Katherine June 27, 2015 Share June 27, 2015 A Deep-Fried Korean Thanksgiving The Big One Link to comment
eledgy June 28, 2015 Share June 28, 2015 Like Mother, Like Daughter and The Big One are gone, keep voting against two: PilotLorelai's First Day at ChiltonRory's Birthday PartiesForgiveness and StuffDouble DateThe Bracebridge DinnerA-Tisket, A-TasketThere's the RubDead Uncles and VegetablesLorelai's Graduation DayThey Shoot Gilmores, Don't They?Let the Games BeginA Deep-Fried Korean ThanksgivingThose Are Strings, Pinocchio Link to comment
lulu1960 June 29, 2015 Share June 29, 2015 My favorites aren't jiving with you guys. Lol 1 Link to comment
Kohola3 June 29, 2015 Share June 29, 2015 Well, as already stated, some have good scenes so it's hard but if there were more scenes that make you squirm, then the whole thing has to go! 1 Link to comment
ghoulina June 29, 2015 Share June 29, 2015 To be fair, at this point, ALL of the episodes are ones I love, or at least have favorite moments. It's getting super hard for me to pick, so it's just like - "I love this one, but I love that one more". 1 Link to comment
Taryn74 June 29, 2015 Share June 29, 2015 Yep. It hurts to vote against both ATAT and TTR, but I had to vote for something LOL. 1 Link to comment
lulu1960 June 30, 2015 Share June 30, 2015 I just enjoy all the bits of Tisket. Well except for Jealous Dean that is. Link to comment
LeafontheWind June 30, 2015 Share June 30, 2015 (edited) Jealous Dean and Wishy-Washy Rory are the reasons Tisket is on my list this round! I love the other parts of that episode, but those two make it one I can afford to lose. Edited June 30, 2015 by LeafontheWind Link to comment
eledgy June 30, 2015 Share June 30, 2015 A Ticket , a Tasket and There's the Rub are gone are gone, keep voting against two: (I'm not sure when ASF usually goes to voting for one--any ideas? Maybe when there're ten left?)PilotLorelai's First Day at ChiltonRory's Birthday PartiesForgiveness and StuffDouble DateThe Bracebridge DinnerDead Uncles and VegetablesLorelai's Graduation DayThey Shoot Gilmores, Don't They?Let the Games BeginA Deep-Fried Korean ThanksgivingThose Are Strings, Pinocchio Link to comment
ghoulina June 30, 2015 Share June 30, 2015 I don't know if I can do this anymore! It's becoming too difficult. Forgiveness Bracebridge Ack!!!! I feel mean now. I love all of these! Link to comment
lulu1960 June 30, 2015 Share June 30, 2015 10 sounds good to start voting for one. Lorelai's Graduation Day Let The Games Begin Link to comment
amensisterfriend July 1, 2015 Share July 1, 2015 Eledgy, thank you so much for taking over and immediately distinguishing yourself as the best game runner ever :) Normally, I switch to voting against just one episode once we're down to five, but since this list was so long, you're absolutely right to shift to voting against one once we're down to 10! LMLD is gone and now LGD looks like it's about to follow?! I'm totally out of sync with most of you guys, but that's what makes this game interesting, right?! :) My votes: ADFKT and Forgiveness Link to comment
lulu1960 July 1, 2015 Share July 1, 2015 Very interesting indeed. Considering F&S is in my top five favorite episodes of the whole series Link to comment
amensisterfriend July 2, 2015 Share July 2, 2015 Lorelai's Graduation Day is history (*sob*), but we have a tie between Forgiveness and Stuff and A Deep Fried Korean Thanksgiving for that second spot. Just vote for the one of those two you most want eliminated :) Link to comment
LeafontheWind July 2, 2015 Share July 2, 2015 Deep Fried! I LOVE the stuff with Dave and Lane, but the rest kind of annoys me... Link to comment
