Wilowy May 23, 2014 Share May 23, 2014 *SNIFF* Goodbye to my The Tribe! ;) my votes: Derailed The Popular Kids Link to comment
mstaken May 24, 2014 Author Share May 24, 2014 Extreme AggressorCompulsionL.D.S.KThe FoxDerailedA Real RainFisher King, Part 1 The Popular Kids and The Tribe are history, and the next round is open! This is the LAST time we're voting against two. My votes: The Fisher King Part 1 and...hmmm....The Fox (I love them all, though!) Link to comment
idiotwaltz May 24, 2014 Share May 24, 2014 Fisher King Part I The Fox - sorry to see this go, but A Real Rain has my beloved Chinese food scene Link to comment
Old Dog May 24, 2014 Share May 24, 2014 The Fox and A Real Rain. I don;t want any of these to go now! Link to comment
mstaken May 24, 2014 Author Share May 24, 2014 Hee---yeah, I think I forgot to warn you guys that the game gets increasingly agonizing with every passing round. But, hey, hasn't CM tried to teach us all that torture can sometimes be entertaining? ;) 1 Link to comment
Old Dog May 24, 2014 Share May 24, 2014 (edited) Except the torture shown in episode 14 of Season 9! That non entertainment should be forgotten forever. (Sorry - I still haven't got over the disappointment of this episode!) Edited May 24, 2014 by Old Dog 1 Link to comment
mstaken May 25, 2014 Author Share May 25, 2014 The Fox is gone, but we have a tie for that second spot between Fisher King Pt 1 and A Real Rain. Just vote for the one of those two you most want eliminated, and I'll try to end this after three voters! My tiebreaker vote: Fisher King Pt 1 Link to comment
mstaken May 25, 2014 Author Share May 25, 2014 The next voter will decide it! *cue suspenseful music* Link to comment
idiotwaltz May 25, 2014 Share May 25, 2014 Fisher King Part I *holds A Real Rain close* Link to comment
mstaken May 25, 2014 Author Share May 25, 2014 Extreme AggressorCompulsionL.D.S.KDerailedFisher King, Part 1 Willowy voted first so, alas, A Real Rain has been, er, washed right out of the game ;) The next round is open! We're down to voting against just one. My vote: Fisher King, Pt 1 Link to comment
Wilowy May 25, 2014 Share May 25, 2014 Augh! I can't vote against Fisher King! Derailed. Jeff Kober gets on my LAST nerve. Link to comment
mstaken May 25, 2014 Author Share May 25, 2014 Derailed. Hee---Derailed is actually one of my top five of the entire series! These are tough, torturous times...S4 will probably be even more painful than this one :) 1 Link to comment
mstaken May 26, 2014 Author Share May 26, 2014 Our Fantastic Four: Extreme AggressorCompulsionL.D.S.KDerailed My vote: LDSK (I really love it...I think I'm just even more attached to the other three) Link to comment
ForeverAlone May 26, 2014 Share May 26, 2014 Wow. It took LDSK this long to get a vote cast against it. Still.. I vote Compulsion. :) Link to comment
SSAHotchner May 27, 2014 Share May 27, 2014 Whoops, I haven't been here in awhile. Voting for The Fox and A Real Rain to go. Okay, that's what I get for not reading the whole thread before I replied. Sorry, guys. COMPULSION Link to comment
mstaken May 27, 2014 Author Share May 27, 2014 It was a close battle, but Compulsion is history. (I'm so weirdly attached to that episode!) Our Final Three: Extreme AggressorL.D.S.K Derailed Link to comment
Old Dog May 27, 2014 Share May 27, 2014 Darn! Compulsion is my favorite episode in Season One! I wouldn't like to say how many times I've seen it! I would lose Extreme Aggressor. Link to comment
mstaken May 27, 2014 Author Share May 27, 2014 I'm desperate to save Derailed, so Extreme Aggressor! Link to comment
missmycat May 28, 2014 Share May 28, 2014 Derailed. I want to save the wonderful pilot that started it all. 1 Link to comment
