Supernatural Survival Game

DittyDotDot · January 27, 2015

I got two birds on a wire for someone!

-- First Born

-- Sharp Teeth
-- #THINMAN

23 - First Born
17 - Bad Boys

17 - Mother's Little Helper

17 - Dog Dean Afternoon
15 - Blade Runners
15 - Road Trip
15 - Devil May Care
15 - Heaven Can't Wait
15 - Holy Terror
15 - Captives
15 - Meta Fiction
15 - King of the Damned
15 - Slumber Party
15 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann
13 - Stairway to Heaven
13 - The Purge
01 - Sharp Teeth
01 - #THINMAN

Off in the Veil with Kevin
Bloodlines
Rock and a Hard Place
Do You Believe in Miracles?
I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here
I'm No Angel

Iguana · January 27, 2015

-- bottom 3

Ah, the double kill. Feels good, almost like I'm satisfying some primal urge from the dawn of creation, symbolized by a sort of F-shaped brand on my arm....

#THINMAN had more plot holes than a colander, and required some huge leaps of logic, and kind of sucked. However, I never had a problem with Dean killing the murderers, as they were as big of monsters as any vampire, demon or witch, just not of the supernatural variety, and in this instance, it's not like they could be successfully prosecuted and jailed for like/executed.

Sharp Teeth was such a massive and stupid revision of all the werewolf lore that had been established previously that I happily put a silver bullet in its heart.

23 - First Born
17 - Bad Boys

17 - Mother's Little Helper

17 - Dog Dean Afternoon
15 - Blade Runners
15 - Road Trip
15 - Devil May Care
15 - Heaven Can't Wait
15 - Holy Terror
15 - Captives
15 - Meta Fiction
15 - King of the Damned
15 - Slumber Party
15 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann
13 - Stairway to Heaven
11 - The Purge

Off in the Veil with Kevin
Bloodlines
Rock and a Hard Place
Do You Believe in Miracles?
I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here
I'm No Angel

#THINMAN

Sharp Teeth

SueB · January 28, 2015

++ Blade Runners

-- Dog Dean Afternoon

-- Mother's Little Helper

23 - First Born
17 - Bad Boys

17 - Blade Runners

15 - Mother's Little Helper

15 - Dog Dean Afternoon
15 - Road Trip
15 - Devil May Care
15 - Heaven Can't Wait
15 - Holy Terror
15 - Captives
15 - Meta Fiction
15 - King of the Damned
15 - Slumber Party
15 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann
13 - Stairway to Heaven
11 - The Purge

Off in the Veil with Kevin
Bloodlines
Rock and a Hard Place
Do You Believe in Miracles?
I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here
I'm No Angel

#THINMAN

Sharp Teeth

rue721 · January 28, 2015

-- Stairway to Heaven

-- Dog Dean Afternoon

-- Blade Runners

23 - First Born
17 - Bad Boys

15 - Blade Runners

15 - Mother's Little Helper
15 - Road Trip
15 - Devil May Care
15 - Heaven Can't Wait
15 - Holy Terror
15 - Captives
15 - Meta Fiction
15 - King of the Damned
15 - Slumber Party
15 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann

13 - Dog Dean Afternoon
11 - Stairway to Heaven
11 - The Purge

Off in the Veil with Kevin
Bloodlines
Rock and a Hard Place
Do You Believe in Miracles?
I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here
I'm No Angel

#THINMAN

Sharp Teeth

AwesomO4000 · January 28, 2015

I didn't want to be a partial broken record here, but a lot of the episodes left are kind of similar to me, and I'm finding it hard to decide which other ones to vote for.

++ Mother's Little Helper

++ Dog Dean Afternoon

-- The Purge

23 - First Born
17 - Bad Boys

17 - Mother's Little Helper

15 - Blade Runners

15 - Road Trip
15 - Devil May Care
15 - Heaven Can't Wait
15 - Holy Terror
15 - Captives
15 - Meta Fiction
15 - King of the Damned
15 - Slumber Party
15 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann

15 - Dog Dean Afternoon
11 - Stairway to Heaven
09 - The Purge

Off in the Veil with Kevin
Bloodlines
Rock and a Hard Place
Do You Believe in Miracles?
I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here
I'm No Angel

#THINMAN

Sharp Teeth

catrox14 · January 28, 2015

Oops forgot to vote.. Well I'll just say it now. 'First Born' is my top episode from s9 easily, hands down, no contest and one of my top episodes in the entire series. So I'll be upvoting the hell out of that one.

I also think Blade Runners was great too. I find that with most of s9 there is something really great in almost every episode, even if the entire episode is sucks for the most part.

