7kstar September 3, 2014 Share September 3, 2014 -- It's a Terrible Life ++ Death Takes a Holiday ++ Yellow Fever 33 - Lazarus Rising29 - On the Head of a Pin25 - In the Beginning21 - The Monster at the End of This Book 19 - Death Takes a Holiday19 - Yellow Fever17 - It's a Terrible Life17 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester15 - Jump the Shark15 - Lucifer Rising15 - Wishful Thinking15 - Monster Movie13 - The Rapture13 - When the Levee Breaks07 - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School Special Link to comment
SueB September 4, 2014 Share September 4, 2014 -- The Rapture ++ The Monster at the End of This Book -- It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester 33 - Lazarus Rising29 - On the Head of a Pin25 - In the Beginning23 - The Monster at the End of This Book 19 - Death Takes a Holiday19 - Yellow Fever17 - It's a Terrible Life17 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester15 - Jump the Shark15 - Lucifer Rising15 - Wishful Thinking15 - Monster Movie13 - When the Levee Breaks 11 - The Rapture 05 - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School Special Link to comment
Demented Daisy September 4, 2014 Share September 4, 2014 ItGP, SW -- The Rapture -- When the Levee Breaks -- 33 - Lazarus Rising29 - On the Head of a Pin25 - In the Beginning23 - The Monster at the End of This Book19 - Death Takes a Holiday19 - Yellow Fever17 - It's a Terrible Life17 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester15 - Jump the Shark15 - Lucifer Rising15 - Wishful Thinking15 - Monster Movie11 - When the Levee Breaks09 - The Rapture03 - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam WinchesterSent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School Special Link to comment
AwesomO4000 September 4, 2014 Share September 4, 2014 -- Yellow Fever ++ The Monster... ++ It's a Terrible Life 33 - Lazarus Rising29 - On the Head of a Pin25 - In the Beginning25 - The Monster at the End of This Book19 - Death Takes a Holiday 19 - It's a Terrible Life17 - Yellow Fever17 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester15 - Jump the Shark15 - Lucifer Rising15 - Wishful Thinking15 - Monster Movie11 - When the Levee Breaks09 - The Rapture03 - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School Special Link to comment
DittyDotDot September 4, 2014 Share September 4, 2014 Oh my, I've been neglecting this game lately...and look at the delighfully deadly progress! ;) -- On the Head of a Pin++ Jump the Shark++ Wishful Thinking 33 - Lazarus Rising27 - On the Head of a Pin25 - In the Beginning25 - The Monster at the End of This Book19 - Death Takes a Holiday 19 - It's a Terrible Life17 - Yellow Fever17 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester17- Jump the Shark 17 - Wishful Thinking15 - Lucifer Rising15 - Monster Movie11 - When the Levee Breaks09 - The Rapture03 - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School Special 1 Link to comment
catrox14 September 4, 2014 Share September 4, 2014 ++ On the Head of a Pin--ITGP,SW--When the Levee Breaks 33 - Lazarus Rising29 - On the Head of a Pin25 - In the Beginning25 - The Monster at the End of This Book19 - Death Takes a Holiday 19 - It's a Terrible Life17 - Yellow Fever17 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester17- Jump the Shark 17 - Wishful Thinking15 - Lucifer Rising15 - Monster Movie09 - When the Levee Breaks09 - The Rapture01 - It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School Special Link to comment
SueB September 5, 2014 Share September 5, 2014 So let us talk about the wonder that was: It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester. First of all, kudos for quoting a Charlie Brown. Second, my heart breaks for Sam when he finds out that not only do the Angels not LIKE him, they are great big dicks. And bless Dean for encouraging him. I love the scene of Dean and Cas in the park. Profound bond scene. And Uriel is a BadAss. OTOH -- Razors in the candy is a personal squick. Teen witch was awful. So... an episode with some excellent scenes so I'll remember it for that. ++ The Monster at the End of This Book-- It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester--The Rapture 33 - Lazarus Rising29 - On the Head of a Pin 27 - The Monster at the End of This Book 25 - In the Beginning19 - Death Takes a Holiday 19 - It's a Terrible Life17 - Yellow Fever17 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester17- Jump the Shark 17 - Wishful Thinking15 - Lucifer Rising15 - Monster Movie09 - When the Levee Breaks07 - The Rapture Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School Special It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester Link to comment
