Gilmore Girls Elimination Game

[LeafontheWind]

I must need to rewatch the episode with number 13. I keep voting for it because I just can't remember it at all. So, I will go with 6,13, and 24.

[amensisterfriend]

I'll go against 10, 21 and 22...but it pains me to part with any of these :) 

[lulu1960]

12, 13, 24

[Kohola3]

5, 22, 24

[Taryn74]

6 (because the santa burger IS pretty disgusting looking), 10 (because in retrospect, the whole thing is just 'ugh'), and 21 (because as much as I love DD and S/J, there are other moments of this ep that I love more)

[cantbeflapped]

1,6,22

[betterthisway]

This looks like so much fun! Can anyone jump in at any time? If it's not too late, I'll vote to eliminate 12, 21 and 22. 

[lulu1960]

betterthisway, people are always welcome. Enjoy the game.

[amensisterfriend]

This looks like so much fun! Can anyone jump in at any time?

Oh my gosh, yes, we love new game playing GG fans around here! Welcome!!! 

I'll end this round later tonight or tomorrow morning :)

[ghoulina]

6, 22, 23

[Kohola3]

I must jump in to say that while the Santaburger was really disgusting, I did like the sentiment behind it.

[elang4]

1 minute ago, Kohola3 said:

I must jump in to say that while the Santaburger was really disgusting, I did like the sentiment behind it.

Same! I thought it was sweet because it's obvious he did it just to make her smile. :)

[amensisterfriend]

6 and 22 are gone, but we have a tie between 21 and 24 for that next spot! Just vote for the one of those two you most want eliminated, and to make this quick, I'll end this after just ONE vote :) 

[elang4]

21

[amensisterfriend]

1) "Sorry, too late..." (Final scene from the Pilot in response to Luke's mock warning that Rory doesn't want to turn out like her mom)

2) Lorelai and Rory hug and commiserate over their terrible days (LFDAC) 

5) Luke makes Rory a special coffee cake for her birthday (RBP) 

7) Luke closes the diner immediately upon learning that Richard is ill and insists on driving Lorelai to the hospital (F&S)

8) Lorelai gently says that they don't have to change EVERYTHING about the diner after Luke reminisces about his dad (TDDR) 

10) Lorelai cradles Rory and orders pizza upon seeing that Rory is finally 'ready to wallow' (The Breakup, Pt 2) 

12) Rory helps Paris get ready for her date with Tristan, trying to boost her confidence (and sanity!) along the way 

13) Lorelai and Emily bond on the couch (Rory's Dance)

15) Luke brings hot drinks to the reenactors (L&W&S)

16) Lorelai gives Luke a new blue cap (F&S)

19) Rory asks if she can hug Richard while he's lying in a hospital bed (F&S)

23) Lorelai and Luke talk about Lorelai's love of snow. Luke shares memories of his dad.

24) Lorelai and Rory sit on the grass looking at the Dragonfly talking about opening the Inn.

26)  "Yes, Emily, you may go first" (F&S) 

 

...and the next round is open :) The good news is that we can now start voting against TWO, which I guess in theory makes this a tad less painful?! 

My votes: 10 and 13 (13 is sweet, but knowing what happens between Lorelai and Emily in this very same episode---and countless times after!---makes it a little less enjoyable for me now!) 

[Kohola3]

Ditto.

[elang4]

10 and 13 for me as well. :)

[Taryn74]

1013 (I made this!) works for me too.

[LeafontheWind]

13 and 24

[Viqutorious]

5. & 24

[junienmomo]

13 and 26

[lulu1960]

12, 13

[cantbeflapped]

10,12

[ghoulina]

5, 23

[amensisterfriend]

1) "Sorry, too late..." (Final scene from the Pilot in response to Luke's mock warning that Rory doesn't want to turn out like her mom)

2) Lorelai and Rory hug and commiserate over their terrible days (LFDAC) 

5) Luke makes Rory a special coffee cake for her birthday (RBP) 

7) Luke closes the diner immediately upon learning that Richard is ill and insists on driving Lorelai to the hospital (F&S)

8) Lorelai gently says that they don't have to change EVERYTHING about the diner after Luke reminisces about his dad (TDDR) 

12) Rory helps Paris get ready for her date with Tristan, trying to boost her confidence (and sanity!) along the way 

15) Luke brings hot drinks to the reenactors (L&W&S)

16) Lorelai gives Luke a new blue cap (F&S)

19) Rory asks if she can hug Richard while he's lying in a hospital bed (F&S)

23) Lorelai and Luke talk about Lorelai's love of snow. Luke shares memories of his dad.

