4evaQuez July 7, 2016 Share July 7, 2016 Cole Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2386433
Not Beth July 7, 2016 Share July 7, 2016 Cole. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2386723
amensisterfriend July 7, 2016 Author Share July 7, 2016 (edited) I'm so torn, because on one hand Cole was so much more important to the storylines, themes and overall show than Henry, and I did find him compelling and entertaining most of the time...but I just genuinely LIKE Henry so much more! So I'll sadly vote against Cole :) Edited July 7, 2016 by amensisterfriend 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2386786
amensisterfriend July 7, 2016 Author Share July 7, 2016 Just waiting for Lady C :) Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2387229
Lady Calypso July 7, 2016 Share July 7, 2016 Oh god, this is hard because I like both. Sadly, I'll vote Henry, only because Cole was one of my first male crushes. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2387549
amensisterfriend July 7, 2016 Author Share July 7, 2016 1. Prue 2. Piper 3. Phoebe 4. Paige 13. Henry We're down to our final five, and there's just one male character left standing :) Just vote for the one character you most want eliminated! Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2387612
Lady Calypso July 7, 2016 Share July 7, 2016 *whispers* Phoebe *unwhispers* Phoebe's obsession with family/babies led to a lot of bad choices for me by the last two seasons. And it led to Dex. I was never sick of Henry, maybe because he was only in one season. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2387629
4evaQuez July 8, 2016 Share July 8, 2016 I'll echo Phoebe Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2387928
Kohola3 July 8, 2016 Share July 8, 2016 Henry was OK but not sure how he made it this far! Not exactly a pivotal character in my book. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2387933
amensisterfriend July 8, 2016 Author Share July 8, 2016 I'll vote against Henry. He's great, but not nearly as essential to my personal obsession with this show as the four sisters :) Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2387944
Not Beth July 8, 2016 Share July 8, 2016 I will vote Phoebe. Especially since when I compare Phoebe to Henry in season eight, I know who I prefer. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2388510
amensisterfriend July 8, 2016 Author Share July 8, 2016 In a surprising twist, Henry has outlasted Phoebe by a vote of 3-2! Our final four: 1. Prue 2. Piper 4. Paige 13. Henry Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2388645
Kohola3 July 8, 2016 Share July 8, 2016 Henry Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2388652
Lady Calypso July 8, 2016 Share July 8, 2016 Now I can go with Henry. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2388668
amensisterfriend July 8, 2016 Author Share July 8, 2016 Reiterating my vote for Henry :) Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2388692
Not Beth July 8, 2016 Share July 8, 2016 Well, I guess I shall have to choose Henry, but I'm glad he made it as far as he did. :) Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2388751
4evaQuez July 8, 2016 Share July 8, 2016 Henry! I'm shocked he made it this far! Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2388848
Kohola3 July 8, 2016 Share July 8, 2016 I am surprised he's been hanging in there as well. Not arguing, Not Beth, just curious as to why you like Henry so much. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2388854
Not Beth July 8, 2016 Share July 8, 2016 1 hour ago, Kohola3 said: I am surprised he's been hanging in there as well. Not arguing, Not Beth, just curious as to why you like Henry so much. He's possibly the only good thing about season eight. It's also probable that just he's not in the show for long enough for his character to get ruined. Cole was in the show for just long enough for his character to get ruined - I enjoyed his arc in the third season; I didn't like his arc in season four, but at least they gave him a good ending, until they dragged him back for season five. And Phoebe's personality just went downhill as each season went by. :) I hope that answers your curiosity. Please feel free to respond with your opinions too. 2 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2389150