++First Born

--King of the Damned

--Road Trip

25 - First Born
17 - Bad Boys

17 - Mother's Little Helper

15 - Blade Runners

15 - Devil May Care
15 - Heaven Can't Wait
15 - Holy Terror
15 - Captives
15 - Meta Fiction
15 - King of the Damned
15 - Slumber Party
15 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann

13 - Road Trip
13 - King of the Damned

11 - Stairway to Heaven

09 - The Purge

Off in the Veil with Kevin
Bloodlines
Rock and a Hard Place
Do You Believe in Miracles?
I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here
I'm No Angel

#THINMAN

Sharp Teeth

Off in the Veil with Kevin
Bloodlines
Rock and a Hard Place
Do You Believe in Miracles?
I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here
I'm No Angel

#THINMAN

Sharp Teeth

Edited January 28, 2015 by catrox14

Demented Daisy · January 28, 2015

First Born --

Blade Runners --

Dog Dean Afternoon ++

23 - First Born
17 - Bad Boys
17 - Mother's Little Helper

17 - Dog Dean Afternoon

15 - Devil May Care
15 - Heaven Can't Wait
15 - Holy Terror
15 - Captives
15 - Meta Fiction
15 - King of the Damned
15 - Slumber Party
15 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann

13 - Blade Runners

13 - Road Trip

13 - King of the Damned
11 - Stairway to Heaven
09 - The Purge

Off in the Veil with Kevin
Bloodlines
Rock and a Hard Place
Do You Believe in Miracles?
I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here
I'm No Angel
#THINMAN
Sharp Teeth

DittyDotDot · January 28, 2015

I didn't want to be a partial broken record here, but a lot of the episodes left are kind of similar to me, and I'm finding it hard to decide which other ones to vote for.

AwesomO, you could adopt my voting strategy--just down-vote 'em all and get this round over with. Okay, I won't vote against a couple, but I won't give 'em a leg up either. I feel the same way about S9, it all stands at subpar, to me, and none stand out all that much either.

-- First Born

-- Stairway to Heaven

-- The Purge

21 - First Born

17 - Bad Boys

17 - Mother's Little Helper

17 - Dog Dean Afternoon

15 - Devil May Care

15 - Heaven Can't Wait

15 - Holy Terror

15 - Captives

15 - Meta Fiction

15 - King of the Damned

15 - Slumber Party

15 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann

13 - Blade Runners

13 - Road Trip

13 - King of the Damned

09 - Stairway to Heaven

07 - The Purge

Off in the Veil with Kevin

Bloodlines

Rock and a Hard Place

Do You Believe in Miracles?

I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here

I'm No Angel

#THINMAN

Sharp Teeth

7kstar · January 28, 2015

++ First Born

++ Bad Boys
-- Meta Fiction - Just voting down Metratron...I want him gone...I'm sure there is something good in the ep but I'm so ready for Metratron to die!!! Does that make me evil?

23 - First Born
19 - Bad Boys
17 - Mother's Little Helper

17 - Dog Dean Afternoon

15 - Devil May Care
15 - Heaven Can't Wait
15 - Holy Terror
15 - Captives
15 - Meta Fiction
15 - King of the Damned
15 - Slumber Party
15 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann

13 - Meta Fiction

13 - Blade Runners

13 - Road Trip

13 - King of the Damned
09 - Stairway to Heaven
07 - The Purge

Off in the Veil with Kevin
Bloodlines
Rock and a Hard Place
Do You Believe in Miracles?
I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here
I'm No Angel
#THINMAN
Sharp Teeth

SueB · January 29, 2015

++ Blade Runners

-- Slumber Party

-- Meta Fiction

23 - First Born
19 - Bad Boys
17 - Mother's Little Helper

17 - Dog Dean Afternoon

15 - Devil May Care
15 - Heaven Can't Wait
15 - Holy Terror
15 - Captives
15 - Meta Fiction
15 - King of the Damned
15 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann

15 - Blade Runners

13 - Slumber Party

13 - Meta Fiction

13 - Road Trip

13 - King of the Damned
09 - Stairway to Heaven
07 - The Purge

Off in the Veil with Kevin
Bloodlines
Rock and a Hard Place
Do You Believe in Miracles?
I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here
I'm No Angel
#THINMAN
Sharp Teeth

rue721 · January 29, 2015

-- Stairway to Heaven

-- Dog Dean Afternoon

-- Captives

23 - First Born
19 - Bad Boys
17 - Mother's Little Helper

15 - Dog Dean Afternoon

15 - Devil May Care
15 - Heaven Can't Wait
15 - Holy Terror
15 - Meta Fiction
15 - King of the Damned
15 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann

15 - Blade Runners

13 - Captives

13 - Slumber Party

13 - Meta Fiction

13 - King of the Damned
13 - Road Trip

07 - Stairway to Heaven
07 - The Purge

Off in the Veil with Kevin
Bloodlines
Rock and a Hard Place
Do You Believe in Miracles?
I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here
I'm No Angel
#THINMAN
Sharp Teeth

Demented Daisy · January 29, 2015

First Born --

Blade Runners --

Dog Dean Afternoon ++

21 - First Born
19 - Bad Boys
17 - Mother's Little Helper
17 - Dog Dean Afternoon
15 - Devil May Care
15 - Heaven Can't Wait
15 - Holy Terror
15 - Meta Fiction
15 - King of the Damned
15 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann
13 - Blade Runners
13 - Captives
13 - Slumber Party
13 - Meta Fiction
13 - King of the Damned
13 - Road Trip
07 - Stairway to Heaven
07 - The Purge

Off in the Veil with Kevin
Bloodlines
Rock and a Hard Place
Do You Believe in Miracles?
I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here
I'm No Angel
#THINMAN
Sharp Teeth

DittyDotDot · January 29, 2015

-- Road Trip
-- Stairway to Heaven
-- The Purge

21 - First Born
19 - Bad Boys
17 - Mother's Little Helper
17 - Dog Dean Afternoon
15 - Devil May Care
15 - Heaven Can't Wait
15 - Holy Terror
15 - Meta Fiction
15 - King of the Damned
15 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann
13 - Blade Runners
13 - Captives
13 - Slumber Party
13 - Meta Fiction
13 - King of the Damned
11 - Road Trip
05 - Stairway to Heaven
05 - The Purge

Off in the Veil with Kevin
Bloodlines
Rock and a Hard Place
Do You Believe in Miracles?
I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here
I'm No Angel
#THINMAN
Sharp Teeth

AwesomO4000 · January 29, 2015

Hmm, I'm still having difficulties here trying to decide. Most episodes left have something to like and dislike (season 8 was easier since there were so many I outright disliked), so I'm torn here. Okay, decision time...

Also: note - I'm removing the second "Meta Fiction" listing (I'm pretty sure I removed the right one). It will just get confusing later, and although Metatron would approve of his episode being included twice, no need to make him happy.

++ Mother's Little helper - I may be the only one, but I liked Sam actually having an active case. And despite his anger, Sam even told Dean he was right. Take note other writers: Sam doesn't have to be pissy and hold a grudge all the time. (Actually he didn't used to do that much at all until the last few seasons. *sigh*)

-- Slumber Party

-- The Purge (see above note.)

21 - First Born
19 - Bad Boys
19 - Mother's Little Helper
17 - Dog Dean Afternoon
15 - Devil May Care
15 - Heaven Can't Wait
15 - Holy Terror
15 - King of the Damned
15 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann
13 - Blade Runners
13 - Captives
13 - Meta Fiction
13 - King of the Damned

11 - Slumber Party
11 - Road Trip
05 - Stairway to Heaven
03 - The Purge

Off in the Veil with Kevin
Bloodlines
Rock and a Hard Place
Do You Believe in Miracles?
I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here
I'm No Angel
#THINMAN
Sharp Teeth

DittyDotDot · January 29, 2015

I'm still counting 24 episodes on the list, but can't see anything repeated. I'm not sure if I should be more annoyed that I can't count or if I can't see double. Does anyone else see the problem here?

ETA: never mind...King of The Damned was on the list twice as well. I removed the one higher on the list--let me know if I was wrong, though. Here's a new one for y'all.

21 - First Born
19 - Bad Boys
19 - Mother's Little Helper
17 - Dog Dean Afternoon
15 - Devil May Care
15 - Heaven Can't Wait
15 - Holy Terror
15 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann
13 - Blade Runners
13 - Captives
13 - Meta Fiction
13 - King of the Damned

11 - Slumber Party
11 - Road Trip
05 - Stairway to Heaven
03 - The Purge

Off in the Veil with Kevin
Bloodlines
Rock and a Hard Place
Do You Believe in Miracles?
I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here
I'm No Angel
#THINMAN
Sharp Teeth

Edited January 29, 2015 by DittyDotDot

Demented Daisy · January 29, 2015

Looks right to me!