Demented Daisy September 5, 2014 Share September 5, 2014 I can get past a lot of stuff in that episode, but not the mispronunciation of "Samhain". Call me pedantic, I know, but I can't help it. 2 Link to comment
7kstar September 5, 2014 Share September 5, 2014 ++ Yellow Fever++ Death Takes a Holiday--It's a Terrible Life 33 - Lazarus Rising29 - On the Head of a Pin 27 - The Monster at the End of This Book 25 - In the Beginning21 - Death Takes a Holiday 19 - Yellow Fever 17 - It's a Terrible Life17 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester17- Jump the Shark 17 - Wishful Thinking15 - Lucifer Rising15 - Monster Movie09 - When the Levee Breaks07 - The Rapture Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School Special It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester Link to comment
AwesomO4000 September 5, 2014 Share September 5, 2014 -- On the Head of a Pin ++ It's A Terrible Life ++ Monster Movie 33 - Lazarus Rising27 - On the Head of a Pin 27 - The Monster at the End of This Book 25 - In the Beginning21 - Death Takes a Holiday 19 - Yellow Fever 19 - It's a Terrible Life17 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester17- Jump the Shark 17 - Wishful Thinking 17 - Monster Movie15 - Lucifer Rising09 - When the Levee Breaks07 - The Rapture Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School Special It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester Link to comment
Demented Daisy September 5, 2014 Share September 5, 2014 The Rapture -- (I have nothing against Cas, I just don't care about Jimmy.) Wishful Thinking -- On the Head of a Pin -- 33 - Lazarus Rising 27 - The Monster at the End of This Book 25 - On the Head of a Pin 25 - In the Beginning21 - Death Takes a Holiday19 - Yellow Fever19 - It's a Terrible Life17 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester17- Jump the Shark 17 - Monster Movie 15 - Wishful Thinking 15 - Lucifer Rising09 - When the Levee Breaks05 - The RaptureSent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester Link to comment
SueB September 6, 2014 Share September 6, 2014 The Rapture -- (ditto.) Jump the Shark -- On the Head of a Pin ++ 33 - Lazarus Rising 27 - The Monster at the End of This Book 27 - On the Head of a Pin 25 - In the Beginning21 - Death Takes a Holiday19 - Yellow Fever19 - It's a Terrible Life17 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester 17 - Monster Movie 15- Jump the Shark 15 - Wishful Thinking 15 - Lucifer Rising09 - When the Levee Breaks03 - The Rapture Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester Link to comment
catrox14 September 6, 2014 Share September 6, 2014 MATHEofTB -- Jump the Shark++ (I give this high marks for Dean skulking about the Jeffries tubes and the mausoleum and high bar manuevers) When the Levee Breaks -- 33 - Lazarus Rising 27 - On the Head of a Pin 25 - The Monster at the End of This Book 25- In the Beginning21 - Death Takes a Holiday19 - Yellow Fever19 - It's a Terrible Life17 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester 17 - Monster Movie 17- Jump the Shark 15 - Wishful Thinking 15 - Lucifer Rising07 - When the Levee Breaks03 - The Rapture Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester Link to comment
DittyDotDot September 6, 2014 Share September 6, 2014 -- On the Head of a Pin ++ Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester ++ Wishful Thinking 33 - Lazarus Rising 25 - On the Head of a Pin 25 - The Monster at the End of This Book 25- In the Beginning21 - Death Takes a Holiday19 - Yellow Fever19 - It's a Terrible Life19 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester 17 - Monster Movie 17- Jump the Shark 17 - Wishful Thinking 15 - Lucifer Rising07 - When the Levee Breaks03 - The Rapture Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester Link to comment
SueB September 6, 2014 Share September 6, 2014 the Jeffries tubes excellent reference Link to comment
