amensisterfriend December 26, 2014 Share December 26, 2014 6 is gone (you guys are killing me with this Jess round!!! Nearly all of my favorites are gone :() The next round is open: 2. "Then you gotta go" powerful scene between Jess and Luke4. Jess going in the lake5. "I made sure she was okay." "I know you did." Jess and Luke after the accident in Teach Me Tonight17. Jess and Rory share their first kiss at the gas station25. Jess and Rory sitting on the bridge eating the picnic lunch from the bid-a-basket. My vote: 5 Link to comment
amensisterfriend December 27, 2014 Share December 27, 2014 We have a tie between 5 and 25! Just vote for the one of those two that you most want eliminated :) Link to comment
amensisterfriend December 27, 2014 Share December 27, 2014 My vote: 5. The next one is our tiebreaker! Link to comment
Taryn74 December 27, 2014 Share December 27, 2014 25! 25! 25! Ya'll are killing me voting for 5.....lol..... Link to comment
amensisterfriend December 27, 2014 Share December 27, 2014 Our final four: 2. "Then you gotta go" powerful scene between Jess and Luke4. Jess going in the lake5. "I made sure she was okay." "I know you did." Jess and Luke after the accident in Teach Me Tonight17. Jess and Rory share their first kiss at the gas station Link to comment
Taryn74 December 27, 2014 Share December 27, 2014 Sorry Taryn. Now I'm voting for 5 It's on now! :P I'm voting for 4. Link to comment
amensisterfriend December 28, 2014 Share December 28, 2014 I'll cast my vote against five, which means we're down to our final three! 2. "Then you gotta go" powerful scene between Jess and Luke4. Jess going in the lake17. Jess and Rory share their first kiss at the gas station My vote: 2 Link to comment
amensisterfriend December 29, 2014 Share December 29, 2014 Our final two: 2. "Then you gotta go" powerful scene between Jess and Luke17. Jess and Rory share their first kiss at the gas station My vote: 2 Link to comment
Taryn74 December 29, 2014 Share December 29, 2014 2, reluctantly. It was a painful scene, but very powerful and very well acted by both men. Link to comment
lulu1960 December 29, 2014 Share December 29, 2014 I like the last two selections. 2 was a very powerful scene indeed. Very raw and emotional. But 17 was just so sweet and natural. Rory (Alexis) didn't look uncomfortable doing the kissing part of it. (It could be because she was dating Milo). So I shall vote to eliminate 2 Link to comment
LeafontheWind December 30, 2014 Share December 30, 2014 2 for me as well. Though Jess going in the lake will always be top of my list ;) Link to comment
junienmomo December 30, 2014 Share December 30, 2014 I can't figure out if the last round is to name the one we want to keep or the one we want to let go. I vote to keep 2 as the winner. It was a springboard to the next season, which the kiss was just a sweet moment. 1 Link to comment
lulu1960 December 31, 2014 Share December 31, 2014 Junie, it is always to eliminate the one you do not want so we end up with the ultimate winner Link to comment
amensisterfriend December 31, 2014 Share December 31, 2014 17. Jess and Rory share their first kiss at the gas station is our triumphant winner! What should we do next?! Link to comment
junienmomo December 31, 2014 Share December 31, 2014 Have we done an elimination round on funniest moments? 1 Link to comment
amensisterfriend December 31, 2014 Share December 31, 2014 Good question! Have we done the funniest moments of each season? Should we do it anyway, regardless of whether we did it at some point in the past?! Sounds like a really fun one. 1 Link to comment
junienmomo December 31, 2014 Share December 31, 2014 I vote for yes, because we'll get a lot of different points of view. That makes it more challenging. Link to comment
amensisterfriend December 31, 2014 Share December 31, 2014 Great! Te only issue I foresee is that there are so many funny (or at least moments/lines attempting to be funny!) in each episode :) In light of Edward Hermann's passing, I'd love to do a round of Richard's best/most memorable moments as well! Link to comment
junienmomo January 1, 2015 Share January 1, 2015 Let's start with Richard, shall we? 1 Link to comment
amensisterfriend January 1, 2015 Share January 1, 2015 Agreed, Junie! Should we do then one season at a time? Link to comment