Iguana · January 29, 2015

-- bottom 3

21 - First Born
19 - Bad Boys
19 - Mother's Little Helper
17 - Dog Dean Afternoon
15 - Devil May Care
15 - Heaven Can't Wait
15 - Holy Terror
15 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann
13 - Blade Runners
13 - Captives
13 - Meta Fiction
13 - King of the Damned

11 - Slumber Party
09 - Road Trip
03 - Stairway to Heaven
01 - The Purge

Off in the Veil with Kevin
Bloodlines
Rock and a Hard Place
Do You Believe in Miracles?
I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here
I'm No Angel
#THINMAN
Sharp Teeth

7kstar · January 30, 2015

First Born ++

Bad Boys ++

Alex Annie Alexis Ann ++

23 - First Born
21 - Bad Boys
19 - Mother's Little Helper
17 - Dog Dean Afternoon

17 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann
15 - Devil May Care
15 - Heaven Can't Wait
15 - Holy Terror
13 - Blade Runners
13 - Captives
13 - Meta Fiction
13 - King of the Damned

11 - Slumber Party
09 - Road Trip
03 - Stairway to Heaven
01 - The Purge

Off in the Veil with Kevin
Bloodlines
Rock and a Hard Place
Do You Believe in Miracles?
I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here
I'm No Angel
#THINMAN
Sharp Teeth

I can't kill the Purge. Not my favorite all the way through, but I love the Sheriff and Sam coming to help a doped up Dean.

catrox14 · January 30, 2015

First Born ++

Stairway to Heaven --

Blade Runners ++

25 - First Born

21 - Bad Boys

19 - Mother's Little Helper

17 - Dog Dean Afternoon

17 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann

15 - Devil May Care

15 - Heaven Can't Wait

15 - Holy Terror

15 - Blade Runners

13 - Captives

13 - Meta Fiction

13 - King of the Damned

11 - Slumber Party

09 - Road Trip

01 - Stairway to Heaven

01 - The Purge

Off in the Veil with Kevin

Bloodlines

Rock and a Hard Place

Do You Believe in Miracles?

I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here

I'm No Angel

#THINMAN

Sharp Teeth

I won't kill the Purge either. I love Sheriff Donna and Dean. I hated Sam's speech but I love the emotion in the scene from Dean. Jensen was pretty great there IMO.

SueB · January 30, 2015

Well I SHIP Dean and Donna. Like, for real. So... nope, someone else bring that ax. I will, however, kill off Stairway to Heaven

Stairway to Heaven was a mixed bag episode I felt. It did bring the funny with Gadreel's epic bitch face and Metatron trying to dress like Cas. I LOATHED with the heat of a 1000 fiery suns the death of Tessa. *pauses to collect self* I also loathed Metatron getting the upper hand with his kamikaze gambit. OTOH, I must admit I had a hardtime holding up my feminist card when Dean put a beatdown on that nasty self-important Flagstaff (damn! son). And I flat out cheered when Dean went primal on Gadreel. "For Kevin!" I may have shouted. Strategic decision making was missing from my brain that episode. Another nice little bit was Sam/Cas bonding ("Seven ate Nine"). Finally, precisely no one was surprised when Cas wouldn't kill Dean (really Hannah? What show have YOU been watching?) So...off to the veil this episodes scampers. Maybe it'll make Kevin feel better.

Slumber Party --
Stairway to Heaven --
Blade Runners ++

25 - First Born
21 - Bad Boys

19 - Mother's Little Helper

17 - Blade Runners

17 - Dog Dean Afternoon
17 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann
15 - Devil May Care
15 - Heaven Can't Wait
15 - Holy Terror
13 - Captives
13 - Meta Fiction
13 - King of the Damned
09 - Slumber Party
09 - Road Trip
01 - The Purge

Off in the Veil with Kevin
Bloodlines
Rock and a Hard Place
Do You Believe in Miracles?
I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here
I'm No Angel
#THINMAN
Sharp Teeth

Stairway to Heaven

Demented Daisy · January 30, 2015

Sorry, I'm on a mission. Someone else can have the honor.

First Born --

Blade Runners --

Dog Dean Afternoon ++

23 - First Born
21 - Bad Boys
19 - Mother's Little Helper
19 - Dog Dean Afternoon
17 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann

15 - Blade Runners

15 - Devil May Care

15 - Heaven Can't Wait
15 - Holy Terror
13 - Captives
13 - Meta Fiction
13 - King of the Damned
09 - Slumber Party
09 - Road Trip
01 - The Purge

Off in the Veil with Kevin
Bloodlines
Rock and a Hard Place
Do You Believe in Miracles?
I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here
I'm No Angel
#THINMAN
Sharp Teeth
Stairway to Heaven

rue721 · January 30, 2015

Goodbye, "The Purge"! I liked the businesslike cafeteria manager and the relationship between the monster lady and trainer husband-wife team. But pudding is disgusting, as is lying in a drugged puddle on a store room floor. Getting fat sucked out of you by a monster's tongue/straw thing is also disgusting, albeit maybe not as horrible as pudding (blech). Probably better to lose weight by just running more, tbh.

