Supernatural Survival Game

[Demented Daisy]

WIaWSNB --

Crossroad Blues --

BUaBS --

 

38 - In My Time of Dying
34 - What Is and What Should Never Be
12 - Hollywood Babylon
08 - Nightshifter
07- Tall Tales
01 - Crossroad Blues
01 - Born Under a Bad Sign

Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues

[Mcolleague]

WIAWSNB + 

Tall Tales --  

BUABS -- Sorry guys, I had to do it! This episode already survived an extra couple of days since I haven't had a chance to come online and vote. This was probably the best Jared episode of the series for me. It's so well paced and had some incredible, chilling scenes. Too many good eps this season so it had to go! 

 

38 - In My Time of Dying
35 - What Is and What Should Never Be
12 - Hollywood Babylon
08 - Nightshifter
05- Tall Tales
01 - Crossroad Blues
 

Moved on:

Born Under a Bad Sign

Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues

[SueB]

Most of these episodes are hard to vote against. S2 really was a treasure for me.

Still ...

Hollywood Babylon --

Tall Tales --

Crossroad Blues + a little love for this episode because it really had such a dark moody tone with a fantastic plot. Felt like a game changer for me.

38 - In My Time of Dying

35 - What Is and What Should Never Be

10 - Hollywood Babylon

08 - Nightshifter

03 - Tall Tales

02 - Crossroad Blues

Moved on:

Born Under a Bad Sign

Roadkill

No Exit

Heart

Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things

Croatoan

Everybody Loves a Clown

Playthings

Simon Said

Hunted

Houses of the Holy

Bloodlust

All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1

The Usual Suspects

All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2

Folsom Prison Blues

[AwesomO4000]

-- In My Time...

+ What Is...

+ Nightshifter

 

36 - In My Time of Dying
36 - What Is and What Should Never Be
10 - Hollywood Babylon
09 - Nightshifter
03 - Tall Tales
02 - Crossroad Blues

 

Moved on:
Born Under a Bad Sign
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues

[mstaken]

TT +

HB --

Nightshfter --

 

36 - In My Time of Dying
36 - What Is and What Should Never Be

08 - Hollywood Babylon

07 - Nightshifter
04 - Tall Tales
02 - Crossroad Blues

Moved on:
Born Under a Bad Sign
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues

[DittyDotDot]

I give up...I see the writing on the walls. There's just no point living in denial anymore, I guess. Let's pause for a moment of silence for Crossroad Blues... ... .... ... ... .... ... ... ... .... ... ... ...  Was that moment long enough? Okay, carry on!

 

-- Nightshifter
-- Tall Tales
-- Crossroad Blues

 

36 - In My Time of Dying
36 - What Is and What Should Never Be

08 - Hollywood Babylon

05 - Nightshifter
02 - Tall Tales

 

Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues

Born Under a Bad Sign

Crossroad Blues

[SueB]

Ahhhhhh! Crossroad Blues!  The agony.  I may have to rewatch today out of respect for such a fantastic episode.

[7kstar]

Crossroads Blues, how much I love ' Dean almost making a deal to bring Dad back' Then how Dean refuses to answer Sam.  Sam getting concerned when he finally realizes that Dean almost caved when Dean won't answer the question and insteads turns his head and turns up the music.  Sam you should have really given him a what for, for even considering making a deal.

 

Not ready to take out Tall Tales, I know call me whimp I don't care.  Sorry Nightshifter but something has to go down.  Who made the stupid rules you have to vote one down????

 

-- Nightshifter

+ Hollywood Babylon
+ What Is and What Should Never Be

 

37 - What Is and What Should Never Be

36 - In My Time of Dying

09 - Hollywood Babylon

03 - Nightshifter
02 - Tall Tales

 

Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues

Born Under a Bad Sign

Crossroad Blues

[Demented Daisy]

WIaWSNB --

In My Time of Dying +

Nightshifter +

 

37 - In My Time of Dying

35 - What Is and What Should Never Be

09 - Hollywood Babylon
04 - Nightshifter
02 - Tall Tales

Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues
Born Under a Bad Sign
Crossroad Blues

[Mcolleague]

Tall Tales -- Sorry for killing another one! *dodges rotten tomatoes* RIP brotherly wrestling on the bed and slow dancing aliens.