7kstar September 6, 2014 Share September 6, 2014 ++ On the Head of a Pin ++ Yellow Fever -- The Rapture 33 - Lazarus Rising 27 - On the Head of a Pin 25 - The Monster at the End of This Book 25- In the Beginning21 - Death Takes a Holiday21 - Yellow Fever19 - It's a Terrible Life19 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester 17 - Monster Movie 17- Jump the Shark 17 - Wishful Thinking 15 - Lucifer Rising07 - When the Levee Breaks01 - The Rapture Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester Link to comment
AwesomO4000 September 6, 2014 Share September 6, 2014 -- Lazurus Rising -- On the Head of a Pin -- Yellow Fever 31 - Lazarus Rising 25 - On the Head of a Pin 25 - The Monster at the End of This Book 25- In the Beginning21 - Death Takes a Holiday19 - Yellow Fever19 - It's a Terrible Life19 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester 17 - Monster Movie 17- Jump the Shark 17 - Wishful Thinking 15 - Lucifer Rising07 - When the Levee Breaks01 - The Rapture Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester Link to comment
Demented Daisy September 6, 2014 Share September 6, 2014 Jump the Shark -- Wishful Thinking -- Lucifer Rising -- 31 - Lazarus Rising25 - On the Head of a Pin25 - The Monster at the End of This Book25- In the Beginning21 - Death Takes a Holiday19 - Yellow Fever19 - It's a Terrible Life19 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester17 - Monster Movie15- Jump the Shark15 - Wishful Thinking13 - Lucifer Rising07 - When the Levee Breaks01 - The RaptureSent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester Link to comment
DittyDotDot September 6, 2014 Share September 6, 2014 -- On the Head of a Pin-- When the Levee Breaks--The Rapture 31 - Lazarus Rising25 - The Monster at the End of This Book25- In the Beginning 23 - On the Head of a Pin 21 - Death Takes a Holiday19 - Yellow Fever19 - It's a Terrible Life19 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester17 - Monster Movie15- Jump the Shark15 - Wishful Thinking13 - Lucifer Rising05 - When the Levee Breaks Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester The Rapture Link to comment
SueB September 7, 2014 Share September 7, 2014 (edited) Well we need to eulogize The Rapture. Bits I kinda loved -- that Jimmy was a devoted man and that the way Castiel first approached him (at the start of S4) was slowly and as kindly as Cas would understand. I attribute Cas' douchey behavior at the end to his retraining. I like that Sam and Dean assumed responsibility for Jimmy and tried to protect him. "Was it a refreshing Coke?" ++ On the Head of a Pin-- Jump the Shark-- In The Beginning 31 - Lazarus Rising25 - The Monster at the End of This Book 25 - On the Head of a Pin 23 - In the Beginning 21 - Death Takes a Holiday19 - Yellow Fever19 - It's a Terrible Life19 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester17 - Monster Movie15 - Wishful Thinking13 - Lucifer Rising 13- Jump the Shark 05 - When the Levee Breaks Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester The Rapture Edited September 7, 2014 by SueB Link to comment
catrox14 September 7, 2014 Share September 7, 2014 RIP The Rapture. Misha was a revelation as Jimmy. Such great work but I just never connected with this episode because I didn't really care about Jimmy. Like ever. And agree with SueB about "Was it a refreshing coke?". Great line reading by Jensen. ++Lazarus Rising--When the Levee Breaks --Lucifer Rising 33 - Lazarus Rising25 - The Monster at the End of This Book 25 - On the Head of a Pin 23 - In the Beginning 21 - Death Takes a Holiday19 - Yellow Fever19 - It's a Terrible Life19 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester17 - Monster Movie15 - Wishful Thinking 13- Jump the Shark11 - Lucifer Rising 03 - When the Levee Breaks Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester The Rapture Link to comment
