amensisterfriend August 21, 2016 Author Share August 21, 2016 I'll go with Hell Hath and Siren Song as well :) Link to comment
amensisterfriend August 22, 2016 Author Share August 22, 2016 Morality Bites (I'm not sure if this one counts, but Phoebe is a murderer in this one, so I thought maybe we should include it...?!) Pardon My Past (Phoebe is transported to the 1920s in the manor where she is to kill Prue and Piper.) Sin Fransisco (We could argue that they weren't technically evil here, but they WERE turned into beings totally driven by sin, so maybe we can count it! Long Live the Queen (Phoebe is Queen of the Underworld) Y Tu Mummy Tambien Centennial Charmed (Cole throws everyone into an alternate reality where Paige never existed.) Hell Hath and Siren Song are history, and we're down to voting against just one! Link to comment
amensisterfriend August 23, 2016 Author Share August 23, 2016 Sin (which may be my very favorite episode of the whole series for some reason---I can't even justify it!) is now history, and the next round is open! Morality Bites (I'm not sure if this one counts, but Phoebe is a murderer in this one, so I thought maybe we should include it...?!) Pardon My Past (Phoebe is transported to the 1920s in the manor where she is to kill Prue and Piper.) Long Live the Queen (Phoebe is Queen of the Underworld) Y Tu Mummy Tambien Centennial Charmed (Cole throws everyone into an alternate reality where Paige never existed.) Link to comment
Kohola3 August 23, 2016 Share August 23, 2016 Mummy. Apparently I'm the only one who dislikes it although InsaneCole was pretty darned good. 1 Link to comment
amensisterfriend August 24, 2016 Author Share August 24, 2016 Morality Bites (I'm not sure if this one counts, but Phoebe is a murderer in this one, so I thought maybe we should include it...?!) Long Live the Queen (Phoebe is Queen of the Underworld) Y Tu Mummy Tambien Centennial Charmed (Cole throws everyone into an alternate reality where Paige never existed.) I'll go against Pardon as well, and the next round is open! My vote: Mummy, and not just because I love Kohola and want to see her happy ;) Link to comment
Lady Calypso August 24, 2016 Share August 24, 2016 Man, I really do love Mummy; it might be my favourite season 5 episode, even above Centennial! But, I will also have to vote against it, just because I know Centennial's much more important! Link to comment
amensisterfriend August 25, 2016 Author Share August 25, 2016 And then there were three... Morality Bites (I'm not sure if this one counts, but Phoebe is a murderer in this one, so I thought maybe we should include it...?!) Long Live the Queen (Phoebe is Queen of the Underworld) Centennial Charmed (Cole throws everyone into an alternate reality where Paige never existed.) My vote: Morality Bites Link to comment
amensisterfriend August 25, 2016 Author Share August 25, 2016 (edited) Our terrific two! Long Live the Queen (Phoebe is Queen of the Underworld) Centennial Charmed (Cole throws everyone into an alternate reality where Paige never existed.) ...how can I choose between these two, both of which I adore beyond the telling of it?! I'll reluctantly vote against Centennial, because you could argue that some of it was a little anticlimactic given what we already saw in episodes like Long Live the Queen :) Meanwhile, what are we playing next? Edited August 25, 2016 by amensisterfriend Link to comment
Kohola3 August 25, 2016 Share August 25, 2016 I'm going with Queen. Totally shallow reason - hated Phoebe's haircut. Link to comment
Kohola3 August 25, 2016 Share August 25, 2016 Dunno what we can do next. Favorite elder? Favorite costumes? Least favorite story line? Least favorite hairstyle? I have no imagination! Link to comment
amensisterfriend August 25, 2016 Author Share August 25, 2016 Least favorite hairstyle? Oh my god, I'm kind of in love with this idea! We have A LOT to choose from :) 1 Link to comment
Kohola3 August 25, 2016 Share August 25, 2016 Could be a challenge. We'd probably need pix. 1 Link to comment