amensisterfriend July 8, 2016 Author Share July 8, 2016 (edited) Our triumphant trio: Prue Piper Paige This pains me, but I have t vote against Piper. She's got so many great qualities and I've grown to like and appreciate her more than ever before, especially after reading some of your great posts, but she's got this tendency to be depressingly negative and constantly complain and nag about every little thing (which happens to be a pet peeve of mine!), and most of her many storylines with Leo didn't do either character any favors IMO. I'll probably be the only one to vote against her, though, so knowing my vote is most likely meaningless makes me feel less guilty about casting it :) Edited July 8, 2016 by amensisterfriend Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2389165
4evaQuez July 8, 2016 Share July 8, 2016 Prue. I love Prue, and I originally started watching the show specifically for Shannon Doherty - I used to be a huge fan. However; of the three remaining women, I just love her just a little less. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2389215
Not Beth July 8, 2016 Share July 8, 2016 Paige. I just prefer Prue and Piper to Paige, even despite Piper's own annoyances in later seasons. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2389225
Kohola3 July 8, 2016 Share July 8, 2016 Paige Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2389795
Lady Calypso July 8, 2016 Share July 8, 2016 I'm voting against Piper. Paige was my first favourite out of the show, since I started watching in late season 5. I grew to really love and appreciate Prue as a character during rewatches. Piper's great, but she can be a little much at times. Mainly her attitude toward Leo in the later seasons. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2389973
amensisterfriend July 8, 2016 Author Share July 8, 2016 Okay, so Piper and Paige are tied---the first person who sees this can cast a tiebreaker vote (even if you've already voted!) for the one of those two you want eliminated! Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2389998
4evaQuez July 8, 2016 Share July 8, 2016 Piper Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2390018
amensisterfriend July 8, 2016 Author Share July 8, 2016 Prue Paige Our final two never got to interact on screen, but they both have a special place in my heart :) Should we do relationships next? If so, platonic relationships, romantic relationships, or both on the the same list? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2390055
Lady Calypso July 9, 2016 Share July 9, 2016 Ok, this one is surprisingly difficult, because I really do love both (and I also relate to both). But I have to cast my vote to evict Prue. I just related to Paige more, and I'll always enjoy her the most out of all the sisters. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2390315
amensisterfriend July 9, 2016 Author Share July 9, 2016 Lady C., can I beg you to go over to the Paige thread and talk in detail about why you love and relate to her? I'd love to read it and will probably agree with the majority of it :) Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2390319
Lady Calypso July 9, 2016 Share July 9, 2016 25 minutes ago, amensisterfriend said: Lady C., can I beg you to go over to the Paige thread and talk in detail about why you love and relate to her? I'd love to read it and will probably agree with the majority of it :) No begging is required! At some point this weekend, if it's not tonight, I'll hop over and express my feelings on the lovely Paige Matthews (Halliwell)! 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2390373
4evaQuez July 9, 2016 Share July 9, 2016 Wow, so we're down to the classic battle Prue vs. Paige. I vote against Prue. Paige has just always had a quality I truly love. 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2390716
amensisterfriend July 9, 2016 Author Share July 9, 2016 4eva, LadyC and I just gushed about her in her thread, so please come join us! I love Prue, too, by the way, and am always curious about what sort of relationship they'd have had. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2390727
Not Beth July 9, 2016 Share July 9, 2016 I vote against Paige. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2391134
amensisterfriend July 9, 2016 Author Share July 9, 2016 Just waiting for our Kohola! Meanwhile, are we doing relationships next? Should we do platonic relationships and romantic relationships at the same time? I'd love to keep the game going if people still want to play! Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2391389