mstaken May 28, 2014 Author Share May 28, 2014 *sob* Derailed (which is definitely my favorite of S1 and one of my all-time favorites of the series) has crashed, and we have our final two: Extreme AggressorL.D.S.K My two favorites of S1 are gone, but this is still a great final two. I'll vote against LDSK. Link to comment
Old Dog May 28, 2014 Share May 28, 2014 No No No! This is too hard! We should have stopped at the top three! But I will say Extreme Aggressor. Link to comment
ForeverAlone May 28, 2014 Share May 28, 2014 As much as I love Reid in this episode, it is an easy vote for me. LDSK Link to comment
mstaken May 28, 2014 Author Share May 28, 2014 (edited) No No No! This is too hard! We should have stopped at the top three! Hee! Well, if it's any consolation, I think we'd agreed that afterwards the top three (or was it five..?!) from each season would compete in a 'best of the best' tournament, so we'll see those episodes again :) It looks like Extreme Aggressor is our S1 winner! Ready to continue the enjoyable torture with S2?! Fisher King Part II P911 Perfect Storm Psychodrama The Aftermath The Boogeyman North Mammon Empty Planet The Last Word Lessons Learned Sex, Birth and Death Profiler, Profiled No Way Out The Big Game Revelations Fear and Loathing Distress Jones Ashes and Dust Honor Among Thieves Open Season Legacy No Way Out II: The Evilution of Frank My votes: The Big Game Distress Jones ...I know these aren't the three 'worst' episodes, but for whatever weird combination of reasons, they're probably the three I'm least likely to rewatch! Edited May 28, 2014 by mstaken Link to comment
ForeverAlone May 28, 2014 Share May 28, 2014 Honor Among Thieves Distress Fear and Loathing Link to comment
Wilowy May 28, 2014 Share May 28, 2014 The Big Game Revelations Jones Wow this is gonna be a haaaard season! Also huzzah for Extreme Aggressor!! Best series opener I've ever had the pleasure of watching! Link to comment
mstaken May 28, 2014 Author Share May 28, 2014 (edited) Honor Among Thieves Heh---I know this one isn't long for this game, but it's kind of a guilty pleasure of mine :) I love getting to meet Elizabeth Prentiss and seeing a glimpse of her relationship with her daughter, which (for me!) sheds a lot of light on Emily's character and motivations. Edited May 28, 2014 by mstaken 2 Link to comment
SSAHotchner May 29, 2014 Share May 29, 2014 Honor Among Thieves Distress The Boogeyman Link to comment
idiotwaltz May 29, 2014 Share May 29, 2014 Heh---I know this one isn't long for this game, but it's kind of a guilty pleasure of mine :) I love getting to meet Elizabeth Prentiss and seeing a glimpse of her relationship with her daughter, which (for me!) sheds a lot of light on Emily's character and motivations. Same here! I actually rewatch this one quite often, fast forwarding all the case parts and just watching Em and her mother. It's not even a guilty pleasure; where my shame gland is, there's a second awesome gland. My votes: Fear and Loathing Jones Psychodrama 1 Link to comment
mstaken May 29, 2014 Author Share May 29, 2014 Fisher King Part IIP911Perfect StormPsychodramaThe AftermathThe BoogeymanNorth MammonEmpty PlanetThe Last WordLessons LearnedSex, Birth and DeathProfiler, ProfiledNo Way OutThe Big GameRevelationsFear and LoathingAshes and DustOpen SeasonLegacyNo Way Out II: The Evilution of Frank Distress, Jones and Honor Among Thieves are our first victims, and the next round is open! My votes: The Big Game Profiler, Profiled Fear and Loathing Link to comment
ForeverAlone May 29, 2014 Share May 29, 2014 (edited) Fear and Loathing Open Season Ashes and Dust Edited May 29, 2014 by ForeverAlone Link to comment
idiotwaltz May 29, 2014 Share May 29, 2014 Fear and Loathing Psychodrama Profiler Profiled Link to comment
Old Dog May 29, 2014 Share May 29, 2014 Profiler Profiled Fear and Loathing Psychodrama Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.