Gilmore Girls Elimination Game

[Kohola3]

20

[ghoulina]

12

[amensisterfriend]

12 and 20 are deadlocked! Cheeseburgh, since you're the only person who didn't vote for either of those two, maybe you could break our tie by choosing one of those two to eliminate?! 

[amensisterfriend]

Since cheese burgh isn't around, let's just do a normal tiebreaker: 12 vs 20, and I'll end this after the first person swoops in to vote :) 

[elang4]

20 to eliminate. I love 12 too much!

[amensisterfriend]

2. When Lorelai sees the chuppah Luke made for her. (Road Trip)

9. Emily and Lorelai stealing bathrobes together. (There's the Rub)

10. When the Reenactors show up at Louie's funeral. (Dead Uncles)

12. Lorelai tucks her hand under Luke's arm as she reassures him that he is not his uncle. (Dead Uncles). (DUAV)

32. Lorelai's parents look on proudly as she graduated from business school

 

Our fabulous final five! My vote: 12 

[Taryn74]

12

[elang4]

Noooo why 12??? That's one of my faves!! :( I'll go with 9.

[Kohola3]

12 is my fave as well. I'll go with 9.

[LeafontheWind]

I really like 9, especially since it goes along with the time Emily was a vicious trollop, but I like 12 more. So 9 it is!

[amensisterfriend]

Noooo why 12??? That's one of my faves!!

Generally speaking, these games tend to end up divided between people who find most of the Luke and/or Luke/Lorelai moments the best/most touching etc and those who usually prefer other characters/relationships/aspects of the show :) 

[cantbeflapped]

9.  Last time after I went with the flow, the flow changed.  :). 

[ghoulina]

12

[Taryn74]

1 hour ago, elang4 said:

Noooo why 12??? That's one of my faves!! :( 

Because I consider 10 and 12 basically the same scene, but I like the moment in 10 a wee bit better.  :)

[ghoulina]

2 hours ago, Taryn74 said:

Because I consider 10 and 12 basically the same scene, but I like the moment in 10 a wee bit better.  :)

That's my rationale as well. 

[lulu1960]

9

[Viqutorious]

12. Sorry I was out of town before!

Edited July 23, 2016 by CheeseBurgh

[amensisterfriend]

9 is history, and we're down to our final four:

2. When Lorelai sees the chuppah Luke made for her. (Road Trip)

10. When the Reenactors show up at Louie's funeral. (Dead Uncles)

12. Lorelai tucks her hand under Luke's arm as she reassures him that he is not his uncle. (Dead Uncles). (DUAV)

32. Lorelai's parents look on proudly as she graduated from business school

 

My vote: 12 

[elang4]

32

[Viqutorious]

12

[Kohola3]

32

[lulu1960]

10. 

[ghoulina]

12

[LeafontheWind]

10

[A Beaverhausen]

32

[cantbeflapped]

Oh no....votes for 32 already?    12 is my vote....has to be done to try and save 32.  :). 

[Taryn74]

Ah, dang.  9 may be my favorite E/L moment of the entire series.  *sniff*

Onward!  Voting 12 again.

[amensisterfriend]

Our terrific final three:

2. When Lorelai sees the chuppah Luke made for her. (Road Trip)

10. When the Reenactors show up at Louie's funeral. (Dead Uncles)

32. Lorelai's parents look on proudly as she graduated from business school

[LeafontheWind]

I am sticking with 10. I love 2 and 32 equally.

[Kohola3]

32.  The first round winner was the elder Gilmores so I'd like to see another pairing.

[Viqutorious]

2, that chuppah bugged me so much! 

[Taryn74]

10

[cantbeflapped]

10

[elang4]

32. I did love that moment but I love the other two even more and as Kohola said, we had an Elder Gilmore winner for season 1. 

[lulu1960]

32

[ghoulina]

2

[amensisterfriend]

I'll cast my vote against 10, so we're now down to our fabulous final two:

2. When Lorelai sees the chuppah Luke made for her. (Road Trip)

32. Lorelai's parents look on proudly as she graduated from business school

 

...Feel free to start nominating sweet S3 moments as they pop to mind! 