4evaQuez July 9, 2016 Share July 9, 2016 My vote is for platonic relationships first. I have a question. Can we add the sister's relationships to ghosts/demons, etc. I ask because I can't think of a lot of significant platonic relationships on the show outside of the sisters. However, I would love to include Piper's relationship to John Cho's character or Phoebe's relationship to Cordelia Chase...err...Kira. There's also the Leo/Chris relationship. Leo/Cole. Paige/Leo. Did Prue and Antonio Sabato Jr. ever get romantic? Gram/Leo/Chris? I guess what I'm asking is how significant does the relationship have to be to the show, since a lot of these relationships were shown in one-off episodes or were given very minimal attention. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2391667
amensisterfriend July 9, 2016 Author Share July 9, 2016 4eva, you just reminded me that we were going to do demons/villains next, not relationships! Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2391729
Lady Calypso July 9, 2016 Share July 9, 2016 After demons/villains, we could split relationships in two. Platonic relationships, and then romantic relationships. We could expand romantic relationships to more than just a recurring arc, but ones that people remember (Jeremy/Piper, or Piper/Ghost John Cho, for example, as both are memorable in their own ways). I mean, for me, we'd have to include Phoebe/Cupid, even if it was only a one episode thing and it didn't really go anywhere. It's still memorable to me and I think it could count as potential for a romantic relationship, right? But I guess we should start compiling a list for the demons/villains of the series. I guess I'll leave that to @amensisterfriend Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2391781
amensisterfriend July 9, 2016 Author Share July 9, 2016 But I guess we should start compiling a list for the demons/villains of the series. I guess I'll leave that to @AMENSISTERFRIEND I'm going to need tons of help compiling the list of villains/demons, so please feel free to start listing any and all that come to mind! Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2391819
Lady Calypso July 9, 2016 Share July 9, 2016 Ok! Well, I guess I'll start! Well, there's The Source, Belthazor, Barbas, Gideon, Zankou, Jeremy, The Triad, Christy/The Ultimate Power, Rex, Hannah, The Crone, The Seer, and I think those are all the 'main' demons/villains. Then there are the one off or small arc villains, but I'll let others throw out suggestions! 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2391836
Not Beth July 9, 2016 Share July 9, 2016 Kyra; Litvack (the demon after Bane whilst he hid away at his dream house with Prue); Ludlow (owned the demon academy that had bounty hunters bring in potential trainees like Tyler the firestarter); speaking of bounty hunters: Krell the Zotar (he went after Cole/Belthazor after he killed the Triad); Stanely (We can never forget Stanley! - The Day the Magic Died). I'll leave it at that for now. I might suggest more one-episode only demons later. If I think of more. 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2391867
Lady Calypso July 9, 2016 Share July 9, 2016 1 minute ago, Not Beth said: Krell the Zotar "I'm Krell, a Zotar." "I'm Prue, a Scorpio." Love that moment. Also don't forget Matthew Tate and Nicholas. And the Water Demon. And would the Nexus count? LOL. Oh, and don't forget Abby, the one from Sight Unseen. And....do we include the Elders or not? I'm really trying to think of memorable, one off villains. I know we can't include them all! 2 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2391874
Not Beth July 9, 2016 Share July 9, 2016 24 minutes ago, Lady Calypso said: "I'm Krell, a Zotar." "I'm Prue, a Scorpio." Love that moment. Also don't forget Matthew Tate and Nicholas. And the Water Demon. And would the Nexus count? LOL. Oh, and don't forget Abby, the one from Sight Unseen. And....do we include the Elders or not? I'm really trying to think of memorable, one off villains. I know we can't include them all! That's so the part I was thinking of when I mentioned Krell. xD Great scene. Can't believe I forgot Matthew and Nicholas and the Water Demon! They're integral warlocks and demons to the early years of the show. I don't think the Nexus counts, but definitely the Woogyman. 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2391950
4evaQuez July 9, 2016 Share July 9, 2016 I'm shocked no one has mentioned Shax yet. The one demon to successfully kill a Charmed one. I always liked the Warlock from Pre-Witched. (I did a Google search but his name in that episode didn't seem to be listed.) I also liked Kurzon from the Three Faces of Phoebe. And also the Spider Demon from Spin City. (Glancing at the list it seems we need more female villains.) 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2392063
