amensisterfriend October 19, 2014 Share October 19, 2014 28 is gone, but we have a four-way tie for that second spot among 6, 20, 25 and 27. Just vote for the one of those four that you most want eliminated! Link to comment
lulu1960 October 19, 2014 Share October 19, 2014 27. The sentiment is good but Lorelai's lie ruins it a bit. Link to comment
amensisterfriend October 20, 2014 Share October 20, 2014 (edited) 20 and 28 are gone, and the next round is open. We're still voting against two! 6. Luke and Lorelai discuss their first date plans - Hot Plates!8. Luke and Lorelai discuss the kiss (SGTDM)9. Luke leaves Lorelai messages on her machine (SGTDM)12. Luke and Lorelai get back together (the big kiss at her front door)13. Luke gives Lorelai cheesecake to take home at the end of the Party's Over16. Luke tells Lorelai to keep thinking the way she thinks (Pushkin)17. Luke tells Lorelai about the horoscope. "This thing we're doing. I'm all in." (Wits)25. Tastes like peppermint (Blame Booze and Melville)27. Luke builds Lorelai an ice rink. (Women of Questionable Morals30. Luke tells Lorelai about his Dark Day (BNACAP) Edited October 20, 2014 by amensisterfriend Link to comment
AlinaRay October 20, 2014 Share October 20, 2014 16, 30 I'm just curious, why don't y'all like 27? I thought it was a sweet moment. Link to comment
lulu1960 October 20, 2014 Share October 20, 2014 (edited) Alina, I like the moment. Luke was awesome and I loved Lorelai's expression when he gave it to her. But for me the moment was clouded by her omission to Luke. He asks her straight up what was wrong and she could have just told him. She turned it into a bigger deal than it needed to be. Plus at this point in voting there are others I like a bit more. Edited October 20, 2014 by lulu1960 1 Link to comment
Taryn74 October 20, 2014 Share October 20, 2014 Yeah, what lulu said. The ice rink itself was awesome, but Lorelai not using it as an opening to just come clean about tequila night really frustrates me and ruins my enjoyment of the scene. 1 Link to comment
AlinaRay October 20, 2014 Share October 20, 2014 Ah, gotcha! :) I was just curious. Thank you for clarifying. :D Link to comment
amensisterfriend October 21, 2014 Share October 21, 2014 I'll vote for 25 and 27 (I love 27, but it's gone anyway!), so those two are history. The next round is open! This is the last time we'll vote against two... 6. Luke and Lorelai discuss their first date plans - Hot Plates!8. Luke and Lorelai discuss the kiss (SGTDM)9. Luke leaves Lorelai messages on her machine (SGTDM)12. Luke and Lorelai get back together (the big kiss at her front door)13. Luke gives Lorelai cheesecake to take home at the end of the Party's Over16. Luke tells Lorelai to keep thinking the way she thinks (Pushkin)17. Luke tells Lorelai about the horoscope. "This thing we're doing. I'm all in." (Wits)30. Luke tells Lorelai about his Dark Day (BNACAP) Link to comment
junienmomo October 21, 2014 Share October 21, 2014 We can declare all of these winners as far as I'm concerned, but here are my least favorites: 6, 30 Link to comment
amensisterfriend October 22, 2014 Share October 22, 2014 30 is gone, but we have a tie between 6 and 12 for that final spot. My tiebreaker vote: 6 Link to comment
lulu1960 October 22, 2014 Share October 22, 2014 So tough. I'll base it on my rewind test. I must have rewound the kiss tons of times so I will go with 6 Link to comment
amensisterfriend October 22, 2014 Share October 22, 2014 Okay, so 6 and 30 are history...and we're down to voting against just one! 8. Luke and Lorelai discuss the kiss (SGTDM)9. Luke leaves Lorelai messages on her machine (SGTDM)12. Luke and Lorelai get back together (the big kiss at her front door)13. Luke gives Lorelai cheesecake to take home at the end of the Party's Over16. Luke tells Lorelai to keep thinking the way she thinks (Pushkin)17. Luke tells Lorelai about the horoscope. "This thing we're doing. I'm all in." (Wits) Link to comment
amensisterfriend October 23, 2014 Share October 23, 2014 8. Luke and Lorelai discuss the kiss (SGTDM)9. Luke leaves Lorelai messages on her machine (SGTDM)12. Luke and Lorelai get back together (the big kiss at her front door)16. Luke tells Lorelai to keep thinking the way she thinks (Pushkin)17. Luke tells Lorelai about the horoscope. "This thing we're doing. I'm all in." (Wits) 13 is gone, and the next round is open! Just vote for the one you most want eliminated :) Link to comment
amensisterfriend October 23, 2014 Share October 23, 2014 17---the line delivery and the way Lauren Graham looks (to me!) somewhat trapped and panicked rather than delighted mars this scene for me! Link to comment
Taryn74 October 23, 2014 Share October 23, 2014 Giving up on 12 for now to vote 17 for the same reasons you listed! A panicked reaction rather than a delightfully pleased one was not what I wanted to see right then. :( Link to comment
junienmomo October 23, 2014 Share October 23, 2014 Piling onto 17 - it was a confusing moment for me, watching her response. Link to comment
amensisterfriend October 24, 2014 Share October 24, 2014 17 is gone, and we're down to our final four! 8. Luke and Lorelai discuss the kiss (SGTDM)9. Luke leaves Lorelai messages on her machine (SGTDM)12. Luke and Lorelai get back together (the big kiss at her front door)16. Luke tells Lorelai to keep thinking the way she thinks (Pushkin) Link to comment
amensisterfriend October 25, 2014 Share October 25, 2014 I'll vote against 12 as well, so we're down to our final three: 8. Luke and Lorelai discuss the kiss (SGTDM)9. Luke leaves Lorelai messages on her machine (SGTDM)16. Luke tells Lorelai to keep thinking the way she thinks (Pushkin) Link to comment
amensisterfriend October 27, 2014 Share October 27, 2014 Our final two! 8. Luke and Lorelai discuss the kiss (SGTDM)16. Luke tells Lorelai to keep thinking the way she thinks (Pushkin) Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.