Yay, this thread! I am a Christmas-movie-loving-Jew so will have to look for the Joey Lawrence one. This is indeed the most wonderful time of the year, especially since Hallmark started airing these, like, a month ago. I have not checked Lifetime out yet but plan to.
I re-watched The Nine Lives of Christmas last night and also caught the end of A Cookie Cutter Christmas which was OK. Then I started All I Want for Christmas which looked promising but I was tired...I'll catch the end the next time it's on or what not.
Getting some other ideas upthread, woohoo thanks.
Oh, and The Christmas Shepherd looks like it will be good.