-- The Purge

-- Dog Dean Afternoon (sorry Demented Daisy, I know you love this episode! Am not trying to be difficult! But I really, really hate it).

-- Meta Fiction

23 - First Born
21 - Bad Boys
19 - Mother's Little Helper
17 - Dog Dean Afternoon
17 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann

15 - Blade Runners

15 - Devil May Care

15 - Heaven Can't Wait
15 - Holy Terror
13 - Captives
13 - King of the Damned
11 - Meta Fiction

09 - Slumber Party
09 - Road Trip

Off in the Veil with Kevin
Bloodlines
Rock and a Hard Place
Do You Believe in Miracles?
I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here
I'm No Angel
#THINMAN
Sharp Teeth
Stairway to Heaven

The Purge

Demented Daisy · January 30, 2015

*shrug* That's the way it works.

catrox14 · January 30, 2015

Well I SHIP Dean and Donna.

NO I SHIP DEAN AND DONNA. I CAN PROVE IT.

DittyDotDot · January 30, 2015

::Pouts:: But I wanted to kill SOMETHING! I never get to have any fun anymore!

-- Meta Fiction

-- Slumber Party
-- Road Trip

23 - First Born
21 - Bad Boys
19 - Mother's Little Helper
17 - Dog Dean Afternoon
17 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann

15 - Blade Runners

15 - Devil May Care

15 - Heaven Can't Wait
15 - Holy Terror
13 - Captives
13 - King of the Damned
09 - Meta Fiction

07 - Slumber Party
07 - Road Trip

Off in the Veil with Kevin
Bloodlines
Rock and a Hard Place
Do You Believe in Miracles?
I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here
I'm No Angel
#THINMAN
Sharp Teeth
Stairway to Heaven

The Purge

Edited January 30, 2015 by DittyDotDot

Iguana · January 30, 2015

-- bottom 3

23 - First Born
21 - Bad Boys
19 - Mother's Little Helper
17 - Dog Dean Afternoon
17 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann

15 - Blade Runners

15 - Devil May Care

15 - Heaven Can't Wait
15 - Holy Terror
13 - Captives
13 - King of the Damned
07 - Meta Fiction

05 - Slumber Party
05 - Road Trip

Off in the Veil with Kevin
Bloodlines
Rock and a Hard Place
Do You Believe in Miracles?
I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here
I'm No Angel
#THINMAN
Sharp Teeth
Stairway to Heaven

The Purge

7kstar · January 30, 2015

Just making a plea...can someone help me kill Meta Fiction before Slumber Party...PLEASE!

I'm sorry but I would much rather have Charlie over Metatron and actually I like Slumber Party. I get it is on the hit list but I would love for Meta to go out before Slumber....

catrox14 · January 30, 2015

I'll help if you'll help me take out Road Trip. LOL

7kstar · January 31, 2015

I'll help if you'll help me take out Road Trip. LOL

Deal... :)

catrox14 · January 31, 2015

But I will add the caveat that Dean in the shower...is hard for me to vote against......but I will for the sake of the game

7kstar · January 31, 2015

@Catrox14

I like parts of it and won't be voting until tomorrow morning, so if you want me to wait just say so. :) The shower scene...awesome. I also like parts of it...but I also hate the torture part. So for the pain alone, I should take it out...right?

Edited January 31, 2015 by 7kstar

SueB · January 31, 2015

++ First Born

++ Blade Runners

-- Alex Annie Alexis Ann

25 - First Born
21 - Bad Boys
19 - Mother's Little Helper
17 - Dog Dean Afternoon

17 - Blade Runners

15 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann

15 - Devil May Care

15 - Heaven Can't Wait
15 - Holy Terror
13 - Captives
13 - King of the Damned
07 - Meta Fiction

05 - Slumber Party
05 - Road Trip

Off in the Veil with Kevin
Bloodlines
Rock and a Hard Place
Do You Believe in Miracles?
I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here
I'm No Angel
#THINMAN
Sharp Teeth
Stairway to Heaven

The Purge

catrox14 · January 31, 2015

++ First Born

-- Meta Fiction

++ Slumber Party

27 - First Born

21 - Bad Boys

19 - Mother's Little Helper

17 - Dog Dean Afternoon

17 - Blade Runners

15 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann

15 - Devil May Care

15 - Heaven Can't Wait

15 - Holy Terror

13 - Captives

13 - King of the Damned

07 - Slumber Party

05 - Meta Fiction

05 - Road Trip

Off in the Veil with Kevin

Bloodlines

Rock and a Hard Place

Do You Believe in Miracles?

