Gilmore Girls Elimination Game

[amensisterfriend]

Waiting for more votes before I end this round... :) 

[nolieblue]

9, 13

[Kohola3]

1, 13

[amensisterfriend]

1 and 13 are gone, and the next round is open! I'm surprised that 1 is already gone...it's easily my favorite L/L moment of this terrible season :)  This is the last time we're voting against two:

 

 

2. "We should drink Zima and have sex every single night." NaILG
5. "She remembers the plan." 21ITLN
8. "Does this dress look good with a baby?" "I like the green one."  (Always a Godmother, Never a God.)
9. Luke on the roof with the frisbee. "I'm in the middle."  (Fight Face)
10. "Hole!" Luke wants to garrotte TJ. Lorelai calms him down. (Fight Face)
15. Luke tells Lorelai she is not a bad mother when Paul Anka is sick (Balalaikas)
19. Lorelai tries to get Luke to do the Hallowe'en skit (21)

Edited November 8, 2014 by amensisterfriend

[Kohola3]

2, 8

[junienmomo]

5,19

[lulu1960]

5 and 8

[amensisterfriend]

2. "We should drink Zima and have sex every single night." NaILG
9. Luke on the roof with the frisbee. "I'm in the middle."  (Fight Face)
10. "Hole!" Luke wants to garrotte TJ. Lorelai calms him down. (Fight Face)
15. Luke tells Lorelai she is not a bad mother when Paul Anka is sick (Balalaikas)
19. Lorelai tries to get Luke to do the Hallowe'en skit (21)

 

5 and 8 are history, and we're down to voting against just one! 

[lulu1960]

9

[nolieblue]

9

[Kohola3]

10

[amensisterfriend]

2. "We should drink Zima and have sex every single night." NaILG
10. "Hole!" Luke wants to garrotte TJ. Lorelai calms him down. (Fight Face)
15. Luke tells Lorelai she is not a bad mother when Paul Anka is sick (Balalaikas)
19. Lorelai tries to get Luke to do the Hallowe'en skit (21)

 

9 (which, by the way, I absolutely hate!) is gone, and the next round is open. We're still voting against one :) 

[lulu1960]

10

[Kohola3]

10

[junienmomo]

19

[nolieblue]

10

[amensisterfriend]

Our final three:

 

2. "We should drink Zima and have sex every single night." NaILG
15. Luke tells Lorelai she is not a bad mother when Paul Anka is sick (Balalaikas)
19. Lorelai tries to get Luke to do the Hallowe'en skit (21)

[lulu1960]

2

[junienmomo]

19

[Kohola3]

19

[nolieblue]

2

[amensisterfriend]

I'll break the tie by voting against 2, and we're down to our final two:

 

15. Luke tells Lorelai she is not a bad mother when Paul Anka is sick (Balalaikas)
19. Lorelai tries to get Luke to do the Hallowe'en skit (21)

[lulu1960]

I'll go with happy even though I do like the supportive ness of Luke in 15. Voting to eliminate 15

[nolieblue]

15

[Kohola3]

19

[amensisterfriend]

19. Lorelai tries to get Luke to do the Hallowe'en skit (21) is our winner! 

 

If anyone is into S7 L/L moments enough to play that round, please feel free to start listing them :) 

 

1. "I just want to see you happy..." (BV)

[nolieblue]

Car shopping

Hay Bale Maze conversation

"I wanna horn"

Lorelai meets Luke with Doula in the stroller

Supermarket meeting (sad but well done)

Luke shows up at the hospital with food

Luke asks Lorelai for a character reference at the Dragonfly

Lorelai sings I Will Always Love You

Luke and April meet Lorelai and Rory at the science store

Lorelai and Luke discuss the boat trip (Barnacle Billy's shout out)

[lulu1960]

Lorelai tells Luke she slept with Chris

Luke sees Lorelai in the crosswalk and says he's fine.

Lorelai tells Luke that Logan asked Rory to marry him. (Kirk is in the box)

Lorelai goes to the hospital and Luke sees the ring.

[Kohola3]

Um, well, er.  Nope, I got nuthin'.