amensisterfriend July 2, 2015 Share July 2, 2015 I'll go against Forgiveness as well (it's too melodramatic and heavyhanded for me!) Ooops---lulu beat me to it, so ADFKT is out instead. PilotLorelai's First Day at ChiltonRory's Birthday PartiesForgiveness and StuffDouble DateThe Bracebridge DinnerDead Uncles and VegetablesThey Shoot Gilmores, Don't They?Let the Games BeginThose Are Strings, Pinocchio We're down to voting against just one. My vote: Forgiveness and Stuff Link to comment
LeafontheWind July 2, 2015 Share July 2, 2015 Forgiveness seems inevitable, so why not join the crowd! Link to comment
amensisterfriend July 2, 2015 Share July 2, 2015 So how close is our collective top 10 S1-S3 list to your own?! My own list would definitely include LMLD, Lorelai's Graduation Day, Lazy Hazy Crazy, and a few others I'm blanking out on :) It would also include fewer S1 episodes---only Double Date and possibly Rory's Birthday Parties would make the cut! Link to comment
lulu1960 July 2, 2015 Share July 2, 2015 Let the Games Begin. Buh bye Forgiveness. *tear* 3 for sure would make my top 10. Maybe 4 Or 5 1 Link to comment
amensisterfriend July 3, 2015 Share July 3, 2015 PilotLorelai's First Day at ChiltonRory's Birthday PartiesDouble DateThe Bracebridge DinnerDead Uncles and VegetablesThey Shoot Gilmores, Don't They?Let the Games BeginThose Are Strings, Pinocchio Forgiveness is gone, and the next round is open! My vote: Pilot (I like this episode a lot and think it's a great introduction to the show, but for me it's not an all-time classic like many of the others that remain...I'm not even sure it would have made my top 15-20 from these first three seasons!) As a huge S2 fan, it's kind of sad for me to see just one S2 episode remaining...and I'm not even sure Bracebridge is among my very favorites from that season :) I am, however, happily surprised that my beloved Let the Games Begin has survived this long! Link to comment
lulu1960 July 3, 2015 Share July 3, 2015 So sad to see Forgiveness gone. We still have Season 2 DUAV left. So yay for that! Pilot Link to comment
amensisterfriend July 3, 2015 Share July 3, 2015 LOL---how did I miss that?! So we have TWO S2 episodes remaining...and you guys get to ignore most of my above rambling :) Link to comment
LeafontheWind July 3, 2015 Share July 3, 2015 Pilot was my next choice as well. As a pilot, it is a great introduction to the show. As a stand alone episode, some of it is just a little too on the nose (as most pilots tend to be) for my liking. I am also sad to see so few Season 2 episodes, but I think that while it is the strongest season overall there are a lot of great stand out episodes in other seasons. 1 Link to comment
lulu1960 July 3, 2015 Share July 3, 2015 As far as the first three seasons go. Season 2 is my fave. In the latter 4 seasons, it is Season 4 hands down. Link to comment
Kohola3 July 3, 2015 Share July 3, 2015 I'll go for Pilot as well. A necessary episode at the beginning but really quite forgettable. Link to comment
amensisterfriend July 4, 2015 Share July 4, 2015 Lorelai's First Day at ChiltonRory's Birthday PartiesDouble DateThe Bracebridge DinnerDead Uncles and VegetablesThey Shoot Gilmores, Don't They?Let the Games BeginThose Are Strings, Pinocchio The Pilot is history, and we're down to eight! Just vote for the one you most want/least don't want eliminated... My vote: Lorelais' First Day at Chilton---it will always have a lot of sentimental value for me and contains a few phenomenal scenes, but aspects of it kind of annoy me now, and that nonsense with Lorelai's outfit is such a ridiculous contrivance! Link to comment
LeafontheWind July 4, 2015 Share July 4, 2015 I wouldn't mind seeing First Day off the list. Link to comment
Kohola3 July 4, 2015 Share July 4, 2015 Ditto. The Daisy Duke story line was idiotic. 1 Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.