24) Lorelai and Rory sit on the grass looking at the Dragonfly talking about opening the Inn.

26)  "Yes, Emily, you may go first" (F&S) 

 

10 and 13 are gone, and the next round is open! 

 

My votes: 12 and 23 

[Viqutorious]

5 & 23

[elang4]

2 and 12

[betterthisway]

I feel guilty when I vote out any because I love them all. Someone has to bring me back to reality and remind me that voting out moments doesn't actually mean erasing them from the series! 

 

23 and 24

[Kohola3]

2, 16

[LeafontheWind]

I will also go with 23 and 24

[lulu1960]

12, 24. I feel your pain, betterthisway.

[Taryn74]

4 hours ago, betterthisway said:

Someone has to bring me back to reality and remind me that voting out moments doesn't actually mean erasing them from the series! 

Ha ha, yes!

12 and 23

[junienmomo]

2 and 12

[cantbeflapped]

12,2

[ghoulina]

5, 23

[amensisterfriend]

1) "Sorry, too late..." (Final scene from the Pilot in response to Luke's mock warning that Rory doesn't want to turn out like her mom)

2) Lorelai and Rory hug and commiserate over their terrible days (LFDAC) 

5) Luke makes Rory a special coffee cake for her birthday (RBP) 

7) Luke closes the diner immediately upon learning that Richard is ill and insists on driving Lorelai to the hospital (F&S)

8) Lorelai gently says that they don't have to change EVERYTHING about the diner after Luke reminisces about his dad (TDDR) 

15) Luke brings hot drinks to the reenactors (L&W&S)

16) Lorelai gives Luke a new blue cap (F&S)

19) Rory asks if she can hug Richard while he's lying in a hospital bed (F&S)

24) Lorelai and Rory sit on the grass looking at the Dragonfly talking about opening the Inn.

26)  "Yes, Emily, you may go first" (F&S) 

 

12 and 23 are gone, and we're down to our final 10! Just vote for the two that you can most handle eliminating :) 

[elang4]

I love them all but I'll have to say 2 and 24.

[Taryn74]

1 and 16

This is hard, though.

[amensisterfriend]

16 and 19

[Kohola3]

2, 16

[betterthisway]

My votes are for 19 and 24, but every scene on this list is wonderful and helps remind me why this is my favorite show

[LeafontheWind]

16 and 24 for me! 

[Viqutorious]

5 & 24

[junienmomo]

2, 24

[ghoulina]

5, 16

[lulu1960]

2, 24

[Kohola3]

I am offline until Thursday night.  Carry on! 

[amensisterfriend]

1) "Sorry, too late..." (Final scene from the Pilot in response to Luke's mock warning that Rory doesn't want to turn out like her mom)

2) Lorelai and Rory hug and commiserate over their terrible days (LFDAC) 

5) Luke makes Rory a special coffee cake for her birthday (RBP) 

7) Luke closes the diner immediately upon learning that Richard is ill and insists on driving Lorelai to the hospital (F&S)

8) Lorelai gently says that they don't have to change EVERYTHING about the diner after Luke reminisces about his dad (TDDR) 

15) Luke brings hot drinks to the reenactors (L&W&S)

19) Rory asks if she can hug Richard while he's lying in a hospital bed (F&S)

26)  "Yes, Emily, you may go first" (F&S) 

 

You'll be missed, Kohola! 

16 and 24 will also be missed, as they've now been eliminated from our game :) The next round is open, and we're still voting against two!

My votes: 5 and 19 

[elang4]

2 and 19 for me. God this is getting so hard now!

[Taryn74]

1, 19, and I agree.