I mean, that's essentially this ALCS since both are about the end of America and of civilization and of the world as we know it. However, The Day After Tomorrow has approximately 11 billion times the entertainment value and doesn't involve cheating cheaters who cheat. So, there's that.
What I'm saying is, I unashamedly love The Day After Tomorrow (I mean, 57 tornadoes annihilating LA all at once? As an Angeleno, YES, that shit is hilarious!!!!!), and you made the only correct choice!