amensisterfriend July 19, 2016 Author Share July 19, 2016 Our terrific---er, terrible (they are demons, after all)---three :) Belthazor The Seer Evil Wyatt Link to comment
Lady Calypso July 19, 2016 Share July 19, 2016 The Seer (she really annoyed me by the end of her run). Link to comment
amensisterfriend July 19, 2016 Author Share July 19, 2016 I'll break the tie by voting against Belth, and we're down to our final two! The Seer Evil Wyatt Meanwhile, I think we said we were doing relationships next...? It probably makes sense to do romantic relationships and then platonic ones. Here's what I have so far for the romantic round: Prue/Andy Prue/Bane Prue/Jack Prue/Justin Prue/Micah (aka guy from All Halliwell's Eve who reappeared at 'Micth'in modern times) Piper/Leo Piper/Mark Chao Piper/Dan Piper/Jeremy Piper/Greg Phoebe/Cole Phoebe/Coop Phoebe/Clay Phoebe/Miles Phoebe/Jason Phoebe/Leslie Phoebe/Drake Phoebe/Dex Paige/Henry Paige/Glen Paige/Richard Paige/Kyle Link to comment
Not Beth July 19, 2016 Share July 19, 2016 The Seer. Lol, Phoebe really has the longest list of romantic relationships out of the four sisters. Link to comment
amensisterfriend July 19, 2016 Author Share July 19, 2016 Okay, so congratulations to Evil Wyatt for being voted the best/worst demon of all :) Here's our list of romantic relationships. Just vote for the three you most want eliminated! And thanks to all who play this game---it's such a fun and desperately needed distraction for me! Prue/Andy Prue/Bane Prue/Jack Prue/Justin Prue/Micah (aka guy from All Halliwell's Eve who reappeared at 'Micth'in modern times) Piper/Leo Piper/Mark Chao Piper/Dan Piper/Jeremy Piper/Greg Phoebe/Cole Phoebe/Coop Phoebe/Clay Phoebe/Miles Phoebe/Jason Phoebe/Leslie Phoebe/Drake Phoebe/Dex Paige/Henry Paige/Glen Paige/Richard Paige/Kyle Link to comment
Kohola3 July 19, 2016 Share July 19, 2016 Gosh, I don't remember a whole lot of these dudes. Who the heck is Bane? Or Jack? Or Justin? Since I don't recall any of them (apparently only Andy made an impression), I will go with Prue/Bane/Jack/Justin. Link to comment
amensisterfriend July 19, 2016 Author Share July 19, 2016 Kohola, I can certainly see why you'd have repressed the horribly smug, obnoxious Jack Sheridan from S2 :) 1 Link to comment
Lady Calypso July 19, 2016 Share July 19, 2016 Who in the hell is Justin? I'll go with Prue/Jack/Justin (since I loathe Jack and don't know who Justin is) and.... Phoebe/Dex, since Dex ruined Phoebe for me in the first few episodes of season 8. Link to comment
amensisterfriend July 20, 2016 Author Share July 20, 2016 Justin is the guy who Prue (re)connected with at Piper's high school reunion in S3. We then saw him a few episodes later in Bride and Gloom. I thought he seemed nice and adorkable, but he ended up one of a few guys who Prue deemed too boring to continue dating past that episode. I kind of hate myself for knowing this stuff...I really need more of a life outside of my favorite TV shows :) I'll go with Phoebe/Coop (as you guys know, I recently watched S8 again, and while they didn't bug me quite as much this time, there's just something about Coop that I find so pushy, smug, arrogant, obnoxious etc., and their connection felt so forced to me), Prue/Jack and Phoebe/Dex Link to comment
amensisterfriend July 20, 2016 Author Share July 20, 2016 I totally thought Phoebe/Dex and Prue/Jack would be our final two! ;) I'm being sarcastic, of course, but the interesting thing about this round is that I actually have no clue who the top three will be, and usually I can at least take a guess. Oh, and the eminently forgettable Prue/Justin is gone as well. We're still voting against THREE: Prue/Andy Prue/Bane Prue/Micah (aka guy from All Halliwell's Eve who reappeared at 'Micth'in modern times) Piper/Leo Piper/Mark Chao Piper/Dan Piper/Jeremy Piper/Greg Phoebe/Cole Phoebe/Coop Phoebe/Clay Phoebe/Miles Phoebe/Jason Phoebe/Leslie Phoebe/Drake Paige/Henry Paige/Glen Paige/Richard Paige/Kyle Link to comment
Lady Calypso July 20, 2016 Share July 20, 2016 Well, I'm going with Piper/Dan (even on rewatch, I find that guy as dull as dishwater), Piper/Greg, and Phoebe/Leslie. Link to comment