Nightshifter --  

IMTOD -- 

 

35 - In My Time of Dying
35 - What Is and What Should Never Be
09 - Hollywood Babylon
02 - Nightshifter
 

Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues
Born Under a Bad Sign
Crossroad Blues

[SueB]

Wow...shit's getting real.

 

But first let me sing some praises for Tall Tales.  Thank you Mcolleague for doing the dirty work but I do need to give a moments pause and remember some of the brilliance of the episode.

Ah... Richard Speight Jr... so PERFECT for this role.... and all the permutations that come after.  The DANCING ALIEN.  The two different Sam and Dean perspectives.  God Bless both Jared Padalecki and Jensen Ackles for acting like complete fools for the sake of entertainment.  The Sam "bitchface" and Dean "chipmonk face".  Fanfuckingtastic.  Plus wrestling like 10 yr olds for the wallet.  This was an truly enjoyable episode.  But not my favorite of favorites... so with that I'll continue the vote....

 

In My Time of Dying +

What Is and What Should Never Be -- 

Hollywood Babylon --

 

36 - In My Time of Dying
33 - What Is and What Should Never Be
07 - Hollywood Babylon
02 - Nightshifter

 

Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues
Born Under a Bad Sign
Crossroad Blues

Tall Tales

[AwesomO4000]

Sorry I have to vote one down, and sorry @SueB that I seem to be oppositing you... I just like "What Is..." just a liiiittle bit more... and I'm not ready to kill Nightshifter... I just can't, and I love Hollywood Babylon, so...

 

-- In My Time of Dying

+ What Is...

+ Hollywood Babylon

 

34 - In My Time of Dying
34 - What Is and What Should Never Be
08 - Hollywood Babylon
02 - Nightshifter

 

Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues
Born Under a Bad Sign
Crossroad Blues

Tall Tales

 

Edited to add: Crap - all my hemming and hawing, I missed it by thaaat much.

Edited July 18, 2014 by AwesomO4000

[mstaken]

 My two personal favorites, TT and BUABS, are gone. I guess that means I'm forced to rewatch them tonight as a tribute. Such a hardship! :) 

 

Nightshifter --

HB --

WIANSB --

 

34 - In My Time of Dying
32 - What Is and What Should Never Be
06 - Hollywood Babylon


Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues
Born Under a Bad Sign
Crossroad Blues
Tall Tales

Nightshifter

Edited July 18, 2014 by mstaken

[DittyDotDot]

Holy crap, where'd they all go?

 

+ In My Time of Dying
-- What Is and What Should Never Be
-- Hollywood Babylon

 

35 - In My Time of Dying
30 - What Is and What Should Never Be
04 - Hollywood Babylon

Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues
Born Under a Bad Sign
Crossroad Blues
Tall Tales

Nightshifter

[7kstar]

Sniff Hollywood I doubt I can save ya and it looks like a bitter battle for the top two.  Several gave Tall Tales a good send off and how I love the trickster but it wasn't my favorite ep  of his. 

 

The cool music ending for Nightshifter and poor Dean trying to savage the mistakes poor Ronnie made when he got killed but at least he died knowing he wasn't totally crazy.

 

I haven't made my mind up on the top two since I love them both!

 

-- In My Time of Dying
+ What Is and What Should Never Be
+ Hollywood Babylon

 

33 - In My Time of Dying
31 - What Is and What Should Never Be
05 - Hollywood Babylon

 

Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues
Born Under a Bad Sign
Crossroad Blues
Tall Tales

Nightshifter

[Demented Daisy]

In My Time of Dying +

Hollywood Babylon +

WIaWSNB --

 

34 - In My Time of Dying
29 - What Is and What Should Never Be
06 - Hollywood Babylon

Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues
Born Under a Bad Sign
Crossroad Blues
Tall Tales
Nightshifter

[SueB]

Ah Nightshifter.... there are times I will watch the end of Nightshifter just for the hell of it if I have 5 mins.  IMO it's one of the best musical montages of any show, let alone Supernatural. And of course I LOVED Ronald Resnick (say it like Sam!).  He was such an adorable dweeb.