Lady Calypso August 25, 2016 Share August 25, 2016 I'm going against Centennial, sadly. I laughed at the Favourite Elder suggestion. Not going to lie. But the least favourite hairstyle would be fun. I have a lot on my list. 1 Link to comment
amensisterfriend August 25, 2016 Author Share August 25, 2016 Please feel free to start nominating hairstyles, including pictures whenever you feel like it :) Link to comment
4evaQuez August 25, 2016 Share August 25, 2016 Centennial. I would love least favorite haircut Link to comment
amensisterfriend August 26, 2016 Author Share August 26, 2016 (edited) So it looks like Queen reigns supreme :) Meanwhile, let's start our list of hairstyles! Not everyone will agree that all of these belong in the 'least favorite' category, of course, but that's part of the fun :) Prue's short hair (S1) Piper's fringe/bangs (S1) Phoebe's short hair (S1) Prue's long blonde wig (Morality Bites) Piper's suddenly curly hair (Morality Bites and maybe a couple of other episodes too!) Prue's ill-fitting "bob" wig (Pardon My Past) Phoebe's blonde hair (S3) Phoebe's super spiral 'poodle' perm (parts of S3) Phoebe's reaaallly short, poorly cut bangs (S4) Phoebe's almost-no-hair-left hair of S6 Paige's really flat, dully brown hair (S4) (I don't know how to explain her S4 hair, but I think it's by far her least flattering) Paige's braided pigtails (a couple of times in S4!) Paige's unnaturally blonde hair (on and off!) Please feel free to add to the list!!! Edited August 26, 2016 by amensisterfriend 1 Link to comment
4evaQuez August 26, 2016 Share August 26, 2016 What about Phoebe's wig from Oh My Goddess Link to comment
amensisterfriend August 28, 2016 Author Share August 28, 2016 Prue's short hair (S1) Piper's fringe/bangs (S1) Phoebe's short hair (S1) Prue's long blonde wig (Morality Bites) Piper's suddenly curly hair (Morality Bites and maybe a couple of other episodes too!) Prue's ill-fitting "bob" wig (Pardon My Past) Phoebe's blonde hair (S3) Phoebe's super spiral 'poodle' perm (parts of S3) Phoebe's reaaallly short, poorly cut bangs (S4) Phoebe's almost-no-hair-left hair of S6 Paige's really flat, dully brown hair (S4) (I don't know how to explain her S4 hair, but I think it's by far her least flattering) Paige's braided pigtails (a couple of times in S4!) Paige's unnaturally blonde hair (on and off!) Phoebe's wig from Oh My Goddess Phoebe's wig from All Halliwell's Eve Piper's wig from All Halliwell's Eve If you guys think of more, let me know! Meanwhile, feel free to start voting against TWO :) Link to comment
raven August 28, 2016 Share August 28, 2016 Didn't Paige have red hair at one point? I love Prue's casual hairstyle when she wears a colorful bandana to tie it back - but that's not really a haircut. I vote against Prue's blonde wig (Morality Bites) - awful and unflattering and Phoebe's S3 blonde hair (also unflattering). Link to comment
amensisterfriend August 28, 2016 Author Share August 28, 2016 Didn't Paige have red hair at one point? She did! I think for this round people mostly just nominated hairstyles they didn't like, but if you don't like Paige's red hair, I can add it to the list :) Link to comment
raven August 28, 2016 Share August 28, 2016 I did not like Paige's red hair, so please add :) Rose McGowan looked her best with dark hair. Link to comment
amensisterfriend August 28, 2016 Author Share August 28, 2016 Updated list: Prue's short hair (S1) Piper's fringe/bangs (S1) Phoebe's short hair (S1) Prue's long blonde wig (Morality Bites) Piper's suddenly curly hair (Morality Bites and maybe a couple of other episodes too!) Prue's ill-fitting "bob" wig (Pardon My Past) Phoebe's blonde hair (S3) Phoebe's super spiral 'poodle' perm (parts of S3) Phoebe's reaaallly short, poorly cut bangs (S4) Phoebe's almost-no-hair-left hair of S6 Paige's really flat, dully brown hair (S4) (I don't know how to explain her S4 hair, but I think it's by far her least flattering) Paige's braided pigtails (a couple of times in S4!) Paige's unnaturally blonde hair (on and off!) Phoebe's wig from Oh My Goddess Phoebe's wig from All Halliwell's Eve Piper's wig from All Halliwell's Eve Paige's red hair ...something just occurred to me: are we eliminating the ones we hate most or the ones we dislike least?! If the goal to to end up with the worst hairstyle, should we be eliminating the ones we dislike least? I'm confusing myself... :) Link to comment
