Katherine June 17, 2015 Share June 17, 2015 This is painful. I'm gonna have to go with That Damn Donna Reed and Those Lazy-Hazy-Crazy Days (I'm not giving up on this one ;) ). Link to comment
ghoulina June 17, 2015 Share June 17, 2015 Donna Reed Say Goodnight Gracie Agree, this is getting hard!!! Link to comment
Taryn74 June 17, 2015 Share June 17, 2015 Red Light SG,G (though Mrs. Kim's "Walking with dead people, not my thing" is worth the price of admission LOL) 1 Link to comment
amensisterfriend June 18, 2015 Share June 18, 2015 PilotLorelai's First Day at ChiltonRory's Birthday PartiesForgiveness and StuffDouble DateEmily in WonderlandRed Light on the Wedding NightNick & Nora/Sid & NancyLike Mother, Like DaughterThe Bracebridge DinnerA-Tisket, A-TasketLost and FoundThere's the RubDead Uncles and VegetablesBack in the Saddle AgainLorelai's Graduation DayI Can't Get StartedThose Lazy-Hazy-Crazy DaysOne's Got Class and the Other One DyesEight O'Clock at the OasisThey Shoot Gilmores, Don't They?Let the Games BeginA Deep-Fried Korean ThanksgivingThe Big OneSay Goodnight, GracieThose Are Strings, Pinocchio That Damn Donna Reed and Teach Me Tonight are history, and the next round is open! I used to be really meh on TDDR but grew to love it...other than Dean, of course :) I actually think it has arguably the best L/L chemistry and best Luke scenes of the series, or at least the top three...but then we all know I have weird opinions when it comes to L/L! My Votes: Emily in Wonderland (there are some fabulous scenes here---I just don't love it quite as much as most of the remaining episodes) and Nick and Nora Link to comment
Kohola3 June 18, 2015 Share June 18, 2015 Tisket and Nick As I tried to decide, I realized that there are so many episodes that have great scenes but are otherwise painful. We should do just scenes next time. If we could figure out how! 1 Link to comment
amensisterfriend June 18, 2015 Share June 18, 2015 As I tried to decide, I realized that there are so many episodes that have great scenes but are otherwise painful. Kohola, I suspect will find this to be even truer of S4-S7! I've always said that for me GG is a show of sublime individual scenes, lines and moments :) Link to comment
ghoulina June 18, 2015 Share June 18, 2015 Red Light (LOVE the chuppah and the traffic light, but I can't stand Max and the bachelor/ette party stuff.) Say Goodnight Gracie Link to comment
lulu1960 June 18, 2015 Share June 18, 2015 Back in the Saddle I Can't Get Started. I enjoy TDDR. Sorry it is gone. Link to comment
Katherine June 18, 2015 Share June 18, 2015 Those Lazy-Hazy-Crazy Days One's Got Class and the Other One Dyes Link to comment
amensisterfriend June 19, 2015 Share June 19, 2015 PilotLorelai's First Day at ChiltonRory's Birthday PartiesForgiveness and StuffDouble DateEmily in WonderlandNick & Nora/Sid & NancyLike Mother, Like DaughterThe Bracebridge DinnerA-Tisket, A-TasketLost and FoundThere's the RubDead Uncles and VegetablesBack in the Saddle AgainLorelai's Graduation DayI Can't Get StartedThose Lazy-Hazy-Crazy DaysOne's Got Class and the Other One DyesEight O'Clock at the OasisThey Shoot Gilmores, Don't They?Let the Games BeginA Deep-Fried Korean ThanksgivingThe Big OneThose Are Strings, Pinocchio Red Light is history, and I'll switch my vote from EiW to Say Goodnight Gracie to avoid yet another game-delaying tiebreaker :) The next round is open! My votes: Emily in Wonderland and Nick and Nora Link to comment
eledgy June 20, 2015 Share June 20, 2015 Too late to save Emily in Wonderland, one of my all-time faves... One's Got Class and the Other One DyesEight O'Clock at the Oasis Link to comment
amensisterfriend June 22, 2015 Share June 22, 2015 Emily in Wonderland is gone, but we have a tie between Nick and Nora and I Can't Get Started! Just vote for the one of those two that you most want eliminated :) My tiebreaker vote: Nick and Nora (I think I Can't Get Started is actually a fantastic episode!) Link to comment
Taryn74 June 22, 2015 Share June 22, 2015 Nick and Nora, if I have to choose. Jess' arrival is such a breath of fresh air to this show, but ICGS is by far the better episode. Link to comment
amensisterfriend June 22, 2015 Share June 22, 2015 PilotLorelai's First Day at ChiltonRory's Birthday PartiesForgiveness and StuffDouble DateLike Mother, Like DaughterThe Bracebridge DinnerA-Tisket, A-TasketLost and FoundThere's the RubDead Uncles and VegetablesBack in the Saddle AgainLorelai's Graduation DayI Can't Get StartedThose Lazy-Hazy-Crazy DaysOne's Got Class and the Other One DyesEight O'Clock at the OasisThey Shoot Gilmores, Don't They?Let the Games BeginA Deep-Fried Korean ThanksgivingThe Big OneThose Are Strings, Pinocchio Okay, so Nick and Nora is gone too, and the next round is open! We're still voting against two :) Link to comment