 

In My Time of Dying +

Hollywood Babylon --

What Is and What Should Never Be --

 

35 - In My Time of Dying
27 - What Is and What Should Never Be
04 - Hollywood Babylon

 

Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues
Born Under a Bad Sign
Crossroad Blues
Tall Tales
Nightshifter

[PeteMartell]

I know it will go next but I just can't vote against it.

 

Hollywood Babylon +

IMTOD --

WIAWSNB --

 

33 - In My Time of Dying
25 - What Is and What Should Never Be
05 - Hollywood Babylon

Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues
Born Under a Bad Sign
Crossroad Blues
Tall Tales
Nightshifter

[AwesomO4000]

I'm being a rebel and only voting one "-" for one of these.

 

-- In My Time...

+ What Is...

- Hollywood Babylon

 

31 - In My Time of Dying
26 - What Is and What Should Never Be
04 - Hollywood Babylon

 

Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues
Born Under a Bad Sign
Crossroad Blues
Tall Tales
Nightshifter

[mstaken]

IMToD +

WIANSB --

HB --

 

32 - In My Time of Dying
24 - What Is and What Should Never Be
02 - Hollywood Babylon

Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues
Born Under a Bad Sign
Crossroad Blues
Tall Tales
Nightshifter

[Pete Martell]

My last vote for HB (I was in under the wire for the last one). Goodbye to my favorite episode.

 

Hollywood Babylon +

IMTOD --

WIAWSNB --

 

30 - In My Time of Dying
22 - What Is and What Should Never Be
03 - Hollywood Babylon

 

Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues
Born Under a Bad Sign
Crossroad Blues
Tall Tales
Nightshifter

[DittyDotDot]

+ In My Time of Dying
-- What Is and What Should Never Be
-- Hollywood Babylon

 

31 - In My Time of Dying
20 - What Is and What Should Never Be
01 - Hollywood Babylon

 

Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues
Born Under a Bad Sign
Crossroad Blues
Tall Tales
Nightshifter

[7kstar]

-- In My Time of Dying
+ What Is and What Should Never Be
+ Hollywood Babylon

 

29 - In My Time of Dying
21 - What Is and What Should Never Be
02 - Hollywood Babylon

 

Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues
Born Under a Bad Sign
Crossroad Blues
Tall Tales
Nightshifter

 

I rewatched HB last night, it is such a fun ep.  But mostly I love Dean's beginning to think that being a PA sucks to finding out he is really good at it.  It's like for one ep he's a little boy in heaven.  Plus I like the story of them making fun of hunters killing ghost with salt and the girl having trouble screaming.  How many girls have to scream in a stupid horror flick.

 

My top two  are not separated by much.  It depends on my mood, so I guess I will be in the minority here.  But at least my top two are there.  I can't save HB, but at least it lived for a bit longer.

[Demented Daisy]

In My Time of Dying +

WIaWSNB --

Hollywood Babylon +  (I can't save it either, but it can't hurt to try.  I just love that moment when Dean offers the mini sandwich to Sam.)

 

30 - In My Time of Dying
19 - What Is and What Should Never Be
03 - Hollywood Babylon

Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues
Born Under a Bad Sign
Crossroad Blues
Tall Tales
Nightshifter

[SueB]

In My Time of Dying +

What Is and What Should Never Be --

Hollywood Babylon --

31 - In My Time of Dying

17 - What Is and What Should Never Be

01 - Hollywood Babylon

Moved on:

Roadkill

No Exit

Heart

Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things

Croatoan

Everybody Loves a Clown

Playthings

Simon Said

Hunted

Houses of the Holy

Bloodlust

All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1

The Usual Suspects

All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2

Folsom Prison Blues

Born Under a Bad Sign

Crossroad Blues

Tall Tales

Nightshifter

[AwesomO4000]

I'm not going to kill it, and I won't give up on "What Is" so...

