Ziggy

Right, I understand why the show portrayed it that way. What I’m asking is, did Jenny travel with Claire or with Jamie in the books? And who did Young Iam travel with? I just can’t remember how it happened in the books, so I was hoping somebody would remind me.

Did Jenny not travel to the Colonies with Claire in the book? I do distinctly remember her saying she was coming with them, now that Ian had passed away.

I didn’t view it as Olivia critiquing the apology. It was more like she was trying to figure out whether this Mariah actually cared or was just trying to clear her conscience. I thought it was fair that Olivia didn’t completely let her off the hook without knowing for sure that Mariah felt remorseful. i also found it quite sad that in her interview, Mariah said that Olivia was only nice to her when she wasn’t getting along with her parents. What a bunch of hoowie!

Yes! It was a very interesting premise, and I really wanted to see where they were going with it. I wish the pacing had been a little better, and I suppose the season was a little too much set up. I thought Ahsoka was too much set up, as well, but it's getting a 2nd season. Maybe having characters that are already beloved made the difference.

I'm not quite sure I understand what you're referring to. I thought Olivia very much accepted Mariah's apology. At first, I was honestly quite frustrated that Olivia was so kind and understanding. I guess I wanted Olivia to really put her in her place! But then Olivia talked about how she had made mistakes when she was 20, and she wished she had been given a little grace. Wow! If only more people could respond that way. My oldest son made some pretty big mistakes in the past year, and he feels remorseful and embarrassed, and he's really matured since then. When we talk about things, one thing we talk about is trying to be understanding and compassionate when others make really bad choices. It was so refreshing to see someone be so kind and mature. In accepting Mariah's apology, I don't think Olivia said that what Mariah did was ok. She simply said that she had also made mistakes in the past and she wasn't going to hold it against Mariah. Awesome! It's so important to remember that forgiving someone else really is a gift you give yourself. It doesn't excuse what the other person did. It doesn't mean that what they did didn't hurt you. It really means that you are going to let it go and not let those hurt feelings control you. Mariah made some really bad decisions. It's too bad that she still believes that Olivia was only nice to her when she was not on good terms with her family. Maybe someday she will realize that Olivia really was there for her, always, and stop blaming Olivia for all of the problems in their family.

I think logically, everything you said is correct. Missy would realize that Sheldon was grieving in his own way, as she has seen many times. But because Missy was grieving, she just couldn't see it. She was so consumed with her own grief that she couldn't see it. I was actually surprised when Mary told Missy to go to her room. Under normal circumstances, sure. But Missy's behavior was not extreme. I thought Pastor Jeff could have said more. In the Big Bang Theory when Sheldon asked Georgie to come to his wedding, Georgie mentioned that Georgie was the only one who was there for Missy after George died. I thought it was a nice moment at the funeral when he put his arm around Missy and then when he said people were laughing because they loved him. He really was there for Missy.

I was a little disappointed in MIssy's story. Her grieving was 100% authentic. She didn't understand that people grieve differently, but no one really bothered to talk to her about it. At the funeral, I loved it that when she was hurt by everyone laughing at Meemau's jokes, Georgie said something that helped a little, but she was still clearly upset and confused by Sheldon. I just really wanted to see someone talk to her and help her to at least realize that Sheldon wasn't unaffected by their dad passing.

You're not wrong! True.

This is absolutely a common myth, but Limbo is not (and never has been) an official teaching of the Catholic Church. If you want to read about it, here is the link from the Vatican website: https://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/cti_documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_20070419_un-baptised-infants_en.html But this is the relevant information: The teaching of Limbo was "never entered into the dogmatic definitions of the Magisterium" "in the Catechism of the Catholic Church (1992), the theory of limbo is not mentioned. Rather, the Catechism teaches that infants who die without baptism are entrusted by the Church to the mercy of God, as is shown in the specific funeral rite for such children. The principle that God desires the salvation of all people gives rise to the hope that there is a path to salvation for infants who die without baptism (cf. CCC, 1261)"

There were definitely Catholics who were taught about Limbo, but it has never been an official teaching of the Catholic Church. There was also a time when Catholics were also taught that anyone who was not Baptized could not go to Heaven, but officially the Church says that we don't know but hope that they can be saved by the Grace of God. I wish the Church would go a step further and admit that they have no business definitively saying what happens after we die and that God can do whatever God wants to do. I've always been a bit put off by humans claiming to have that authority. But I'll try to get off my soap box and remind myself that Young Sheldon is a sitcom and a show that I enjoy and that I should try to stop taking those things so seriously :-)

Many Christians do believe that the unbaptized will not go to Heaven, but the Catholic Church does not teach that. Although, I supposed it's possible that Mandy's mom didn't know that.

Me, too! I love this show. I really do! It is absolutely better than most of the shows on TV these days. Sure, there are parts that don't perfectly mesh with me, but overall, I love it!

I think they definitely downplayed Mandy’s reaction. Most parents I know it would’ve been absolutely livid! I thought the baptisms were unrealistic - at least the Catholic one. I don’t know any priest who would baptize a baby without first meeting with the parents. Most priest would want to have a couple of different sessions with them before the baptism. But, Young Sheldon is a sitcom, and in general, the seriousness of everything was downplayed.

I don't know that they retconned it. Sheldon has never been a reliable narrator.

I would be willing to bet they didn't have a choice. From what other TLC reality stars have said in interviews, once you sign that contract, TLC has the right to film those moments if they want.