Katherine June 22, 2015 Share June 22, 2015 Those Lazy-Hazy-Crazy Days One's Got Class and the Other One Dyes Link to comment
lulu1960 June 22, 2015 Share June 22, 2015 I Can't Get Started Back in the Saddle Again I love Lost and Found. Link to comment
eledgy June 23, 2015 Share June 23, 2015 One's Got Class and the Other One DyesEight O'Clock at the Oasis Link to comment
amensisterfriend June 23, 2015 Share June 23, 2015 So I was initially horrified by our six-way (!) tie...until I realized that I forgot to vote :) I'll go with (well, against, but you get the point) Lost and Found and One Has Class, so those two are history and the next round is open! We're still voting against two: PilotLorelai's First Day at ChiltonRory's Birthday PartiesForgiveness and StuffDouble DateLike Mother, Like DaughterThe Bracebridge DinnerA-Tisket, A-TasketThere's the RubDead Uncles and VegetablesBack in the Saddle AgainLorelai's Graduation DayI Can't Get StartedThose Lazy-Hazy-Crazy DaysEight O'Clock at the OasisThey Shoot Gilmores, Don't They?Let the Games BeginA Deep-Fried Korean ThanksgivingThe Big OneThose Are Strings, Pinocchio Link to comment
Taryn74 June 23, 2015 Share June 23, 2015 What is it that I'm missing about BitSA? I do love Richard, Paris, and Rory all working together, but unless I'm forgetting other parts of it I don't find it all that special. Just curious!!! BitSA and Lazy, Hazy Link to comment
LeafontheWind June 23, 2015 Share June 23, 2015 I don't think BitSA is amazing or anything, but the stuff with Richard and Paris is pretty awesome. I think those scenes make it better than several that are left on the list. 1 Link to comment
eledgy June 24, 2015 Share June 24, 2015 Those Lazy-Hazy-Crazy DaysEight O'Clock at the Oasis Link to comment
amensisterfriend June 24, 2015 Share June 24, 2015 Hi guys! I'm actually away for the next 4-5 days and might not have much access to a computer. If someone could take over as temporary game runner, I'd be eternally grateful :) Link to comment
eledgy June 25, 2015 Share June 25, 2015 (edited) Hi guys! I'm actually away for the next 4-5 days and might not have much access to a computer. If someone could take over as temporary game runner, I'd be eternally grateful :) I have a 4 day weekend and no major plans, so I'll give it a whirl! Lazy Hazy and Oasis are gone goodbye! I assume we keep voting for two? (Let me know when and if we should go to voting against one...) Pilot Lorelai's First Day at Chilton Rory's Birthday Parties Forgiveness and Stuff Double Date Like Mother, Like Daughter The Bracebridge Dinner A-Tisket, A-Tasket There's the Rub Dead Uncles and Vegetables Back in the Saddle Again Lorelai's Graduation Day I Can't Get Started They Shoot Gilmores, Don't They? Let the Games Begin A Deep-Fried Korean Thanksgiving The Big One Those Are Strings, Pinocchio Edited June 25, 2015 by eledgy Link to comment
LeafontheWind June 25, 2015 Share June 25, 2015 These will probably be unpopular, but... Like Mother, Like Daughter (I just hate all the Francie/Puffs stuff!) The Big One (love the Paris breakdown, hate the stuff with Max!) Link to comment
Kohola3 June 25, 2015 Share June 25, 2015 Like Mother, Like Daughter (ditto on the Puffs hate) Can't Get Started (Christopher at his worst) Link to comment
lulu1960 June 25, 2015 Share June 25, 2015 I Can't Get Started Back in the Saddle You know you've vote for the same two a lot when your phone anticipates what you are writing 1 Link to comment
Katherine June 26, 2015 Share June 26, 2015 Back in the Saddle Again A Deep Fried Korean Thanksgiving Link to comment
eledgy June 27, 2015 Share June 27, 2015 I forgot to vote, so I'll break a potential three-way tie by going with Back in the Saddle and Can't Get started, sparing Like Mother, Like Daughter for at least one more round.... PilotLorelai's First Day at ChiltonRory's Birthday PartiesForgiveness and StuffDouble DateLike Mother, Like DaughterThe Bracebridge DinnerA-Tisket, A-TasketThere's the RubDead Uncles and VegetablesLorelai's Graduation DayThey Shoot Gilmores, Don't They?Let the Games BeginA Deep-Fried Korean ThanksgivingThe Big OneThose Are Strings, Pinocchio Still voting out two per round. Link to comment
lulu1960 June 27, 2015 Share June 27, 2015 Thanks Eledgy for taking over. There's the Rub The Big One Link to comment
eledgy June 27, 2015 Share June 27, 2015 You're welcome, Lulu! There's the RubThe Big One Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.