I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here

I'm No Angel

#THINMAN

Sharp Teeth

Stairway to Heaven

The Purge

AwesomO4000 · January 31, 2015

Just making a plea...can someone help me kill Meta Fiction before Slumber Party...PLEASE!

I'm sorry but I would much rather have Charlie over Metatron and actually I like Slumber Party. I get it is on the hit list but I would love for Meta to go out before Slumber....

But I like to hate Metatron... and, and Gabriel. Well fake Gabriel, but even fake Gabriel is better than no Gabriel at all, besides Slumber Party had dumb Sam and Dean again, so I'm torn. So my solution - kill them all! What do you mean that's a bad solution? I will not be swayed. Mwah ha ha... cough cough - oh wait. I think "First Born" is getting too far ahead for my liking. Never mind... you are all saved for now. Carry on. Except I'm tying them all up.

-- First Born

-- Slumber Party

++ Mother's Little Helper

25 - First Born

21 - Bad Boys

21 - Mother's Little Helper

17 - Dog Dean Afternoon

17 - Blade Runners

15 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann

15 - Devil May Care

15 - Heaven Can't Wait

15 - Holy Terror

13 - Captives

13 - King of the Damned

05 - Slumber Party

05 - Meta Fiction

05 - Road Trip

Off in the Veil with Kevin

Bloodlines

Rock and a Hard Place

Do You Believe in Miracles?

I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here

I'm No Angel

#THINMAN

Sharp Teeth

Stairway to Heaven

The Purge

rue721 · January 31, 2015

-- Meta Fiction

-- Road Trip

-- Dog Dean Afternoon

25 - First Born
21 - Bad Boys
21 - Mother's Little Helper

17 - Blade Runners
15 - Dog Dean Afternoon
15 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann
15 - Devil May Care
15 - Heaven Can't Wait
15 - Holy Terror
13 - Captives
13 - King of the Damned
05 - Slumber Party
03 - Meta Fiction
03 - Road Trip

Off in the Veil with Kevin
Bloodlines
Rock and a Hard Place
Do You Believe in Miracles?
I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here
I'm No Angel
#THINMAN
Sharp Teeth
Stairway to Heaven
The Purge

catrox14 · January 31, 2015

Thank you for reminding me that I hated the reappearance of Gabriel. Unpopular opinion, I never liked Gabriel except as the Trickster. So I have another reason to kill Meta Fiction.

Edited January 31, 2015 by catrox14

DittyDotDot · January 31, 2015

So my solution - kill them all! What do you mean that's a bad solution? I will not be swayed. Mwah ha ha... cough cough - oh wait. I think "First Born" is getting too far ahead for my liking. Never mind... you are all saved for now. Carry on. Except I'm tying them all up.

Oh the sheer maniacal glee I get from this. Welcome to the dark side AwesomO! ;)

Let the killing resume!

-- Slumber Party

-- Meta Fiction

-- Road Trip

25 - First Born

21 - Bad Boys

21 - Mother's Little Helper

17 - Blade Runners

15 - Dog Dean Afternoon

15 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann

15 - Devil May Care

15 - Heaven Can't Wait

15 - Holy Terror

13 - Captives

13 - King of the Damned

03 - Slumber Party

01 - Meta Fiction

01 - Road Trip

Off in the Veil with Kevin

Bloodlines

Rock and a Hard Place

Do You Believe in Miracles?

I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here

I'm No Angel

#THINMAN

Sharp Teeth

Stairway to Heaven

The Purge

7kstar · January 31, 2015

++ Slumber Party
-- Meta Fiction
-- Road Trip

25 - First Born
21 - Bad Boys
21 - Mother's Little Helper

17 - Blade Runners
15 - Dog Dean Afternoon
15 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann
15 - Devil May Care
15 - Heaven Can't Wait
15 - Holy Terror
13 - Captives
13 - King of the Damned
05 - Slumber Party

Off in the Veil with Kevin
Bloodlines
Rock and a Hard Place
Do You Believe in Miracles?
I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here
I'm No Angel
#THINMAN
Sharp Teeth
Stairway to Heaven
The Purge

Meta Fiction
Road Trip

I had to keep my promise so @Catrox14 Road Trip now is with Kevin in the Veil.