4evaQuez August 29, 2016 Share August 29, 2016 i was thinking the ones we dislike least Link to comment
Kohola3 August 29, 2016 Share August 29, 2016 So the ones we like are the first to go? Link to comment
raven August 29, 2016 Share August 29, 2016 OK, if that's what's happening, I will have to revise my first vote :) Link to comment
amensisterfriend August 29, 2016 Author Share August 29, 2016 Sure, let's eliminate the ones we like most/dislike since the goal this time is to find the worst of the worst rather than the best of the best :) Is that okay? Raven, feel free to revise your vote! Link to comment
raven August 29, 2016 Share August 29, 2016 ooohkay then, dislike the least: 5 hours ago, amensisterfriend said: Prue's short hair (S1) Piper's fringe/bangs (S1) Link to comment
Kohola3 August 29, 2016 Share August 29, 2016 Piper's fringe/bangs (S1) Paige's braided pigtails (a couple of times in S4!) Link to comment
amensisterfriend August 29, 2016 Author Share August 29, 2016 I'll go with Paige's red hair (which I really liked for some reason!) and Piper's fringe/bangs because I can pretty much never NOT love Piper's hair :) Link to comment
Lady Calypso August 29, 2016 Share August 29, 2016 Ok! So I'm going to select Piper's fringe/bangs and Paige's braided pigtails! Link to comment
4evaQuez August 29, 2016 Share August 29, 2016 paige pig tails and piper fringe bangs Link to comment
amensisterfriend August 30, 2016 Author Share August 30, 2016 Updated list: Prue's short hair (S1) Phoebe's short hair (S1) Prue's long blonde wig (Morality Bites) Piper's suddenly curly hair (Morality Bites and maybe a couple of other episodes too!) Prue's ill-fitting "bob" wig (Pardon My Past) Phoebe's blonde hair (S3) Phoebe's super spiral 'poodle' perm (parts of S3) Phoebe's reaaallly short, poorly cut bangs (S4) Phoebe's almost-no-hair-left hair of S6 Paige's really flat, dully brown hair (S4) (I don't know how to explain her S4 hair, but I think it's by far her least flattering) Paige's unnaturally blonde hair (on and off!) Phoebe's wig from Oh My Goddess Phoebe's wig from All Halliwell's Eve Piper's wig from All Halliwell's Eve Paige's red hair So Piper's fringe/bangs of S1 and Paige's braids were deemed the 'best of the worst' :) Just vote for the two you like best/dislike least of the ones that remain! My votes: Paige's red hair and Paige's S4 hair Link to comment
raven August 30, 2016 Share August 30, 2016 Yeah, Piper's hair never looked bad and the wigs almost always did so... Piper's suddenly curly hair (Morality Bites and maybe a couple of other episodes too!) Prue's short hair (S1) - not my fave but she didn't look bad! Link to comment
Lady Calypso August 30, 2016 Share August 30, 2016 Piper's curly hair, and Paige's red hair! Link to comment
Kohola3 August 30, 2016 Share August 30, 2016 Paige's red hair and Piper's curly hair (I agree, her hair always looked wonderful) Link to comment
amensisterfriend August 30, 2016 Author Share August 30, 2016 Updated list: Prue's short hair (S1) Phoebe's short hair (S1) Prue's long blonde wig (Morality Bites) Prue's ill-fitting "bob" wig (Pardon My Past) Phoebe's blonde hair (S3) Phoebe's super spiral 'poodle' perm (parts of S3) Phoebe's reaaallly short, poorly cut bangs (S4) Phoebe's almost-no-hair-left hair of S6 Paige's really flat, dully brown hair (S4) (I don't know how to explain her S4 hair, but I think it's by far her least flattering) Paige's unnaturally blonde hair (on and off!) Phoebe's wig from Oh My Goddess Phoebe's wig from All Halliwell's Eve Piper's wig from All Halliwell's Eve Piper's curly hair and Paige's red hair have been rescued from the indignity of being named our worst hairstyles, and the next round is open! We're still voting for the TWO we want to save, ie the ones we dislike least :) Link to comment
Lady Calypso August 31, 2016 Share August 31, 2016 Piper's wig and Phoebe's poorly cut bangs. What can I say? Phoebe's bangs grew on me. Link to comment
Recommended Posts