7kstar September 7, 2014 Share September 7, 2014 (edited) ++ Yellow Fever++ In the Beginning -- It's a Terrible Life 33 - Lazarus Rising25 - The Monster at the End of This Book 25 - On the Head of a Pin 25 - In the Beginning 21 - Death Takes a Holiday21 - Yellow Fever17 - It's a Terrible Life19 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester17 - Monster Movie15 - Wishful Thinking 13- Jump the Shark11 - Lucifer Rising 03 - When the Levee Breaks Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester The Rapture I know I'm in the minority of loving Yellow Fever, but Eye of the tiger, Dean screaming like a girl when a bitty dog is chasing him, the scene with the cat and the scary moment with Lilith helps me to forgive the awful ending. I really think this is one of the shows where they looked at a few moments and didn't really think about what it meant when they put Dean as the victim and I do watch those moments. Edited September 7, 2014 by 7kstar Link to comment
catrox14 September 7, 2014 Share September 7, 2014 You're not alone. I love Yellow Fever. I think it's one of Jensen's best all around performances. It was a really nuanced performance that never mocked people who suffer from severe anxiety and panic disorder and I thought he was very believable and funny at the same time. And then he turned on a dime with drama and real terror when he was hallucinating Samazel. Link to comment
AwesomO4000 September 7, 2014 Share September 7, 2014 (edited) ++ It's A Terrible Life -- Jump the Shark -- Death Takes a Holiday 33 - Lazarus Rising25 - The Monster at the End of This Book 25 - On the Head of a Pin 25 - In the Beginning 21 - Yellow Fever 19 - Death Takes a Holiday19 - It's a Terrible Life19 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester17 - Monster Movie15 - Wishful Thinking 11- Jump the Shark11 - Lucifer Rising 03 - When the Levee Breaks Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester The Rapture I actually think I'm in the minority for really disliking "Yellow Fever." I think it's almost a crime how it screwed up a ghost story * and made it an awful message to boot - the solution to getting rid of a ghost of someone who was abused is to... abuse him some more? What? Awful. For me some of Jensen's work was very subtle and great, but the comedy scenes were a bit over the top for me. My fault: I tend to prefer more wry subtle humor - or dick jokes for some reason (since not really subtle) - but the more slapstick stuff alone isn't my thing for the most part. For example: in "Bad Day At Black Rock" the scene with Sam and the air conditioner was funny for me more because of the irony and Jared's subtle stuff (like scratching his nose in defiance of Dean) much more than the physical aspects. So all of Jensen's subtle work does not save this overall episode for me or make up for the awful message and having Sam call Dean's personality into question the entire episode and show him very little consideration/sympathy and then have Bobby add to it. Neither of which seemed in character to me. Just no. I felt manipulated with "poor Dean" when it wasn't necessary - the situation was already sympathetic - and I don't like that. More season 4 piling on stuff - bah. Like with Sam in "Metamorphosis," it's too bad for me that the writers put so much Dean character insight and progression in an otherwise (for me anyway) weak episode. I think this is going to be a rough round for me... My favorite episodes don't seem to be as much liked. And there are much beloved episodes that I really dislike. * I liked "It's a Terrible Life's" ghost story so much better. Edited September 7, 2014 by AwesomO4000 Link to comment
Demented Daisy September 7, 2014 Share September 7, 2014 When the Levee Breaks -- Lucifer Rising -- Jump the Shark -- 33 - Lazarus Rising25 - The Monster at the End of This Book25 - On the Head of a Pin25 - In the Beginning21 - Yellow Fever19 - Death Takes a Holiday19 - It's a Terrible Life19 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester17 - Monster Movie15 - Wishful Thinking09- Jump the Shark09 - Lucifer Rising01 - When the Levee BreaksSent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam WinchesterThe Rapture Link to comment