I did like parts of Road Trip. But hated how they had Dean leave so he would wind up with Crowley. I did like how Cas tried to support Dean who was so lost in this ep.

on Meta I love to hate Metratron so much that I had to kill him off. I had too. Although there might be some parts I liked in this ep, I really don't want to see him now. So since the show won't kill him off, well here I am doing it for them. I'm sure there is someone that loves these two more than I do that can give them a proper good bye.

7kstar · January 31, 2015

Thank you for reminding me that I hated the reappearance of Gabriel. Unpopular opinion, I never liked Gabriel except as the Trickster. So I have another reason to kill Meta Fiction.

Well I liked Gabriel but I hate Metratron more...so off with it's head!

But I like to hate Metatron... and, and Gabriel. Well fake Gabriel, but even fake Gabriel is better than no Gabriel at all, besides Slumber Party had dumb Sam and Dean again, so I'm torn. So my solution - kill them all! What do you mean that's a bad solution? I will not be swayed. Mwah ha ha... cough cough - oh wait. I think "First Born" is getting too far ahead for my liking. Never mind... you are all saved for now. Carry on. Except I'm tying them all up.

I like Gabriel and I do like what they did with Charlie in Slumber Party....could they have done it better without making Sam & Dean dumb...sure but that would mean we have really smart talented writers...oops...now someone will tear me up about talking about the writers...right? :)

Demented Daisy · January 31, 2015

Kill 'em all and let Chuck sort 'em out? Is that what you're saying, AwesomO and Ditty? ;-)

First Born --

Blade Runners --

Dog Dean Afternoon ++

23 - First Born
21 - Bad Boys
21 - Mother's Little Helper
17 - Dog Dean Afternoon

15 - Blade Runners

15 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann

15 - Devil May Care
15 - Heaven Can't Wait
15 - Holy Terror
13 - Captives
13 - King of the Damned
05 - Slumber Party

Off in the Veil with Kevin
Bloodlines
Rock and a Hard Place
Do You Believe in Miracles?
I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here
I'm No Angel
#THINMAN
Sharp Teeth
Stairway to Heaven
The Purge
Meta Fiction
Road Trip

DittyDotDot · January 31, 2015

Kill 'em all and let Chuck sort 'em out? Is that what you're saying, AwesomO and Ditty? ;-)

You betcha! ;)

Iguana · January 31, 2015

"I say, let's take off and nuke the site (season) from orbit. It's the only way to be sure." - Ellen Ripley, Aliens

-- bottom 3

23 - First Born
21 - Bad Boys
21 - Mother's Little Helper
17 - Dog Dean Afternoon

15 - Blade Runners

15 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann

15 - Devil May Care
15 - Heaven Can't Wait
15 - Holy Terror
11 - Captives
11 - King of the Damned
03 - Slumber Party

Off in the Veil with Kevin
Bloodlines
Rock and a Hard Place
Do You Believe in Miracles?
I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here
I'm No Angel
#THINMAN
Sharp Teeth
Stairway to Heaven
The Purge
Meta Fiction
Road Trip

DittyDotDot · January 31, 2015

"I say, let's take off and nuke the site (season) from orbit. It's the only way to be sure." - Ellen Ripley, Aliens

Bwah, ha, ha! We should probably nuke the S8 site while were being "sure." ;)

rue721 · February 1, 2015

-- Captives

-- Devil May Care

-- Dog Dean Afternoon

23 - First Born
21 - Bad Boys
21 - Mother's Little Helper
15 - Dog Dean Afternoon

15 - Blade Runners

15 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann

15 - Heaven Can't Wait
15 - Holy Terror

13 - Devil May Care
11 - King of the Damned

09 - Captives
03 - Slumber Party

Off in the Veil with Kevin
Bloodlines
Rock and a Hard Place
Do You Believe in Miracles?
I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here
I'm No Angel
#THINMAN
Sharp Teeth
Stairway to Heaven
The Purge
Meta Fiction
Road Trip

catrox14 · February 1, 2015

++ first born

-- king of the damned

++ blade runners

25 - First Born

21 - Bad Boys

21 - Mother's Little Helper

17 - Blade Runners

15 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann

15 - Dog Dean afternoon

15 - Heaven Can't Wait

15 - Holy Terror

13 - Devil May Care

09 - King of the Damned

09 - Captives

03 - Slumber Party

Off in the Veil with Kevin

Bloodlines

Rock and a Hard Place

Do You Believe in Miracles?

I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here

I'm No Angel

#THINMAN

Sharp Teeth

Stairway to Heaven

The Purge

Meta Fiction

Road Trip

AwesomO4000 · February 1, 2015

Kill 'em all and let Chuck sort 'em out? Is that what you're saying, AwesomO and Ditty? ;-)

It's certainly the easiest solution ; ) .