 

+ Hollywood Babylon

+ What Is...

-- In My Time

 

29 - In My Time of Dying
18 - What Is and What Should Never Be
02 - Hollywood Babylon

 

Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues
Born Under a Bad Sign
Crossroad Blues
Tall Tales
Nightshifter

[mstaken]

HB --

WIANSB --

IMToD +

 

30 - In My Time of Dying
16 - What Is and What Should Never Be


Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues
Born Under a Bad Sign
Crossroad Blues
Tall Tales
Nightshifter

Hollywood Babylon 

[DittyDotDot]

Hollywood Babylon silently went away, but lets pause and remember its fun light-heartedness for a moment--if for nothing else we should revel in a guest appearance from Gary Cole and Dean getting to have some fun hanging around a film set. ... Okay, carry on.

 

This is so hard, I love them both, but I'm sticking with In My Time Of Dying for now.

 

+ In My Time of Dying
-- What Is and What Should Never Be

 

31 - In My Time of Dying
14 - What Is and What Should Never Be

Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues
Born Under a Bad Sign
Crossroad Blues
Tall Tales
Nightshifter

Hollywood Babylon

[7kstar]

Hollywood Babylon - how I miss Dean's love of life and food.  Dean showing he's good at being in charge of more than Hunts. 

 

Also for me the top two are tied so it makes it easy to vote.

 

-- In My Time of Dying

+ What Is and What Should Never Be

 

29 - In My Time of Dying
15 - What Is and What Should Never Be

 

Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues
Born Under a Bad Sign
Crossroad Blues
Tall Tales
Nightshifter

Hollywood Babylon

Edited July 20, 2014 by 7kstar

[Demented Daisy]

In My Time of Dying +

WIaWSNB --

 

30 - In My Time of Dying
13 - What Is and What Should Never Be

Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues
Born Under a Bad Sign
Crossroad Blues
Tall Tales
Nightshifter
Hollywood Babylon

[SueB]

In My Time of Dying is my favorite but its not so much better than What Is and What Never Should Be that I want to increase the gap. So I'll just burn off some points.

In My Time of Dying --

WIaWSNB --

28 - In My Time of Dying

11 -What Is and What Should Never Be

Moved on:

Roadkill

No Exit

Heart

Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things

Croatoan

Everybody Loves a Clown

Playthings

Simon Said

Hunted

Houses of the Holy

Bloodlust

All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1

The Usual Suspects

All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2

Folsom Prison Blues

Born Under a Bad Sign

Crossroad Blues

Tall Tales

Nightshifter

Hollywood Babylon

[mstaken]

IMToD +

WIANSB --

 

29 - In My Time of Dying
09 -What Is and What Should Never Be

 

 

Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues
Born Under a Bad Sign
Crossroad Blues
Tall Tales
Nightshifter
Hollywood Babylon

[Demented Daisy]

In My Time of Dying +

WIaWSNB --

 

30 - In My Time of Dying
07 -What Is and What Should Never Be


Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues
Born Under a Bad Sign
Crossroad Blues
Tall Tales
Nightshifter
Hollywood Babylon

[7kstar]

In My Time of Dying --

WIaWSNB +

 

28 - In My Time of Dying
08 -What Is and What Should Never Be

Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues
Born Under a Bad Sign
Crossroad Blues
Tall Tales
Nightshifter
Hollywood Babylon

Edited July 21, 2014 by 7kstar

[SueB]

Moving us along...