SueB September 8, 2014 Share September 8, 2014 Yellow Fever- I'm in the middle. Loved the return of Lilith and Dean going off on how stupid their life is. OTOH, HATED the resolution of the ghost story. As for Eye of the Tiger. It's hilarious and I can't watch it because I am odd in that way. So it's one I'll neither save nor persecute. If it's hanging on I'd push it over the edge, just to move the game along. Eulogy for "When the Levee Breaks": Well I hated the fight. Let's get that right out there. And Ruby needs to die. OTOH, I'm shallow enough to say "hubba hubba" on the Ruby/Sam chemistry when he was reaching for her knife. I also felt like the promise Dean made to Cas to serve God and "you guys" was sort of a lost opportunity. It seemed like a big deal but it didn't really bind him in anyway. I did love Dean being able to figure out Sam's moves when Sam was trying to throw him off. OTOH, Sam was playing 'hurt' so... I don't know if a determined Sam (who was not strung out) would be able to elude Dean or not. If the objective was to make us SUPER UNHAPPY before the finale -- they succeeded. So..yay?! You did your job well "When the Levee Breaks". On the Head of a Pin ++ When the Levee Break -- Jump the Shark -- 33 - Lazarus Rising27 - On the Head of a Pin 25 - The Monster at the End of This Book25 - In the Beginning21 - Yellow Fever19 - Death Takes a Holiday19 - It's a Terrible Life19 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester17 - Monster Movie15 - Wishful Thinking09 - Lucifer Rising 07- Jump the Shark Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam WinchesterThe Rapture When the Levee Breaks 1 Link to comment
DittyDotDot September 8, 2014 Share September 8, 2014 -- On the Head of a Pin ++ The Monster at the End of This Book++ Wishful Thinking 33 - Lazarus Rising 27 - The Monster at the End of This Book25 - On the Head of a Pin 25 - In the Beginning21 - Yellow Fever19 - Death Takes a Holiday19 - It's a Terrible Life19 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester17 - Monster Movie17 - Wishful Thinking09 - Lucifer Rising 07- Jump the Shark Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam WinchesterThe Rapture When the Levee Breaks Link to comment
7kstar September 8, 2014 Share September 8, 2014 (edited) ++ On the Head of a Pin -- The Monster at the End of This Book++ In the Beginning 33 - Lazarus Rising27 - On the Head of a Pin 27 - In the Beginning 25 - The Monster at the End of This Book21 - Yellow Fever19 - Death Takes a Holiday19 - It's a Terrible Life19 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester17 - Monster Movie17 - Wishful Thinking09 - Lucifer Rising 07- Jump the Shark Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam WinchesterThe Rapture When the Levee Breaks Just so you know, all the negative things you point out is why Yellow Fever isn't my top 3. I really think they just didn't think it through because they were so surprised at the negative reaction that for the first time Kripke gave a personal reaction to explain it. I think they just focused on the funny moments and never thought about how fans would react to how they treated the ghost at the end, which does lower the ep. But for me it seems like most eps for season 4 I only thought parts were good and the rest should be dumped. So many missed opportunities in my opinion and sad that a season that starts off with a bang seems to whimper on the ending of the season. It will be interesting to see the final results. :) Edited September 8, 2014 by 7kstar Link to comment
Demented Daisy September 8, 2014 Share September 8, 2014 Lazarus Rising ++ On the Head of a Pin -- The Monster at the End of This Book ++ 35 - Lazarus Rising27 - In the Beginning27 - The Monster at the End of This Book 25 - On the Head of a Pin 21 - Yellow Fever19 - Death Takes a Holiday19 - It's a Terrible Life19 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester17 - Monster Movie17 - Wishful Thinking09 - Lucifer Rising07- Jump the SharkSent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam WinchesterThe RaptureWhen the Levee Breaks Link to comment
SueB September 9, 2014 Share September 9, 2014 On the Head of a Pin ++ Wishful Thinking -- (Sam Raime's character gets away too easy) Jump the Shark -- 35 - Lazarus Rising27 - In the Beginning27 - The Monster at the End of This Book 27 - On the Head of a Pin 21 - Yellow Fever19 - Death Takes a Holiday19 - It's a Terrible Life19 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester17 - Monster Movie15 - Wishful Thinking09 - Lucifer Rising05- Jump the Shark Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam WinchesterThe RaptureWhen the Levee Breaks Link to comment