junienmomo January 1, 2015 Share January 1, 2015 Oh, yes, Richard's role has lots of good content. Link to comment
Taryn74 January 1, 2015 Share January 1, 2015 Agree, let's start with Richard. I'm sitting here with tears dripping down my face. :( Link to comment
lulu1960 January 1, 2015 Share January 1, 2015 "You need money." Lorelai asks for Chilton money. "You're tall." Richard and Rory at the first FND Pilot Link to comment
junienmomo January 1, 2015 Share January 1, 2015 Rory, are you in any way malnourished or in need of some international relief organization to recruit acelebrity to raise money on your account? EMILY: Oh, no, we let Heidi go months ago. She had a problem closing things -- the door, the refrigerator --RICHARD: The liquor bottle. When Rory arrives late for golf: Ah, 8:30. We must remember to buy her a watch. Link to comment
amensisterfriend January 1, 2015 Share January 1, 2015 I'm sitting here with tears dripping down my face. :( I'm really saddened by it as well. I'm so glad we're using this round to honor him. Happy 2015, everyone! I'm adding some that popped to mind: 1. "You need money." Lorelai asks for Chilton money.2. "You're tall." Richard and Rory at the first FND Pilot 3. Rory, are you in any way malnourished or in need of some international relief organization to recruit acelebrity to raise money on your account?4. EMILY: Oh, no, we let Heidi go months ago. She had a problem closing things -- the door, the refrigerator --RICHARD: The liquor bottle.5. When Rory arrives late for golf: Ah, 8:30. We must remember to buy her a watch. 6. "I'm an autumn!" (Richard's realization at Rory's birthday party!) 7. Richard keeps giving Rory money to support her dram of going to Fez 8. Richard is incredibly excited to have his beloved granddaughter meet his beloved (albeit difficult!) mother (The Third Lorelai) 9. Seeing how upset Emily is, a hospitalized Richard gently says "Yes Emily. You may go first." (Forgiveness and Stuff) 10. Richard defends Lorelai when Straub insults her (Christopher Returns) 11. Richard is quietly complicit in helping Lorelai sneak away from the painfully boring date Emily sprung on her (Star Crossed Lovers) Link to comment
LeafontheWind January 1, 2015 Share January 1, 2015 (edited) Can we still add to the list? What about when Richard helps Rory play a joke on Logan by pretending that the two are engaged after Logan plays that prank on her in front of her class. I think it is from Not as Cute as Pushkin. Edited January 1, 2015 by LeafontheWind 1 Link to comment
lulu1960 January 1, 2015 Share January 1, 2015 Richard proudly beams about Rory to him Golf Cronies. (Kill Me Now) Rory reads the Newspaper to Richard and then asks if she can hug him. (Forgiveness and Stuff) Link to comment
amensisterfriend January 1, 2015 Share January 1, 2015 Leafonthewind, yes, we're still adding! We're doing it season by season, though, so this first list contains moments from the first season. 1. "You need money." Lorelai asks for Chilton money.2. "You're tall." Richard and Rory at the first FND Pilot3. Rory, are you in any way malnourished or in need of some international relief organization to recruit acelebrity to raise money on your account?4. EMILY: Oh, no, we let Heidi go months ago. She had a problem closing things -- the door, the refrigerator --RICHARD: The liquor bottle.5. When Rory arrives late for golf: Ah, 8:30. We must remember to buy her a watch.6. "I'm an autumn!" (Richard's realization at Rory's birthday party!)7. Richard keeps giving Rory money to support her dram of going to Fez8. Richard is incredibly excited to have his beloved granddaughter meet his beloved (albeit difficult!) mother (The Third Lorelai)9. Seeing how upset Emily is, a hospitalized Richard gently says "Yes Emily. You may go first." (Forgiveness and Stuff)10. Richard defends Lorelai when Straub insults her (Christopher Returns)11. Richard is quietly complicit in helping Lorelai sneak away from the painfully boring date Emily sprung on her (Star Crossed Lovers) 12. Richard proudly beams about Rory to him Golf Cronies. (Kill Me Now)13, Rory reads the newspaper to Richard and then asks if she can hug him. (Forgiveness and Stuff) Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.