[elang4]

2 to win!! I think the chuppah was so sweet! :)

Some season 3 moments:

1. Paris being asked out on a date by Jamie and her not realising. (Those Lazy Hazy Crazy Days)

2. Rory helping Paris get ready for her date with Jamie. (TLHCD)

3. Lorelai meeting Rory at the airport after her Washington trip. (TLHCD)

4. Lorelai letting Kirk down gently after he asked her out. (Haunted Leg)

5. Lorelai and Rory cancelling plans to spend time together after realising that Rory going off to college was coming quicker than they thought. (Application Anxiety)

6. Luke and Lorelai talk about possibly having kids in the future if they find the right person. (They Shoot Gilmores, Don't They?)

7. Paris admitting to Rory that Jamie had told her he loved her. (TSGDT)

8. Richard and Emily tell Lorelai and Rory how Richard proposed. (Let the Games Begin)

9. Rory and Jess' first kiss. "I'm glad you didn't smoke it." (LTGB)

10. Lorelai and Rory noticing Luke's disappointment when they told him they couldn't make his thanksgiving dinner and subsequently Lorelai pretending to change plans so that they could. (A Deep Fried Korean Thanksgiving)

11. Lane and Dave's First Kiss (ADFKT)

12. Luke teaches Lorelai how to fish. (Lorelai Out Of Water)

13. Paris tells Rory she slept with Jamie. (The Big One)

14. Rory comforts Paris after her meltdown. (TBO)

15. Lorelai tells Luke about her dream. (A Tale Of Poes And Fire)

16. Lorelai changes all of Rory's Harvard memorabilia to Yale. (ATOPAF)

17. Luke's awkward hug with Rory. (ATOPAF)

18. Dave asks Mrs Kim if he can take Lane to the prom. (Say Goodnight Gracie)

19. Lorelai finds out Rory was named valedictorian. (Here Comes The Son)

20. Rory's speech at her Chilton graduation. (Those Are Strings Pinnochio)

Sorry I've literally just watched season 3 on Netflix so it's fresh in my mind! I've probably missed some moments. You don't have to use all of these. :)

Oh forgot some from The Big One!

1. Lorelai and Sookie realising at the same time that Sookie was pregnant.

2. Jackson finally telling Sookie how happy he was about the baby.

[amensisterfriend]

Thanks for the wonderful nominations, elang! 

[elang4]

I keep thinking of them!! Got another!

Jess knowing how far away Yale was from Stars Hollow.

:)

[Kohola3]

32.  Save the chuppah!

[LeafontheWind]

32, we have to protect Gilbert!

[Taryn74]

32

[Viqutorious]

2! The Chuppah was cheesy, and Lorelai wasn't Jewish.

added note: Where and when did he build it? He had no storage, just never made sense to me.

Edited July 25, 2016 by CheeseBurgh

[Viqutorious]

season 3. I loved the scene when Dean told Rory, (paraphrasing here) 'Too bad someone doesn't like you for once" 

are we only supposed to pick sweet moments? 

20 hours ago, elang4 said:

32. I did love that moment but I love the other two even more and as Kohola said, we had an Elder Gilmore winner for season 1. 

That is because those are the best scenes! :) I actually choked up at 32.

Edited July 25, 2016 by CheeseBurgh

[ghoulina]

2, The Reenactor moment was my absolute favorite, so this is a little sad for me. 

[cantbeflapped]

2...I'm a L/L fan, but the chuppah moment is far from a favorite for me.   And, as I said before, 32 is one of my favorites of the series.

[ghoulina]

Season 3 moments - 

 

~ When Dave tells Lane he's an audiophile and she tells him she loves him...."for that". (Application Anxiety)

~When Jess turns the sprinkler back on so Dean can save Rory. (Eight O'Clock)

~Rory and Dean getting pie together and deciding to be friends. (That'll Do, Pig)

~When Lorelai gets Emily a DVD player and movies for when Richard is out of town. (Dear Emily and Richard)

~Emily trying her hardest to be nice to Jess at dinner, even though he's being a surly ass. (Swan Song)

~Emily and Trix making up after Emily exposed her kiss with the man in a track suit. (Face Off)

~Dave running all the way to hockey rink during a break from playing just to see Lane. (Face Off)

[amensisterfriend]

Wow, who would have thought that S3 had a lot more sweet "awww" worthy moments than my beloved S2?! Clearly I need to do another S3 rewatch :) 

[lulu1960]

32. I love Gilbert. ;)