Not Beth July 9, 2016 Share July 9, 2016 (edited) 7 minutes ago, 4evaQuez said: The one demon to successfully kill a Charmed one. I always liked the Warlock from Pre-Witched. (I did a Google search but his name in that episode didn't seem to be listed.) I think everyone called him Shadow because that was his name when he was a cat. What about the Warlock that killed Natalie? I think his name was Eames? Also, how about the Brotherhood of the Thorn? The only demon's name I can think of off the top of my head from that lot is Klea. Oh and Raynor who I think was Cole's mentor. Edited to add: Oh and can we add Evil Wyatt to this one? Edited July 9, 2016 by Not Beth Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2392076
Lady Calypso July 9, 2016 Share July 9, 2016 (edited) 13 minutes ago, 4evaQuez said: I'm shocked no one has mentioned Shax yet. The one demon to successfully kill a Charmed one. I always liked the Warlock from Pre-Witched. (I did a Google search but his name in that episode didn't seem to be listed.) I also liked Kurzon from the Three Faces of Phoebe. And also the Spider Demon from Spin City. (Glancing at the list it seems we need more female villains.) How did I forget about Shax? Yeah, I'm thinking about some more memorable female villains, but a lot of them I just didn't like (for example, I didn't like the Sea Hag, or the Wicked Witch from Happily Ever After or the villain from Freaky Phoebe). I guess that's why they could fit on the list? Oh, there's also Ginny the genie. And there's Terra, the evil spirit who possessed Piper in season 3. Oh, and the Siren. Also other villains I've thought of? Vinceres from Primrose, Abraxas, the Banshee. Obviously, we should narrow our list down a little bit because we have so many villains we could use. Also, another possible round we could play is a round where the sisters turn into something else (Banshee, vampire, Wendigo, and we could even include possessions or when the sisters go evil). Edited July 9, 2016 by Lady Calypso Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2392091
amensisterfriend July 9, 2016 Author Share July 9, 2016 Okay, here's what we have so far....let me know if there are any more we should add! The Source Belthazor Barbas Gideon Zankou Jeremy The Triad Christy/The Ultimate Power Rex Hannah The Crone The Seer Evil Wyatt Shax Shadow Brotherhood of the Thorn Eames Kurzon Spider Demon Matthew Nicholas Water Demon Woogyman Kyra Litvack (the demon after Bane whilst he hid away at his dream house with Prue) Ludlow (owned the demon academy that had bounty hunters bring in potential trainees like Tyler the firestarter) Krell the Zotar (he went after Cole/Belthazor after he killed the Triad) Stanely (We can never forget Stanley! - The Day the Magic Died) 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2392161
Not Beth July 9, 2016 Share July 9, 2016 If I counted correctly, that's 28, so I don't think we need anymore than that. It's just a case of whether or not some are replaced with other villains we can think of? Also, you don't need to keep the brackets after the names of the demons I mentioned. xD I only did that since they're not necessarily best remembered by name. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2392172
Lady Calypso July 9, 2016 Share July 9, 2016 I was also going to throw out Evil Wyatt, mostly because even though Evil Wyatt was from the future, that was the entire purpose of Chris coming back from the future and it gave the entire main plot of season 6. But I also understand that we have a lot of villains. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2392188
amensisterfriend July 9, 2016 Author Share July 9, 2016 Lady C, Evil Wyatt is already on the list! Not Beth, I LOVE your descriptors of those demons...it helps people with memories as awful as mine to recall who the heck some of these are :) Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2392204
Lady Calypso July 9, 2016 Share July 9, 2016 3 minutes ago, amensisterfriend said: Lady C, Evil Wyatt is already on the list! Not Beth, I LOVE your descriptors of those demons...it helps people with memories as awful as mine to recall who the heck some of these are :) Heh, I guess I didn't look closely enough! I was about to go on another one of my spiels! I tend to forget a lot of the demons' names, so the descriptions are great! Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/39473-charmed-elimination-games/page/12/#findComment-2392209
Recommended Posts