-- Slumber Party

-- King of the Damned

++ Dog Dean Afternoon - I can't help it. I love the fetch scene, I adore Steve Valentine, and I adore whenever I get to hear Leslie Jordan on my screen.

25 - First Born

21 - Bad Boys

21 - Mother's Little Helper

17 - Blade Runners

17 - Dog Dean afternoon

15 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann

15 - Heaven Can't Wait

15 - Holy Terror

13 - Devil May Care

09 - Captives

07 - King of the Damned

01 - Slumber Party

Off in the Veil with Kevin

Bloodlines

Rock and a Hard Place

Do You Believe in Miracles?

I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here

I'm No Angel

#THINMAN

Sharp Teeth

Stairway to Heaven

The Purge

Meta Fiction

Road Trip

DittyDotDot · February 1, 2015

Aren't you peoples sweet giving me something to kill--DIE, DIE, DIE--and an episode I don't care much for to boot! How will I ever be able to repay this kindness? I'm feeling so gracious now, I'm going to give a couple other episodes a leg up.

All I'll say in memorial of Slumber Party is, Dorothy is the kind of plucky gal I rather like.

++ Dog Dean afternoon

++ Captives

-- Slumber Party

25 - First Born
21 - Bad Boys
21 - Mother's Little Helper

19 - Dog Dean afternoon
17 - Blade Runners

15 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann
15 - Heaven Can't Wait
15 - Holy Terror
13 - Devil May Care
11 - Captives

07 - King of the Damned

Off in the Veil with Kevin
Bloodlines
Rock and a Hard Place
Do You Believe in Miracles?
I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here
I'm No Angel
#THINMAN
Sharp Teeth
Stairway to Heaven
The Purge
Meta Fiction
Road Trip

Slumber Party

Demented Daisy · February 1, 2015

First Born --

Blade Runners --

Dog Dean Afternoon ++

23 - First Born
21 - Bad Boys
21 - Mother's Little Helper
21 - Dog Dean afternoon
15 - Blade Runners
15 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann
15 - Heaven Can't Wait
15 - Holy Terror
13 - Devil May Care
11 - Captives
07 - King of the Damned

Off in the Veil with Kevin
Bloodlines
Rock and a Hard Place
Do You Believe in Miracles?
I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here
I'm No Angel
#THINMAN
Sharp Teeth
Stairway to Heaven
The Purge
Meta Fiction
Road Trip
Slumber Party

7kstar · February 1, 2015

First Born ++

Captives ++

Bad Boys ++

25 - First Born
23 - Bad Boys
21 - Mother's Little Helper
21 - Dog Dean afternoon
15 - Blade Runners
15 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann
15 - Heaven Can't Wait
15 - Holy Terror
13 - Devil May Care
13 - Captives
07 - King of the Damned

Off in the Veil with Kevin
Bloodlines
Rock and a Hard Place
Do You Believe in Miracles?
I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here
I'm No Angel
#THINMAN
Sharp Teeth
Stairway to Heaven
The Purge
Meta Fiction
Road Trip
Slumber Party

Well bye Slumber Party. At least you lasted longer than Meta Fiction. Yes there are parts I don't like, but I liked the idea. Dorothy was really interesting and that moment where Dean sees Charlie die gets to me every time. I wish they had done more with the cars...but it was a cool shot...How the boys were taken over was stupid...but then again this show does do some stupid so often that I just sigh and move on.

Kevin please Comfort poor Charlie and Dorothy or are they stuck in Oz? :)

SueB · February 2, 2015

Failed to vote yesterday. Going to push time earlier to get more sleep.

We are past halfway. Only 1 + for each positive vote.

Blade Runners +

Heaven can't Wait --

Alex Annie Alexis Ann --

25 - First Born

23 - Bad Boys

21 - Mother's Little Helper

21 - Dog Dean afternoon

16 - Blade Runners

15 - Holy Terror

13 - Alex Annie Alexis Ann

13 - Heaven Can't Wait

13 - Devil May Care

13 - Captives

07 - King of the Damned

Off in the Veil with Kevin

Bloodlines

Rock and a Hard Place

Do You Believe in Miracles?

I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here

I'm No Angel

#THINMAN

Sharp Teeth

Stairway to Heaven

The Purge

Meta Fiction

Road Trip

Slumber Party

Sign In

Supernatural Survival Game

Recommended Posts

Link to comment

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Popular Posts

DittyDotDot

DittyDotDot

SueB

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment

Link to comment