DittyDotDot September 9, 2014 Share September 9, 2014 ++ The Monster at the End of This Book -- On the Head of a Pin++ Wishful Thinking 35 - Lazarus Rising29 - The Monster at the End of This Book 27 - In the Beginning25 - On the Head of a Pin 21 - Yellow Fever19 - Death Takes a Holiday19 - It's a Terrible Life19 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester17 - Monster Movie17 - Wishful Thinking09 - Lucifer Rising05- Jump the Shark Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam WinchesterThe RaptureWhen the Levee Breaks Link to comment
AwesomO4000 September 9, 2014 Share September 9, 2014 -- Lazurus Rising -- On the Head Of a Pin ++ Monster Movie 33 - Lazarus Rising29 - The Monster at the End of This Book 27 - In the Beginning23 - On the Head of a Pin 21 - Yellow Fever 19 - Death Takes a Holiday 19 - It's a Terrible Life19 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester19 - Monster Movie17 - Wishful Thinking09 - Lucifer Rising05- Jump the Shark Link to comment
Demented Daisy September 9, 2014 Share September 9, 2014 On the Head of a Pin -- Yellow Fever -- It's a Terrible Life ++ 33 - Lazarus Rising 29 - The Monster at the End of This Book27 - In the Beginning 21 - It's a Terrible Life 21 - On the Head of a Pin19 - Yellow Fever19 - Death Takes a Holiday19 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester19 - Monster Movie17 - Wishful Thinking09 - Lucifer Rising05- Jump the Shark Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam WinchesterThe RaptureWhen the Levee Breaks Link to comment
AwesomO4000 September 10, 2014 Share September 10, 2014 -- Yellow Fever -- Death Takes A holiday ++ It's A Terrible Life 33 - Lazarus Rising 29 - The Monster at the End of This Book27 - In the Beginning 23 - It's a Terrible Life 21 - On the Head of a Pin19 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester19 - Monster Movie 17 - Yellow Fever17 - Death Takes a Holiday17 - Wishful Thinking09 - Lucifer Rising05- Jump the Shark Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam WinchesterThe RaptureWhen the Levee Breaks Link to comment
SueB September 10, 2014 Share September 10, 2014 -- On the Head of a Pin -- In the Beginning -- It's A Terrible Life 33 - Lazarus Rising 29 - The Monster at the End of This Book25 - In the Beginning 23 - On the Head of a Pin 21 - It's a Terrible Life19 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester19 - Monster Movie 17 - Yellow Fever17 - Death Takes a Holiday17 - Wishful Thinking09 - Lucifer Rising05- Jump the Shark Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam WinchesterThe RaptureWhen the Levee Breaks Link to comment
DittyDotDot September 10, 2014 Share September 10, 2014 ++ The Monster at the End of This Book-- On the Head of a Pin ++ It's a Terrible Life 33 - Lazarus Rising 31 - The Monster at the End of This Book25 - In the Beginning 23 - It's a Terrible Life 21 - On the Head of a Pin 19 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester19 - Monster Movie 17 - Yellow Fever17 - Death Takes a Holiday17 - Wishful Thinking09 - Lucifer Rising05- Jump the Shark Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam WinchesterThe RaptureWhen the Levee Breaks Link to comment
catrox14 September 10, 2014 Share September 10, 2014 ++ Lazarus Rising ++ On the Head of a Pin --Jump the Shark 35 - Lazarus Rising 31 - The Monster at the End of This Book25 - In the Beginning 23 - It's a Terrible Life 23- On the Head of a Pin 19 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester19 - Monster Movie 17 - Yellow Fever17 - Death Takes a Holiday17 - Wishful Thinking09 - Lucifer Rising03- Jump the Shark Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam WinchesterThe RaptureWhen the Levee Breaks Link to comment
7kstar September 10, 2014 Share September 10, 2014 ++ In the Beginning ++ On the Head of a Pin --It's a Terrible Life 35 - Lazarus Rising 31 - The Monster at the End of This Book27 - In the Beginning 25- On the Head of a Pin 21 - It's a Terrible Life 19 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester19 - Monster Movie 17 - Yellow Fever17 - Death Takes a Holiday17 - Wishful Thinking09 - Lucifer Rising03- Jump the Shark Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam WinchesterThe RaptureWhen the Levee Breaks Link to comment