amensisterfriend July 20, 2016 Author Share July 20, 2016 (edited) Piper/Greg, Piper/Dan and Phoebe/Coop Kohola, when you typed Dane, did you mean Piper/Dan or Prue/Bane?! Edited July 20, 2016 by amensisterfriend Link to comment
Kohola3 July 20, 2016 Share July 20, 2016 Oops. Prue/Bane. Another one of whom I have no recollection. Bad memory, the the bane of my existence (pun intended). 1 Link to comment
4evaQuez July 21, 2016 Share July 21, 2016 (edited) P/Dan, P/Greg, P/Leslie Edited July 21, 2016 by 4evaQuez Link to comment
amensisterfriend July 21, 2016 Author Share July 21, 2016 Prue/Andy Prue/Bane Prue/Micah (aka guy from All Halliwell's Eve who reappeared at 'Micth'in modern times) Piper/Leo Piper/Mark Chao Piper/Jeremy Phoebe/Cole Phoebe/Coop Phoebe/Clay Phoebe/Miles Phoebe/Jason Phoebe/Drake Paige/Henry Paige/Glen Paige/Richard Paige/Kyle The not-so-epic romances of Piper/Dan, Phoebe/Leslie and Piper/Greg have been put out to pasture, and the next round is open! We're still voting against three :) Link to comment
Lady Calypso July 21, 2016 Share July 21, 2016 Piper/Jeremy, Phoebe/Miles, Phoebe/Clay Link to comment
amensisterfriend July 21, 2016 Author Share July 21, 2016 Phoebe/Coop, Piper/Jeremy and Phoebe/Jason Link to comment
amensisterfriend July 21, 2016 Author Share July 21, 2016 I had this weird soft spot for Miles, despite or maybe because of how little we saw of him :) I love geeky guys, and he seemed endearing and sincere to me---an improvement over the more slick, somewhat smarmy guys Phoebe was usually paired with! Link to comment
amensisterfriend July 22, 2016 Author Share July 22, 2016 Prue/Andy Prue/Bane Prue/Micah (aka guy from All Halliwell's Eve who reappeared at 'Micth'in modern times) Piper/Leo Piper/Mark Chao Phoebe/Cole Phoebe/Coop Phoebe/Jason Phoebe/Drake Paige/Henry Paige/Glen Paige/Richard Paige/Kyle Piper/Jeremy, Phoebe/Clay and Phoebe/Miles have broken up permanently, and the next round is open! My votes: Prue/Bane, Phoebe/Jason, Phoebe/Coop Link to comment
amensisterfriend July 22, 2016 Author Share July 22, 2016 I'm so ridiculously influenced by you guys that I'm now convinced I should like Coop more than I think I do....I'll be rewatching their scenes this weekend :) 1 Link to comment
Kohola3 July 22, 2016 Share July 22, 2016 I don't get the Coop dislike. I quite liked him myself. I realize that he was the end game for the writers to tie everything up but I thought they were a good match in the end. But my UO, I guess. Link to comment
amensisterfriend July 23, 2016 Author Share July 23, 2016 Prue/Andy Prue/Micah (aka guy from All Halliwell's Eve who reappeared at 'Micth'in modern times) Piper/Leo Piper/Mark Chao Phoebe/Cole Phoebe/Drake Paige/Henry Paige/Glen Paige/Richard Paige/Kyle Prue/Bane, Phoebe/Jason and Phoebe/Coop are gone, and the next round is open! We're down to voting against just TWO :) Link to comment
Not Beth July 23, 2016 Share July 23, 2016 (edited) Micah, Glenn. Edited July 23, 2016 by Not Beth Forgot it was two and wrote three. Link to comment
amensisterfriend July 24, 2016 Author Share July 24, 2016 Prue/Andy Piper/Leo Piper/Mark Chao Phoebe/Cole Phoebe/Drake Paige/Henry Paige/Richard Paige/Kyle I'll vote against Micah and Glen too, though I have to admit I loved the idea of Micah---I think it would be fun seeing one of our generally very modern sisters date someone who's from a whole other era where norms, beliefs, ideas about gender etc are all very different! The next round is open, and I'll vote against Paige/Kyle (who, to be totally honest, I forgot was even still in the game!) and Paige/Richard Link to comment
Kohola3 July 24, 2016 Share July 24, 2016 Kyle, Richard. And I agree about Micah. It's too bad that they didn't have an arch with Micaj/Mitch. Plus he had gorgeous eyes. 1 Link to comment
amensisterfriend July 24, 2016 Author Share July 24, 2016 Plus he had gorgeous eyes. So now I have to go rewatch All Halliwell's Eve for the 15 billionth time! I must do some careful research on said eyes so that I can properly discuss these vitally important issues with my fellow Charmed fans :) Link to comment
amensisterfriend July 24, 2016 Author Share July 24, 2016 Prue/Andy Piper/Leo Piper/Mark Chao Phoebe/Cole Phoebe/Drake Paige/Henry Richard and Kyle are history, and the next round is open! We're down to voting against just ONE :) Link to comment
Recommended Posts