is it?" (Dead Uncles)

 

...is our triumphant S2 winner! Here's the list if S3 scenes. Feel free to add to it before we start voting!

 

1. Luke tells "Mimi" to come again and hands her a donut as they subtly reconcile from their fight (LHCDS)
2. Luke tries to get a sick Lorelai to eat chicken soup (Haunted Leg)
3. Luke teases Lorelai about her "relationship" with Kirk (Haunted Leg)
4. Lorelai threatens Lorelai with her Louie Armstrong impersonation if he doesn't speak at the school (One Has Class)
5. Lorelai faux swoons over "Butch" Danes (One Has Class)
6. Luke fixes Lorelai's shoe and awkwardly explains that maybe he would want kids...with the right person (TSG,DT)
7. Lorelai tells a happily surprised Luke that Jess and Rory have started dating (Let the Games Begin)
8. Lorelai calmly informs Luke, who's proud of what close tabs he'll keep on Jess, that Jess and Rory are together right at that moment (LtGB)
9. When Lorelai sees that Luke is disappointed at the possibility of not having Thanksgiving with Lorelai and Rory, she pretends their plans just changed (ADFKT)
10. Jess indicates that Luke was waiting for Lorelai and Rory to arrive (ADFKT)
11. Luke teaches Lorelai how to fish (Lorelai Out of Water)
12. Lorelai sleeps over at Luke's ("dream tramp!") (Poes and Fire)
13. Luke is thrilled at Lorelai and Rory's news that she got accepted to all of her chosen colleges and shyly tells Lorelai about Jess getting Employee of the Month
14. Luke comes over to the CS to do Lorelai's list of chores in honor of her birthday (best gift EVER, by the way!)
15. Luke lurks on Lorelai's porch and eagerly gets her attention to tell her that Jess has left town (HCtS)
16. Luke is among those totally NOT crying at Rory's graduation (TASP)
17. Luke dreams of Lorelai telling him not to go on that cruise with Nicole (TASP)

18. Luke know an awful lot about the different sweater colors Lorelai has. "You’ve got the purple, you’ve got the powder blue, you’ve got three shades of red, you’ve got a ton of black, all of which will go with that coat. Plus, you’ve got a dozen scarves to mix and match with any of those tops." (Swan Song)
19. Luke tells Lorelai about his system of going upstairs to check on Rory and Jess (Swan Song)

[Taryn74]

20.  Luke wants Lorelai to go tell the mom to stop breastfeeding in the diner because she's a woman and "not scared of it" - Eight O'clock at the Oasis

[amensisterfriend]

1. Luke tells "Mimi" to come again and hands her a donut as they subtly reconcile from their fight (LHCDS)
2. Luke tries to get a sick Lorelai to eat chicken soup (Haunted Leg)
3. Luke teases Lorelai about her "relationship" with Kirk (Haunted Leg)
4. Lorelai threatens Lorelai with her Louie Armstrong impersonation if he doesn't speak at the school (One Has Class)
5. Lorelai faux swoons over "Butch" Danes (One Has Class)
6. Luke fixes Lorelai's shoe and awkwardly explains that maybe he would want kids...with the right person (TSG,DT)
7. Lorelai tells a happily surprised Luke that Jess and Rory have started dating (Let the Games Begin)
8. Lorelai calmly informs Luke, who's proud of what close tabs he'll keep on Jess, that Jess and Rory are together right at that moment (LtGB)
9. When Lorelai sees that Luke is disappointed at the possibility of not having Thanksgiving with Lorelai and Rory, she pretends their plans just changed (ADFKT)
10. Jess indicates that Luke was waiting for Lorelai and Rory to arrive (ADFKT)
11. Luke teaches Lorelai how to fish (Lorelai Out of Water)
12. Lorelai sleeps over at Luke's ("dream tramp!") (Poes and Fire)
13. Luke is thrilled at Lorelai and Rory's news that she got accepted to all of her chosen colleges and shyly tells Lorelai about Jess getting Employee of the Month
14. Luke comes over to the CS to do Lorelai's list of chores in honor of her birthday (best gift EVER, by the way!)
15. Luke lurks on Lorelai's porch and eagerly gets her attention to tell her that Jess has left town (HCtS)
16. Luke is among those totally NOT crying at Rory's graduation (TASP)
17. Luke dreams of Lorelai telling him not to go on that cruise with Nicole (TASP)
18. Luke know an awful lot about the different sweater colors Lorelai has. "You’ve got the purple, you’ve got the powder blue, you’ve got three shades of red, you’ve got a ton of black, all of which will go with that coat. Plus, you’ve got a dozen scarves to mix and match with any of those tops." (Swan Song)
19. Luke tells Lorelai about his system of going upstairs to check on Rory and Jess (Swan Song)