 

In My Time of Dying --

WIaWSNB --

 

26 - In My Time of Dying
06 -What Is and What Should Never Be

Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues
Born Under a Bad Sign
Crossroad Blues
Tall Tales
Nightshifter
Hollywood Babylon

[DittyDotDot]

+ In My Time of Dying
-- What Is and What Should Never Be

 

27 - In My Time of Dying
04 - What Is and What Should Never Be

 

Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues
Born Under a Bad Sign
Crossroad Blues
Tall Tales
Nightshifter
Hollywood Babylon

[mstaken]

Both: --

 

25 - In My Time of Dying
02 - What Is and What Should Never Be

Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues
Born Under a Bad Sign
Crossroad Blues
Tall Tales
Nightshifter
Hollywood Babylon

[DittyDotDot]

I'm going to skip this round, I can't...I just can't be the one to kill What Is An What Should Never Be...I can't. For just the bits between Jensen and Samantha Smith alone, I can't. But I also can't vote against In My Time Of Dying. Sorry, someone else will have to be better than me and put WIAWSNB out of it's misery.

[SueB]

Well I'm voting at 7:30pm East Coast time.  I'll handle it then if necessary.  But I intend to write a lovely tribute to both.

[7kstar]

I'm going to skip this round, I can't...I just can't be the one to kill What Is An What Should Never Be...I can't. For just the bits between Jensen and Samantha Smith alone, I can't. But I also can't vote against In My Time Of Dying. Sorry, someone else will have to be better than me and put WIAWSNB out of it's misery.

I agree with you 100%.  I love them both and well I doubt I will have to worry about it because many have been voting WIAWSNB down.  To me they are pretty equal but I doubt it will make it to my time to vote.  But I won't be the one to vote it off...I Refuse to believe they aren't equal and my love for both of them will continue even if it makes it an unpopular opinion.  At least I know there are some that agree with me.  LOL>

[7kstar]

Told you I wasn't taking it out.

 

In My Time of Dying --

What Is and What Should Never Be

 

23 - In My Time of Dying
03 - What Is and What Should Never Be

 

Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues
Born Under a Bad Sign
Crossroad Blues
Tall Tales
Nightshifter
Hollywood Babylon

[Demented Daisy]

@SueB will have to do the honors, even though I was willing to do it.  I am not particularly fond of WIaWSNB -- but that's a post for another thread.

 

In My Time of Dying +

WIaWSNB --

 

25 - In My Time of Dying
01 - What Is and What Should Never Be

Moved on:
Roadkill
No Exit
Heart
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Croatoan
Everybody Loves a Clown
Playthings
Simon Said
Hunted
Houses of the Holy
Bloodlust
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1
The Usual Suspects
All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2
Folsom Prison Blues
Born Under a Bad Sign
Crossroad Blues
Tall Tales
Nightshifter
Hollywood Babylon

[SueB]

And so it S2 survival game has wrapped. But first let us praise the #1 & 2 episodes.

What Is and What Should Never Be: A painful and poignant episode that shows us how damaged Dean is as the season is wrapping up. Masterful performance by Jensen Ackles as we see him turn into a little child in the presence of his mother. The look of longing as she caresses his face. Haunting. The insights into his character are pure gold.

In My Time Of Dying: I personally voted this as #1 because the show just takes the series to the next level in this episode and never looks back. The chemistry between father and sons ... So painful and so real. That Sammy NEVER gives up on Dean. John kicking off the first event tnat eventually leads to the Apocalypse. And finally, the ribald scene between John and Dean followed by that perfect coffee drop and slo-motion horror as Sam discovers John. Just electrifying.

S2....so many great episodes.

In My Time of Dying --

WIaWSNB --

23- In My Time of Dying

Moved on:

Roadkill

No Exit

Heart

Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things

Croatoan

Everybody Loves a Clown

Playthings

Simon Said

Hunted

Houses of the Holy

Bloodlust

All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1

The Usual Suspects

All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2

Folsom Prison Blues

Born Under a Bad Sign

Crossroad Blues

Tall Tales

Nightshifter

Hollywood Babylon

What Is and What Should Never Be

Edited July 23, 2014 by SueB

[mstaken]

Who's ready to move on to the enjoyable torture of voting for and against S3 episodes?! 