SueB September 11, 2014 Share September 11, 2014 -- Jump the Shark ++ On the Head of a Pin --It's a Terrible Life 35 - Lazarus Rising 31 - The Monster at the End of This Book27 - In the Beginning 27- On the Head of a Pin 19 - It's a Terrible Life 19 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester19 - Monster Movie 17 - Yellow Fever17 - Death Takes a Holiday17 - Wishful Thinking09 - Lucifer Rising01- Jump the Shark Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam WinchesterThe RaptureWhen the Levee Breaks Link to comment
AwesomO4000 September 11, 2014 Share September 11, 2014 -- On the Head Of A Pin -- Are You There God, It's Me Dean Winchester ++ It's A Terrible Life 35 - Lazarus Rising 31 - The Monster at the End of This Book27 - In the Beginning 25- On the Head of a Pin 21 - It's a Terrible Life 19 - Monster Movie 17 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester 17 - Yellow Fever17 - Death Takes a Holiday17 - Wishful Thinking09 - Lucifer Rising01- Jump the Shark Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam WinchesterThe RaptureWhen the Levee Breaks Link to comment
DittyDotDot September 11, 2014 Share September 11, 2014 ++ The Monster at the End of This Book-- On the Head of a Pin ++ It's a Terrible Life 35 - Lazarus Rising 33 - The Monster at the End of This Book27 - In the Beginning 23- On the Head of a Pin 23 - It's a Terrible Life 19 - Monster Movie 17 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester 17 - Yellow Fever17 - Death Takes a Holiday17 - Wishful Thinking09 - Lucifer Rising01- Jump the Shark Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam WinchesterThe RaptureWhen the Levee Breaks Link to comment
catrox14 September 11, 2014 Share September 11, 2014 -- Monster at the End of This Book--Lucifer Rising --In the Beginning 35 - Lazarus Rising 31 - The Monster at the End of This Book25- In the Beginning 23- On the Head of a Pin 23 - It's a Terrible Life 19 - Monster Movie 17 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester 17 - Yellow Fever17 - Death Takes a Holiday17 - Wishful Thinking07 - Lucifer Rising01- Jump the Shark Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam WinchesterThe RaptureWhen the Levee Breaks Link to comment
Demented Daisy September 11, 2014 Share September 11, 2014 Oops, forgot to vote yesterday. On the Head of a Pin -- It's a Terrible Life ++ Wishful Thinking -- 35 - Lazarus Rising31 - The Monster at the End of This Book25- In the Beginning25 - It's a Terrible Life 21- On the Head of a Pin 19 - Monster Movie17 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester17 - Yellow Fever17 - Death Takes a Holiday15 - Wishful Thinking07 - Lucifer Rising01- Jump the Shark Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam WinchesterThe RaptureWhen the Levee Breaks Link to comment
ohjoy September 11, 2014 Share September 11, 2014 (edited) Shame I found this game three a half seasons in (since I only watched seven), but I'm still totally up for this. Death Takes a Holiday --Wishful Thinking ++Lucifer Rising -- 35 - Lazarus Rising31 - The Monster at the End of This Book25- In the Beginning25 - It's a Terrible Life 21- On the Head of a Pin 19 - Monster Movie17 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester17 - Yellow Fever17 - Wishful Thinking15 - Death Takes a Holiday05 - Lucifer Rising01- Jump the Shark Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam WinchesterThe RaptureWhen the Levee Breaks Edited September 11, 2014 by RandomMe Link to comment
7kstar September 12, 2014 Share September 12, 2014 Welcome RandomMe! It's a Terrible Life --On the Head of a Pin ++Yellow Fever ++ 35 - Lazarus Rising31 - The Monster at the End of This Book25- In the Beginning23 - It's a Terrible Life 23- On the Head of a Pin 19 - Monster Movie 19 - Yellow Fever17 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester17 - Wishful Thinking15 - Death Takes a Holiday05 - Lucifer Rising01- Jump the Shark Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam WinchesterThe RaptureWhen the Levee Breaks Link to comment