[junienmomo]

I'm out. Even the remotely pleasant moments make me feel sad.   :(

[amensisterfriend]

I actually think there are better L/L moments in S7 than S6---though, granted, that's a REALLY low bar for me :) If you guys want to skip this and play something else, I totally understand! If you want to stick with this one to the bitter end, here are the L/L moments we have so far:

 

1. "I just want to see you happy..." (BV)

2. Car shopping
3. Hay Bale Maze conversation
4. "I wanna horn"
5. Lorelai meets Luke with Doula in the stroller
6. Supermarket meeting (sad but well done)
7. Luke shows up at the hospital with food
8. Luke asks Lorelai for a character reference at the Dragonfly
9. Lorelai sings I Will Always Love You
10. Luke and April meet Lorelai and Rory at the science store
11. Lorelai and Luke discuss the boat trip (Barnacle Billy's shout out)

12. Lorelai tells Luke she slept with Chris
13. Luke sees Lorelai in the crosswalk and says he's fine.
14. Lorelai tells Luke that Logan asked Rory to marry him. (Kirk is in the box)

15. Lorelai goes to the hospital and Luke sees the ring.

[Kohola3]

Let's put on a brave front and see this through.  We're tough.

[junienmomo]

OK, Kohola, brave front is on. We'll hold hands and skip afterwards.

 

Perfect storm of caffeine and genetics (Long Morrow) Where Luke wants to talk and Lorelai refuses.

[amensisterfriend]

I love the spirit and courage!!! :) Since we only have 15 here, let's just vote against two. 

 

 

1. "I just want to see you happy..." (BV)
2. Car shopping
3. Hay Bale Maze conversation
4. "I wanna horn"
5. Lorelai meets Luke with Doula in the stroller
6. Supermarket meeting (sad but well done)
7. Luke shows up at the hospital with food
8. Luke asks Lorelai for a character reference at the Dragonfly
9. Lorelai sings I Will Always Love You
10. Luke and April meet Lorelai and Rory at the science store
11. Lorelai and Luke discuss the boat trip (Barnacle Billy's shout out)
12. Lorelai tells Luke she slept with Chris
13. Luke sees Lorelai in the crosswalk and says he's fine.
14. Lorelai tells Luke that Logan asked Rory to marry him. (Kirk is in the box)
15. Lorelai goes to the hospital and Luke sees the ring.

[amensisterfriend]

My votes: 10 and 13 (they both really frustrate me here!) 

 

It's weird, but I actually really like a lot of these...especially as compared to S6 :) 

[Kohola3]

10, 12

[lulu1960]

10, 13. (In 12 I felt Luke's pain so much. I thought it was well done.)

In 10 it felt like so much Revisionist history to me.

13 was just sad because Luke's way of dealing with his pain was anger (which I get but still...)

Edited November 16, 2014 by lulu1960

[junienmomo]

10,13

[Taryn74]

I might survive this shorter round LOL. 

 

12, 13

[amensisterfriend]

Courage, my comrades---we'll fight this battle together!!! By the way, what are we doing once L/L moments are complete?! Have we ever done the best of Jess, which would include Luke/Jess, Rory/Jess etc.???

 

10 and 13 are gone, and the next round is open! We're still voting against two :) 

 

1. "I just want to see you happy..." (BV)
2. Car shopping
3. Hay Bale Maze conversation
4. "I wanna horn"
5. Lorelai meets Luke with Doula in the stroller
6. Supermarket meeting (sad but well done)
7. Luke shows up at the hospital with food
8. Luke asks Lorelai for a character reference at the Dragonfly
9. Lorelai sings I Will Always Love You
11. Lorelai and Luke discuss the boat trip (Barnacle Billy's shout out)
12. Lorelai tells Luke she slept with Chris
14. Lorelai tells Luke that Logan asked Rory to marry him. (Kirk is in the box)
15. Lorelai goes to the hospital and Luke sees the ring.

[lulu1960]

6 Hated that Luke said he was just the guy who poured her coffee.

12 So sad

[Taryn74]

12, 6

[amensisterfriend]

5 (I really don't think this scene was very well done!) and 12

[junienmomo]

11, 14

Both of these felt awkward and confused me.

I'm up for a Jess love/hate fest, or anything along that line.

[nolieblue]

12, 14

 

14 drives  me crazy -- they should have reconciled the night of the serenade except TPTB had to drag it out to 8:55. ARGH!

[Kohola3]

6, 12

[amensisterfriend]

1. "I just want to see you happy..." (BV)
2. Car shopping
3. Hay Bale Maze conversation
4. "I wanna horn"
5. Lorelai meets Luke with Doula in the stroller
7. Luke shows up at the hospital with food
8. Luke asks Lorelai for a character reference at the Dragonfly
9. Lorelai sings I Will Always Love You
11. Lorelai and Luke discuss the boat trip (Barnacle Billy's shout out)
14. Lorelai tells Luke that Logan asked Rory to marry him. (Kirk is in the box)
15. Lorelai goes to the hospital and Luke sees the ring.

 

6 and 12 are gone, and the next round is open! 

 

My votes: 5 and 14 

[junienmomo]

11 and 14

[Taryn74]

11, 14

[lulu1960]

3 Compartmentalize Blegh

14