 

15 - The Magnificent Seven

15 - The Kids Are Alright

15 - Bad Day at Bad Rock

15 - Sin City

15 - Bedtime Stories

15 - Red Sky at Morning

15 - Fresh Blood 

15 - A Very Supernatural Christmas 

15 - Malleus Maleficarum 

15 - Dream a Little Dream of Me 

15 - Mystery Spot 

15 - Jus in Bello

15 - Ghostfacers 

15 - Long Distance Call

15 - Time is on My Side 

15 - No Rest for the Wicked 

[mstaken]

My votes:

 

Mystery Spot ++

Bad Day ++

Red Sky --

 

17 - Bad Day at Black Rock

17 - Mystery Spot

15 - The Magnificent Seven
15 - The Kids Are Alright
15 - Sin City
15 - Bedtime Stories
15 - Fresh Blood
15 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
15 - Malleus Maleficarum
15 - Dream a Little Dream of Me
15 - Jus in Bello
15 - Ghostfacers
15 - Long Distance Call
15 - Time is on My Side
15 - No Rest for the Wicked

13 - Red Sky at Morning

[DittyDotDot]

Nice eulogy @SueB...and on to the task of S3, should be mighty interesting!

 

-- The Magnificent Seven
-- The Kids Are Alright
-- Sin City
 

17 - Bad Day at Black Rock

17 - Mystery Spot

15 - Bedtime Stories
15 - Fresh Blood
15 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
15 - Malleus Maleficarum
15 - Dream a Little Dream of Me
15 - Jus in Bello
15 - Ghostfacers
15 - Long Distance Call
15 - Time is on My Side
15 - No Rest for the Wicked

13 - Red Sky at Morning

13 - The Magnificent Seven
13 - The Kids Are Alright
13 - Sin City

[Demented Daisy]

A Very Supernatural Christmas ++

Jus In Bello ++

Long Distance Call --

 

17 - Bad Day at Black Rock
17 - Mystery Spot
17 - A Very Supernatural Christmas

17 - Jus in Bello

15 - Malleus Maleficarum
15 - Dream a Little Dream of Me
15 - Bedtime Stories
15 - Fresh Blood

15 - Ghostfacers
15 - Time is on My Side
15 - No Rest for the Wicked
13 - Red Sky at Morning
13 - The Magnificent Seven
13 - The Kids Are Alright
13 - Sin City

13 - Long Distance Call

[7kstar]

The Kids Are Alright ++

No Rest for the Wicked ++

Malleus Maleficarum --

 

17 - Bad Day at Black Rock
17 - Mystery Spot
17 - A Very Supernatural Christmas

17 - Jus in Bello

17 - No Rest for the Wicked
15 - Dream a Little Dream of Me
15 - Bedtime Stories
15 - Fresh Blood

15 - Ghostfacers
15 - Time is on My Side

15 - The Kids Are Alright

13 - Malleus Maleficarum
13 - Red Sky at Morning
13 - The Magnificent Seven
13 - Sin City

13 - Long Distance Call

 

I really have to watch season 3 to see which ones are my highest, but I've always liked Lisa and Ben.  I do think we will not be agreeing this much on this season...It will be interesting to see.  :)

[SueB]

Mystery Spot ++

A Very Supernatural Christmas ++

Long Distance Call --

 

 

19 - Mystery Spot
19 - A Very Supernatural Christmas

17 - Bad Day at Black Rock

17 - Jus in Bello

17 - No Rest for the Wicked
15 - Dream a Little Dream of Me
15 - Bedtime Stories
15 - Fresh Blood

15 - Ghostfacers
15 - Time is on My Side

15 - The Kids Are Alright

13 - Malleus Maleficarum
13 - Red Sky at Morning
13 - The Magnificent Seven
13 - Sin City

11 - Long Distance Call

[mstaken]

Mystery Spot ++ 

Long Distance Call ++

The Kids Are Alright --

 

21 - Mystery Spot
19 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
17 - Bad Day at Black Rock
17 - Jus in Bello
17 - No Rest for the Wicked
15 - Dream a Little Dream of Me
15 - Bedtime Stories
15 - Fresh Blood
15 - Ghostfacers
15 - Time is on My Side
13 - The Kids Are Alright
13 - Malleus Maleficarum
13 - Red Sky at Morning
13 - The Magnificent Seven
13 - Sin City
13 - Long Distance Call