SueB September 12, 2014 Share September 12, 2014 (edited) Man, this Season is brutal. At this rate, we won't finish S4 before S10. Well I'm taking out "Jump The Shark". And with THAT, we are at the half-way point and voting rules change. +'s (plus-ups) are limited to a single count, --'s (downvotes) can still be two. Jump the Shark eulogy: This episode actually had some awesome bits for me. The freak-out by Dean of learning John had another son that he PROTECTED from the brutal hunting life. And so Dean immediately picks up on his father's wishes. When you look in the Psychology Dictionary, does it have Dean Winchester's picture next to the definition of Daddy Issues? Just putting that out there. Plus we get (as catrox pointed out) jeffries tube Dean as ex-cheerleader Jensen gymnastics with a pull-up bar. I also liked Sam getting to play older brother for a moment -- although I didn't like him roping Adam into the life. Didn't like: sorry, too gory for me with the eviscerating Sam moment. It's a Terrible Life --On the Head of a Pin ++Jump the Shark -- 35 - Lazarus Rising31 - The Monster at the End of This Book25- In the Beginning 25- On the Head of a Pin 21 - It's a Terrible Life 19 - Monster Movie 19 - Yellow Fever17 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester17 - Wishful Thinking15 - Death Takes a Holiday05 - Lucifer Rising Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam WinchesterThe RaptureWhen the Levee Breaks Jump the Shark Edited September 12, 2014 by SueB Link to comment
DittyDotDot September 12, 2014 Share September 12, 2014 (edited) Thanks, SueB, for taking out Jump The Shark and putting it out of it's misery. I knew it wouldn't make it to the end, but I also couldn't bring myself to take it out. I rather enjoy the episode, if for nothing else than the quiet moments. -- On the Head of a Pin + It's a Terrible Life + Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester 35 - Lazarus Rising31 - The Monster at the End of This Book25- In the Beginning 23- On the Head of a Pin 22 - It's a Terrible Life 19 - Monster Movie 19 - Yellow Fever18 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester17 - Wishful Thinking15 - Death Takes a Holiday05 - Lucifer Rising Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam WinchesterThe RaptureWhen the Levee Breaks Jump the Shark Edited September 12, 2014 by DittyDotDot Link to comment
AwesomO4000 September 12, 2014 Share September 12, 2014 @RandomMe - Shame I found this game three a half seasons in (since I only watched seven), but I'm still totally up for this. One of us... One of us.... and if that doesn't make you run away: Welcome to our little madhouse! -- Lazarus Rising -- Yellow Fever -- Death Takes A Holiday 33 - Lazarus Rising 31 - The Monster at the End of This Book 25- In the Beginning 23- On the Head of a Pin 22 - It's a Terrible Life 19 - Monster Movie 18 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester 17 - Yellow Fever 17 - Wishful Thinking 13 - Death Takes a Holiday 05 - Lucifer Rising Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel Rescue Criss Angel Is a Douchebag Family Remains Metamorphosis Sex and Violence I Know What You Did Last Summer Heaven and Hell After School Special It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester The Rapture When the Levee Breaks Jump the Shark 1 Link to comment
catrox14 September 12, 2014 Share September 12, 2014 -- Lucifer Rising -- Monster at the End of this Book +Lazarus Rising 34 - Lazarus Rising29 - The Monster at the End of This Book25- In the Beginning 23- On the Head of a Pin 22 - It's a Terrible Life 19 - Monster Movie 18 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester 17 - Yellow Fever17 - Wishful Thinking13 - Death Takes a Holiday03 - Lucifer Rising Sent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam WinchesterThe RaptureWhen the Levee Breaks Jump the Shark Link to comment
Demented Daisy September 12, 2014 Share September 12, 2014 On the Head of a Pin -- Lucifer Rising -- It's a Terrible Life + 34 - Lazarus Rising29 - The Monster at the End of This Book25- In the Beginning23 - It's a Terrible Life 21- On the Head of a Pin 19 - Monster Movie18 - Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester17 - Yellow Fever17 - Wishful Thinking13 - Death Takes a Holiday01 - Lucifer RisingSent to Hell with No Hope of an Angel RescueCriss Angel Is a DouchebagFamily RemainsMetamorphosisSex and ViolenceI Know What You Did Last SummerHeaven and HellAfter School SpecialIt's the Great Pumpkin, Sam WinchesterThe RaptureWhen the Levee BreaksJump the Shark Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.