20.  Luke wants Lorelai to go tell the mom to stop breastfeeding in the diner because she's a woman and "not scared of it" - Eight O'clock at the Oasis

 

Let's start voting! Just pick the three you most want eliminated :) 

[nolieblue]

4, 11, 20

[amensisterfriend]

I'll go with 4, 7 and 20 

[Taryn74]

4, 7, and 20 here too

[lulu1960]

2, 7, 20

[amensisterfriend]

1. Luke tells "Mimi" to come again and hands her a donut as they subtly reconcile from their fight (LHCDS)
2. Luke tries to get a sick Lorelai to eat chicken soup (Haunted Leg)
3. Luke teases Lorelai about her "relationship" with Kirk (Haunted Leg)
5. Lorelai faux swoons over "Butch" Danes (One Has Class)
6. Luke fixes Lorelai's shoe and awkwardly explains that maybe he would want kids...with the right person (TSG,DT)
8. Lorelai calmly informs Luke, who's proud of what close tabs he'll keep on Jess, that Jess and Rory are together right at that moment (LtGB)
9. When Lorelai sees that Luke is disappointed at the possibility of not having Thanksgiving with Lorelai and Rory, she pretends their plans just changed (ADFKT)
10. Jess indicates that Luke was waiting for Lorelai and Rory to arrive (ADFKT)
11. Luke teaches Lorelai how to fish (Lorelai Out of Water)
12. Lorelai sleeps over at Luke's ("dream tramp!") (Poes and Fire)
13. Luke is thrilled at Lorelai and Rory's news that she got accepted to all of her chosen colleges and shyly tells Lorelai about Jess getting Employee of the Month
14. Luke comes over to the CS to do Lorelai's list of chores in honor of her birthday (best gift EVER, by the way!)
15. Luke lurks on Lorelai's porch and eagerly gets her attention to tell her that Jess has left town (HCtS)
16. Luke is among those totally NOT crying at Rory's graduation (TASP)
17. Luke dreams of Lorelai telling him not to go on that cruise with Nicole (TASP)
18. Luke know an awful lot about the different sweater colors Lorelai has. "You’ve got the purple, you’ve got the powder blue, you’ve got three shades of red, you’ve got a ton of black, all of which will go with that coat. Plus, you’ve got a dozen scarves to mix and match with any of those tops." (Swan Song)
19. Luke tells Lorelai about his system of going upstairs to check on Rory and Jess (Swan Song)

 

4, 7 and 20 are gone, and the next round is open! We're still voting against three :) 

[nolieblue]

5, 11 and 15

[lulu1960]

2, 18, 15

[Kohola3]

3, 5, 11

[Taryn74]

2, 11, 15

[amensisterfriend]

I'll go with 5, 11 and 15 too, which means those are our latest casualties. The next round is open! 

 

1. Luke tells "Mimi" to come again and hands her a donut as they subtly reconcile from their fight (LHCDS)
2. Luke tries to get a sick Lorelai to eat chicken soup (Haunted Leg)
3. Luke teases Lorelai about her "relationship" with Kirk (Haunted Leg)
6. Luke fixes Lorelai's shoe and awkwardly explains that maybe he would want kids...with the right person (TSG,DT)
8. Lorelai calmly informs Luke, who's proud of what close tabs he'll keep on Jess, that Jess and Rory are together right at that moment (LtGB)
9. When Lorelai sees that Luke is disappointed at the possibility of not having Thanksgiving with Lorelai and Rory, she pretends their plans just changed (ADFKT)
10. Jess indicates that Luke was waiting for Lorelai and Rory to arrive (ADFKT)
12. Lorelai sleeps over at Luke's ("dream tramp!") (Poes and Fire)
13. Luke is thrilled at Lorelai and Rory's news that she got accepted to all of her chosen colleges and shyly tells Lorelai about Jess getting Employee of the Month
14. Luke comes over to the CS to do Lorelai's list of chores in honor of her birthday (best gift EVER, by the way!)
16. Luke is among those totally NOT crying at Rory's graduation (TASP)
17. Luke dreams of Lorelai telling him not to go on that cruise with Nicole (TASP)
18. Luke know an awful lot about the different sweater colors Lorelai has. "You’ve got the purple, you’ve got the powder blue, you’ve got three shades of red, you’ve got a ton of black, all of which will go with that coat. Plus, you’ve got a dozen scarves to mix and match with any of those tops." (Swan Song)
19. Luke tells Lorelai about his system of going upstairs to check on Rory and Jess (Swan Song)

 

We can switch to voting against just two :) 

[nolieblue]

8 and 19